促進醫院安全風氣－由安全領導層面探討

Promoting Hospital Safety Culture: The Perspective of Safety Leadership

10.6224/JN.202210_69(5).03

曹常成(Charng-Cheng TSAUR)；李金泉(Jing-Chuan LEE)

健康照護組織 ； 醫院安全 ； 醫院安全風氣 ； health care organization ； hospital safety ； hospital safety culture

護理雜誌

69卷5期（2022 / 10 / 01）

14 - 20

繁體中文

在安全的文化中，對零傷害目標以及實現該目標所需的持續改進和創新有著堅定的承諾。然而目前在許多健康照護組織，安全往往是被疏忽且事後才想到的，或者充其量只是一個遙遠的次要問題，沒有承諾感亦無零傷害的目標。本文首先簡述安全文化的起源與定義、安全文化的組成、以及安全文化金字塔；其次是談論醫院安全風氣的定義、重要性與影響作用、以及醫院安全風氣的評估工具；最後則是引介國外許多促進醫院安全風氣的領導實務指引，可供國內健康照護組織之參考與應用。病人安全是一種動態而複雜的現象，因此，建議每兩到三年進行一次研究和調查醫院安全風氣，以確保病人安全的最佳實踐，實現病人安全和醫院安全風氣的持續改進需要各層級領導。同時，需要在整個健康照護系統中灌輸全面安全文化，領導層和管理層的承諾對於建立和維護一個安全的、以人為本的環境至關重要。

Cultures of safety share a strong commitment to the goal of achieving zero harm and to continuously implementing the improvements and innovations necessary to achieve this goal. However, in some healthcare organizations today, safety is often undervalued and considered only after the occurrence of safety incidents, with no sense of commitment and no goal of zero harm. This article first briefly introduces the origin and definition of safety culture, the composition of safety culture, and the safety culture pyramid. Secondly, the definition, importance, and impact of hospital safety culture as well as the assessment tools for hospital safety culture are discussed. Finally, many practical leadership guidelines used in other countries to promote hospital safety culture are introduced as references for domestic healthcare organizations. Because patient safety is a dynamic and complex phenomenon, research and surveys of hospital safety culture conducted every two to three years are recommended to ensure best practices in patient safety. Achieving continuous improvement in patient safety and hospital safety culture requires leadership at all levels. In tandem, a total safety culture must be instilled throughout the health system. Commitment from leadership and management is critical to establishing and maintaining a safe, people-centered environment.

1. American College of Healthcare Executives,IHI/NPSF Lucian Leape Institute(2017).Leading a culture of safety: A blueprint for success.:American College of Healthcare Executives.
2. Azyabi, A.,Karwowski, W.,Davahli, M. R.(2021).Assessing patient safety culture in hospital settings.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,18(5),Article 2466.
3. Brborović, H.,Šklebar, I.,Brborović, O.,Brumen, V.,Mustajbegović, J.(2014).Development of a Croatian version of the US hospital survey on patient safety culture questionnaire: Dimensionality and psychometric properties.Postgraduate Medical Journal,90(1061),125-132.
4. Brennan, T. A.,Leape, L. L.,Laird, N. M.,Hebert, L.,Localio, A. R.,Lawthers, A. G.,Newhouse, J. P.,Weiler, P. C.,Hiatt, H. H.(1991).Incidence of adverse events and negligence in hospitalized patients: Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study I.The New England Journal of Medicine,324(6),370-376.
5. Busse, R.(Ed.),Klazinga, N.(Ed.),Panteli, D.(Ed.),Quentin, W.(Ed.)(2019).Improving healthcare quality in Europe: Characteristics, effectiveness and implementation of different strategies.World Health Organization.
6. Busse, R.,Klazinga, N.,Panteli, D.,Quentin, W.(2019).Improving healthcare quality in Europe: Characteristics, effectiveness and implementation of different strategies.:OECD Publishing.
7. de Bienassis, K.,Klazinga, N.(2022).Developing international benchmarks of patient safety culture in hospital care.OECD Health Working Papers,134
8. de Bienassis, K.,Llena-Nozal, A.,Klazinga, N.(2020).The economics of patient safety part III: Long-term care: Valuing safety for the long haul.:OECD Publishing.
9. Edwards, J. R. D.,Davey, J.,Armstrong, K.(2013).Returning to the roots of culture: A review and re-conceptualisation of safety culture.Safety Science,55,70-80.
10. Frankel, A.,Haraden, C.,Federico, F.,Lenoci-Edwards, J.(2017).A framework for safe, reliable, and effective care.:Institute for Healthcare Improvement.
11. Health and Safety Commission(1993).ACSNI Human Factors Study Group. Third report: Organising for safety.Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
12. Huang, C.-H.,Wu, H.-H.,Lee, Y.-C.(2018).The perceptions of patient safety culture: A difference between physicians and nurses in Taiwan.Applied Nursing Research,40,39-44.
13. Institute of Medicine(2001).Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system for the 21st century.National Academies Press.
14. Jha, A. K.,Larizgoitia, I.,Audera-Lopez, C.,Prasopa-Plaizier, N.,Waters, H.,Bates, D. W.(2013).The global burden of unsafe medical care: Analytic modelling of observational studies.BMJ Quality & Safety,22(10),809-815.
15. Kohn, L. T.,Corrigan, J. M.,Donaldson, M. S.(2000).To err is human: Building a safer health system.National Academies Press.
16. Leape, L. L.(Ed.)(2000).Making healthcare safe: The story of the patient safety movement.Springer Nature.
17. Pronovost, P.,Sexton, B.(2005).Assessing safety culture: Guidelines and recommendations.BMJ Quality & Safety,14(4),231-233.
18. Reason, J. T.(2016).Managing the risks of organizational accidents.Routledge Taylor & Francis Group.
19. Reason, J. T.(1997).Managing the risks of organizational accidents.Routledge Taylor & Francis Group.
20. Salas, E.(Ed.),Maurino, D.(Ed.)(2010).Human factors in aviation.Academic Press.
21. Schwendimann, R.,Blatter, C.,Dhaini, S.,Simon, M.,Ausserhofer, D.(2018).The occurrence, types, consequences and preventability of in-hospital adverse events-A scoping review.BMC Health Services Research,18(1),Article 521.
22. Slawomirski, L.,Auraaen, A.,Klazinga, N.(2017).The economics of patient safety.OECD Publishing.
23. Slawomirski, L., & Klazinga, N. (2020). The economics of patient safety, from analysis to action. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. https://www.oecd.org/health/health-systems/Economics-of-Patient-SafetyOctober-2020.pdf
24. Stoyanova, R.,Dimova, R.,Tornyova, B.,Mavrov, M.,Elkova, H.(2021).Perception of patient safety culture among hospital staff.Slovenian Journal of Public Health,60(2),97-104.
25. Vincent, C.(2010).Patient safety.:John Wiley & Sons.
26. Vincent, C.,Amalberti, R.(2016).Safer healthcare: Strategies for the real world.Springer Nature.
27. World Health Organization(2021).Global patient safety action plan 2021-2030.
28. World Health Organization(2013).Exploring patient participation in reducing healthcare-related safety risks.WHO Regional Office for Europe.
29. World Health Organization. (2009). Research for patient safety - Better knowledge for safer care. World Health Organization. https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/70145