腹部按摩於改善脊髓損傷者神經性腸道功能障礙之成效－系統性文獻回顧

The Effectiveness of Abdominal Massage on Neurogenic Bowel Dysfunction in Patients With Spinal Cord Injury: A Systematic Review

10.6224/JN.000012

吳姿蓉(Tzu-Jung Wu)；林秋菊(Chiu-Chu Lin)；王秀紅(Hsiu-Hung Wang)

脊髓損傷 ； 腹部按摩 ； 神經性腸道功能障礙 ； spinal cord injury ； abdominal massage ； neurogenic bowel dysfunction

護理雜誌

64卷1期（2017 / 02 / 01）

90 - 97

繁體中文

背景　神經性腸道功能障礙是造成脊髓損傷病人大便失禁常見的合併症，腹部按摩為腸道訓練的步驟之一，可增進腸蠕動與促進排便。目的　旨在透過系統性文獻回顧研究方式，探討腹部按摩運用於改善脊髓損傷病人神經性腸道功能障礙之成效。方法　以系統性文獻回顧方式，運用「脊髓損傷」、「腹部按摩」、「神經性腸道功能障礙」、「腸道訓練」等關鍵字，於中、英文6個資料庫進行搜尋。主要選取截至2016年6月符合納入與排除條件之相關文獻，使用Downs 及 Black量表進行文獻評讀，最後納入8篇文獻進行分析。結果　有4篇文獻顯示腹部按摩介入後，分別在腸道功能、排便時間與排便頻率上有顯著改善；2篇分別顯示在甘油球與瀉劑使用上獲得顯著改善，另兩篇則無成效。分析文獻品質得分介於13至25分之間。結論／實務應用　文獻樣本中，以腹部按摩對改善脊髓損傷病人神經性腸道功能障礙之成效仍不一致。未來應以更嚴謹之實驗性研究設計，例如：以隨機對照研究來探討按摩時間、按摩頻率以及腸道功能改善之關係，以提供臨床照護之指引及運用。

Background: Neurogenic bowel dysfunction is a common comorbidity in spinal cord injury patients that may result in fecal incontinence. Abdominal massage is one intestinal training method that is used to improve bowel movement and defecation. Purpose: To review the effectiveness of abdominal massage on neurogenic bowel dysfunction in patients with spinal cord injury. Methods: A systematic review of Chinese and English-language articles was performed in six databases using the following key words: spinal cord injury, abdominal massage, neurogenic bowel dysfunction, and bowel training. Relevant studies published prior to June 2016 that met the inclusion and exclusion criteria were selected. The Downs and Black scale was used to appraise the quality of each of the included studies. Eight studies were included in the final analysis. Results: Four of these studies indicated that abdominal massage significantly improved bowel functions and the regularity and frequency of bowel movements. Although two of the studies indicated that abdominal massage significantly reduced the use of glycerin and laxatives, the remaining six did not. The eight studies earned respective quality scores ranging between 13 and 25. Conclusions / Implications for Practice: The current literature lacks consensus on the efficacy of abdominal massage in terms of improving bowel dysfunction in patients with spinal cord injuries. Future studies should use more stringent experimental designs such as randomized controlled studies to explore the correlations among massage time and frequency and bowel function improvements in order to provide guidelines for clinical care applications.

1. National Spinal Cord Injury Statistical Center. (2013). Spinal cord injury factors and figures at a glance. Retrieved from https://www.nscisc.uab.edu/PublicDocuments/fact_figures_docs/Facts%202013.pdf
2. Albers, B.,Cramer, H.,Fischer, A.,Meissner, A.,Schürenberg, A.,Bartholomeyczik, S.(2006).Abdominal massage as intervention for patients with paraplegia caused by spinal cord injury-A pilot study.Pflege Zeitschrift,59(3),2-8.
3. Ash, D.(2005).Sustaining safe and acceptable bowel care in spinal cord injured patients.Nursing Standard,20(8),55-64.
4. Ayaş, Ş.,Leblebici, B.,Sözay, S.,Bayramoğlu, M.,Niron, E. A.(2006).The effect of abdominal massage on bowel function in patients with spinal cord injury.American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation,85(12),951-955.
5. Chen, H. Y.,Lai, C. H.,Wu, T. J.(2011).A study of factors affecting moving-forward behaviour among people with spinal cord injury.Rehabilitation Nursing,36(3),91-97.
6. Coggrave, M.(2008).Neurogenic continence. part 3: Bowel management strategies.British Journal of Nursing,17(15),962-968.
7. Coggrave, M. J.,Norton, C.(2010).The need for manual evacuation and oral laxatives in the management of neurogenic bowel dysfunction after spinal cord injury: A randomized controlled trial of a stepwise protocol.Spinal Cord,48(6),504-510.
8. Coggrave, M.,Burrows, D.,Durand, M. A.(2006).Progressive protocol in the bowel management of spinal cord injuries.British Journal of Nursing,15(20),1108-1103.
9. Coggrave, M.,Wiesel, P. H.,Norton, C. C.(2006).Management of faecal incontinence and constipation in adults with central neurological disease.Cochrane Database of Systematic Review,2,CD002115.
10. Correa, G. I.,Rotter, K. P.(2000).Clinical evaluation and management of neurogenic bowel after spinal cord injury.Spinal Cord,38(5),301-308.
11. Downs, S. H.,Black, N.(1998).The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomized and non-randomized studies of healthcare interventions.Journal of Epidemiology of Community Health,52(6),377-384.
12. Emmanuel, A.(2010).Rehabilitation in practice: Managing neurogenic bowel dysfunction.Clinical Rehabilitation,24(6),483-488.
13. Hu, C.,Ye, M.,Huang, Q.(2013).Effects of manual therapy on bowel function of patients with spinal cord injury.Journal of Physical Therapy Science,25(6),687-688.
14. Janssen, T. W. J.,Prakken, E. S.,Hendriks, J. M. S.,Lourens, C.,Van, D. V.,Smit, C. A. J.(2014).Electromechanical abdominal massage and colonic function in individuals with a spinal cord injury and chronic bowel problems.Spinal Cord,52(9),693-696.
15. Kassolik, K.,Andrzejewski, W.,Wilka, I.,Brzozowski, M.,Voyce, K.,Jaworska-Krawiecka, E.,Kurpas, D.(2015).The effectiveness of massage based on the tensegrity principle compared with classical abdominal massage performed on patients with constipation.Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics,61(2),202-211.
16. McClurg, D.,Lowe-Strong, A.(2011).Does abdominal massage relieve constipation?.Nursing Times,107(12),20-22.
17. Ozisler, Z.,Koklu, K.,Ozel, S.,Unsal-Delialioglu, S.(2015).Outcomes of bowel program in spinal cord injury patients with neurogenic bowel dysfunction.Neural Regeneration Research,10(7),1153-1158.
18. Pardee, C.,Bricker, D.,Rundquist, J.,MacRae, C.,Tebben, C.(2012).Characteristics of neurogenic bowel in spinal cord injury and perceived quality of life.Rehabilitation Nursing,37(3),128-135.
19. 王顏和、林光華(1994)。脊髓損傷之神經檢查與功能評估。中華民國物理治療學會雜誌，19(1)，78-87。
20. 李嘉綺、陳筱瑀、吳姿蓉(2012)。運用超連結系統理論於一位壯年期不完全性頸髓損傷個案重返職場之護理經驗。長庚護理雜誌，23(2)，268-275。

1. 胡嘉桂,林佩昭(2020).脊髓損傷者之持續性照護.領導護理,21(3),24-35.