题名

獨立性護理業務之護病糾紛爭訟

并列篇名

Nurse and Patient Dispute Litigation in Independent Nursing Practice

DOI

10.6224/JN.202006_67(3).08

作者

呂曉寬(Shaio-Kuan LU)；蔡芸芳(Yun-Fang TSAI)；陳月枝(Yueh-Chih CHEN)；林萍章(Pyng-Jing LIN)

关键词

護理業務 ； 業務過失 ； 護病糾紛 ； 刑事判決 ； nursing practice ； practice negligence ； nurse patient disputes ； criminal judgments

期刊名称

護理雜誌

卷期/出版年月

67卷3期（2020 / 06 / 01）

页次

56 - 63

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

背景：護理人員與病患爭訟案件與日俱增，然而目前研究護理人員因護病糾紛進入法院爭訟之相關文獻較少。目的：本研究目的為探討護病糾紛中獨立性護理業務爭訟之背景屬性、獨立性護理業務爭訟類別、以及法院裁判案由與判決結果。方法：採質性研究，由司法院法學資料檢索系統選取臺灣地方法院2008-2017年獨立性護理業務爭訟之刑事判決書，以內容分析法進行分析。結果：共有41間醫療院所，55位護理人員涉案。醫院屬性以區域醫院（36.6%）、內科醫療（31.7%）、一般內外科病房（46.3%），及小夜班（40.0%）居多；護理職稱則以護理師（85.5%）最多。獨立性護理業務爭訟可分為觀察評估、環境安全、通報醫師、及護理記錄等四類別。法院裁判案由以業務過失致死（58.2%）最多，共有10名（18.2%）護理人員面臨有罪判決的結果。結論／實務應用：本研究結果可協助臨床護理人員了解獨立性護理業務導致爭訟內容及判決結果，期望能預防護病爭訟發生。
英文摘要

Background: Although medical dispute and other contentious cases involving patients and nurses have risen significantly in recent years, few studies have examined the litigation issues involved in nurse-patient disputes. Purpose: This study was designed to explore the background, categories, and degrees of harm to patients and the judgments made by the courts. Methods: Qualitative research was used. Cases of criminal, written judgments related to nurse practice negligence and recorded in district courts in Taiwan from 2008 to 2017 were selected. Data were analyzed using content analysis. Results: A total of 41 hospitals and 55 nurses were identified. The largest number of cases involved regional hospitals (36.6%), internal medicine departments (31.7%), general wards (46.3%), night shifts (40.0%), and staff nurses (85.5%). Four categories of independent nurse practice negligence were identified, including observation-evaluation, environmental security, physician notification, and nursing records. Negligent homicide (58.2%) was the most common court judgment and ten nurses (18.2%) were found guilty of the charges brought against them. Conclusion/ Implications for Practice: The results of this study highlight for nurses the content of nurse practice negligence and the related judgments by the courts, which hopefully may guide nurses to avoid practice negligence in the future.
主题分类 醫藥衛生 > 預防保健與衛生學
醫藥衛生 > 社會醫學
参考文献
  1. 王采芷, T. J.,郭斐翎, P. L.(2019)。進階護理的發展與現況。源遠護理，13(1)，5-13。
    連結：
  2. 朱宗藍, T. L.(2018)。中華民國護理師護士公會全國聯合會護理人力政策之規畫與推動。領導護理，19(4)，3-10。
    連結：
  3. 邱慧洳, H. J.(2016)。專科護理師輔助醫療行為適法性之探討。國立中正大學法學集刊，53，231-276。
    連結：
  4. 洪翠蓮, T. L.,齊偉先, W. H.(2019)。臺灣專科護理師在臨床實務上面臨的困境與挑戰。台灣專科護理師學刊，6(1)，12-21。
    連結：
  5. 郭淑珍, S. C.,邱文宏, W. H.,胡月娟, Y. J.,賴慧貞, H. J.(2016)。機構照顧疏失類型分析—以法院判決案例。長期照護雜誌，20(3)，269-290。
    連結：
  6. Angelini, D.,Greenwald, L.(2005).Closed claims analysis of 65 medical malpractice cases involving nurse midwives.Journal of Midwifery & Women’s Health,50(6),454-460.
  7. Benner, P.,Sheets, V.,Uris, P.,Malloch, K.,Schwed, K.,Jamison, D.(2002).Individual, practices, and system causes of errors in nursing: A taxonomy.JONA: The Journal of Nursing Administration,32(10),509-523.
  8. Denzin, N. K.(Ed.),Lincoln, Y. S.(Ed.)(1994).Handbook of qualitative research.London, England:Sage.
  9. Hyman, D. A.,Silver, C.(2012).Medical malpractice and compensation in global perspective: How does the U.S. do it?.Chicago-Kent Law Review,87(1),163-198.
  10. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  11. Morse, J. M.(1991).Negotiating commitment and involvement in the nurse patient relationship.Journal of Advanced Nursing,16(4),455-468.
  12. Nanda, A.,Wasan, A.,Sussman, J.(2017).Provider health and wellness.The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology: In Practice,5(6),1543-1548.
  13. Peplau, H. E.(1952).Interpersonal relations in nursing: A conceptual frame of reference for psychodynamic nursing.New York, NY:Springer.
  14. Rush, B.,Cook, J.(2006).What makes a good nurse? Views of patients and carers.British Journal of Nursing,15(7),382-385.
  15. 全國法規資料庫（2020）．護理人員法．取自https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?PCode=L0020166 [Laws & Regulations Database of The Republic China. (2020).Nursing Personnel Act. Retrieved from https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?PCode=L0020166]
  16. 陳鏡華, C. H.,李曉惠, H. H.(2018)。刑事法上醫療過失之認定案例分析。醫療品質雜誌，12(3)，56-65。
  17. 黃婉筠, W. Y.,翁慧卿, H. C.,孫淑芬, S. F.(2016)。物理治療人員醫療錯誤行為調查與發生因素認知之探討。物理治療，41(4)，242-253。
  18. 黃惠滿, H. M.,孫凡軻, F. K.(2014)。兒科護理人員業務過失有責任之個案研究。護理雜誌，61(2)，63-73。
  19. 臺北市政府衛生局（2016）．醫療爭議．取自https://health.gov.taipei/Content_List.aspx?n=3BDD8E009C9270F0 [Department of Health, Taipei City Government. (2016). Medical dispute. Retrieved from http://health.gov.taipei/Content_List.aspx?n=3BDD8E009C9270F0]
  20. 劉邦揚, P. Y.(2011)。我國地方法院刑事醫療糾紛判決的實證分析：2000年至2010年。科技法學評，8(2)，257-294。
  21. 劉邦揚, P. Y.(2016)。刑事醫療糾紛判決於上訴審的實證考察。中研院法學期刊，18，267-313。
  22. 劉彩娥, T. E.,應立志, L. C.,王萬琳, W. L.(2016)。某醫院住院病房之護病關係。醫院雙月刊，49(1)，34-45。
  23. 衛生福利部醫事司（2019，8月6日）．受理委託醫事鑑定收案件數統計表（統計區間：1987年-2018年）．取自https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-42067-ad196d3c-b5d8-47a3-a3f0-f1251bc35fa1.html [Department of Medical Affairs, Ministry of Health and Welfare, Taiwan, ROC. (2019, August 6). Numbers of medical dispute cases (Statistical interval: 1987-2018). Retrieved from https://www.mohw.gov.tw/dl-42067-ad196d3c-b5d8-47a3-a3f0-f1251bc35fa1.html]
print cancel