题名

新金融服務開發過程的行銷活動對其績效之影響－服務／市場新穎性的干擾角色

并列篇名

The Impact of Marketing-Related Activities during New Financial Service Development on New Service Performance: The Moderating Role of Service-Market Newness

DOI

10.6504/JOM.2004.21.04.07

作者

陳嵩(Song Chen)

关键词

構想篩選 ； 市場研究 ； 試銷 ； 服務／市場新穎性 ； 新服務績效 ； idea screening ； market research ； test marketing ； service-market newness ； new service performance

期刊名称

管理學報

卷期/出版年月

21卷4期（2004 / 08 / 01）

页次

531 - 551

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

許多學者建議金融服務業者應改善構想篩選、市場研究的執行品質以提昇新服務績飰，惟少有研究驗證這些這些活動對新服務績效的貢獻。此外，許多研究探討服務業者在新服務開發過程忽略市場研究及試銷活動的理由，惟有研究驗證這些理由的客觀性。本研究以金融服務業的新服務開發為焦點，探討構想篩選、市場研究及試銷等行活動的執行品質對新服務績效的貢獻、服務／市場新穎性對行銷活動－新服務績效關聯的影響，並以國內銀行業及保險業的62個新服務開發專案為實證對象。實證結果顯示，市場研究對新服務績效有較顯著的正向影響。子群迴歸分析顯示，在高、低服務／市場新穎性群，構想篩選、市場研究及試銷活動對新服務績效呈不同的影響。最後，研究者對實證結果在新服裝開發管理涵義及後續研究做一些討論與建議。
英文摘要

Facing deregulation, blurring of industry boundaries, increasing competition, rapidly advancing information technology, and increased customer sophistication, financial institutions attempting to survive and grow will need continuously to create new ideas and launch new financial products. Successful new financial products (new services hereafter) not only contribute to the increase in sales and profits, but also help the institution build up reputation, improve customer royalty, boost the sales of existing products, and develop into new markets. However, the results of empirical researches show that only 60-70% of new services are successful, the failure rate of some financial sectors even amount to 50%. The financial loss directly caused by unsuccessful new services may not be great, but the hidden costs, such as the wasted human capital, negative impact on company image, opportunity cost (other new services with success potentials are missed) and customers’ losing faith in other services, can’t be neglected. How to improve the performance of new service development (NSD)? Scholars have suggested that financial service industries should enhance executive quality of idea screening and market studies to improve new service performance, yet these suggestions have seldom been verified empirically. Also substantial research has investigated the reasons that service industries neglected market research and test marketing during new service development (NSD), but little empirical research has examined the objectivity of these reasons. This study focuses on NSD in financial service industries in an attempt to explores the contribution of executive quality for idea screening, market research and test marketing on new service performance, and also examines the influence of service-market newness on the relationship of marketing-related activities to new service performance. Sixty-two NSD projects form banking and insurance industries in Taiwan were sampled as empirical subjects. The empirical results show that the executive quality of market research has significantly positive impact on new service performance. Subgroup regression analyses indicate that idea screening and test marketing have significantly positive impact on new service performance for projects of low service-market newness. Furthermore, market research has significantly positive impact and test marketing has significantly negative influence on new service performance for projects of high service-market newness. Overall, the significance of idea screening, market research, and test marketing during the new financial service development process varies depending the degree of newness that characterizes the new service and the targeted market. Therefore, this study suggests that for proving new financial service performance, participants in financial industries may adopt contingency criteria for new service idea screening and flexibly implement market research and test marketing during new financial service development process. For projects of low service-market newness, meeting the existent competencies, resource, and experience should be adopted as the idea screening criteria, and implementing detailed, formal and planned test marketing would help participants verify the effectiveness of marketing mix on attracting customers from competitors or potential customers. For projects of high service-market newness, strategic alignment may be the proper criteria for new service idea screening, and participants should enhance the executive quality of market research to reduce the uncertainty during new financial service development process (i.e., customer preference, expected market size), but should not implement overly complicated test marketing planning before launch to avoid giving competitor’s possible opportunity of leading into targeted market.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. Chen, Song(2001).Design-Manufacturing Integration in the Early Phases of New Product Development: An Exploratory Analysis and Empirical Study.NTU Management Review,12(1),85-121.
    連結：
  2. Adler, P. S.(1995).Interdepartmental Interdependence and Coordination: The Case of the Design/Manufacturing Interface.Organization Science,6(2),147-167.
  3. Alam, I.,C. Perry(2002).A Customer-Oriented New Service Development Process.Journal of Services Marketing,16(6),515-534.
  4. Ali, A.(1994).Pioneering Versus Incremental Innovation: Review and Research Propositions.The Journal of product Innovation Management,11(1),46-61.
  5. Amstrong, J.,T. S. Overton(1977).Estimating Non-response Bias in Mail Surveys.Journal of Marketing Research,16,396-402.
  6. Atuahene-Gima, K.(1996).Differential Potency of Factors Affecting Innovation Performance in Manufacturing and Service Firms in Australia.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,13(1),35-52.
  7. Avlonitis, G. J.,Papastathopoulou, P. G.,S. P. Gounaris(2001).An Empirically- based Typology of Product Innovativeness for New Financial Services: Success and Failure Scenarios.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,18(5),324-342.
  8. Ayers, D.,Dahistrom, R.,S. J. Skinner(1997).An Exploratory Investigation of Organizational Antecedents to New Product Success.Journal of Marketing Research,34(1),107-116.
  9. Booz, Allen,Hamiltom(1982).New Products Management for the 1980s.New York:Booz, Allen & Hamilton Inc.
  10. Bowers, M. R.(1989).Developing New Services: Improving the Process Makes It Better.Journal of Services marketing,3(1),15-20.
  11. Brentani, U.(2001).Innovative versus Incremental New Business Services: Different Keys for Achieving Success.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,18(3),169-187.
  12. Brentani, U.(1989).Success and Failure in Developing New Industrial Services.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,6(4),239-258.
  13. Brentani, U.(1991).Success Factors in Developing New Business Service.European Journal of Marketing,25(2),33-59.
  14. Brentani, U.(1993).The New Product Process in Financial Services: Strategy for Success.International Journal of Bank Marketing,11(3),15-22.
  15. Brentani, U.,R. G. Cooper(1992).Developing Successful New Financial Services for Businesses.Industrial Marketing Management,21(3),231-242.
  16. Brentani, U.,R. G. Cooper,E. Ragot(1992).Developing New Business- to-business Professional Services: What Factors Impact Performance.Industrial Marketing Management,25(6),517-530.
  17. Cheng, Tsun-jin,Luan-yuan, Lu(2001).Factors Affecting the R&D/Marketing Integration and NPD Success-A Path Analysis.Journal of Business Administration,49,97-134.
  18. Clark, K. B.,S. C. Wheelwright(1993).Managing New Product and Process Development.N.Y.:Free Press.
  19. Colarelli, O`Connor, G.(1998).Market Learning and Radical Innovation: A Cross Case Comparison of Eight Innovation Projects.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,15(4),151-166.
  20. Cooper, R. G.,Easingwood, C. J.,Edgett, S.,Kleinsvhmidt, E. J.,C. Storey(1994).What Distinguishes the Top Performing New Products in Financial Services.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,11(4),281-299.
  21. Cooper, R. G.,Easingwood, C. J.,Edgett, S.,Kleinsvhmidt, E. J.,C. Storey,S. J. Edgett(1996).Critical Success Factors for New Financial Services.Marketing Management,5(3),26-37.
  22. Cooper, R. G.,Easingwood, C. J.,Edgett, S.,Kleinsvhmidt, E. J.,C. Storey,S. J. Edgett(1991).Product Development for the Service Sector: Lessons from Market Leaders.Cambridge. MA:Preseus Books.
  23. Cooper, R. G.,Easingwood, C. J.,Edgett, S.,Kleinsvlimidt, E. J.,C. Storey,U. de Brentani(1991).New Industrial Financial services: What Distinguishes the Winners.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,8(2),75-90.
  24. Crawford, M. E.(1994).New Product Management.Boston, Mass:Irwin, Inc.
  25. Daft, R. L.(1998).Organization Theory and Design.Ohio:South- Western College Publishing.
  26. Daniel, E.,C. Storey(1997).On-Line Banking: Strategic and Management Challenges.Long Range Planning,30(6),890-898.
  27. Davison, H.,Watkins, T.,M. Wright(1989).Developing New Personal Financial Products-Some Evidence of the Role of Market Research.International Journal of Bank Marketing,7(1),8-15.
  28. Driva, H.,Pawar, K. S.,U. Menon(2001).Performance Evaluation of New Product Development from a Company Perspective.Integrated Manufacturing Systems,12(5),368-378.
  29. Easingwood, C. J.(1986).New Product Development for Service Companies.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,3(4),264-275.
  30. Easingwood, C. J.,C. Storey(1991).Success Factors for New Consumer Financial Services.International Journal of Bank Marketing,9(1),3-10.
  31. Edgett, S.(1994).The Traits of Successful New Service Development.Journal of Service Marketing,8(3),40-49.
  32. Edgett, S.(1996).The New Product Development Process for Commercial Financial Services.Industrial Marketing Management,25(6),507-515.
  33. Edgett, S.,S. Parkinson(1994).The Development of New Financial Services: Identifying Determinants of Success and Failure.International Journal of Service Industry Management,5(4),24-38.
  34. Galbraith, J. R.(1977).Organization Design, Reading.MA:Addison Wesley.
  35. Gounaris, S. P.,Papastathopoulou, P. G.,G. J. Avionitis(2003).Assessing the Importance of the Development Activities for Successful New Service: Does Innovativeness Matter?.International Journal of Bank Marketing,21(5),266-279.
  36. Griffin, A.(1997).PDMA Research on New Product Development Practices: Updating Trends and Benchmarking Best Practices.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,14(6),429-458.
  37. Griffin, A.,A. L. Page(1993).An Interim Report on Measuring Product Development Success and Failure.The Journal of product Innovation Management,10(4),291-308.
  38. Griffin, A.,J. R. Hauser(1996).Integrating R&D and Marketing: A Review and Analysis of the Literature.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,13(2),191-215.
  39. Gupta, A. K.,Raj, S. P.,D. Wilemon(1986).A Model for Studying R&D-Marketing Interface in the Product Innovation Process.Journal of Marketing,50,7-17.
  40. Hair, Jr. Joseph F.,Anderson, R. E.,Tatham, R. L.,W. C. Black(1995).Multivariate Data Analysis.N.Y.:Macmillan Publishing Company.
  41. Horng, Shun-ching(1999).Marketing Management.Taipei:Shinlou Company.
  42. Howell, D. C.(1982).Statistical Methods for Psychology.Boston:PWS-Kent Publishing.
  43. Kaplan, R. S.,D. P. Norton(1992).The Balances Scorecard: Measures that Drive Performance.Harvard Business Review,70(1),71-79.
  44. Kelly, D.,C. Storey(2000).New Service Development: Initiation Strategy.International Journal of Service Industry Management,11(1),45-62.
  45. Kessler, E. H.,P. E. Bierly(2002).Is Fast Really Better? An Empirical Test of the Implications of Innovation Speed.IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,49(1),2-12.
  46. Ketchen, Jr. D. J.,C. L. Shook(1996).The Application of Cluster Analysis in Strategic Management Research: An Analysis and Critique.Strategic Management Journal,17(6),441-458.
  47. Khurnan, A.,S. R. Rosenthal(1998).Towards a Holistic Front End in NPD.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,15(1),57-74.
  48. Lievens, A.,R. K. Moenaert(2001).Communication Flows During Financial Service Innovation.International Journal of Bank Marketing,19(2),68-88.
  49. Lynn, G. S.,Morone, J. P.,A. S. Paulson(1996).Marketing and Discontinuous Innovation: The Probe and Learn Process.California Management Review,38(3),3-37.
  50. Maidique, M. A.,B. J. Zirger(1985).The New Product Learning Cycle.Research Policy,14(6),299-313.
  51. Menor, L. J.,Tatikonda, M. V.,S. E. Sampson(2002).New Service Development: Areas for Exploitation and Exploration.Journal of Operations Management,20(2),135-157.
  52. Meyers, P. W.,F. G. Tucker(1989).Defining the Roles for Logistics During Routine and Radical Technological Innovation.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,17(1),73-82.
  53. Millson, M. R.,Raj, S. P.,D. Wileman(1992).A Survey of Major Approaches for Accelerating New Product Development.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,10(1),53-69.
  54. Moenaert, R. K.,W. E. Souder(1990).An Information Transfer Model for Integrating Marketing and R&D Personnel in New Product Development Projects.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,7(2),91-107.
  55. Mohammed-Salleh, A.,C. Easingwood(1993).Why European Financial Institution Do Not Test-Market New Consumer Products.International Journal of Bank Marketing,11(3),23-27.
  56. Nystrom, H.(1985).Product Development Strategy: An Integration of Technology and Marketing.The Journal of Product Innovation management,2(1),25-33.
  57. Olson, E. M.,Orville, Jr. C.,R. W. Ruekert(1995).Organizing for Effective New Product Development: The Moderating Role of Product Innovativeness.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,12(1),48-62.
  58. Porter, M. E.(1985).Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance.New York:Free Press.
  59. Reidenbach, E.,D. Moak(1986).Exploring Retail Bank Performance and New Product Development: A Profile of Industry Practices.Journal of Product Innovation Management,3(3),187-194.
  60. Roger, E. M.(1983).Diffusion of Innovation.N.Y.:Free Press.
  61. Rusinko, C.(1999).Exploring the Use of Design- Manufacturing Integration (DM1) to Facilitate Product Development: A Test of Some Practices.IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,46(1),56-71.
  62. Scheuing, E. E.,M. E. Johnson(1989).New Product Development and Management in Financial Institutions.International Journal of Bank Marketing,7(2),17-21.
  63. Scheuing, E. E.,M. E. Johnson(1989).A Proposal Model for New Service Development.Journal of Services marketing,3(2),25-34.
  64. Song, X. M.,M. M. Montoya-Weiss(1998).Critical Development Activities for Really New versus Incremental Products.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,15(2),124-135.
  65. Song, X. M.,M. M. Montoya-Weiss,Thieme, R. J.,J. Xie(1999).Pioneering Advantage in Manufacturing and Service Industries: Empirical Evidence from Nine Countries.Strategic Management Journal,20(9),811-836.
  66. Song, X. M.,M. M. Montoya-Weiss,Thieme, R. J.,J. Xie,Xie, J.,B. Dyer(2000).Antecedents and Consequences of Marketing Manager`s Conflict-Handling Behaviors.Journal of Marketing,64(1),50-66.
  67. Storey, C.,D. Kelly(2001).Measuring the Performance of New Service Development Activities.The Service Industries Journal,21(2),71-90.
  68. Storey, C.,D. Kelly,C. J. Easingwood(1999).Types of New Product Performance: Evidence from the Consumer Financial Services Sector.Journal of Business Research,46(2),193-203.
  69. Storey, C.,D. Kelly,C. J. Easingwood(1998).The Augmented Service Offering: A Conceptualization and Study of Its Impact on New Service Success.The Journal of Product Innovation management,15(4),335-351.
  70. Storey, C.,D. Kelly,C. J. Easingwood(1996).Determinants of New Product performance: A Study in the Financial Service Sector.International Journal of Service Industry Management,7(1),32-55.
  71. Swink, M.(1999).Threats to New Product Manufacturability and the Effects of Development Team Integration Processes.Journal of Operations Management,17(6),691-709.
  72. Tushman, M. L.,D. Nadler(1986).Organizing for Innovation.California Management Review,28(3),74-92.
  73. Urban, G. L.,J. R. Hauser(1993).Design and Marketing of New Products.Eanglewood Cliffs, N.Y.:Prentice Hall.
  74. Veryzer, R. W.(1998).Discontinuous Innovation and the New Product Development Process.The Journal of Product Innovation Management,15(4),304-321.
被引用次数
  1. (2007)。自我監控能力、適應性銷售行為、銷售績效之關聯性。臺灣銀行季刊，58(2)，170-185。
print cancel