混合式衛教對全膝關節置換術老年病人疼痛及關節角度之成效

Effects of a Hybrid Health Education Program on Pain and Knee Angle in Elderly Patients After Total Knee Replacement Surgery

10.6224/JN.202304_70(2).07

張雪玲(Hsueh-Ling CHANG)；黃曉令(Hsiao-Ling HUANG)；鍾玉珠(Yu-Chu CHUNG)

混合式衛教 ； 全膝關節置換術 ； 疼痛 ； 膝關節角度 ； hybrid health education ； total knee replacement ； pain ； knee angle

護理雜誌

70卷2期（2023 / 04 / 01）

45 - 55

繁體中文;英文

背景：全膝關節置換術病人術後仍存在疼痛及膝關節角度受限，一般出院衛教成效有限。目的：混合式衛教對全膝關節置換術病人疼痛及膝關節角度之成效探討。方法：單盲隨機控制組試驗，方便取樣選取北部某區域教學醫院骨科病房單側全膝關節置換術老年病人為研究對象，收案52人，隨機分派二組，每組各26人，實驗組接受混合式衛教，居家復健運動每日2次，每次15分鐘，共16週；控制組則接受常規衛教。資料收集時間為手術前及術後第1週、第6週、第12週、第16週，收案日期自2020年11月15日至2022年1月13日。結果：共完成實驗組22人，控制組26人。介入混合式衛教第16週之成效，廣義估計方程式分析結果顯示，二組比較，實驗組的「現在的疼痛」於第12週（β= -1.43, p = .025）及第16週（β= -1.52, p = .014）達顯著差異；過去1週「最嚴重疼痛」於第12週（β = -1.40, p = .041）及第16週（β= -1.55, p = .024）達顯著差異；過去1週平均疼痛於第16週（β= -1.24, p = .035）達顯著差異及伸膝角度於第16週（β = -5.52,p = .033）達顯著差異。結論／實務應用：本研究結果指出老年病人於膝關節置換術後接受混合式衛教，能強化動機執行居家復健，改善術後疼痛及伸膝角度。建議本研究發展的衛教內容及方式可納入出院衛教計畫及進行長期追蹤其成效。

Background: Patients experience pain and limited knee angle after total knee replacement (TKR) surgery. The effectiveness of routine discharge health education remains limited. Purpose: This study was designed to assess the effect of hybrid health education on postoperative pain and knee angle in patients with TKR. Methods: A single blind and randomized controlled trial study was used. Fifty-two patients with TKR were randomly assigned to either the experimental group (n = 26), which received standard care with hybrid health education and performed the multimedia-guided intervention for 30 min per day for 16 weeks, or the control group (n = 26), which received routine care only. The data collection times were at pretest (preoperative) and at the 1st week, 6th week, 12th week, 16th week after surgery. Results: A total of 22 patients in the experimental group and 26 patients in the control group completed this study. After the 16-week hybrid health education intervention, the results of generalized estimating equations analysis showed that pain in the experimental and control groups differed significantly at week 12 (β= -1.43, p = .025) and week 16 (β= -1.52, p = .014); worst pain in the past week had significantly improved at week 12 (β= -1.40, p = .041) and week 16 (β= -1.55, p = .024); average pain over the past 1 week had significantly improved at week 16 (β = -1.24, p = .035); and knee extension angle had significantly improved at week 16 (β= -5.52, p = .033). Conclusion/ Implications for Practice: The results of this study showed that elderly patients who received hybrid health education after TKR had significantly improved postoperative pain and knee angle and that degree of improvement in the experimental group was better than in the control group. It is recommended that the content and methods of hybrid health education developed in this study be incorporated into discharge interventions and that long-term outcomes be tracked for reference.

1. 吳依蘋, Y.-P.,唐國民, K.-M.,洪麗珍, L.-C.(2016)。人工膝關節及髖關節置換術病患術後疼痛之分析。領導護理，17(2)，80-93。
   連結：
2. Allsop, S.,Fairhall, R.,Morphet, J.(2019).The impact of pre-operative telephone support and education on symptoms of anxiety, depression, pain and quality of life post total knee replacement: An exploratory case study.International Journal of Orthopaedic and Trauma Nursing,34,21-27.
3. Bade, M. J.,Kittelson, J. M.,Kohrt, W. M.,Stevens-Lapsley, J. E.(2014).Predicting functional performance and range of motion outcomes after total knee arthroplasty.American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation,93(7),579-585.
4. Bourne, R. B.,Chesworth, B. M.,Davis, A. M.,Mahomed, N. N.,Charron, K. D. J.(2010).Patient satisfaction after total knee arthroplasty: Who is satisfied and who is not?.Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research,468(1),57-63.
5. Boyce, L.,Prasad, A.,Barrett, M.,Dawson-Bowling, S.,Millington, S.,Hanna, S. A.,Achan, P.(2019).The outcomes of total knee arthroplasty in morbidly obese patients: A systematic review of the literature.Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery,139(4),553-560.
6. Chen, S.-R.,Chen, C.-S.,Lin, P.-C.(2014).The effect of educational intervention on the pain and rehabilitation performance of patients who undergo a total knee replacement.Journal of Clinical Nursing,23(1-2),279-287.
7. Damar, H. T.,Bilik, O.(2022).Effects of video-based education program on pain, physical function, and quality of life in patients with total knee replacement.Inonu University Journal of Art and Design,10(1),96-115.
8. de Achaval, S.,Kallen, M. A.,Amick, B.,Landon, G.,Siff, S.,Edelstein, D.,Zhang, H.,Suarez-Almazor, M. E.(2016).Patients’ expectations about total knee arthroplasty outcomes.Health Expectations,19(2),299-308.
9. Holley, S.,McMillan, S. C.,Hagan, S. J.,Palacios, P.,Rosenberg, D.(2005).Pain resource nurses: Believing the patients, believing in themselves.Oncology Nursing Forum,32(4),843-848.
10. Kahlenberg, C. A.,Nwachukwu, B. U.,McLawhorn, A. S.,Cross, M. B.,Cornell, C. N.,Padgett, D. E.(2018).Patient satisfaction after total knee replacement: A systematic review.Hospital for Special Surgery Journal,14(2),192-201.
11. Kornuijt, A.,de Kort, G. J. L.,Das, D.,Lenssen, A. F.,van der Weegen, W.(2019).Recovery of knee range of motion after total knee arthroplasty in the first postoperative weeks: Poor recovery can be detected early.Musculoskeletal Surgery,103(3),289-297.
12. Lange, T.,Schmitt, J.,Kopkow, C.,Rataj, E.,Günther, K.-P.,Lützner, J.(2017).What do patients expect from total knee arthroplasty? A Delphi consensus study on patient treatment goals.The Journal of Arthroplasty,32(7),2093-2099.E1.
13. Lin, Y.-H.,Lee, S.-Y.,Su, W.-R.,Kao, C.-C.,Tai, T.-W.,Chen, T.-B.(2018).Effects of nurse-led lower extremity strength training on knee function recovery in patients who underwent total knee replacement.Journal of Clinical Nursing,27(9-10),1836-1845.
14. Mai, K. T.,Verioti, C. A.,Hardwick, M. E.,Ezzet, K. A.,Copp, S. N.,Colwell, C. W., Jr.(2012).Measured flexion following total knee arthroplasty.Orthopedics,35(10),e1472-e1475.
15. Moutzouri, M.,Gleeson, N.,Billis, E.,Tsepis, E.,Gliatis, J.(2017).Greek physiotherapists’ perspectives on rehabilitation following total knee replacement: A descriptive survey.Physiotherapy Research International,22(4),e1671.
16. Mutsuzaki, H.,Takeuchi, R.,Mataki, Y.,Wadano, Y.(2017).Target range of motion for rehabilitation after total knee arthroplasty.Journal of Rural Medicine,12(1),33-37.
17. Myles, P. S.,Myles, D. B.,Galagher, W.,Boyd, D.,Chew, C.,MacDonald, N.,Dennis, A.(2017).Measuring acute postoperative pain using the visual analog scale: The minimal clinically important difference and patient acceptable symptom state.British Journal of Anaesthesia,118(3),424-429.
18. Papalia, R.,Campi, S.,Vorini, F.,Zampogna, B.,Vasta, S.,Papalia, G.,Fossati, C.,Torre, G.,Denaro, V.(2020).The role of physical activity and rehabilitation following hip and knee arthroplasty in the elderly.Journal of Clinical Medicine,9(5),1401.
19. Prvu Bettger, J. P.,Green, C. L.,Holmes, D. N.,Chokshi, A.,Mather, R. C., Ⅲ.,Hoch, B. T.,de Leon, A. J.,Aluisio, F.,Seyler, T. M.,Del Gaizo, D. J.,Chiavetta, J.,Webb, L.,Miller, V.,Smith, J. M.,Peterson, E. D.(2020).Effects of virtual exercise rehabilitation in-home therapy compared with traditional care after total knee arthroplasty: VERITAS, a randomized controlled trial.The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery,102(2),101-109.
20. Pua, Y.-H.,Poon, C. L.-L.,Seah, F. J.-T.,Thumboo, J.,Clark, R. A.,Tan, M.-H.,Chong, H.-C.,Tan, J. W.-M.,Chew, E. S.-X.,Yeo, S.-J.(2019).Predicting individual knee range of motion, knee pain, and walking limitation outcomes following total knee arthroplasty.Acta Orthopaedica,90(2),179-186.
21. Rat, A.-C.,Guillemin, F.,Osnowycz, G.,Delagoutte, J.-P.,Cuny, C.,Mainard, D.,Baumann, C.(2010).Total hip or knee replacement for osteoarthritis: Mid-and long-term quality of life.Arthritis Care & Research,62(1),54-62.
22. Rice, D. A.,Kluger, M. T.,McNair, P. J.,Lewis, G. N.,Somogyi, A. A.,Borotkanics, R.,Barratt, D. T.,Walker, M.(2018).Persistent postoperative pain after total knee arthroplasty: A prospective cohort study of potential risk factors.British Journal of Anaesthesia,121(4),804-812.
23. Sattler, L. N.,Hing, W. A.,Vertullo, C. J.(2019).What is the evidence to support early supervised exercise therapy after primary total knee replacement? A systematic review and meta-analysis.BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders,20(1),42.
24. Singh, J. A.,Dowsey, M. M.,Dohm, M.,Goodman, S. M.,Leong, A. L.,Scholte Voshaar, M. M. J. H.,Choong, P. F.(2017).Achieving consensus on total joint replacement trial outcome reporting using the OMERACT filter: Endorsement of the final core domain set for total hip and total knee replacement trials for endstage arthritis.The Journal of Rheumatology,44(11),1723-1726.
25. Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre. (2009, December). Knee replacement exercise booklet: Weight bearing as tolerated. https://sunnybrook.ca/uploads/TKRexerciseUpdate.pdf
26. Vuorenmaa, M.,Ylinen, J.,Piitulainen, K.,Salo, P.,Kautiainen, H.,Pesola, M.,Häkkinen, A.(2014).Efficacy of a 12-month, monitored home exercise programme compared with normal care commencing 2 months after total knee arthroplasty: A randomized controlled trial.Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine,46(2),166-172.
27. Zheng, H.,Chen, C.(2015).Body mass index and risk of knee osteoarthritis: Systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective studies.BMJ Open,5(12),e007568.
28. 國家發展委員會=Nation Development Council(2020).中華民國人口推估報告（2020年至2070年）.