兩岸三地百貨零售業消費者行為、生活型態、促銷方式、廣告媒體與商店印象相關之研究

A Study of the Relationship Between Consumer Behavior, Life Style, Promotion Mode, Media Usage and Store Image for the General Merchandise of Retail Industry in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Shanghai

10.6504/JOM.2004.21.01.06

詹惠君(Hui-Chun Chan)；徐村和(Tsuen-Ho Hsu)；朱國明(Kuo-Ming Chu)

消費者行為 ； 商店印象 ； 參考點 ； 促銷方式 ； 廣告媒體 ； Consumer Behavior ； Reference ； Store Image ； promotion Mode ； Media

管理學報

21卷1期（2004 / 02 / 01）

103 - 130

繁體中文

零售業產值在世界經濟體制中已扮演極為重要的角色，而百貨零售業更有「經濟櫥窗」之美譽，因此，本研究以台、港、滬百貨零售業消費者為研究對象，利用廣告及促銷方式二參考點，分析消費者在購買商品時相對性價值的影響，以暸解三地區百貨零售業消費者行為，以及其他影響消費型態因素的差異情況，可做為台商進軍大陸市場之參考。本研究發現：兩岸三地的百貨零售業的消費者在生活型態、消費行為、廣告媒體及促銷方式選擇偏好上均有顯著的差異。消費者在百貨零售業商店印象因素及滿意度顯示：台灣地區以商品之品牌、包裝、標示與結帳迅速最為重要；香港重視商品貨源充足；上海地區則重視商品種類齊全及賣場氣氛，但三個地區的消費者對百貨零售業商店印象因素的共通偏好均為便利性。

The net growth of retail service industry has played a rather significant role in the world economy. The general merchandise retail industry especially gains the fame of the window economy. This research will focus on the evaluation of the reference frames and consuming behaviors when consumers are engaged in general merchandise purchasing. The principal goal at the end of this paper is to provide suggestions for firms to establish favorable store image under limited amount of resources to other pats of the world. Thus, this paper will lay emphasis on the consumers of general merchandise retail industry in three cross-strait areas: Taiwan, Hong Kong and Shanghai. Through understanding consumer behavior and life style, the study could be served as a reference for providing strategies for Taiwanese business, which intends to invest the China market. According to the purpose of this study, we probe consumer’s different impression of store image in the general merchandise retail industry of this research in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Shanghai. It is suggested that consumers with different patterns of life styles exposures to different advertising media and promotion activities will lead to different preferences of store image attributes. This paper adopts Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), which combines Factor Analysis and Path Analysis, to analyze our study model in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Shanghai. Prior studies have indicated that a consumer’s awareness; concept of bias and attitude is very vague and uncontrollable during the process of decision-making. In order to overcome this uncertainty, this paper will adopt Chan(1999) interpretations on ways consumer react to constructive Fuzzy Linguistic Scale for the consumers in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Shanghai. By using this model, the problems that involve different cognitive awareness on linguistic terms from the interviewees, could eventually be surmounted. There is a strong lack of records and documents from scholars that focus on the consumer activities of multinational general merchandise retail industry. As a result, this paper will classify the effect of consumer evaluation on the related variation from store image through case studies. The fourth aim of this study is to find out the positive bias from a consumer’s point of view on the degree of satisfaction in favorable store image. All this careful examination will act as reference for a market. The results show a significant difference in the consumers’ life style, the consumer condition, the advertising media, the promotion mode, different preferences of store attributes for consumers of general merchandise retail industry in Taiwan, Hong Kong and Shanghai. The advertising media and promotion activities of the general merchandise retail industry differ significantly in store images and from areas. This result indicates the more advertising media and promotion activities are implemented, the more influential it is on the consumers’ store images in the general merchandise retail industry. The means of promotion activities have a stronger impact than the advertising media in the choice of consumer purchase in the general merchandise retail industry. In terms of Taiwan, Hong Kong and Shanghai, consumer life style, advertising media and promotion activities have a significant influence on the store image. In Taiwan and Shanghai, the more often advertising media and promotion activities play a role, the more influences there are on consumer store image; The promotion activities on the other hand, have a significant influence than advertising media in terms of effecting the choice of consumer store image of the general merchandise retail industry. However, in Hong Kong region, the relationship between advertising media and consumer store image appear to be negative. From the result of this paper; though the three regions share a common Chinese culture, however; economic background could result in dominant differences. Five years after Hong Kong returned to China the high economic growth in Shanghai have made the structure and development a step closer to Taiwan. In terms of some partial content, there is no significant difference. As a result, this paper takes living styles and factors that influence consumer behavior into consideration, to further discuss what makes the consumers of similar background and life styles affect one another. So researchers must construct a complete behavior model, including important variables that might cause consumer behavior differences, and thus be able to provide international marketing studies for business implementation.

1. Aaker, David A.(1973).Toward A Normative Model of Promotional Decision Marketing.Management Science,19(6),593-603.
2. Ajzen, I.,M. Fishbein(1980).Understanding Attitudes and Predicting Social Behavior.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
3. Anderson, Thomas,Golden, Linda(1984).Advances in Consumer Research XI.Ann Arbor, Mich:Association for Consumer Research.
4. Batra, Rajeev,Douglas M. Stayman(1990).The Role of Mood in Advertising Effectiveness.Journal of Consumer Research,17,203-214.
5. Bearden, W. O.,Teel, Jr. I. E.,Durand, R. M.(1978).Media Usage, Psychographic and Demographic of Retail Shoppers.Journal of Retailing,54(1),65-74.
6. Belch, George E.,Michael A. Belch(1999).Advertising and Promotion: An Integrated Marketing Communications Perspective
7. Berry, Leonard, L.,A Parasuman(1993).Building A New Academical Field-The Case of Service Marketing.Journal of Retailing,69,13-60.
8. Blattberg, Robert C.,Scott A. Neslin(1990).Sales Promotion: Concept, Methods, and Strategies.Englewood Chiffs, N. J. Prentice-Hall.
9. Bollen, K. A.,Brab, K. H.(1981).Pearson`s R and Coarsely Categorized Measures.American Sociological Review,46,232-239.
10. Boulding, Kenneth E.(1956).The Image.Ann Arbor, Mich:The University of Michigan Press.
11. Bradly, R. A.,Katti, S. K.,Coons, I. J.(1962).Optimal Scaling for Ordered Categories.Psychometrika,27,355-374.
12. Braun, K. A.(1999).Postexperience Advertising Effects on Consumer Memory.Journal of Consumer Research,25(4),319-352.
13. Campbell, L.,Diamond, W. D.(1990).Framing and Sales Promotions: The Characteristics of a Good Deal.Journal of Consumer Marketing,7(4),25-31.
14. Chan, Hui-Chun(1999).A Study on Consumer Behavior of the Department Store on Taiwan, Hongkong, Shanhai: Application on Fuzzy Set and Gray Theory.
15. Chang, Ai-Hua(1977).A Study on Consumer`s Store Image.Taipei, Taiwan (in Chinese):unpublished master thesis, National Cheng Chi University.
16. Chang, Shao-shiun(2000).Researh Method.Tsang-Hai Book Publishing Co.
17. Chen, Shih-Fen S.,Kent B. Monroe,Yung-Chien Lou(1998).The Effects of Framing Price Promotion Messages on Consumers` Perceptions and Purchase Intentions.Journal of Retailing,74,353-372.
18. Chow, Tai-Hwa, Fu-Yann Duh(1997).Retail Management.Hwa-Tai Inc.
19. Curren, Mary T.,Katrin R. Harich(1994).Consumers` Mood States: The Mitigating Influence of Personal Relevance on Product Evaluations.Psychology and Marketing,11(2),91-107.
20. Del. I. Hawkins,Roger J. Best,Kenneth A. Coney(1995).Consumer Behavior: Implication For Marketing Strategy.Irwin, Inc.
21. Dommermuth, W. P.(1989).Promotion: Analysis Creativity and Strategy.Boston, Mass:PWS-Kent Publishing Company.
22. Engel, J. F.,Blackwell, R. D.,Miniard, P. W.(1993).Consumer Behavior, 7th.
23. Fisk, Raymond P.,Mary Jo Bitner,Stephen W. Brown(1993).Tracing the Evaluation of the Services Marketing Literature.Journal of Retailing,69,61-103.
24. Folkes, Valerie,Rita D. Wheat(1995).Consumers` Price Perceptions of Promoted Products.Journal of Retailing,71,317-328.
25. Goldberg, Marvin E.,Gerald J. Gorn(1987).Happy and Sad TV Programs: How They Affect Reactions to Commercials.Journal of Consumer Research,14,387-403.
26. Goodstein, Ronald C.(1993).Category-based Applications and Extensions in Advertising: Motivating More Extensive Ad Processing.Journal of Consumer Research,20,87-99.
27. Greenleaf, E. A.(1995).The Impact of Reference Price Effects on The Profitability of Price Promotions.Marketing Science,14(1),82-104.
28. Grewal, Dhruv,R. Krishnan, Julie Baker,Norm Bonin(1998).The Effect of Store Name, Brand Name and Price Discounts on Consumers` Evaluations and Purchase Intentions.Journal of Retailing,74,331-352.
29. Gupta, Sunil,Lee G. Cooper(1992).The Discounting of Discounts and Promotion Thresholds.Journal of Consumer Research,19,401-411.
30. Haley, Russell I.,Allan L. Baldinger(1991).The ARF Copy Research Validity Project.Journal of Advertising Research,31,11-32.
31. Hansen, Robert A.,Terry Deutscher(1977).An Empirical Investigation of Attribute Importance in Retail Store Selection.Journal of Retailing,53(4),59-73.
32. James, Don L.,Richard M. Durand,Robert Dreves(1976).The Use of a Multi-Attribute in a Store Image Study.Journal of Retailing,52,23-34.
33. Janiszewski, Chris(1993).Perception Without Awareness: Cognitive, Clinical and Social.Journal Of Marketing Research,30(4),530-532.
34. Janiszewski, Chris(1988).Preconscious Processing Effects: The Independence of Attitude Formation and Conscious Thought.Journal Of Consumer Research,15(2),199-209.
35. Janiszewski, Chris(1998).The Influence of Display Characteristics on Visual Exploratory Search Behavior.Journal of Consumer Research,25(3),290-301.
36. Janiszewski, Chris(1990).The Influence of Nonattended Material on the Processing of Advertising Claims.Journal Of Marketing Research,27(3),263-278.
37. Janiszewski, Chris(1990).The Influence of Print Advertisement Organization on Affect Toward A Brand Name.Journal Of Consumer Research,17(1),53-65.
38. Johansson, Thomas,Fredrik Miegel(1992).Do the Right Thing: Lfes1yle and Identity in contemporary Youth Culture.Stockholm:Almqvist & Wiksell International.
39. Kahneman, Darieh,Amos Tversky(1979).Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision Under Risk.Econometrica,47,263-291.
40. Kim, Sandra, Gu,Moon(2002).Cross-cultural consumer values, needs and purchase behavior.The Journal of Consumer Marketing,19(6),481-502.
41. Knowles, Patricia A.,Stephen J. Grove,Jeffrey Burroughs(1993).An Examination of Mood Effects on Retrieval and Evaluation of Advertisement and Brand Information.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,21,135-142.
42. Kotler, P.(2003).Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning Implementation and Control.New Jersey, Prentice-Hall Inc.
43. Lazer, William(1963).Proceedings of the American Marketing Association.
44. Lin, Qi-Ming(2002).A Discriminate Analysis on Department Store: The Citizens of Hsinchu as an Example.Hsinchu, Taiwan (in Chinese):unpublished master thesis, Chung Hua University.
45. Lindquist, Jy D.(1974).Meaning of Image.Journal of Retailing,50(4),29-38.
46. Lo, Lieh-Ming(2001).The Study of the Impact of Price Promotion and Country-of-origin Effect on Consumer Behavior.Tainan, Taiwan (in Chinese):unpublished master thesis, National Cheng Kung University.
47. Luick, John F.,Willeam Lee Ziegler(1968).Sales Promotion and Modern Merchandising.New York:McGraw-Hill Company.
48. Marian, Frand M.(1987).Doctoral Dissertation, Memphis State University.
49. Marieke de Mooij,Geert Hofstede(2002).Convergence and divergence in consumer behavior: implications for international retailing.Journal of Retailing,78(1),62-69.
50. Martineau, Pierre(1958).The Personality of The Retail Store.Harvard Business Review,36,47-55.
51. Mela F. Carl,Kamel, C. F.,Bowman(1998).Journal of Marketing Research.
52. Mela F. Carl,Sunil Gupta,Donald R. Lehmann(1997).The Long-Term Impact of Promotion and Advertising on Consumer Brand Choice,.Journal of Marketing,34,248-261.
53. Mitchell, Arnold(1983).The Nine American Lifestyles: Who We Are and Where We Are Going?.New York:Warner Books.
54. Monroe, Kent B.(1990).Pricing: Making Profitable Decisions.Second Edition, New York:McGraw-Hill Book Company.
55. Nevin, J. R.,Houston, M. J.(1980).Image as a Component of Attraction to Intraurban Shopping Areas.Journal of Retailing,56(1),77-93.
56. Olsson, U.,Drasgow, F.,Dorans, N. J.(1982).The Polyserical Correlation Coefficient.Psychometrika,47,337-347.
57. Oxenfeldt, Alfred R.(1974).Developing a Favorable Price-Quality Image.Journal of Retailing,50,8-14.
58. Peterson, Robert A.,Roger A. Kerin(1983).Store Image Measurement in Patronage Research: Fact and Artifact.New York:North Holland.
59. Plummer, J. T.(1974).The Concept and Application of Life Style Segmentation.Journal of Marketing,38,34.
60. Raghubir, P.,Corfman, K.(1999).When do Price Promotions Affect Pretrial Brand Evaluations?.Journal of Marketing Research,36,211-222.
61. Ralston, D. A.(1997).The Impact of National Culture And Economic Ideology on Managerial Values: A Study of the U.S., Russia, Japan, and China.Journal of International Business Studies,28(1),177-208.
62. Reynolds, Fred D.,Wells, William D.(1977).Consumer Behavior.Mcgraw-Hill.
63. Rossiter, John R.,Larry Percy(1998).Advertising Communications and Promotion Management.Singapore:McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
64. Shafir, Itamar Simonson,Amos Tversky(1993).Reason-Based Choice.Cognition,49,11-36.
65. Shapiro, Stewart,Deborah J. Macinnis,Susan E. Heckler(1997).The Effects of Incidental Ad Exposure on The Formation of Consideration Sets.Journal of Consumer Research,24(1),94-104.
66. Sheth, Jagdish N.,David M. Gardner,Dennis E. Garrett(1988).Marketing Theory: Evolution and Evaluation.New York:John Wiley &Sons.
67. Shi, Shing-Hong(1994).The Consumer Behavior`s Comparsion of the GMS,SM and CVS.Taichung, Taiwan (in Chinese):unpublished master thesis, Tung Hai University.
68. Shimp, T. A.(1997).Advertising, Promotion, and Supplemental Aspects Integrated Marketing Communications.Harcourt Brace Chicago:Dryden Press.
69. Shimp, T. A.(1990).Promotion Management and Marketing Communications.Chicago, IL:Dryden Press.
70. Solomon R. Michael(1999).Consumer Behavior: Buying, Having, and Being.Prentice Hall International, Inc., New Jersey.
71. Tohmatsu, Deloitte Touche(2000).GIobal Powers of Retailing.Stores,2,3-46.
72. Trivedi, M.(1999).Using Variety-Seeking-Based Segmentation to Study Promotional Response.Academy of Marketing Science,27,37-49.
73. Tsai, Kuen-hung(1997).The Influences of the Interval Assumption of Ordinal Scale on the CFA Model.Journal of Management,14(3),387-402.
74. Tsai, Ming-Shung.A Study on the Effect of Retail Atmosphere on Consumers` Purchasing Decesions.Taichung, Taiwan (in Chinese):unpublished master thesis, Chao Yang University of Technology.
75. Tversky,Daniel Kahneman(1991).Loss Aversion in Riskless Choice: A Reference-Dependence Model.Quarterly Journal of Economics,106,1039-1063.
76. Walters, C. Glenn,Paul W. Gorden(1970).Consumer Behavior: An Integrated Framework.Homewood, III, Richard D Irwin Inc.
77. Wilhelm, M.R.,Parsaei, H.R.(1991).A Fuzzy Linguistic Approach to Implementing A Strategy for Computer Integrated Manufacturing.Fuzzy Sets and Systems,42,191-204.
78. Wortzel, L. H.(1987).Retailing Strategies for Today`s Mature Marketplace.The Journal of Business Strategy,7(4),45-56.
79. Yang, Ya-fen(1996).A Study of Consumer Behavior under Product Sampling: The Citizens of Taipei as an Example.Hsinchu, Taiwan (in Chinese):unpublished master thesis, National Chiao Tung University.
80. Zimmer, M. R.,Golden, L. L.(1988).Impression of Retail Stores: A Content Analysis of Consumer Images.Journal of Retailing,64,265-293.
81. Zotti, E.(1985).Thinking Psychographically.Public Relations Journal,41,26-30.

1. 林怡吟(2017)。大中華區品牌認知差異對購買意願之影響-以隨身碟產品為例。臺中科技大學企業管理系碩士班學位論文。2017。1-54。