以修正型德菲法建立台灣愛滋個管師角色與愛滋護理照顧之核心能力

Applying the Modified Delphi Technique to Develop the Role of HIV Case Managers and Essential Nursing Competencies in HIV Care

10.6224/JN.62.4.63

柯乃熒(Nai-Ying Ko)；謝佳吟(Chia-Yin Hsieh)；陳嬿今(Yen-Chin Chen)；蔡承熹(Chen-Hsi Tsai)；劉曉穎(Hsiao-Ying Liu)；劉麗芳(Li-Fang Liu)

愛滋照護 ； 德菲法 ； 核心能力 ； 個案管理 ； HIV/AIDS care ； Delphi ； core competency ； case management

護理雜誌

62卷4期（2015 / 08 / 01）

63 - 72

繁體中文

背景　台灣疾病管制署於2005年始，於指定醫院推行愛滋個管計畫，提供整合性服務及降低風險諮詢。面對臨床照護的日漸複雜性及需要高度專業性，發展以愛滋護理照顧核心能力為基礎的專業教育刻不容緩。目的　建立台灣愛滋個案管理師角色與愛滋護理照顧之核心能力。方法　本研究參考加拿大、英國及非洲的愛滋照顧核心能力，草擬台灣「愛滋個管師角色與愛滋護理照顧之核心能力」架構，包含七個角色及27項能力，以修正型德菲法邀請15位專家共同評定。結果　第一回合共識決策有三項目未達成共識，經整合並修改後，第二回合整體專家共識收斂度達97.06%。定稿的「愛滋個管師角色與愛滋護理照顧之核心能力」為：愛滋病照護專家-9項能力、溝通者-1項能力、合作者-4項能力、領航員-2項能力、管理者-4項能力、代言人-2項能力、專業人員-5項能力。結論／實務應用透過愛滋護理核心照顧能力指標的建立，未來可發展、培育進階愛滋病護理師的核心能力，並應用於長期監測進階護理師提供的愛滋個案管理之照顧品質。

Background: Since 2005, the Taiwan Centers for Disease Control (Taiwan CDC) initiated an HIV case management program in AIDS-designated hospitals to provide integrative services and risk-reduction counseling for HIV-infected individuals. In light of the increasingly complex and highly specialized nature of clinical care, expanding and improving competency-based professional education is important to enhance the quality of HIV/AIDS care. Purpose: The aim of this study was to develop the essential competency framework for HIV care for HIV case managers in Taiwan. Methods: We reviewed essential competencies of HIV care from Canada, the United Kingdom, and several African countries and devised descriptions of the roles of case managers and of the associated core competencies for HIV care in Taiwan. The modified Delphi technique was used to evaluate the draft framework of these roles and core competencies. A total of 15 HIV care experts were invited to join the expert panel to review and rank the draft framework. Results: The final framework consisted of 7 roles and 27 competencies for HIV case managers. In Round 1, only 3 items did not receive consensus approval from the experts. After modification based on opinions of the experts, 7 roles and 27 competencies received 97.06% consensus approval in Round 2 and were organized into the final framework for HIV case managers. These roles and associated core competencies were: HIV Care Expert (9 competencies), Communicator (1 competency), Collaborator (4 competencies), Navigator (2 competencies), Manager (4 competencies), Advocate (2 competencies), and Professional (5 competencies). Conclusion/Implications for Practice: The authors developed an essential competency framework for HIV care using the consensus of a multidisciplinary expert panel. Curriculum developers and advanced nurses and practitioners may use this framework to support developments and to ensure a high quality of HIV care.

1. 宋文娟, W. C.,黃久秦, C. C.,洪錦墩, C. T(2008)。應用德菲法評估台灣未來老人健康議題暨老年醫師之需求。明新學報，34(2)，355-367。
   連結：
2. 邱珠敏, C. M.,黃彥芳, Y. F.,楊靖慧, C. H.,陳穎慧, Y. H.,林頂, T.(2010)。他山之石—由美國愛滋病個案管理制度談台灣「愛滋病個案管理師計畫」。台灣公共衛生雜誌，29(1)，1-7。
   連結：
3. Association of Nurses in AIDS Care(2007).HIV/AIDS nursing: Scope and standards of practice.Washington, DC:American Nurses Association & Association of Nurses in AIDS.
4. Cheng, S. H.,Yang, C. H.,Hsueh, Y. M.(2013).Highly active antiretroviral therapy is associated with decreased incidence of sexually transmitted diseases in a Taiwanese HIV-positive population.AIDS Patient Care STDS,27(3),155-162.
5. Faherty, V.(1979).Continuing social work education: Results of a Delphi survey.Journal of Education for Social Work,15(1),12-19.
6. Holden, M. C.,Wedman, J. F.(1993).Future issues of computer-mediated communication: The results of a delphi study.Educational Technology Research and Development,41(1),5-24.
7. International Council of Nurses(2008).Nursing care continuum – Framework and competencies.Geneva, Switzerland:Author.
8. Ko, N. Y.,Lai, Y. Y.,Liu, H. Y.,Lee, H. C.,Chang, C. M.,Lee, N. Y.,Ko, W. C.(2012).Impact of the nurse-led case management program with retention in care on mortality among people with HIV-1 infection: A prospective cohort study.The International Journal of Nursing Studies,49(6),656-663.
9. National Case Management Network. (2012, October). Canadian core competency profile for case management providers. Retrieved from http://www.ncmn.ca/Resources/Documents/Final_ncmn_english_report.pdf
10. National HIV Nurses Association. (2007, June). National HIV nursing competencies. Retrieved from http://www.nhivna.org/documents/Competencies-Guidelines/Competencies07.pdf
11. Relf, M. V.,Mekwa, J.,Chasokela, C.,Booth, C.,Deng, L.,Mallinson, R. K.,Liddle, A.(2011).Essential core competencies related to HIV and AIDS are critically needed in nursing.Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care,22(1),S2-S8.
12. Thompson, M. A.,Mugavero, M. J.,Amico, K. R.,Cargill, V. A.,Chang, L. W.,Gross, R.,Nachega, J.(2012).Guidelines for improving entry into and retention in care and antiretroviral adherence for persons with HIV: Evidencebased recommendations from an International Association of Physicians in AIDS care panel.Annals of Internal Medicine,156(11),817-833.
13. World Health Organization(1993).Integrating HIV-related content into a competency-based curriculum.Manila, Philippines:World Health Organization Regional Office for the Western Pacific.
14. 宋文娟, W. C.(2001)。一種質量並重的研究法─德菲法在醫務管理學研究領域之應用。醫務管理期刊，2(2)，1-20。
15. 郭鳳霞, F. S.,徐南麗, N. L(2002)。個案管理師的角色與必備能力。志為護理—慈濟護理雜誌，1(3)，22-27。
16. 游千代, C. T.,馮明珠, M. C.,柯乃熒, N. Y.(2013)。個案管理之概念分析。護理雜誌，60(4)，99-104。
17. 楊麗瑟, L. S.,梁淑玲, S. L.,徐亞瑛, Y. Y.(1986)。我們的護理經驗─臺灣第一位愛滋病病人及照顧者的壓力。護理雜誌，33(3)，101-105。

1. 林良餘(Liang-Yu Lin);洪富如(Fu-Ju Hung);林資諺(Zi-Yan Lin)(2023)。照護一位愛滋病感染者併發伺機性感染行人工造口術後之護理經驗。志為護理-慈濟護理雜誌。22(6)。99-109。