多層級治理於氣候調適與減災融合決策上之研究－以新北市石碇區大崙山大規模崩塌潛勢區為例

Multilevel Governance to Integrate Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction Policies: a Large-Scale Landslide Area in Shi-Ding District, New Taipei City as an Example

10.29417/JCSWC.201912_50(4).0004

何謹余(Chin-Yu He)；童慶斌(Ching-Pin Tung)；王晉倫(Chin-Lun Wang)；林永峻(Yong-Jun Lin)

氣候變遷 ； 減災 ； 多層級治理 ； 調適路徑 ； 融合 ； climate change adaptation ； disaster risk reduction ； multi-level governance ； adaptation pathway ； integration

中華水土保持學報

50卷4期（2019 / 12 / 01）

166 - 177

繁體中文

越來越多研究指出氣候變遷與減災之間具有重疊的目標與相似的策略，然而融合的過程中卻有一定的挑戰，2013聯合國國際減災策略組織（United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction）」在關於實施兵庫行動綱領（Hyogo Framework）建議的國家級進展的報告提到「幾乎所有國家都報告難以將氣候變化適應措施納入國家減災（DRR, Disaster Risk Reduction）政策（Seidlera et al., 2018）。大部分的研究認為最大的困難在於兩個領域有各自獨立的行政推動架構，兩者行政推動框架之間資訊並不流通。此外，自然災害風險管理研究已從過去的危害議題發展至重視脆弱性與人為因素，災害風險不再只是或然率或是發生度的問題，轉向更複雜的系統方法，包括政治和社會層面之間的關係，以產生更廣泛的系統觀點與協同、持續和負責任地管理災害風險的新策略。本文著重多層級間的能力評估與環境負荷間的關係，以氣候調適路徑法為工具，進行減災與調適融合過程之研究，並嘗試提出在調適路徑法進行過程中同時評估多層級治理能力的方法，以規劃出最適路徑。研究案例以新興危害-大規模崩塌為實例，採用「多層級治理評估結合調適路徑法」進行示例，三條融合調適路徑，說明如何在潛在轉乘點時，應重新進行各層級治理能力評估，以找到最適路徑。

Numerous scholars have argued that climate change adaptation (CCA) and disaster risk reduction (DRR) have overlapping goals and similar strategies. However, the process of integration tends to encounter particular challenges. Most studies have claimed that the paramount difficulty was attributable to the two frameworks having their own independent administrative promotion structures. The implementation of climate policy has been greatly affected by multilevel governance (MLG). In the process of integrating DRR and CCA, MLG capability and the interrelationships between its various levels are important. The study presents the case of an emerging large-scale landslide hazard. In this study, we present an application of MLG and CCA to the large-scale landslide area in Shi-Ding District, New Taipei City. Considering the CCA pathway method as a tool and taking an emerging landslide hazard as an example to illustrate the relationship between multilevel capability assessment and environmental load. Besides, to minimize the systemic risk of internal conflicts, the capacity between the various levels must be considered to coordinate internal strategy formulation.

1. 何謹余, C.Y.,童慶斌, C.P.,王涴雅, W.Y.(2020)。減災與氣候變遷調適在區域治理上之融合研究-以坡地災害為例。農業工程學報，66(2)
   連結：
2. (1987).Judgmental Forecasting.Chichester, UK:Wiley.
3. Brooks, K.W.(1979).Delphi Technique: Expanding Applications.North Central Association Quarterly,53(3),377-385.
4. Bulkeley, H.,Andonova, L.B.,Betsill, M.M.,Compagnon, D.,Hale, T.,Hoffmann, M.J.,Newell, P.,Paterson, M.,Roger, C.,VanDeveer, S.D.(2014).Transnational Climate Change Governance.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
5. Corfee-Morlot, J.,Kamal-Chaoui, L.,Donovan, M.G.,Cochran, I.,Robert, A.,Teasdale, P.-J.(2009).OECD Environmental Working PapersOECD Environmental Working Papers,Paris, France:OECD Publishing.
6. Dalkey, N.C.(1969).The Delphi Method: An Experimental Study of Group Opinion.Santa Monica:Rand.
7. de Leon, E.G.,Pittock, J.(2017).Integrating climate change adaptation and climate-related disaster risk-reduction policy in developing countries: a case study in the Philippines.Climate and Development,9(5),471-478.
8. Dias, N.,Amaratunga, D.,Haigh, R.(2018).Challenges associated with integrating CCA and DRR in the UK- A review on the existing legal and policy background.Procedia Engineering,978-985.
9. Dias, N.,Clegg, C.,Amaratunga, D.,Haigh, R.(2019).A Resilient Environment through The Integration of CCA and DRR: An Overview of Existing Challenges.International Journal on Advanced Science Engineering and Information Technology,9(1),129-135.
10. Frey, K.,Ramírez, D.R.C.(2019).Multi-level network governance of disaster risks: the case of the Metropolitan Region of the Aburra Valley (Medellin, Colombia).Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,424-445.
11. Gebreyes, M.,Tesfaye, K.,Feleke, B.(2017).Climate change adaptation-disaster risk reduction nexus: case study from Ethiopia.International Journal of Climate Change Strategies and Management,9(6),829-845.
12. Haasnoot, M.,Kwakkel, J.H.,Warren, E.W.,ter Maatd, J.(2013).Dynamic adaptive policy pathways: A method for crafting robust decisions for a deeply uncertain world.Global Environmental Change,23(2),485-498.
13. Haasnoot, M.,Middelkoop, H.,Offermans, A.,van Beek, E.,van Deursen, W.P.A.(2012).Exploring pathways for sustainable water management in river deltas in a changing environment.Climatic Change,115,795-819.
14. IPCC(2012).Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation (A Special Report of Working Groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change).Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
15. ISO(2019).ISO/CD 14091. (2019). In Adaptation to climate change Vulnerability, impacts and risk assessment. ISO, Geneva, Switzerland..
16. Jordan, A.J.,Huitema, D.,Hildén, M.,van Asselt, H.,Rayner, T.J.,Schoenefeld, J.J.,Tosun, J.,Forster, J.,Boasson, E.L.(2015).Emergence of polycentric climate governance and its future prospects.Nature Climate Change,5(11),977-982.
17. Kelman, I.,Gaillard, J.(2010).Embedding climate change adaptation within disaster risk reduction.Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction: Issues and Challenges,Bingley, UK:
18. Kelman, I.,Mercer, J.,Gaillard, J.C.(2017).The Routledge Handbook of Disaster Risk Reduction Including Climate Change Adaptation.London, UK:Routledge.
19. Mall, R.K.,Srivastava, R.K.,Banerjee, T.,Mishra, O.P.,Bhatt, D.,Sonkar, G.(2019).Disaster Risk Reduction Including Climate Change Adaptation Over South Asia: Challenges and Ways Forward.International Journal of Disaster Risk Science,10(1),14-27.
20. Marquardt, J.(2017).Conceptualizing power in multilevel climate governance.Journal of Cleaner Production,167-175.
21. Maru, Y.T.,Smith, M.S.,Sparrow, A.,Pinhoc, P.F.,Dube, O.P.(2014).A linked resilience and vulnerability framework for adaptation pathways in remote disadvantaged communities.Global Environmental Change,28,337-350.
22. Mitchell, T.,van Aalst, M.,Villanueva, P.S.(2010).,Brighton, UK:Institute of Development Studies.
23. Monica Di Gregorio, L. F.,Paavola, Jouni,Locatelli, Bruno,Pramova, Emilia,Nurrochmat, Dodik Ridho,May, Peter H.,Brockhaus, Maria,Sari, Intan Maya,Kusumadewi, Sonya Dyah(2019).Multi-level governance and power in climate change policy networks.Global Environmental Change,54,64-77.
24. Mysiak, J.,Castellari, S.,Kurnik, B.,Swart, R.,Pringle, P.,Schwarze, R.,Wolters, H.,Jeuken, A.,van der Linden, P.(2018).Brief communication: Strengthening coherence between climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction.Nature Hazards and Earth System Science,18,3137-3143.
25. Nemakonde, L.D.,van Niekerk, D.(2017).A normative model for integrating organisations for disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation within SADC member states.Disaster Prevention and Management: An International Journal,26(3),361-376.
26. O’Brien, K.,Sygna, L.,Leichenko, R.,Adger, N.,Barnett, J.,Mitchell, T.T.,Schipper, L.,Tanner, T.,Vogel, C.,Mortreux, C.(2008).Disaster risk reduction, climate change adaptation and human security.Global Environmental Change and Human Security (GECHS) Project,2008(3)
27. Seidlera, R.,Dietrich, K.,Schweizerb, S.,Bawaa, K.S.,Chopdec, S.,Zamand, F.,Sharmae, A.,Bhattacharyaf, S.,Devkotag, L.P.,Khalingh, S.(2018).Progress on integrating climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction for sustainable development pathways in South Asia: Evidence from six research projects.International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction,31,92-101.
28. Siebentritt, M.,Halsey, N.,Stafford-Smith, M.(2014).Report prepared for the Eyre Peninsula Integrated Climate Change Agreement CommitteeReport prepared for the Eyre Peninsula Integrated Climate Change Agreement Committee,Adelaide, Australia:Government of South Australia.
29. Solecki, W.,Leichenko, R.,O’Brien, K.(2011).Climate change adaptation strategies and disaster risk reduction in cities: connections, contentions, and synergies.Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability,3,135-141.
30. Termeer, C.J.A.M.,Dewulf, A.,Biesbroek, G.R.(2017).Transformational Change: Governance Interventions for Climate Change Adaptation from a Continuous Change Perspective.Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,60(4),558-576.
31. UNISDR (2016). UNISDR Strategic Framework 2016–2021. UNISDR, Geneva, Switzerland. (Retrieved from https://www.unisdr.org/files/51557_strategicframework.pdf)
32. UNISDR(2015).Global Assessment Report on Disaster Risk ReductionGlobal Assessment Report on Disaster Risk Reduction,Geneva, Switzerland:UNISDR.
33. van der Heijden,Patterson, J.,Juhola, S.,Wolfram, M.(2018).Special Section: Advancing the Role of Cities in Climate Governance - Promise, Limits, Politics.Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,62(3),365-373.
34. Werners, S.E.,Pfenninger, S.,van Slobbe, E.,Haasnoot, M.,Kwakkel, J.H.,Swart, R.J.(2013).Thresholds, tipping and turning points for sustainability under climate change.Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability,334-340.
35. Wouter Botzen, W.J.,Bouwer, L.M.,Scussolini, P.,Kuik, O.,Haasnoot, M.,Lawrence, J.,Aerts, J.(2018).Integrated Disaster Risk Management and Adaptation.Loss and Damage from Climate Change
36. 國家發展委員會=National Development Conciul(2012).國家氣候變遷調適政策綱領.
37. 農委會水土保持局=SWCB(2019)。,未出版

1. 林昀萱,林明瑞(2022)。民眾颱風、洪水風險及災害調適行為模式之研究。災害防救科技與管理學刊，11(1)，77-102。