陶器「始」用的脈絡與詮釋：以秘魯Virú河谷的Huaca Negra遺址為例

Contextualizing the Emergence of Pottery Use and Its Interpretation: A Case Study from Huaca Negra, Virú Valley, Peru

10.6152/jaa.202306_(98).0003

陳珮瑜(Peiyu Chen)

陶器始用 ； 屬性分析 ； 岩象分析 ； 勞力投入 ； 共享概念 ； the emergence of pottery use ； attribute analysis ； petrographic analysis ； labor investment ； shared idea/experience

考古人類學刊

98期（2023 / 06 / 01）

45 - 88

繁體中文;英文

「人們為何開始製作與使用陶器」是考古學的重要課題之一，而秘魯北海岸Virú河谷的Huaca Negra遺址具備先陶時代到初始時期的連續佔居堆積地層，見證了初代陶器的出現，成為極佳的個案研究。本文嘗試就經濟視角與社會文化意涵兩個層面來理解陶器始用的驅力與詮釋。在方法上，屬性分析揭露了初代陶器主要的實用功能以及紋飾的時空分布差異。另一方面，岩象分析著墨陶器原料來源，並提供初代陶器的製作技術的資訊。兩種分析方法都顯示陶工並未追求成品的一致性或標準化，而是共享製作的基本概念，從中建立共同的製陶與使用經驗甚至社群意識。當前的工作顯示在經濟實用功能與社會意涵兩個層次之外，也應由社群觀點理解始用陶器的動機，這樣的切入點除了為安地斯區域內的比較研究提供新資料，也為整體陶器肇始的探究提供新的脈絡。

"Why did people begin to use pottery vessels" is one of the most compelling questions to archaeologists. Located in the Virú Valley on the north coast of Peru, Huaca Negra presents an excellent case study as the site witnessed the transition from the Late Preceramic Period to the Initial Period occupation. From economic/utilitarian and sociocultural perspectives, the interpretation and driving force for the emergence of pottery use can be addressed. Two analytical methods are applied. Attribute analysis illustrates a clear utilitarian function of this assemblage and the spatiotemporal distribution of different types of decoration. Petrographic analysis traces the provenance of raw materials and depicts the technological aspects of the studied materials. The results of analyses indicate that potters in Huaca Negra did not pursue consistent or standardized ceramic products. Nonetheless, they did possess a shared idea and shared experience of pottery making and use, which contributed to the establishment of a sense of community. Current work suggests that, in addition to the economic/utilitarian and sociocultural aspects, the emergence of pottery use can also be interpreted from a community perspective. This new theoretical framework lays the foundation for future comparative studies in the Andes and for addressing the emergence of pottery use from a broader scope.

1. 陳珮瑜(2020)。生業資源的利用與小規模社會的發展：比較觀點下的海洋假說與宴飲消費。考古人類學刊，93，49-86。
   連結：
2. Arnold, Dean(1985).Ceramic Theory and Cultural Process.New York:Cambridge University Press.
3. Barnett, William K.(ed.),Hoopes, John W.(ed.)(1995).The Emergence of Pottery: Technology and Innovation in Ancient Societies.Washington, D.C.:Smithsonian Institution Press.
4. Bettinger, Robert L.,Madsen, David B.,Elston, Robert G(1994).Prehistoric Settlement Categories and Settlement Systems in the Alashan Desert of Inner Mongolia, PRC.Journal of Anthropological Archaeology,13,74-101.
5. Billman, Brian R(1996).University of California, Santa Barbara.
6. Bischof, Henning(2009).Los Periodos Arcaico Tardío, Arcaico Final y Formativo Temprano en el Valle de Casma: Hipótesis y Evidencias.Boletín de Arqueología PUCP,13,9-54.
7. Briket-Smith, Kaj(1965).The Path of Culture: A General Ethnology.Madison:University of Wisconsin Press.
8. Brown, James A.(1989).The Beginnings of Pottery as an Economic Process.What’s New? A Closer Look at the Process of Innovation,London:
9. Cárdenas, Mercedes(1999).El Período Precerámico en el Valle de Chao.Boletín de Arqueología PUCP,3,141-169.
10. Chen, Peiyu(2019).University of Pittsburgh.
11. Childe, V. Gordon 1936 Man Makes Himself. London: New American Library of World Literature.
12. Cohen, David J.(2013).The Advent and Spread of Early Pottery in East Asia: New Dates and New Considerations for the World’s Earliest Ceramic Vessels.Journal of Austronesian Studies,4(2),55-92.
13. Cohen, David J.,Bar-Yosef, Ofer,Wu, Xiaohong,Patania, Ilaria,Goldberg, Paul(2017).The Emergence of Pottery in China: Recent Dating of Two Early Pottery Cave Sites in South China.Quaternary International,441,36-48.
14. Craig, Oliver E.,Hayley Saul, Alexandre Lucquin,Yastami Nishida,Karine Taché,Leon Clarke, A. Thompson,David T. Altoft,Kevin Gibbs, Sven Isaksson, Carl P. Heron, Peter Jordan(2013).Earliest Evidence for the Use of Pottery.Nature,496(7445),351-354.
15. Crown, Patricia,Wills, Wirt H.(1995).The Origins of Southwestern Ceramic Containers: Women’s Time Allocation and Economic Intensification.Journal of Anthropological Research,51,173-186.
16. Damp, Jonathan E.,Patricia, L.,Vargas, S.(1995).The Many Contexts of Early Valdivia Ceramics.The Emergence of Pottery: Technology and Innovation in Prehistoric Societies,Washington D.C.:
17. Eerkens, Jelmer W.(2004).Privatization, Small-Seed Intensification, and the Origins of Pottery in the Western Great Basin.Antiquity,69,653-670.
18. Foodways, Andean(ed.),Staller, John(ed.)(2021).Grilling Clams and Roasting Tubers: Andean Maritime Foodways in the Second Millennium BC.Cham:Springer.
19. Hayden, Brian(1995).The Emergence of Prestige Technology and Pottery.The Emergence of Pottery: Technology and Innovation in Prehistoric Societies,Washington D.C.:
20. Hayden, Brian(1998).Practical and Prestige Technologies: The Evolution of Material Systems.Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory,5(1),1-55.
21. Hommel, Peter(2014).Ceramic Technology.The Oxford Handbook of the Archaeology and Anthropology of Hunter-Gatherers. Vicki Cummings
22. Hoopes, John W.(1994).Ford Revisited: A Critical Review of the Chronology and Relationships of the Earliest Ceramic Complexes in the New World, 6000-1500 B.C.Journal of World Prehistory,81(8),1-49.
23. Jordan, Peter(ed.),Zvelebil, Marek(ed.)(2009).Ceramics before Farming: the Dispersal of Pottery among Prehistoric Eurasian Hunter-gatherers.Walnut Creek:Left Coast.
24. Kanomata, Yoshitaka,Marcos, Jorge,Popov, Alexander,Lazin, Boris,Tabarev, Andrey(2019).New Data on Early Pottery Traditions in South America: the San Pedro Complex, Ecuador.Antiquity,2019,1-6.
25. Kuzmin, Yaroslav V(2017).The Origins of Pottery in East Asia and Neighboring Regions: An Analysis Based on Radiocarbon Data.Quaternary International,441,29-35.
26. Kuzmin, Yaroslav V.(2013).Origin of Old World Pottery as Viewed from the Early 2010s: When, Where and Why?.World Archaeology,45(4),539-556.
27. Kuzmin, Yaroslav V.(2006).Chronology of the Earliest Pottery in East Asia: Progress and Pitfalls.Antiquity,80(308),362-371.
28. Lucquin, Alexandre,Gibbs, Kevin,Uchiyama, Junzo,Saul, Hayley,Ajimoto, Mayumi,Eley, Yvette,Radini, Anita,Heron, Carl P.,Shoda, Shinya,Nishida, Yastami,Lundy, Jasmine,Jordan, Peter,Isaksson, Sven,Craig, Oliver E.(2016).Ancient Lipids Document Continuity in the Use of Early Hunter-Gatherer Pottery through 9,000 Years of Japanese Prehistory.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,113(15),3991-3996.
29. Magargal, Kate(2022).The Cost of Cooking for Foragers.Journal of Human Evolution,162(2022),103091.
30. Mauricio, Ana C.(2015).University of Maine.
31. Meggers, Betty,Evans, Clifford,Estrada, Emilio(1965).Clifford Evans The Early Formative Period of Coastal Ecuador.Washington DC:Smithsonian Institution Press.
32. Morisaki, Kazuki(2022).What Motivated Early Pottery Adoption in the Japanese Archipelago: A Critical Review.Quaternary International,608-609,65-74.
33. Nakazawa, Yuichi,Naganuma, Masaki,Tsutsumi, Takashi(2022).The Emergence and Transmission of Early Pottery in the Late-Glacial Japan.Quaternary International,608-609,75-87.
34. ONERN=Oficina Nacional de Evaluacion de Recursos Naturales(1973).Inventario, Evaluacion y Uso Racional de los Recursos Naturales de la Costa Cuenca del Rio Moche I. Presidencia de la Republica.Lima:Oficina Nacional de Evaluacion de Recursos Naturales Lima.
35. Oras, Ester,Lucquin, Alexandre,Lõugas, Lembi,Tõrv, Mari,Kriiska, Aivar,Craig, Oliver E.(2017).The Adoption of Pottery by North-East European Hunter-Gatherers: Evidence from Lipid Residue Analysis.Journal of Archaeological Science,78,112-119.
36. Oyuela-Caycedo, Augusto(1995).Rocks versus Clay: the Evolution of Pottery Technology in the Case of San Jacinto 1, Colombia.The Emergence of Pottery: Technology and Innovation in Prehistoric Societies,Washington D.C.:
37. Oyuela-Caycedo, Augusto,Bonzani, Renee M.(2005).San Jacinto I: a Historical Ecological Approach to an Archaic Site in Colombia.Tuscaloosa:University of Alabama Press.
38. Paulsen, Allison C.(1974).The Thorny Oyster and the Voice of God: Spondylus and Strombus in Andean Prehistory.American Antiquity,39(4),597-607.
39. Pearson, Richard(2005).The Social Context of Early Pottery in the Lingnan Region of South China.Antiquity,79(306),819-828.
40. Pozorski, Shelia,Pozorski, Thomas(1979).Alto Salaverry: A Peruvian Coastal Preceramic Site.Annals of Carnegie Museum,48,337-375.
41. Pozorski, Shelia,Pozorski, Thomas(2006).Las Haldas: An Expanding Initial Period Polity of Coastal Peru.Journal of Anthropological Research,62,27-52.
42. Pozorski, Shelia,Pozorski, Thomas(1977).Alto Salaverry: Sitio Preceramico de la Costa Peruana.Revista del Museo Nacional Lima,43,27-60.
43. Pozorski, Shelia,Pozorski, Thomas(1990).Reexamining the Critical Preceramic/Ceramic Period Transition: New Data from Coastal Peru.American Anthropologist,92(2),481-491.
44. Prieto, Gabriel(2014).The Early Initial Period Fishing Settlement of Gramalote, Moche Valley: A Preliminary Report.Peruvian Archaeology,1,1-46.
45. Prieto, Gabriel(2015).Yale University.
46. Prieto, Gabriel(2020).The Fisherman’s Garden Horticultural Practices in a Second Millennium Maritime Community of the North Coast of Peru.Maritime Communities of the Ancient Andes,Gainesville:
47. PuglieseFrancisco,Zimpel, Carlos,Neves, Eduardo(2018).What Do Amazonian Shellmounds Tell Us About the Long-Term Indigenous History of South America.Encyclopedia of Global Archaeology,Cham:
48. Rice, Prudence M.(2015).Pottery Analysis: a Sourcebook.London:University of Chicago Press.
49. Rice, Prudence M.(1999).On the Origins of Pottery.Journal of Archaeological Method Theory,6,1-54.
50. Roosevelt, Anna C.(1995).Early Pottery in the Amazon: Twenty Years of Scholarly Obscurity.The Emergence of Pottery: Technology and Innovation in Ancient Societies,Washington D.C.:
51. Roosevelt, Anna C.(2009).A Historical Memoir of Archaeological Research in Brazil (1981-2007).Boletim do Museu Paraense Emílio Goeldi Ciências Humanas,4(1),155-170.
52. Roosevelt, Anna C.(2022).The Sequence of Amazon Prehistory: A Methodology for Ethical Science.Tessituras Revista de Antropologia e Arqueologia,10(1),11-44.
53. Roosevelt, Anna C.,Housley, Rupert A.,da Silveira, Maura Imazio,Maranca, Silvia,Johnson, Richard(1991).Eighth Millennium Pottery from a Prehistoric Shell Midden in the Brazilian Amazon.Science,254(5038),1621-1624.
54. Sandweiss, Daniel H.(1996).Mid-Holocene Cultural Interaction between the North Coast of Peru and Ecuador.Latin American Antiquity,7(1),41-50.
55. Saunder, Rebecca,Hays, Christopher T.(2004).Introduction: Themes in Early Pottery Research.Early pottery: Technology, Style, and Interaction in the Lower Southeast,Tuscaloosa:
56. Skibo, James M.,Malainey, Mary E.,Drake, Eric C.(2009).Stone Boiling, Fire-Cracked Rock, and Nut Oil: Exploring the Origins of Pottery Making on Grand Island.The Wisconsin Archeologist,90(1&2),47-64.
57. Strong, William D.,Evans, Clifford(1952).Cultural Stratigraphy in the Virú Valley, Northern Peru: the Formative and Florescent Epochs.New York:Columbia University Press.
58. Tabarev, Andrey,Kanomata, Yoshitaka,Marcos, Jorge,Popov, Alexander,Lazin, Boris(2016).Insights into the Earliest Formative Period of Coastal Ecuador: New Evidence and Radiocarbon Dates from the Real Alto Site.Radiocarbon,58,323-330.
59. Taché, Karine,Craig, Oliver E.(2015).Cooperative Harvesting of Aquatic Resources and the Beginning of Pottery Production in North-eastern North America.Antiquity,89,177-190.
60. Testart, Alain,Forbis, Richard G.,Hayden, Brian,Ingold, Tim,Perlman, Stephen M.,Pokotylo, David L.,Rowley-Conwy, Peter,Stuart, David E.(1982).The Significance of Good Storage among Hunter-gatherers: Residence Patterns, Population Densities, and Social Inequalities.Current Anthropology,23(5),523-537.
61. Tsetlin, Yuri B.(2018).The Origin of Ancient Pottery Production.Journal of Historical Archaeology and Anthropological Sciences,3(2),209-214.
62. Willey, Gordon R.(1953).Prehistoric Settlement Patterns in the Viru Valley, Peru.Washington, DC:U.S. Government Print Office.
63. Wu, Xiaohong,Zhang, Chi,Goldberg, Paul,Cohen, David J.,Pan, Yan,Arpin, Trina,Bar-Yosef, Ofer(2012).Ofer Bar-Yosef 2012 Early pottery at 20,000 years ago in Xianrendong Cave, China.Science,336,1696-1700.
64. Yesner, David R.(1980).Maritime Hunter-Gatherers: Ecology and Prehistory.Current Anthropology,21(6),727-750.
65. Zoubek, Thomas A.(2000).Archaeological Investigation at the Initial Period Center of Huaca el Gallo/Huaca la Gallina, Viru Valley, Peru: the 1994 Field Season.Andean Past,6,37-68.
66. Zoubek, Thomas A.(1997).Yale University.