Animal Poverty: Agamben, Heidegger, and Whitehead

困乏的動物：阿岡本、海德格、懷海德

10.6184/TKR201812-2

Gregg Lambert

Agamben ； Heidegger ； Whitehead ； animal (animal studies) ； animal (as ＂poor in world＂) ； 阿岡本 ； 海德格 ； 懷海德 ； 動物（研究） ； 動物（指稱「在世困乏存有」）

Tamkang Review

49卷1期（2018 / 12 / 01）

17 - 32

英文

This article examines the concepts of ＂the animal＂ and ＂animality＂ in the philosophy of Martin Heidegger, particularly in response to the recent debates in the fields of Animal Studies and Posthumanism, as well as in response to the revelation of the Black Notebooks where earlier statements regarding the animal being ＂poor in world＂ also find a resonance with Heidegger's meditations on the relationship between the German people (Volk) and the European Jews. The article concludes by introducing the perspective of ＂life itself＂ from the philosophy of Alfred North Whitehead, and especially concerning the famous proposition ＂Life is robbery.＂

本論文檢視海德格哲學中的「動物」與「動物性」概念，藉此回應現今動物研究與後人類主義中正在進行的若干爭論，同時也回應海德格《黑色筆記》所透露的涵義，亦即此系列筆記中對德國人和歐洲猶太人相互關係的思考，呼應了關於動物「在世困乏存有」的早期論述。本文歸結於懷海德哲學中「生命本身」的視角，尤以懷海德眾所皆知的主張「生命就是掠奪」為核心。

1. Agamben, Giorgio,Attell, Kevin(trans.)(2004).The Open: Man and Animal.Stanford UP.
2. Aristotle,Barnes, Jonathan(ed.)(1984).The Complete Works of Aristotle: The Revised Oxford Translation.Princeton UP.
3. Escudero, Jesus Adrian(2015).Heidegger's Black Notebooks and the Question of Anti-Semitism.Gatherings: The Heidegger Circle Annual,5,21-49.
4. Foucault, Michel,Hurley, Robert(trans.)(1980).The History of Sexuality.Vintage Books.
5. Heidegger, Martin,Lovett, William(trans.)(1977).The Question Concerning Technology.Harper.
6. Heidegger, Martin,McNeill, William(trans.),Walker, Nicholas(trans.)(1995).The Fundamental Concepts of Metaphysics: World, Finitude, Solitude.Indiana UP.
7. Lacan, Jacques,Sheridan, Alan(trans.)(1977).Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis.Penguin Books.
8. Lambert, Gregg(2016).Return Statements: The Return of Religion in Contemporary Philosophy.Edinburgh UP.
9. Nass, Michael(2018).Plato and the Invention of Life.Fordham Press.
10. Whitehead, Alfred North(1969).Process and Reality.Free Press.
11. Wolfe, Cary(2012).Before the Law: Humans and Other Animals in a Biopolitical Frame.U of Chicago P.

1. Karen Ya-chu Yang(2019).Caring for Difference: A Review of Human-Animal Studies in Taiwan from the Last Decade.Tamkang Review,49(2),107-113.