蛻變的白衣天使－進階護理師的發展與突破

Metamorphosis of Nurses: The Development and Breakthroughs of Advanced Practice Registered Nurses

10.6224/JN.202210_69(5).07

陳幸眉(Hsing-Mei CHEN)；許玉雲(Yu-Yun HSU)；蕭淑代(Shu-Tai SHEN HSIAO)；謝曉燕(Hsiao-Yen HSIEH)；黃惠子(Hui-Tzu HUANG)；徐畢卿(Bih-Ching SHU)

進階護理師 ； 專業發展需求 ； 執業範疇 ； 核心能力 ； 認證 ； 焦點團體 ； advanced practice registered nurses ； the professional development of necessity ； practical scope ； core competency ； certification ； focus group

護理雜誌

69卷5期（2022 / 10 / 01）

44 - 55

繁體中文

背景：發展進階護理師制度為全球趨勢，然而台灣進階護理制度的發展仍處於妾身未明階段，亟需凝聚護理界共識。目的：本研究旨在探討產官學界護理專家對台灣發展進階護理師（臨床護理專家、個案管理師、註冊麻醉護理師、註冊助產護理師）的看法與建言。方法：資料收集時間為2017年3月至8月。總計64位專家分別參與北、中、南6場的焦點團體討論，所有內容皆經研究對象同意錄音與繕打成逐字稿後轉製成文本，並以內容分析法進行資料分析。結果：產官學界之護理專家對台灣發展進階護理師的意見與建議可歸納為四項主題：發展需求、核心能力、認證與未來推動相關議題，每一主題皆區分出數個次主題。結論／實務應用：本研究結果彙整護理產官學專家對台灣發展各類進階護理角色功能、執業範疇與管理之現況意見，以及對台灣未來發展各類進階護理角色在教育、核心能力、證照與執業範疇等之建議，可作為建立護理共識模式的視窗及未來推動進階護理師制度的依據。

Background: The introduction and development of the advanced practice registered nurse (APRN) is a global trend in nursing. However, the development of APRNs in Taiwan remains uncertain and lacks necessary consensus. Purpose: This research study aimed to explore the views and suggestions of nursing experts in industry, government, and academia regarding the development of APRNs (clinical nurse specialists, case managers, certified clinical registered nurse anesthetists, and certified nurse-midwives) in Taiwan. Methods: Data were collected from March to August 2017. Sixty-four experts participated in one of six focus group discussions held in northern, central, and southern Taiwan. These group discussions were recorded and transcribed verbatim with the consent of the participants. Content analysis was used to analyze the transcribed data. Results: The comments and suggestions raised during the discussions were categorized into four major themes: professional development of necessity, core competencies, accreditation, and future promotion-related issues. Each theme was further divided into several subthemes. Conclusions/Implications for Practice: The opinions of relevant experts regarding the current status of development of the roles, practical scope, and management and suggestions for APRNs were summarized to facilitate the future development of APRNs in Taiwan in terms of education, core competencies, certification, and practical scope. Furthermore, the results may be referenced in the establishment of a nursing consensus model and as a basis for promoting APRNs.

1. 王采芷, T.-J.,郭裴翎, P.-L.(2019)。進階護理的發展與現況。源遠護理，13(1)，5-13。
   連結：
2. 陳幼梅, Y.-M.,游顯妹, H.-M.,張淑真, S.-C.(2019)。台灣進階護理師認證制度的建立與國際接軌的展望。源遠護理，13(1)，14-21。
   連結：
3. 陳美娟, M.-C.,李碧霞, P.-H.,莊宇慧, Y.-H.,林碧珠, P.-C.(2020)。探討基層護理人員參加臨床專業能力進階動機、壓力、滿意度與相關影響因素。新臺北護理期刊，22(1)，9-19。
   連結：
4. 謝美慧, M.-H.,王秀紅, H.-H.(2017)。個案管理師執業範圍的現況與展望。領導護理，18(3)，2-12。
   連結：
5. 謝美慧, M.-H.,陳幼梅, Y.-M.(2019)。論台灣個案管理師之執業能力。領導護理，20(4)，16-30。
   連結：
6. APRN Consensus Work Group,National Council of State Boards of Nursing APRN Advisory Committee(2008).APRN Joint Dialogue Group ReportAPRN Joint Dialogue Group Report,未出版
7. Bryant-Lukosius, D.,Spichiger, E.,Martin, J.,Stoll, H.,Kellerhals, S. D.,Fliedner, M.,Grossmann, F.,Henry, M.,Herrmann, L.,Koller, A.,Schwendimann, R.,Ulrich, A.,Weibel, L.,Callens, B.,De Geest, S.(2016).Framework for evaluating the impact of advanced practice nursing roles.Journal of Nursing Scholarship,48(2),201-209.
8. Fagerström, L. M.(2021).A caring advanced practice nursing model: Theoretical perspectives and competency domains.Springer Cham.
9. Friedrich, C.,Lindeke, L. L.(2015).Reimbursement realities for the APRN.Advanced practice nursing: Core concepts for professional role development
10. Jokiniemi, K.,Hølge-Hazelton, B.,Kristofersson, G. K.,Frederiksen, K.,Kilpatrick, K.,Mikkonen, S.(2021).Core competencies of clinical nurse specialists: A comparison across three Nordic countries.Journal of Clinical Nursing,30(23-24),3601-3610.
11. Jokiniemi, K.,Pietilä, A.-M.,Kylmä, J.,Haatainen, K.(2012).Advanced nursing roles: A systematic review.Nursing and Health Sciences,14(3),421-431.
12. Kleinheksel, A. J.,Rockich-Winston, N.,Tawfik, H.,Wyatt, T. R.(2020).Demystifying content analysis.American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education,84(1),Article 7113.
13. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1986).But is it rigorous? Trustworthiness and authenticity in naturalistic evaluation.New Directions for Program Evaluation,1986(30),73-84.
14. Lindeke, L. L.,Avery, M.,White, K. W.(2015).Overview of advanced practice registered nursing.Advanced practice nursing: Core concepts for professional role development
15. National CNS Competency Task Force. (2010). Clinical nurse specialist core competencies. https://nacns.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/CNSCoreCompetenciesBroch.pdf
16. Zwilling, J. G.(2015).Multifaceted roles of the APRN.Advanced practice nursing: Core concepts for professional role development
17. 台灣護理學會（2018，11月10日）．基層護理能力進階規劃指引。https://www.twna.org.tw/WebPad/WebPad.aspx?1x8jyHnXeNSHfBGHev4mkg%3D%3D [Taiwan Nurses Association. (2018, November 10). Advanced guidelines for abilities planning for basic nursing. https://www.twna.org.tw/WebPad/WebPad.aspx?1x8jyHnXeNSHfBGHev4mkg%3D%3D]
18. 台灣護理學會（2022，1月）．台灣護理學會進階護理師認證申請統計一覽表。https://www.twna.org.tw/WebUploadFiles/DocFiles/1995_111%e5%b9%b4%e5%85%ac%e5%91%8a%e8%b3%87%e6%96%99.pdf [Taiwan Nurses Association. (2022, January). Statistics on applications for advanced practice nurse certification submitted to the Taiwan Nurses Association. https://www.twna.org.tw/WebUploadFiles/DocFiles/1995_111%e5%b9%b4%e5%85%ac%e5%91%8a%e8%b3%87%e6%96%99.pdf]
19. 台灣護理學會（2020，11月5日）．進階護理師認證發展規劃。https://www.twna.org.tw/WebPad/WebPad.aspx?1x8jyHnXeNRZ7af5neRU%2BA%3D%3D [Taiwan Nurses Association. (2020, November 5). Developmental planning for advanced practice nursing certification. https://www.twna.org.tw/WebPad/WebPad.aspx?1x8jyHnXeNRZ7af5neRU%2BA%3D%3D]
20. 梁淑媛, S.-Y.,莊宇慧, Y.-H.,吳淑芳, S.-F.(2012)。內容分析技巧在護理質性資料之初步應用。護理雜誌，59(5)，84-90。

1. 林靜蘭(2023)。進階精神衛生護理角色的實踐及利基。護理雜誌，70(4)，15-21。
2. 林良姿(2023)。臨床護理專家之專業架構及認證資格敘論。護理雜誌，70(6)，92-98。