支持性關懷對腦腫瘤術後病人之症狀困擾、護理需求與憂鬱成效之前驅性研究

The Effects of Supportive Caring on Symptoms Distress, Nursing Needs, and Depression in Patients With Brain Tumor After Surgery: A Preliminary Study

10.6224/JN.202302_70(1).08

吳麗珠(Li-Chu WU)；林佑樺(Yu-Hua LIN)

腦瘤 ； 支持性關懷 ； 護理需求 ； 症狀困擾 ； 憂鬱情緒 ； brain tumor ； supportive care ； nursing needs ； symptoms distress ； depressive emotion

護理雜誌

70卷1期（2023 / 02 / 01）

48 - 59

英文

背景：腦瘤治療以手術為主，然手術後病人仍因疾病與治療因素產生諸多症狀困擾和護理需求，若未及時改善則容易產生憂鬱情緒。目的：探討支持關懷介入措施對腦腫瘤術後病人之症狀困擾、護理需求與憂鬱之成效。方法：本研究採雙組前、後測實驗設計，以隨機抽樣將參與者分配到兩組，實驗組接受術後1個月和3個月的支持性關懷，對照組接受常規性出院衛教。成果測量包括支持性護理需求量表、症狀困擾量表和流行病學研究中心憂鬱量表。資料收集時間包括：出院前（T0）、術後1個月（T1）、3個月（T2）和6個月（T3）。結果：由廣義估計模式分析顯示，支持性關懷介入後，實驗組護理需求在T1（β=-23.61,p<.001）、T2（β=-22.51,p<.001）、T3（β=-22.26,p<.001）顯著低於對照組。症狀困擾在T1（β=-7.03,p=.019）、T2（β=-8.39,p=.003）顯著低於對照組。憂鬱情緒僅在T2（β=-8.55,p=.005）顯著低於對照組。結論：本研究顯示支持性關懷有助改善腦瘤病人手術後護理需求、症狀困擾和憂鬱情緒，醫護團隊人員應注意腦瘤病人術後護理需求、症狀困擾和憂鬱情緒狀況，必要時提供訊息，以提高護理的照護品質。

Background: Brain tumors are mainly treated with surgery. However, patients still experience many symptoms and nursing needs due to disease and treatment-related factors that, if not improved in a timely manner, may result in depression. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine the effectiveness of supportive caring on symptom distress, nursing needs, and depressive symptoms in patients with brain tumor after surgery. Methods: This study adopted a two-group, pre- and post-test experimental design. The enrolled participants were randomized into two groups. Those in the experimental group received a phone-based supportive caring intervention twice at 1 and 3 months after surgery. Those in the control group received usual discharge care. The measurement outcomes included a supportive care needs survey, symptom distress scales, and the center for epidemiological studies of depression. Baseline data was collected prior to hospital discharge (T0), with follow-up data collected at one month (T1), three months (T2), and six months (T3) after surgery. Results: The results of the generalized estimating equation analysis showed that nursing needs in the experimental group at T1 (β = -23.61, p < .001), T2 (β = -22.51, p < .001), and T3 (β = -22.26, p < .001) were significant lower than in the control group. Also, symptom distress in the experimental group at T1 (β = -7.03, p = .019) and T2 (β = -8.39, p = .003) was significantly lower than in the control group. However, depressive symptoms in the experimental group were lower than in the control group only at T2 (β = -8.55, p = .005). Conclusion: The results of this study confirm that supportive care helps improve nursing needs, symptoms distress, and depressive symptoms in patients with brain tumor after surgery. Medical team members should pay attention to these issues following surgery.

1. 邱惠英, H.-Y.,林佑樺, Y.-H.,王儷螢, L.-Y.,林孟志, M.-C.,陳彥豪, Y.-H.,王金洲, C.-C.(2021)。支持性照護計劃對使用EGFR-TKIs之非小細胞肺癌病人皮膚疾患與生活品質成效追蹤。腫瘤護理雜誌，21(2)，35-41。
   連結：
2. Armstrong, T. S.,Gilbert, M. R.(2012).Practical strategies for management of fatigue and sleep disorders in people with brain tumors.Neuro-Oncology,14(4, Suppl.),iv65-iv72.
3. Arnold, S. D.,Forman, L. M.,Brigidi, B. D.,Carter, K. E.,Schweitzer, H. A.,Quinn, H. E.,Guill, A. B.,Herndon, J. E., II.,Raynor, R. H.(2008).Evaluation and characterization of generalized anxiety and depression in patients with primary brain tumors.Neuro-Oncology,10(2),171-181.
4. Au, A.,Lam, W. W. T.,Kwong, A.,Suen, D.,Tsang, J.,Yeo, W.,Suen, J.,Ho, W. M.,Yau, T. K.,Soong, I.,Wong, K. Y.,Sze, W. K.,Ng, A.,Girgis, A.,Fielding, R.(2011).Validation of the Chinese version of the Short-Form Supportive Care Needs Survey Questionnaire (SCNS-SF34-C).Psycho-Oncology,20(12),1292-1300.
5. Bonevski, B.,Sanson-Fisher, R.,Girgis, A.,Burton, L.,Cook, P.,Boyes, A.(2000).Evaluation of an instrument to assess the needs of patients with cancer.Cancer,88(1),217-225.
6. Bossi, P.,Di Pede, P.,Guglielmo, M.,Granata, R.,Alfieri, S.,Iacovelli, N. A.,Orlandi, E.,Guzzo, M.,Bianchi, R.,Ferella, L.,Infante, G.,Miceli, R.,Licitra, L.,Ripamonti, C. I.(2019).Prevalence of fatigue in head and neck cancer survivors.Annals Otology, Rhinology & Laryngology,128(5),413-419.
7. Cheng, C. P.,Yen, C. F.,Ko, C. H.,Yen, J. Y.(2012).Factor structure of the center for epidemiologic studies depression scale in Taiwanese adolescents.Comprehensive Psychiatry,53(3),299-307.
8. Chien, L.-N.,Gittleman, H.,Ostrom, Q. T.,Hung, K.-S.,Sloan, A. E.,Hsieh, Y.-C.,Kruchko, C.,Rogers, L. R.,Wang, Y. F. G.,Chiou, H.-Y.,Barnholtz-Sloan, J. S.(2016).Comparative brain and central nervous system tumor incidence and survival between the United States and Taiwan based on population-based registry.Frontiers in Public Health,4,151.
9. Dahlberg, M.,Bylund, A.,Gustavsson, P.,Calero, T. H.,Wannheden, C.(2022).What matters to persons living with brain tumors and their informal caregivers? An interview study of qualities in interpersonal relations.Social Science & Medicine,292,114575.
10. Day, J.,Berntzen, B.,Tuck, S.,Rooney, A. R.,Gillespie, D.,Peoples, S.,Erridge, S.,Grant, R.(2019).Fatigue and associated symptoms in patients with a primary brain tumor.Annals of Clinical Oncology,2(3),3-9.
11. Guilkey, R. E.,Von Ah, D.,Carpenter, J. S.,Stone, C.,Draucker, C. B.(2016).Integrative review: Postcraniotomy pain in the brain tumour patient.Journal of Advanced Nursing,72(6),1221-1235.
12. Hickmann, A.-K.,Nadji-Ohl, M.,Haug, M.,Hopf, N. J.,Ganslandt, O.,Giese, A.,Renovanz, M.(2016).Suicidal ideation, depression, and health-related quality of life in patients with benign and malignant brain tumors: A prospective observational study in 83 patients.Acta Neurochirurgica,158(9),1669-1682.
13. Higgins, A.,Downes, C.,Varley, J.,Tyrell, E.,Normand, C.,Doherty, C. P.,Begley, C.,Elliott, N.(2018).Patients with epilepsy care experiences: Comparison between services with and without an epilepsy specialist nurse.Epilepsy & Behavior,85,85-94.
14. Hsieh, C.-C.,Hsiao, F.-H.(2017).The effects of supportive care interventions on depressive symptoms among patients with lung cancer: A metaanalysis of randomized controlled studies.Palliative & Supportive Care,15(6),710-723.
15. Huang, J.,Zeng, C.,Xiao, J.,Zhao, D.,Tang, H.,Wu, H.,Chen, J.(2017).Association between depression and brain tumor: A systematic review and meta-analysis.Oncotarget,8(55),94932-94943.
16. Hwang, T.-Z.,Lin, Y.-H.,Liu, C.-Y.,Kao, C.-C.,Huang, P.-C.(2020).The effects of a supportive care program on the posttraumatic stress symptoms of patients with oral cancer after surgery.Clinical Nursing Research,29(8),598-606.
17. Jeon, M. S.,Agar, M. R.,Koh, E.-S.,Nowak, A. K.,Hovey, E. J.,Dhillon, H. M.(2021).Understanding sleep disturbance in the context of malignant brain tumors: A qualitative analysis.Neuro-Oncology Practice,8(2),179-189.
18. Karppinen, A.,Ritvonen, E.,Roine, R.,Sintonen, H.,Vehkavaara, S.,Kivipelto, L.,Grossman, A. B.,Niemela, M.,Schalin-Jäntti, C.(2016).Health-related quality of life in patients treated for nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas during the years 2000-2010.Clinical Endocrinology,84(4),532-539.
19. Khan, F.,Amatya, B.,Drummond, K.,Galea, M.(2014).Effectiveness of integrated multidisciplinary rehabilitation in primary brain cancer survivors in an Australian community cohort: A controlled clinical trial.Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine,46(8),754-760.
20. Langegård, U.,Ahlberg, K.,Björk-Eriksson, T.,Fransson, P.,Johansson, B.,Ohlsson-Nevo, E.,Witt-Nyström, P.,Sjövall, K.(2020).The art of living with symptoms: A qualitative study among patients with primary brain tumors receiving proton beam therapy.Cancer Nursing,43(2),E79-E86.
21. Larun, L.,Brurberg, K. G.,Odgaard-Jensen, J.,Price, J. R.(2019).Exercise therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome.Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
22. Maqbool, T.,Agarwal, A.,Sium, A.,Trang, A.,Chung, C.,Papadakos, J.(2017).Informational and supportive care needs of brain metastases patients and caregivers: A systematic review.Journal of Cancer Education,32(4),914-923.
23. Molassiotis, A.,Wilson, B.,Brunton, L.,Chaudhary, H.,Gattamaneni, R.,McBain, C.(2010).Symptom experience in patients with primary brain tumours: A longitudinal exploratory study.European Journal of Oncology Nursing,14(5),410-416.
24. Mustian, K. M.,Alfano, C. M.,Heckler, C.,Kleckner, A. S.,Kleckner, I. R.,Leach, C. R.,Mohr, D.,Palesh, O. G.,Peppone, L. J.,Piper, B. F.,Scarpato, J.,Smith, T.,Sprod, L. K.,Miller, S. M.(2017).Comparison of pharmaceutical, psychological, and exercise treatments for cancer-related fatigue: A meta-analysis.JAMA Oncology,3(7),961-968.
25. Ostrom, Q. T.,Gittleman, H.,Liao, P.,Vecchione-Koval, T.,Wolinsky, Y.,Kruchko, C.,Barnholtz-Sloan, J. S.(2017).CBTRUS statistical report: Primary brain and other central nervous system tumors diagnosed in the United States in 2010-2014.Neuro-Oncology,19(5, Suppl.),v1-v88.
26. Ownsworth, T.,Chan, R. J.,Jones, S.,Robertson, J.,Pinkham, M. B.(2021).Use of telehealth platforms for delivering supportive care to adults with primary brain tumors and their family caregivers: A systematic review.Psycho-Oncology,30(1),16-26.
27. Renovanz, M.,Hechtner, M.,Janko, M.,Kohlmann, K.,Coburger, J.,Nadji-Ohl, M.,König, J.,Ringel, F.,Singer, S.,Hickmann, A.-K.(2017).Factors associated with supportive care needs in glioma patients in the neuro-oncological outpatient setting.Journal of Neuro-Oncology,133(3),653-662.
28. Rocha-Filho, P. A. S.(2015).Post-craniotomy headache: A clinical view with a focus on the persistent form.Headache,55(5),733-738.
29. Rozmovits, L.,Khu, K. J.,Osman, S.,Gentili, F.,Guha, A.,Bernstein, M.(2010).Information gaps for patients requiring craniotomy for benign brain lesion: A qualitative study.Journal of Neuro-Oncology,96(2),241-247.
30. Sandler, C. X.,Matsuyama, M.,Jones, T. L.,Bashford, J.,Langbecker, D.,Hayes, S. C.(2021).Physical activity and exercise in adults diagnosed with primary brain cancer: A systematic review.Journal of Neuro-Oncology,153(1),1-14.
31. Scaratti, C.,Leonardi, M.,Saladino, A.,Anghileri, E.,Broggi, M.,Lamperti, E.,Fariselli, L.,Ayadi, R.,Tringali, G.,Schiavolin, S.(2017).Needs of neuro-oncological patients and their caregivers during the hospitalization and after discharge: Results from a longitudinal study.Supportive Care in Cancer,25(7),2137-2145.
32. Schei, S.,Solheim, O.,Jakola, A. S.,Sagberg, L. M.(2020).Perioperative fatigue in patients with diffuse glioma.Journal of Neuro-Oncology,147(1),97-107.
33. Song, L.(2011).Social capital and psychological distress.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,52(4),478-492.
34. Wang, T.-C.,Huang, J.-L.,Ho, W.-C.,Chiou, A.-F.(2016).Effects of a supportive educational nursing care programme on fatigue and quality of life in patients with heart failure: A randomised controlled trial.European Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing,15(2),157-167.
35. Wei, D.,Tian, Y.,Gao, H.,Peng, J.,Tan, Y.,Li, Y.(2013).Patient distress and emotional disclosure: A study of Chinese cancer patients.Journal of Cancer Education,28(2),346-351.
36. Yong, L.,Liu, L.,Ding, T.,Yang, G.,Su, H.,Wang, J.,Yang, M.,Chang, J.(2021).Evidence of effect of aerobic exercise on cognitive intervention in older adults with mild cognitive impairment.Frontiers in Psychiatry,12,713671.
37. Young, J.,Harrison, J.,Solomon, M.,Butow, P.,Dennis, R.,Robson, D.,Auld, S.(2010).Development and feasibility assessment of telephone-delivered supportive care to improve outcomes for patients with colorectal cancer: Pilot study of the CONNECT intervention.Supportive Care in Cancer,18(4),461-470.
38. 劉芝萓, C.-Y.(2018)。義守大學=I-Shou University。