比較精神科住院病人與Wilson-Sims跌倒風險評估量表之臨床診斷效果

Comparison of Clinical Diagnostic Effectiveness Between Psychiatric Inpatient and Wilson-Sims Fall Risk Assessment Tools

10.6224/JN.201906_66(3).06

鄒淑萍(Shu-Ping CHOU)；洪翠妹(Tsui-Mei HUNG)

精神科住院病人 ； 跌倒 ； 敏感度 ； 特異度 ； psychiatric inpatients ； fall ； sensitivity ； specificity

護理雜誌

66卷3期（2019 / 06 / 01）

35 - 45

繁體中文

背景：精神科住院病人跌倒率高，但缺乏有效驗證之跌倒評估量表來輔助醫療人員正確判斷。目的：比較精神科住院病人跌倒風險評估量表（Psychiatric Inpatient Fall Risk Assessment Tool，PIFRAT）與Wilson-Sims Fall Risk Assessment Tool（WSFRAT）之敏感度、特異度、準確度差異並預測精神科住院病人之跌倒危險因素。方法：本研究2016年10月1日至2017年3月10日於台灣北部某精神科醫院，針對新病人住院第1－7天進行跌倒評估資料收集。採描述性統計、邏輯斯迴歸分析、信效度檢測、工具效能檢測及ROC曲線（receiver operating characteristic curve）等分析資料。結果：兩種跌倒評估表敏感度不佳（WSFRAT 57.1%，PIFRAT 50.0%）； 特異度WSFRAT（79.6%）優於PIFRAT（70.4%）；準確度WSFRAT（76.9%）較PIFRAT（67.9%）佳。ROC曲線分析PIFRAT之AUC（area under the curve）=.602，95% CI［0.48，0.73］，根據Youden指數，最佳切點為7.5分，可達88.8%特異度及39.3%敏感度，若要提升敏感度至96.4%，則切點必須調整為1.5分。WSFRAT AUC=.625，最佳切點為3.5分可達82.1%敏感度。多變量邏輯斯迴歸顯示，過去曾跌倒者再跌倒的風險顯著高於無跌倒經驗者；男性病人（OR=2.57，95% CI［1.11，5.94］）、身體活動困難（OR=3.43；95% CI［1.40，8.41］）、虛弱無力（OR=3.03；95% CI［1.08，8.49］）等達統計顯著。結論／實務應用：研究發現四個重要的跌倒危險因素，未來臨床照護人員應提高警覺，發展跌倒相關防範措施。本研究結果亦可作為未來發展精神科跌倒評估量表之參考。

Background: The incidence of falls is very high among psychiatric inpatients. However, the lack of an effective, validated psychiatric inpatient fall risk assessment tool inhibits the ability of medical staffs to make correct judgments. Purpose: The purposes of this study were to compare the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of the psychiatric inpatient fall risk assessment tool (PIFRAT) and the Wilson-Sims fall risk assessment tool (WSFRAT) and to predict the fall risk factors in PIFRAT and WSFRAT for psychiatric inpatients. Methods: Study data were collected from 2016/10/01 to 2017/03/10. Fall assessment data were collected from new patients during their 1^(st) through 7^(th) days after admission to a psychiatry unit in northern Taiwan. Data were analyzed using descriptive analysis, logistic regression analysis, reliability and validity testing, tool effective testing, and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. Results: Both of the fall risk assessment tools exhibited low sensitivity (WSFRAT 57.1%, PIFRAT 50%), the specificity of WSFRAT (79.6%) was higher than that of PIFRAT (70.4%), and the accuracy of WSFRAT (76.9%) was higher than that of PIFRAT (67.9%). The ROC curve analysis revealed that the AUC of PIFRAT was .602 (95% CI [0.48, 0.73]). According to the Youden index, the best cutoff level is 7.5 points, in which the specificity is 88.8% and the sensitivity is 39.3%. To increase the sensitivity to 96.4%, the cutoff level must be set to 1.5 points. Moreover, the AUC of WSFRAT was .625 and the highest sensitivity was 82.1% when the cutoff point was set to 3.5 points. Further, multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that fall risk was significantly higher among patients who had previously fallen than among those had not. Male gender (OR = 2.57, 95% CI [1.11, 5.94]), physical activity difficulties (OR = 3.43; 95% CI [1.40, 8.41]), and weakness (OR = 3.03; 95% CI [1.08, 8.49]) were each significantly associated with fall risk. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: This study identified four critical risk factors for falls. In the future, clinical healthcare professionals should be more aware of these factors and develop related fall-prevention interventions. The findings may serve as references for the future development of psychiatric fall assessment tools.

1. Tseng, C. C.,Su, P. Y.,Huang, H. T.,Chang, Y. C.,Tai, Y. M.(2013).Risk factors for inpatient falls at a mental hospital.Taiwanese Journal of Psychiatry,27(2),131-139.
   連結：
2. 林小玲, S. L.,溫明寰, M. H.,陳玉枝, Y. C.(2010)。跌倒危險評估量表準確度之研究。醫護科技期刊，12(1)，47-59。
   連結：
3. 楊斐卿, F. C.,曾惠珍, H. C.(2017)。簡化住院病人跌倒風險篩檢表。榮總護理，34(1)，98-108。
   連結：
4. 裘苕莙, T. C.,蘇貞云, C. Y.,陳曼君, M. C.,吳肖琪, S. C.,葉馨婷, S. T.,吳欣怡, H. Y.,吳義勇, Y. Y.(2013)。設定單一醫療品質指標閾值應用於醫院不同科別之合宜性探討—以跌倒發生率為例。醫務管理期刊，14(4)，356-366。
   連結：
5. 鍾惠君, H. C.,章淑娟, S. C.,呂基燕, J. Y.,謝宗成, T. C.(2015)。應用ROC曲線分析驗證精簡版住院病人跌倒危險因子評估工具之準確度研究。志為護理—慈濟護理雜誌，14(6)，62-73。
   連結：
6. Abraham, S.(2016).Looking for a psychiatric fall risk assessment tool.Annals of Psychiatry and Mental Health,4(2),1061.
7. Ambrose, A. F.,Paul, G.,Hausdorff, J. M.(2013).Risk factors for falls among older adults: A review of the literature.Maturitas,75(1),51-61.
8. Callis, N.(2016).Falls prevention: Identification of predictive fall risk factors.Applied Nursing Research,29,53-58.
9. Chan, C. H.,Gau, S. S. F.,Chan, H. Y.,Tsai, Y. J.,Chiu, C. C.,Wang, S. M.,Huang, M. L.(2013).Risk factors for falling in psychiatric inpatients: A prospective, matched case-control study.Journal of Psychiatric Research,47(8),1088-1094.
10. Chen, H. Y.,Boore, J. R.(2010).Translation and back-translation in qualitative nursing research: Methodological review.Journal of Clinical Nursing,19(1–2),234-239.
11. Cohen, J.(1988).Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
12. Corley, D.,Brockopp, D.,McCowan, D.,Merritt, S.,Cobb, T.,Johnson, B.,Hall, B.(2014).The Baptist health high risk falls assessment: A methodological study.The Journal of Nursing Administration,44(5),263-269.
13. Cumbler, E. U.,Simpson, J. R.,Rosenthal, L. D.,Likosky, D. J.(2013).Inpatient falls: Defining the problem and identifying possible solutions. Part I: An evidence-based review.The Neurohospitalist,3(3),135-143.
14. Hendrich, A. L.,Bender, P. S.,Nyhuis, A.(2003).Validation of the Hendrich II falls risk model: A large concurrent case/control study of hospitalized patients.Applied Nursing Research,16(1),9-21.
15. Hou, W. H.,Kang, C. M.,Ho, M. H.,Kuo, J. M. C.,Chen, H. L.,Chang, W. Y.(2016).Evaluation of an inpatient fall risk screening tool to identify the most critical fall risk factors in inpatients.Journal of Clinical Nursing,26(5–6),698-706.
16. Jobson, M. D., Marder, S., & Hermann, R. (2017). Second-generation antipsychotic medications: Pharmacology, administration, and side effects. Retrieved from https://www.uptodate.com/contents/second-generation-antipsychotic-medications-pharmacology-administration-and-side-effects
17. Kruszewski, A., Killeen, M., Fettes, S., Wilson, S., & Sims, K. (2011). Content validity of Wilson-Sims falls risk assessment tool. Retrieved from http://www.meetingproceedings.com/2011/posters/apna/SplitViewer.asp?PID=MjAzNzYxOTY
18. Lavsa, S. M.,Fabian, T. J.,Saul, M. I.,Corman, S. L.,Coley, K. C.(2010).Influence of medications and diagnoses on fall risk in psychiatric inpatients.American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy,67(15),1274-1280.
19. Marston, L.,Nazareth, I.,Petersen, I.,Walters, K.,Osborn, D. P. J.(2014).Prescribing of antipsychotics in UK primary care: A cohort study.BMJ Open,4(12),e006135.
20. Myers, H.(2003).Hospital fall risk assessment tools: A critique of the literature.International Journal of Nursing Practice,9(4),223-235.
21. Powell-Cope, G.,Quigley, P.,Besterman-Dahan, K.,Smith, M.,Stewart, J.,Melillo, C.,Friedman, Y.(2014).A qualitative understanding of patient falls in inpatient mental health units.Journal of the American Psychiatric Nurses Association,20(5),328-339.
22. Rose, J. H.(2016).University of San Francisco.
23. Sano, T.,Harada, M.,Sugawara, T.,Isaka, N.,Masuoka, A.,Mikami, A.,Kurosawa, N.(2013).Use of psychotropics and the risk of falls in hospitalized psychiatric patients.Yakugaku Zasshi,133(8),897-903.
24. Scanlan, J.,Wheatley, J.,McIntosh, S.(2012).Characteristics of falls in inpatient psychiatric units.Australasian Psychiatry,20(4),305-308.
25. Stubbs, B.,Mueller, C.,Gaughran, F.,Lally, J.,Vancampfort, D.,Lamb, S. E.,Perera, G.(2018).Predictors of falls and fractures leading to hospitalization in people with schizophrenia spectrum disorder: A large representative cohort study.Schizophrenia Research,201,70-78.
26. Van Dyke, D.,Singley, B.,Speroni, K. G.,Daniel, M. G.(2014).Evaluation of fall risk assessment tools for psychiatric patient fall prevention: A comparative study.Journal of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental Health Services,52(12),30-35.
27. Youden, W. J.(1950).Index for rating diagnostic tests.Cancer,3(1),32-35.
28. 吳錦蓉, C. J.,施欣怡, S. I.,呂育陞, Y. S.,張家銘, C. M.(2012)。社區老年人因跌倒入急診之評估處置。台灣老年醫學暨老年學雜誌，7(1)，1-14。
29. 李欣雅, H. Y.,陳彥宏, Y. H.,劉建宏, C. H.(2015)。評估Flurazepam與住院病人發生跌倒傷害的危險因子。臺灣臨床藥學雜誌，23(3)，215-223。
30. 李麗花, L. H.,羅惠敏, H. M.,林麗娟, L. C.,鍾蝶起, T. C.,李茹萍, R. P.(2005)。精神科住院病患跌倒因素之探討。志為護理—慈濟護理雜誌，5(1)，78-87。
31. 財團法人醫院評鑑暨醫療品質策進會=Joint Commission of Taiwan(2016)。台灣病人安全通報系統 2016年年報
32. 陳文慶, W. C.,孔秀美, S. M.,吳明寶, M. P.,黃景祥, J. S.(2010)。某精神科醫院精神分裂症病人不同發病年層平均餘命的比較。生活科學學報，14，123-138。
33. 黃郁如, Y. J.,鄭婷婷, T. T.,呂韻如, Y. R.,郭珮嫆, P. R.,洪毅芳, Y. F.(2009)。降低精神科急性病房病患跌倒發生率之改善專案。嘉基護理，9(2)，18-27。
34. 蔡佳吟, C. Y.,侯淑英, S. Y.(2010)。精神科急性病房預防跌倒改善專案。精神衛生護理雜誌，5(1)，29-39。
35. 禚昌麟, C. L.,陳其嶸, C. R.,張雁晴, Y. C.,楊沛穎, P. Y.,徐玉英, Y. Y.,陳明德, M. D.(2015)。運動訓練對老年精神障礙者的平衡與行走成效─採專業合作模式。職能治療學會雜誌，33(2)，149-167。