降低急診護理人員執行急救處置缺失率

Reducing False Alarms and Absent Treatments by Nurses During Resuscitation in the Emergency Department

10.6224/JN.202104_68(2).10

王柏予(Bo-Yu WANG)；古雅鈴(Ya-Ling KU)；許瑟音(Se-Yin SHEU)；陳麗貞(Li-Chen CHEN)；施美娟(Mei-Chuan SHIH)

急診 ； 急救處置 ； 缺失率 ； emergency ； emergency resuscitation ； false alarms

護理雜誌

68卷2期（2021 / 04 / 01）

75 - 84

繁體中文

背景：以病人安全為中心是目前醫療管理的主流，尤其急救處置關係著病人生命安全，根據統計顯示2017年急診同仁反應的急救室急救處置缺失中，因新進人員評估錯誤而啟動急救小組造成家屬恐慌產生多件抱怨事件，引發專案小組進行改善的動機，調查顯示2018年6月急診急救處置缺失率為18.7％，分析缺失原因並確立問題為急救小組缺乏工作職責分配及新進人員實務訓練不足。目的：降低急診護理人員執行急救處置缺失率由原18.7％降低至0％。解決方案：修訂急救團隊角色工作分配、規劃使用「急救APP」、設計急救室急救小組位置圖、團隊擬真教育訓練及團隊分配作業宣導並建立定期稽核及持續追蹤制度。結果：經由專案實施改善後，急診護理人員執行急救處置缺失率由18.7％下降至0％。結論：急救流程與病人安全息息相關，團隊合作是其中最重要的因素，專案經由修訂「急救團隊工作職責分配」，舉辦「急救處置教育訓練」，其中包括「擬真實務訓練課程」，以提升急救人員團隊默契；藉由本專案改善策略，包括以急救作業職責海報及急救流程查核表來管理團隊運作，利用分工合作的團隊精神降低急救處置的缺失率，增進病人急救過程安全無虞、減少異常事件發生，提升團隊資源管理成效。

Background & Problems: Medical management protocols prioritize the safety of patients during emergency resuscitation situations. According to a medical center in Taiwan statistics gathered in 2017, the unnecessary activation of resuscitation teams by new nurses because of their improper assessment of patient conditions was a significant cause of anxiety in patient relatives and source of complaints directed at the medical center. In June 2018, 18.7% of the emergency resuscitation calls in the emergency department (ED) were false alarms or absent treatment incidents. After investigation, lack of clearly stated resuscitation team member responsibilities and insufficient practical training for new nurses were primary factors associated with the high rate of false alarm/absent treatment incidents in the ED. Purpose: To decrease the rate of absent treatment by nurses during resuscitation from 18.7% to 0% in the ED. Resolution: The assignments of emergency team members were revised, a new ＂Emergency app＂ was introduced, the assignment schedule of the emergency resuscitation team was distributed, SIM realistic education training was held, stronger team work was promoted, and a standard assignment review schedule was established and regularly monitored. Result: After the introduction of the resolution measures, the false alarm / absent treatment incidents in the ED caused by ED nurses dropped from 18.7% to 0%. Conclusion: Resuscitation workflow is closely related to patient safety, and teamwork among colleagues critical to successful resuscitation. The project revised resuscitation teamwork assignments and organized resuscitation education training, including simulation courses, to enhance the understanding of team members. The strategy outlined in this paper may be used to raise awareness using posters and resuscitation record checklists to track and manage the team's progress. This project was designed to enhance teamwork to decrease the rate of absent treatment and to provide safe and quality resuscitation care in order to improve resource management by the team to increase productivity.

1. 江惠英, H.-Y.(2015)。再談團隊資源管理。領導護理，16(4)，2-10。
   連結：
2. 張玉霞, Y.-H.,李湘鳳, H.-F.,曾燕萍, Y.-P.,蔡秀玲,謝雪貞(2017)。運用醫療團隊資源管理提升某復健單位護理人員急救能力。台灣專科護理師學刊，4(1)，56-66。
   連結：
3. 鄭青青, C.-C.,張乃丹, N.-T.,林幼麗, Y.-L.,賀倫惠, L.-H.,余文彬, W.-P.,郭惠敏, S. H.-M.(2017)。提昇神經內科病房院內急救完整性之專案。長庚護理，28(1)，85-99。
   連結：
4. 賴佩芳, P.-F.,吳彬安, P.-A.(2018)。利用資訊系統優化急診部ACLS流程。護理雜誌，65(4)，24-29。
   連結：
5. Bliss, M.,Aitken, L. M.(2018).Does simulation enhance nurses’ ability to assess deteriorating patients?.Nurse Education in Practice,28,20-26.
6. Buchanan, J.,Dawkins, P.,Lindo, J. L. M.(2015).Satisfaction with nursing care in the emergency department of an urban hospital in the developing world: A pilot study.International Emergency Nursing,23(3),218-224.
7. Lin, M.-H.,Peng, L.-N.,Chen, L.-K.,Chen, T.-J.,Hwang, S.-J.(2012).Cardiopulmonary resuscitation for hospital inpatients in Taiwan: An 8-year nationwide survey.Resuscitation,83(3),343-346.
8. Link, M. S.,Berkow, L. C.,Kudenchuk, P. J.,Halperin, H. R.,Hess, E. P.,Moitra, V. K.,Neumar, R. W.,O’Neil, B. J.,Paxton, J. H.,Silvers, S. M.,White, R. D.,Yannopoulos, D.,Donnino, M. W.(2015).Part 7: Adult advanced cardiovascular life support: 2015 American Heart Association guidelines update for cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascular care.Circulation,132(18, Suppl. 2),S444-S464.
9. Niles, D. E.,Nishisaki, A.,Sutton, R. M.,Elci, O. U.,Meaney, P. A.,OʼConnor, K. A.,Leffelman, J.,Kramer-Johansen, J.,Berg, R. A.,Nadkarni, V.(2017).Improved retention of chest compression psychomotor skills with brief "rolling refresher" training.Simulation in Healthcare,12(4),213-219.
10. Pennington, K. M.,Dong, Y.,Coville, H. H.,Wang, B.,Gajic, O.,Kelm, D. J.(2018).Evaluation of TEAM dynamics before and after remote simulation training utilizing CERTAIN platform.Medical Education Online,23(1),Article 1485431.
11. Tanz, M.(2018).Improving safety knowledge, skills, and attitudes with a good catch program and student-designed simulation.Journal of Nursing Education,57(6),379-384.
12. 李玉茹, Y.-R.,王怡婷, Y.-T.(2013)。談急救能力與經驗。志為護理—慈濟護理雜誌，12(2)，14-21。
13. 李惠珍, H.-J.,高麗茹, L.-J.,詹淑惠, S.-H.(2016)。在擬真情境下應用客觀結構式臨床測驗評量新進護理人員急救技能之成效。台灣擬真醫學教育期刊，3(1)，3-10。
14. 林嘉玲, C.-L.,林君萍, C.-P.,蘇美禎, M.-C.,張媚, M.(2014)。情境模擬教學在護理教育。台灣醫學，18(2)，238-243。
15. 邱俊仁, C.-Z.,徐國基, K.-G.,吳鋼治, G.-J.,邱浩彰, H.-C.,楊國卿, K.-C.,侯勝茂, S.-M.,張嘉宇, P. C. Y.,賴寶琴, B.-C.,施玉珊, Y.-S.,鄭瑞楠, J.-N.,廖若雯, J.-W.,廖熏香, H.-H.(2014)。以醫療品質突破系列提昇院內心跳停止事件急救之照護品質。台灣醫學，18(2)，226-237。
16. 陳夏蓮, S.-L.,黃采薇, T.-W.,劉千琪, C.-C.,李薇莉, W.-L.(2014)。情境模擬教學與學習理論於護理教育之應用。榮總護理，31(3)，220-225。
17. 蕭政廷, C.-T.(2014)。台灣擬真醫學教育之發展與現況。台灣醫學擬真教育期刊，1(1)，18-21。
18. 謝明芫, M.-Y.,謝素英, S.-I.,許麗齡, L.-L.(2014)。某醫學中心護理人員接受高級心臟救命術課程自評執行急救能力之研究。新臺北護理期刊，16(1)，17-28。

1. 蘇欣怡,黃珮庭,陳勤策,周佩君(2023)。應用團隊資源管理與擬真訓練提升急救流程完整率。護理雜誌，70(1)，78-88。