臨床情境模擬教學促進護理人員因應職場暴力之成效研究

Clinical Simulation Teaching Program to Promote the Effectiveness of Nurses in Coping With Workplace Violence

10.6224/JN.201906_66(3).08

明金蓮(Jin-Lain MING)；曾麗華(Li-Hua TSENG)；黃惠美(Hui-Mei HUANG)；洪曉佩(Shiao-Pei HONG)；張靜怡(Ching-I CHANG)；董貞吟(Chen-Yin TUNG)

情境模擬教學 ； 護理 ； 職場暴力 ； simulation teaching ； nursing ； workplace violence

護理雜誌

66卷3期（2019 / 06 / 01）

59 - 71

繁體中文

背景：職場暴力是一個嚴重的全球性現象，護理人員乃為醫療職場暴力中最常受攻擊之對象，不僅危害身心健康，影響工作士氣，甚至導致人員流失，對機構與護理專業造成嚴重傷害。目的：本研究以職場暴力情境模擬教學訓練課程做為介入措施，期望能提升護理人員對職場暴力之認知、態度與因應自信。方法：以類實驗設計，隨機分配選取臺北市某醫學中心臨床護理人員400人，實際參與392人，實驗組200人接受臨床情境模擬教學訓練課程，對照組192人未提供介入措施；於課程介入前、後，以問卷進行資料收集，並採SPSS V23版統計軟體以GEE（generalized estimating equations）模式進行統計分析。結果：臨床情境模擬教學課程介入後，護理人員對於職場暴力認知、態度與因應自信，實驗組的前後測得分變化皆高於對照組，達統計上顯著之差異（p＜.001）。進一步分析認知方面：年齡愈大、護理級階為N3者，得分較高；態度方面：護理級階越高，得分越高；因應自信：男性優於女性、急診與精神科護理人員較佳。結論：「臨床情境模擬教學課程」可提升護理人員對於職場暴力之認知、態度與因應自信，期可降低遭受職場暴力之風險與傷害。未來亦建議可以針對不同級階、科別或單位特性，發展相關職場暴力預防之情境教學課程。

Background: Workplace violence is a phenomenon that is prevalent around the world. Nursing personnel are one of the most frequent victims of workplace attacks. Beyond the harm done to physical health, mental health, and workplace morale, workplace violence also leads to the loss of personnel and causes severe injury to institutions and nursing professionals. Purpose: The aim of this study is to improve the awareness, attitudes, and self-confidence of nurses with regard to workplace violence using clinical simulation teaching and training courses. Methods: A total of 400 clinical nurses at a tertiary hospital in Taipei City were enrolled and randomly assigned into either the experimental group, which received the education intervention, or the control group, which received no intervention. A total of 392 enrolled participants completed the study, including 200 in the experimental group and 192 in the control group. Before and after the intervention, a structured questionnaire was used to collect data, which were analyzed using a GEE model with SPSS V.23. Results: After the clinical simulation teaching course, awareness of workplace violence as well as related attitudes and self-confidence were higher in the experimental group than the control group. Moreover, the posttest scores and pretest-posttest differences in scores were significantly higher in the experimental group than in the control group (p ＜ .001). Advanced analysis of the data showed that cognition scores, being older in age, and having a registered nurse grade of N3 were all associated with earning a higher score. In addition, in terms of attitude, registered nurse grade was found to correlate positively with score. Further, male participants earned higher self-confidence scores than their female colleagues and participants who worked in either the emergency or psychiatric departments earned higher scores. Conclusions: The ＂Workplace Violence Clinical Simulation Teaching and Training Course＂ was shown to improve the awareness, attitudes, and self-confidence of clinical nurses with regard to workplace violence and may thus help reduce the risk and harm of violence in this category. In the future, contextual teaching courses on workplace violence prevention should be developed for different nursing levels, divisions, and units based on their specific characteristics and needs.

1. 明金蓮, J. L.,洪曉佩, S. P.,黃惠美, H. M.,黃瓊慧, C. H.,曾麗華, L. H.,董貞吟, C. Y.(2017)。以焦點團體法探討急診護理人員對急診職場暴力之認知與因應。榮總護理，34(2)，147-156。
   連結：
2. 明金蓮, J. L.,黃惠美, H. M.,洪曉佩, S. P.,曾麗華, L. H.,黃美淑, M. S.,江淑華, S. H.,董貞吟, C. Y.(2016)。以系統性文獻回顧探討護理人員職場暴力現況與影響。台灣公共衛生雜誌，35(2)，116-135。
   連結：
3. 賴擁連, Y. L.,苗延宇, Y. Y.(2017)。日常活動理論分析護理人員職場暴力被害恐懼感之成因。中華心理衛生學刊，30(2)，195-219。
   連結：
4. Adams, J.,Knowles, A.,Irons, G.,Roddy, A.,Ashworth, J.(2017).Assessing the effectiveness of clinical education to reduce the frequency and recurrence of workplace violence.Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing,34(3),6-15.
5. Allison, G.,MacPhee, C.,Noullett, H.(2017).Violence prevention exercises: Enhancing safety through simulation training.Canadian Nurse,113(3),36-38.
6. Ball, C. A.,Kurtz, A. M.,Reed, T.(2015).Evaluating violent person management training for medical students in an emergency medicine clerkship.Southern Medical Journal,108(9),520-523.
7. Besar, S. N.(2018).Situated learning theory: The key to effective classroom teaching?.International Journal for Educational, Social, Political & Cultural Studies,1(1),49-60.
8. Cashmore, A. W.,Indig, D.,Hampton, S. E.,Hegney, D. G.,Jalaludin, B. B.(2012).Workplace violence in a large correctional health service in New South Wales, Australia: A retrospective review of incident management records.BMC Health Services Research,12(1),245.
9. Coyne, E.,Frommolt, V.,Rands, H.,Kain, V.,Mitchell, M.(2018).Simulation videos presented in a blended learning platform to improve Australian nursing students’ knowledge of family assessment.Nurse Education Today,66,96-102.
10. Duxbury, J.(2002).An evaluation of staff and patient views of and strategies employed to manage inpatient aggression and violence on one mental health unit: A pluralistic design.Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing,9(3),325-337.
11. Edward, K.-L.,Ousey, K.,Warelow, P.,Lui, S.(2014).Nursing and aggression in the workplace: A systematic review.British Journal of Nursing,23(12),653-659.
12. Feinstein, R. E.(2014).Violence prevention education program for psychiatric outpatient departments.Academic Psychiatry,38(5),639-646.
13. Guay, S.,Goncalves, J.,Boyer, R.(2016).Evaluation of an education and training program to prevent and manage patients’ violence in a mental health setting: A pretest-posttest intervention study.Healthcare,4(3),49.
14. Heckemann, B.,Breimaier, H. E.,Halfens, R. J. G.,Schols, J. M. G. A.,Hahn, S.(2016).The participant's perspective: Learning from an aggression management training course for nurses. Insights from a qualitative interview study.Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences,30(3),574-585.
15. Heckemann, B.,Zeller, A.,Hahn, S.,Dassen, T.,Schols, J. M. G. A.,Halfens, R. J. G.(2015).The effect of aggression management training programmes for nursing staff and students working in an acute hospital setting. A narrative review of current literature.Nurse Education Today,35(1),212-219.
16. Humphreys, M.(2013).Developing an educational framework for the teaching of simulation within nurse education.Open Journal of Nursing,3(4),363-371.
17. Khademloo, M.,Moonesi, F. S.,Gholizade, H.(2013).Health care violence and abuse towards nurses in hospitals in north of Iran.Global Journal of Health Science,5(4),211-216.
18. Kynoch, K.,Wu, C. J.,Chang, A. M.(2011).Interventions for preventing and managing aggressive patients admitted to an acute hospital setting: A systematic review.Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing,8(2),76-86.
19. Lamont, S.,Brunero, S.(2018).The effect of a workplace violence training program for generalist nurses in the acute hospital setting: A quasi-experimental study.Nurse Education Today,68,45-52.
20. Liang, K. Y.,Zeger, S. L.(1986).Longitudinal data analysis using generalized linear models.Biometrika,73(1),13-22.
21. Lo, T. W.,Chappell, D.,Kwok, S. I.,Wu, J.(2012).Workplace violence in Hong Kong, China: Nature, impact, and preparedness.International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology,56(6),955-975.
22. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. (2002). Violence occupational hazards in hospitals. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-101/pdfs/2002-101.pdf?id=10.26616/NIOSHPUB2002101
23. Needham, I.,Abderhalden, C.,Dassen, T.,Haug, H. J.,Fischer, J. E.(2004).The perception of aggression by nurses: Psychometric scale testing and derivation of a short instrument.Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing,11(1),36-42.
24. Pich, J.,Hazelton, M.,Sundin, D.,Kable, A.(2010).Patient-related violence against emergency department nurses.Nursing & Health Sciences,12(2),268-274.
25. Salam, T.,Saylor, J. L.,Cowperthwait, A. L.(2015).Attitudes of nurse and physician trainees towards an interprofessional simulated education experience on pain assessment and management.Journal of Interprofessional Care,29(3),276-278.
26. Spector, P. E.,Zhou, Z. E.,Che, X. X.(2014).Nurse exposure to physical and nonphysical violence, bullying, and sexual harassment: A quantitative review.International Journal of Nursing Studies,51(1),72-84.
27. Speroni, K. G.,Fitch, T.,Dawson, E.,Dugan, L.,Atherton, M.(2014).Incidence and cost of nurse workplace violence perpetrated by hospital patients or patient visitors.Journal of Emergency Nursing,40(3),218-228.
28. Thackrey, M.(1987).Clinician confidence in coping with patient aggression: Assessment and enhancement.Professional Psychology: Research and Practice,18(1),57-60.
29. Ünsal Atan, Ş,Baysan Arabaci, L.,Sirin, A.,Isler, A.,Donmez, S.,Unsal Guler, M.,Yazar Tasbasi, F.(2013).Violence experienced by nurses at six university hospitals in Turkey.Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing,20(10),882-889.
30. Wilkinson, S.,Perry, R.,Blanchard, K.,Linsell, L.(2008).Effectiveness of a three-day communication skills course in changing nurses’ communication skills with cancer/palliative care patients: A randomised controlled trial.Palliative Medicine,22(4),365-375.
31. 吳佩樺, P. H.,陳茹芳, R. F.,翁于晴, Y. C.,張蕙瀅, H. Y.,洪瑞鎂, R. M.(2017)。淺談臺澳護理教育之情境模擬教學：以澳洲中央昆士蘭大學及長庚科技大學為例。長庚科技學刊，27，87-96。
32. 林小玲, S. L.,尹祚芊, T. J. C.,黃惠美, H. M.(2012)。某醫學中心護理工作職場暴力評估之研究。榮總護理，29(2)，176-186。
33. 林淑芳, S. F.,雲安琪, A. C.,張書菁, S. C.(2016)。工作滿意度、護理人員留任意願—以職場暴力為調節變數。健康管理學刊，14(2)，43-68。
34. 施麗香, L. H.,黃心樹, H. S.(2015)。人力資源彈性運用對護理人員留任意願之影響。澄清醫護管理雜誌，11(2)，15-23。
35. 徐宗國, T. K.(2001)。拓邊照顧工作：男護士在女人工作世界中得其所在。臺灣社會學刊，26，163-209。
36. 張豐圃, F. P.(2017)。急診職場暴力的處理與預防。中華職業醫學雜誌，24(2)，103-113。
37. 勞動部（2017）．執行職務遭受不法侵害預防指引．取自https://laws.mol.gov.tw/FLAW/FLAWDAT0202.aspx?lsid=FL085196 [Ministry of Labor, Taiwan, ROC. (2017). Guide to preventing illicit harm in workplace settings. Retrieved from https://laws.mol.gov.tw/FLAW/FLAWDAT0202.aspx?lsid=FL085196]
38. 曾雅玲, Y. L.,陳靜如, C. J.(2008)。男護士臨床護理工作之生活經驗。實證護理，4(1)，61-70。
39. 黃珮芳, P. F.,應純哲, J. C.,潘豐泉, F. F. C.,馬震中, C. C.(2016)。醫院急診室工作人員的職場暴力預防行為意圖分析。寶建醫護與管理雜誌，13(1&2)，29-43。
40. 鄭展志, C. C.,張孟玲, M. L.,陳穎瑜, Y. Y.,黃曉玲, H. L.,蔡衣帆, Y. F.(2017)。急診暴力的原因分析與預防因應措施。北市醫學雜誌，14(2)，139-146。

1. 蔡騏任,黃品惟,陳冠戎,許瀚仁,邱詠朗(2023)。運用遊戲化教學探討國軍軍護於戰地／災地模擬情境之照護技能學習成效。源遠護理，17(2)，52-61。
2. 蔡諭回,劉寶珠,張雲英,姚愛珠(2022)。運用心智圖創新教學於氣切滑脫處置能力訓練之學習成效。嘉基護理，22(1)，1-11。
3. 李睿軒,石惠美(2021)。急診職場暴力與護理人員之韌性。長庚護理，32(4)，39-47。
4. 趙燕,王智弘,王郁琮(2019)。臨床護理師職業倦怠雙元三因子效度研究。教育心理學報，51(2)，207-230。