生業資源的利用與小規模社會的發展：比較觀點下的海洋假說與宴飲消費

Utilization of Subsistence Resources and the Development of Small-Scale Societies: Comparative Perspectives on the Maritime Hypothesis and Feasting / Consumption Behaviors

10.6152/jaa.202012_(93).0002

陳珮瑜(Peiyu Chen)

海洋假說 ； 生業活動 ； 小規模社會 ； 消費與宴飲 ； 早期安地斯海岸遺址 ； Maritime Hypothesis ； subsistence activity ； small-scale society ； consumption and feasting ； early Andean coastal sites

考古人類學刊

93期（2020 / 12 / 01）

49 - 85

繁體中文

人口數量相對稀少且缺乏制度化社會階序的小規模社會，貫穿歷史長河且普遍存在於世界的各個角落，而其如何隨著時間推移逐漸發展出相對複雜的社會組織，一直以來都是重要的考古學議題之一。以早期安地斯沿海地區為例，本文著重討論生業資源的取得與利用，及其與社會發展可能的關係。透過對Huaca Negra、Cerro Lampay、Gramalote等三個遺址出土資料的摘要與詮釋，分別從「單一地點的縱時性」以及「多元地點的同時性」的角度進行比較分析，初步的結果可用來回應「與安地斯文明發展密切相關的海洋假說」，以及「與生業資源操控相關的宴飲消費行為」。目前的比較結果不只從生業經濟的面相彰顯了小規模社會發展途徑的多元性與能動性，同時也鼓勵後續更大尺度的跨區域比較，透過由下而上的視角，累積包括臺灣在內不同區域的小規模社會相關資料，應有益於理解人類早期歷史中，生業活動與社會發展間的互動關係。

Small-scale societies, characterized by lacking institutionalized hierarchy and as groups of limited population, are prevalent across time and space throughout human history. Archaeologists have always been interested in the developmental trajectories of these societies and their pathways to complexity. Taking the cases from the early Andean Coast, this article focuses on the possible relationship between subsistence utilization and societal development. By summarizing and interpreting data from Huaca Negra, Cerro Lampay, and Gramalote, this article conducts both diachronic comparison of one site (Huaca Negra) and synchronic comparison among different sites. The results offer new perspectives to the critical idea of Maritime Foundations of Andean Civilization and to the discussion of feasting as a possible power strategy. This work not only illustrates the diverse developmental trajectories of small-scale societies within the Andean context but also encourages more input of comparative cases across regions. A comparative perspective would depict a clearer picture of the interaction between subsistence activities and early societies.

1. 李匡悌(2005)。從考古遺留論臺灣史前人的飲食習慣。中國飲食文化，1(1)，49-98。
   連結：
2. 李政益,陳瑪玲,林立虹,Ditchfield, Peter,王珮玲,林秀嫚,Pollard, A. Mark,羅清華,蔡錫圭(2016)。從人骨和獸骨之骨膠原碳與氮穩定同位素組成看圓山文化人的攝食特徵。考古人類學刊，85，109-137。
   連結：
3. 陳有貝(2007)。史前臺灣的兩縊型網墜與投網技術。考古人類學刊，67，117-155。
   連結：
4. 陳維鈞(2006)。臺灣史前考古學的漁撈研究。國立臺灣大學考古人類學刊，66，155-176。
   連結：
5. Bar-Yosef, Ofer(2002).The Upper Paleolithic Revolution.Annual Review of Anthropology,31(1),363-393.
6. Bar-Yosef, Ofer(1998).On the Nature of Transitions: The Middle to Upper Palaeolithic and the Neolithic Revolution.Cambridge Archaeological Journal,8(2),141-163.
7. Bender, Barbara(1978).Gatherer-Hunter to Farmer: A Social Perspective.World Archaeology,10(2),204-222.
8. Billman, Brian R.(1996).Santa Barbara,Department of Anthropology, University of California.
9. Binford, Lewis R.(1968).Post-Pleistocene Adaptations.New Perspective in Archeology,Chicago:
10. Bird, Junius B.,Hyslop, John(1985).The Preceramic Excavations at the Huaca-Prieta-Chicama Valley Peru.New York:American Museum of Natural History.
11. Blitz, John H.(1993).Big Pots for Big Shots: Feasting and Storage in a Mississippian Community.American Antiquity,58(1),80-96.
12. Bray, Tamara L.(2003).The Archaeology and Politics of Food and Feasting in Early States and Empires.New York:Kluwer Academic.
13. Chang, Kwang-chih(1969).Fengpitou, Tapenkeng, and the Prehistory of Taiwan.New Haven:Department of Anthropology, Yale University.
14. Chen, Peiyu(2019).Department of Anthropology, University of Pittsburgh.
15. Chu, Alejandro Jose(2011).Department of Anthropology, University of Pittsburgh.
16. Clark, John E.,Blake, Michael(1994).The Power of Prestige: Competitive Generosity and the Emergence of Rank Societies in Low-Land Mesoamerica.Factional Competition and Political Development in the New World,Cambridge:
17. Creamer, Winifred,Haas, Jonathan,Rutherford, Allen(2014).Peer-Polity Interaction in the Norte Chico, Peru, 3000-1800 BC.The Maya and Their Central American Neighbors: Settlement Patterns, Architecture, Hieroglyphic Texts and Ceramics,London:
18. Dietler, Michael(2001).Theorizing the Feast: Rituals of Consumption, Commensal Politics, and Power in African Contexts.Feasts: Archaeological and Ethnographic Perspectives on Food, Politics, and Power,Washington, D.C.:
19. Dietler, Michael,Herbich, Ingrid(2001).Feasts and Labor Mobilization: Dissecting a Fundamental Economic Practice.Feasts: Archaeological and Ethnographic Perspectives on Food, Politics, and Power,Washington, D.C.:
20. Dillehay, Tom D.(2011).From Foraging to Farming in the Andes: New Perspectives on Food Production and Social Organization.New York:Cambridge University Press.
21. Dillehay, Tom D.,Goodbred, Steve,Pino, Mario,Vásquez Sánchez, Víctor F.,Tham, Teresa Rosales,Adovasio, James,Collins, Michael B.,Netherly, Patricia J.,Hastorf, Christine A.,Chiou, Katherine L.,Piperno, Dolores,Rey, Isabel,Velchoff, Nancy(2017).Simple Technologies and Diverse Food Strategies of the Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene at Huaca Prieta, Coastal Peru.Science Advances,3(5),1-13.
22. Earle, Timothy K.(2001).Economic Support of Chaco Canyon Society.American Antiquity,66(1),26-35.
23. Earle, Timothy K.(1991).The Evolution of Chiefdoms.Chiefdoms, Power, Economy, and Ideology,Cambridge:
24. Earle, Timothy K.(1997).How Chiefs Come to Power: The Political Economy in Prehistory.Stanford:Stanford University Press.
25. Edwards, Clinton R.(1965).Aboriginal Watercraft on the Pacific Coast of South America.Berkeley:University of California Press.
26. Fung, Rosa(1972).El Temprano Surgimiento En El Perú de Los Sistemas Socio-Políticos Complejos: Planteamiento de Una Hipótesis de Desarrollo Original.Apuntes Arqueológicos,2,10-32.
27. Haas, Jonathan,Creamer, Winifred(2012).Why Do People Build Monuments? Late Archaic Platform Mounds in the Norte Chico.Early New World Monumentality,Gainesville:
28. Haas, Jonathan,Creamer, Winifred(2006).Crucible of Andean Civilization: The Peruvian Coast from 3000 to 1800 BC.Current Anthropology,47(5),745-775.
29. Hayden, Brian(2014).The Power of Feasts: From Prehistory to the Present.New York:Cambridge University Press.
30. Hayden, Brian(2001).Fabulous Feasts: A Prolegomenon to the Importance of Feasting.Feasts: Archaeological and Ethnographic Perspectives on Food, Politics, and Power,Tuscaloosa:
31. Hayden, Brian(1998).Practical and Prestige Technologies: The Evolution of Material Systems.Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory,5(1),1-55.
32. Hayden, Brian,Villeneuve, Suzanne(2010).Who Benefits from Complexity? A View from Futuna.Pathways to Power,New York:
33. Hayden, Brian,Villeneuve, Suzanne(2011).A Century of Feasting Studies.Annual Review of Anthropology,40,433-449.
34. Joyce, Rosemary A.,Henderson, John S.(2007).From Feasting to Cuisine: Implications of Archaeological Research in an Early Honduran Village.American Anthropologist,109(4),642-653.
35. Lanning, Edward P.(1963).A Pre-Agricultural Occupation on the Central Coast of Peru.American Antiquity,28(3),360-371.
36. Lee, Cheng-yi,Chen, Maa-ling,Wu, Mu-chun(2018).Isotopic Perspectives of Dietary Patterns in Taiwan after the Introduction of Crops.Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports,20,355-361.
37. Mann, Michael(1986).The Sources of Social Power, Volume 1: A History of Power from the Beginning to AD 1760.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
38. Mauricio, Ana Cecilia(2015).Department of Anthropology, University of Maine.
39. Mills, Barbara J.(2007).Performing the Feast: Visual Display and Suprahousehold Commensalism in the Puebloan Southwest.American Antiquity,72(2),210-239.
40. Moseley, Michael E.(1975).The Maritime Foundations of Andean Civilization.Menlo Park:Cummings Publishing Co.
41. Moseley, Michael E.(1992).Maritime Foundations and Multilinear Evolution: Retrospect and Prospect.Andean Past,3,5-42.
42. Nesbitt, Jason(2012).An Initial Period Domestic Occupation at Huaca Cortada, Caballo Muerto Complex.Andean Past,10,279-284.
43. Osborn, Alan(1977).Strandloopers, Mermaids, and Other Fairy Tales: Ecological Determinants of Marine Resource Utilization: The Peruvian Case.For Theory Building in Archaeology,New York:
44. Pauketat, Timothy R.,Kelly, Lucretia S.,Fritz, Gayle J.,Lopinot, Neal H.,Elias, Scott,Hargrave, Eve(2002).The Residues of Feasting and Public Ritual at Early Cahokia.American Antiquity,67(2),257-279.
45. Paynter, Robert(1989).The Archaeology of Equality and Inequality.Annual Review of Anthropology,18(1),369-399.
46. Potter, James M.(2000).Pots, Parties, and Politics: Communal Feasting in the American Southwest.American Antiquity,65(3),471-492.
47. Pozorski, Shelia,Pozorski, Thomas(1979).An Early Subsistence Exchange System in the Moche Valley, Peru.Journal of Field Archaeology,6(4),413-432.
48. Pozorski, Shelia,Pozorski, Thomas(2008).Early Cultural Complexity on the Coast of Peru.The Handbook of South American Archaeology,New York:
49. Prieto, Gabriel(2018).The Temple of the Fishermen: Early Ceremonial Architecture at Gramalote, a Residential Settlement of the Second Millennium B.C., North Coast of Peru.Journal of Field Archaeology,43(3),200-221.
50. Prieto, Gabriel(2014).The Early Initial Period Fishing Settlement of Gramalote, Moche Valley: A Preliminary Report.Peruvian Archaeology,1,1-46.
51. Prieto, Gabriel(2015).Department of Anthropology, Yale University.
52. Prieto, Gabriel(2020).The Fisherman’s Garden Horticultural Practices in a Second Millennium Maritime Community of the North Coast of Peru.Maritime Communities of the Ancient Andes,Gainesville:
53. Quilter, Jeffrey(1991).Problems with the Late Preceramic of Peru.American Anthropologist,93(2),450-454.
54. Quilter, Jeffrey,Stocker, Terry(1983).Subsistence Economies and the Origins of Andean Complex Societies.American Anthropologist,85(3),545-562.
55. Rappoport, Roy(1968).Pigs for the Ancestors.New Haven:Yale University Press.
56. Raymond, J. Scott(1981).The Maritime Foundations of Andean Civilization: A Reconsideration of the Evidence.American Antiquity,46(4),806-821.
57. Sahlins, Marshall(1972).Stone Age Economics.Chicago:Aldine-Atherton.
58. Sandweiss, Daniel(2009).Early Fishing and Inland Monuments: Challenging the Maritime Foundations of Andean Civilization?.Andean Civilization: A Tribute to Michael E. Moseley,Los Angeles:
59. Sauer, Carl O.(1952).Agricultural Origins and Dispersals.New York:The American Geographical Society.
60. Service, Elman Rogers(1962).Primitive Social Organization, an Evolutionary Perspective.New York:Random House.
61. Shady, Ruth(1999).El Sustento Económico Del Surgimiento de La Civilización En El Peru.La Ciudad Sagrada de Caral-Supe: Los Orígenes de La Civilización Andina y La Formación Del Estado Prístino En El Antiguo Perú,Lima:
62. Shady, Ruth(2006).America’s First City? The Case of Late Archaic Caral.Andean Archaeology III,New York:
63. Shady, Ruth(2009).Caral-Supe y Su Entorno Natural y Social.Andean Civilization: A Tribute to Michael E. Moseley,Los Angeles:
64. Silverman, Helaine(1993).Cahuachi in the Ancient Nasca World.Iowa City:University of Iowa Press.
65. Spielmann, Katherine A.(2002).Feasting, Craft Specialization, and the Ritual Mode of Production in Small-Scale Societies.American Anthropologist,104(1),195-207.
66. Stanish, Charles,Tantaleán, Henry,Knudson, Kelly(2018).Feasting and the Evolution of Cooperative Social Organizations circa 2300 B.P. in Paracas Culture, Southern Peru.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,115(29),6716-6721.
67. Strong, William Duncan,Evans, Clifford(1952).Cultural Stratigraphy in the Virú Valley, Northern Peru: The Formative and Florescent Epochs.New York:Columbia University Press.
68. Thomas, Julian(2003).Thoughts on the ʽRepackedʼ Neolithic Revolution.Antiquity,77(295),67-74.
69. Vaughn, Kevin(2006).Craft Production, Exchange, and Political Power in the Pre-Incaic Andes.Journal of Archaeological Research,14(4),313-344.
70. Vaughn, Kevin(2004).Households, Crafts, and Feasting in the Ancient Andes: The Village Context of Early Nasca Craft Consumption.Latin American Antiquity,15(1),61-88.
71. Vega-Centeno, Rafael(2007).Construction, Labor Organization, and Feasting during the Late Archaic Period in the Central Andes.Journal of Anthropological Archaeology,26(2),150-171.
72. Vega-Centeno, Rafael(2005).Department of Anthropology, University of Arizona.
73. Willey, Gordon R.(1953).Prehistoric Settlement Patterns in the Viru Valley, Peru.Washington, D.C.:Smithsonian Institution.
74. Wilson, David J.(1988).Prehispanic Settlement Patterns in the Lower Santa Valley, Peru: A Regional Perspective on the Origins and Development of Complex North Coast Society.Washington, D.C.:Smithsonian Institution.
75. Wilson, David J.(1981).Of Maize and Men: A Critique of the Maritime Hypothesis of State Origins on the Coast of Peru.American Anthropologist,83(1),93-120.
76. Wilson, David J.(1983).The Origins and Development of Complex Prehispanic Society in the Lower Santa Valley, Peru: Implications for Theories of State Origins.Journal of Anthropological Archaeology,2(3),209-276.
77. Yu, Pei-lin(2020).Modeling Incipient Use of Neolithic Cultigens by Taiwanese Foragers: Perspectives from Niche Variation Theory, the Prey Choice Model, and the Ideal Free Distribution.Quaternary,3(3),1-24.
78. 米泓生,李匡悌(2010)。國科會補助計畫期末報告國科會補助計畫期末報告,國科會。
79. 李光周(1987).墾丁國家公園的史前文化.臺北:行政院文化建設委員會.
80. 李匡悌(2000)。再看三千年前臺灣南端的漁撈和採貝。藍色運動：尋回臺灣的海洋生物（第三屆臺灣海洋環境大會論文集），臺北市:
81. 李匡悌(1995)。臺灣南端的史前海岸適應：經濟學與生態學的研究途徑。國立臺灣大學考古人類學刊，50，197-217。
82. 李匡悌(1989)。保育研究報告第66號保育研究報告第66號,屏東:內政部營建署墾丁國家公園管理處。
83. 李匡悌(1994)。龜山遺址出土的食用貝類及其相關問題的探討。田野考古，5(1)，45-86。
84. 李娜莉(2003)。國立臺灣大學人類學研究所。
85. 陳仲玉(1999)。福建金門金龜山與浦邊史前遺址。東南考古研究，2，52-61。
86. 陳維鈞(2007)。金門金龜山貝塚遺址的重要性及其文化意義。田野考古，11(1/2)，75-107。
87. 彭佳鴻(2010)。國立臺灣大學人類學研究所。
88. 臧振華(2013)。臺灣新石器時代早期居民的環境認知與資源利用。考古學與永續發展研究，臺北:
89. 劉亭攸(2012)。國立臺灣大學人類學研究所。

1. 陳珮瑜(2023)。陶器「始」用的脈絡與詮釋：以秘魯Virú河谷的Huaca Negra遺址為例。考古人類學刊，98，45-88。