團隊成員目標導向對於自我與集體效能及創新之影響一個多層次研究

The Effect of Team Member Goal Orientation on Self-efficacy, Collective Efficacy and Innovation: A Multilevel Study

10.6504/JOM.2006.23.03.03

黃家齊(Jia-Chi Huang)；黃荷婷(Her-Ting Huang)

目標導向 ； 自我效能 ； 集體效能 ； 創新行為 ； 創新績效 ； 多層次研究 ； goal orientation ； self-efficacy ； collective efficacy ； innovative behavior innovation performance ； multilevel study

管理學報

23卷3期（2006 / 06 / 01）

327 - 346

繁體中文

本研究主題探討目標導向在團隊工作情境下的可能影響，推導並實證了一個包含個人與團隊層次的多層次中介模式。在個人層次欲了解個人目標導向、自我效能與創新行為的關係，在團隊層次則欲了解團隊目標導向、集體效能與創新績效的關聯性。經蒐集53個團隊資料，以LISREL進行分析結果發現個人層次理論模式研究結果與過去研究類似，個人學習導向與自我效能及創新行為間有正相關，且自我效能在此關係中扮演了中介變項的角色，個人表現導向與自我效能及創新行為之關係則均不顯著。團隊層次模式研究結果則與個人層次模式不同，團隊學習導向與集體效能及創新績效均無顯著相關，而相對的，團隊表現導向則與集體效能及創新績效均呈顯著負相關。研究結果亦突顯了團隊目標導向研究及多層次研究的必要性。

Goal orientation theory originated in the educational psychology and child development literature. It conceptualized the broader goals pursued by individuals as a personality dimension and proposed that individuals have goal orientations preferences in achievement situation. Though previous studies had proved the proposition of goal orientation has important impact on individual performance. Hat' goal orientation affects innovative behavior is still unclear Moreover if we consider the team work situation, the impact of team member goal orientation on individual innovative behavior and team innovation performance is an unexplored issue especially. This is also the theoretical gap the present study hope to contribute. In this study, we explored the effect of goal orientation trait under team work situations. We developed and testified a multilevel model. At individual level, we examined the relationship between individual goal orientation and innovative behavior and the mediating role of self-efficacy. At group level, we also examined the relationship between team goal orientation and innovation performance, and the mediating role of collective efficacy. 70 R & D teams from 36 firms were recruited to participate in the study. To be included in the final sample, at least 2/3 employees in the R & D team had to complete α survey and their supervisor had to complete another survey. 70 sets (including 490 employees) were distributed and 56 sets (including 228 employees) were collected. However 3 sets were excluded as α result of its response rate under 2/3, compared with the number of the team members. Thus, 53 R & D teams (including 218 employees) were included in the data analysis. We used LISREL to analyze data and examined our hypotheses. The results showed that individual level analysis were consistent with previous researches. Learning orientation was positively related to innovative behavior and self-efficacy mediated this relationship, whereas performance orientation showed no significant relationship with self-efficacy and innovative behavior Results of group level analysis were different. Team learning orientation had no significant relationships with either collective efficacy or innovation performance, whereas team performance orientation had significantly negative relationships with collective efficacy and innovation performance. These results implied learning orientation dominated the impact on self-efficacy and innovative behavior at individual level, whereas team performance orientation dominated the impact on collective-efficacy and innovation performance at team level. These findings highlighted the necessity of study on team goal orientation and multilevel model. The implication of these findings for theory and research on goal orientation in teams and team staffing are also discussed.

1. Huang, Jia-Chi,Ya-Ting Hsu, in press(2006).The Effects of Team Personality Composition on Knowledge Sharing and Innovation Performance: Individual and Team Level Analysis.Journal of Management.
   連結：
2. Aguliar, A. A.(1996).Personality and Creativity.Personality and Individual Differences.
3. Ames, C.,J. Archer(1988).Achievement Goals in the Classroom: Student's Learning Strategies and Motivational Processes.Journal of Educational Psychology.
4. Ancona, D. G.,J. K. Murningham(1993).The Classics and the Contemporary: A New Blend OD Small Group Research.Social Psychology in Organizations,225-243.
5. Anderson, J. C.,D. W. Gerbing(1988).Structural Equation Modeling in Practice: A Review and Recommended Two-step Approach.Psychological Bulletin.
6. Bagozzi, R. R.(1980).Causal Models in Marketing.
7. Bandura, A.(1986).Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory.NJ:Prentice-Hall.
8. Bandura, A.(1982).Self-efficacy Mechanism in Human Agency.American Psychologist.
9. Bantel, K. A.,S. E. Jackson(1989).Top Management and Innovations in Banking: Does the Composition of the Top Team Make a Difference.Strategic Management Journal,10,107-124.
10. Barry, B.,G. L. Stewart(1997).Composition, Process, and Performance in Self-managed Groups: The Role of Personality.Journal of Applied Psychology.
11. Bell, B. S.,S. W. J. Kozlowski(2002).Goal Orientation and Ability: Interactive Effects on Self-efficacy, Performance, and Knowledge.Journal of Applied Psychology.
12. Bliese, P. D.,K. J. Klein,S. W. J. Kozlowski(2000).Within-group Agreement, Nonindependence, and Reliability: Implications for Data Aggregation and Analysis.Multilevel Theory, Research, and Methods in Organizations.
13. Brett, J. F.,D. VandeWalle(1999).Goal Orientation and Goal Content as Predictors of Performance in a Training Program.Journal of Applied Psychology.
14. Brewer, M. B.,R. M. Kramer(1986).Choice Behavior in Social Dillemma: Effects of Social Identity, Group Size, and Decision Framing.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
15. Bunderson, J. S.,K. M. Sutcliffe(2003).Management Team Learning Orientation and Business Unit Performance.Journal of Applied Psychology.
16. Button, S. B., J. E. Mathieu,D. M. Zajac(1996).Goal Orientation in Organizational Research: A Conceptual and Empirical Foundation.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.
17. Chen, G., S. M. Gully,D. Eden(2001).Validation of a New General Self-efficacy Scale.Organizational Research Methods.
18. Chen, G.,P. D. Bliese(2002).The Role of Different Levels of Leadership in Predicting Self- and Collective Efficacy: Evidence for Discontinuity.Journal of Applied Psychology.
19. Colquitt, J. A.,M. J. Simmering(1998).Conscientiousness, Goal Orientation, and Motivation to Learn During the Learning Process: A Longitudinal Study.Journal of Applied Psychology.
20. Dweck, C. S.(1986).Motivational Processes Affecting Learning.American Psychologist.
21. Dweck, C. S.,E. L. Leggett(1988).A Social-cognitive Approach to Motivation and Personality.Psychological Review.
22. Earley, P. C.(1993).East Meets West Meets Mideast: Explorations of Collectivistic and Individualistic Work Groups.Academy of Management Journal.
23. Elliott, E. S.,C. S. Dweck(1988).Goals: An Approach to Motivation and Achievement.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
24. Eysenck, H. J.(1994).Creativity and Personality: Word Association, Origence, and Psychoticism.Creativity Research Journal.
25. Ford, J. K., E. M. Smith, D. A. Weissbein, S. M. Gully,E. Salas(1998).Relationships of Goal Orientation Metacognitive Activity, and Practice Strategies with Learning Outcomes and Transfer.Journal of Applied Psychology.
26. Gelade, G. A.(1997).Creativity in Conflict: The Personality of the Commercial Creative.The Journal of Genetic Psychology,158,67-778.
27. George, J.(1990).Personality, Affect, and Behavior in Groups.Journal of Applied Psychology.
28. Gersick, C. J. G.(1989).Marking Time: Predictable Transitions in Task Groups.Academy of Management Journal.
29. Gibson, C. B.(1999).Do They Do What They Believe They Can? Group Efficacy and Group Effectiveness across Tasks and Cultures.Academy of Management Journal.
30. Gibson, C. B., A. E. Randel,P. C. Earley(2000).Understanding Group Efficacy: An Empirical Test of Multiple Assessment Methods.Group & Organization Management.
31. Gist, M. E.(1987).Self-efficacy: Implications for Organizational Behavior and Human Resource Management.Academy of Management Review.
32. Gully, S. M., K. A. Incalcaterra, A. Joshi,J. M. Beaubien(2002).A Meta-analysis of Team-efficacy, Potency, and Performance: Interdependence and Level of Analysis as Moderators of Observed Relationships.Journal of Applied Psychology.
33. Guzzo, R. A., P. R. Yost, R. J. Compbell,G. P. Shea(1993).Potency in Groups: Articulating a Construct.British Journal of Social Psychology.
34. Hackman, J. R.(1990).Groups That Work (and Those That Don't).
35. Harrison, D. A., K. H. Price, J. H. Gavin,A. T. Florey(2002).Time, Teams, and Task Performance: Changing Effects of Surface- and Deep-level Diversity on Group Functioning.Academy of Management Journal.
36. Holt, K.(1983).User-oriented Product Innovation: Some Research Findings.Technovation,3(3),199-208.
37. Huang, Jia-Chi,Se-Fong Wang(2002).Knowledge Conversion Abilities and Knowledge Creation and Innovation: A New Perspective on Team Composition.Proceedings of the Third European Conference on Organizational Knowledge, Learning and Capabilities.
38. Hui, C., C. Lee,D. M. Rousseau(2004).Psychological Contract and Organizational Citizenship Behavior in China: Investigating Generalizability and Instrumentality.Journal of Applied Psychology.
39. James, L. R.(1982).Aggregation Bias in Estimates of Perceptual Agreement.Journal of Applied Psychology.
40. James, L. R., R. G. Demaree,G. Wolf(1993).rwg: An Assessment of within-group Interrater Agreement.Journal of Applied Psychology.
41. James, L. R., R. G. Demaree,G. Wolf(1984).Estimating within-group Interrater Reliability with and without Response Bias.Journal of Applied Psychology.
42. Jehn, K. A., G. B. Northcraft,M. A. Neale(1999).Why Differences Make a Difference: A Field Study of Diversity Conflict, and Performance in Workgroups.Administrative Science Quarterly.
43. Jex, S. M.,P. D. Bliese(1999).Efficacy Beliefs as a Moderator of the Impact of Work-related Stressor: A Multilevel Study.Journal of Applied Psychology.
44. Kenny, D. A.(1979).Correlation and Causality.
45. Klein, K. J., F. Dansereau,R. J. Hall(1994).Levels Issues in Theory Development, Data Collection, and Analysis.Academy of Management Review.
46. Knight, D., C. C. Durham,E. A. Locke(2001).The Relationship of Team Goals, Incentives, and Efficacy to Strategic Risk, Tactical Implement, and Performance.Academy of Management Journal.
47. Kozlowski, S. W. J., S. W. Gully, K. G. Brown, E. Salas, E. M. Smith,E. R. Nason(2001).Effects of Training Goals and Goal Orientation Traits on Multidimensional Training Outcomes and Performance Adaptability.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.
48. Kozlowski, S. W. J.,K. J. Klein,K. J. Klein and S. W. J. Kozlowski(2000).A Multiple Approach to Theory and Research in Organizations: Contextual, Temporal, and Emergent Process.Multilevel Theory, Research, and Methods in Organizations.
49. Kristof-Brown, A. L.,C. K. Stevens(2001).Goal Congruence in Project Teams: Does the Fit between Members' Personal Mastery and Performance Goals Matter.Journal of Applied Psychology.
50. Lester, S. W., B. M. Meglino,M. A. Korsgaard(2002).The Antecedents and Consequences of Group Potency: A Longitudinal Investigation of Newly Formed Work Group.Academy of Management Journal.
51. Lindsley, D. H., D. J. Brass,J. B. Thomas(1995).Efficacy-performance Spirals: A Multilevel Perspective.Academy of Management Review.
52. London, M.,J. W. Smither(1999).Empowered Selfdevelopment and Continuous Learning.Human Resource Management.
53. Lovelace, K., D. L. Shapiro,L. R. Weingart(2001).Maximizing Gross-functional New Product Teams' Innovativeness and Constraint Adherence: A Conflict Communications Perspective.Academy of Management Journal.
54. Mathieu, J. E.,J. L. Farr(1991).Further Evidence for the Discriminant Validity of Measures of Organizational Commitment, Job Involvement, and Job Satisfaction.Journal of Applied Psychology.
55. McCrae, R. R.(1987).Creativity, Divergent Thinking, and Openness to Experience.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
56. Milliken, F. J.,L. L. Martins(1996).Searching for Common Threads: Understanding the Multiple Effects of Diversity in Organizational Groups.Academy of Management Review.
57. Mone, M. A.(1994).Comparative Validity of Two Measures of Self-efficacy in Predicting Academic Goals and Performance.Educational and Psychological Measurement.
58. Neuman, G. A.,J. Wright(1999).Team Effectiveness: Beyond Skills and Cognitive Ability.Journal of Applied Psychology.
59. Nicholls, J. G.(1984).Achievement Motivation: Conceptions of Ability, Subjective Experience, Task Choice, and Performance.Psychological Review.
60. Niehoff, B. P.,R. H. Moorman(1993).Justice as a Moderator of the Relationship between Methods of Monitoring and Organizational Citizenship Behavior.Academy of Management Journal.
61. Philips, J. M.,S. M. Gully(1997).Role of Goal Orientation, Ability, Need for Achievement, and Locus of Control in the Self-efficacy and Goalsetting Process.Journal of Applied Psychology.
62. Podsakoff, P. M.,D. W. Organ(1986).Self-reports in Organizational Research: Problems and Prospects.Journal of Management.
63. Porter, C. O. L. H(2005).Goal Orientation: Effects on Backing up Behavior, Performance, Efficacy, and Commitment in Teams.Journal of Applied Psychology.
64. Porter, G.,J. W. Tansky(1999).Expatriate Success May Depend on a Learning Orientation: Considerations for Selection and Training.Human Resource Management.
65. Potosky, D.,H. V. Ramakrishna(2002).The Mediating Role of Updating Climate Perceptions in the Relationship between Goal Orientation, Self-efficacy, and Job Performance.Human Performance.
66. Prussia, G. E.,A. J. Kinicki(1996).A Motivational Investigation of Group Effectiveness Using Socialcognitive Theory.Journal of Applied Psychology.
67. Riggs, M. L., J. Warka, B. Babasa, R. Betancourt,S. Hooker(1994).Development and Validation of Selfefficacy and Outcome Expectancy Scales for Jobrelated Applications.Educational and Psychological Measurement.
68. Robert, C., T. M. Probst, J. J. Martocchio, F. Drasgow,J. J. Lawler(2000).Empowerment and Continuous Improvement in the United States, Mexico, Poland, and India: Predicting Fit on the Basis of the Dimensions of Power Distance and Individualism.Journal of Applied Psychology.
69. Rousseau, D. M.,L. L. Cummings,B. M. Staw(1985).Issues of Level in Organizational Research.Research in Organizational Behavior.
70. Schaubroeck, J.,S. S. K. Lam(2000).Collective Efficacy versus Self-efficacy in Coping Responses to Stressors and Control: A Cross-cultural Study.Journal of Applied Psychology.
71. Scott, S. G.,R. A. Bruce(1994).Determinants of Innovative Behavior: A Path Model of Individual Innovation in the Workplace.Academy of Management Journal.
72. Steele-Johnson, D., R. S. Beauregard, P. B. Hoover,A. M. Schmidt(2000).Goal Orientation and Task Demand Effects on Motivation, Affect, and Performance.Journal of Applied Psychology.
73. VandeWalle, D.(1997).Development and Validation of a Work Domain Goal Orientation Instrument.Educational and Psychological Measurement.
74. VandeWalle, D., S. P. Brown, W. L. Cron,J. W. Slocum(1999).The Influence of Goal Orientation and Self-regulation Tactics on Sales Performance: A Longitudinal Field Test.Journal of Applied Psychology.
75. Wang, Sy-Feng, Jia-Chi Huang,Li-Min Cheng(2002).Experimental Study of the Team Knowledge Conversion Abilities and Innovation: An Examination of the Knowledge Spiral Theory.Journal of Management & Systems.
76. West, M. A.(1987).A Measure of Role Innovation at Work.British Journal of Social Psychology.
77. West, M. A.,N. R. Anderson(1996).Innovation in Top Management Teams.Journal of Applied Psychology.
78. Willams, L. J.,J. T. Hazer(1986).Antecedents and Consequences of Satisfaction and Commitment in Turnover Models: A Reanalysis Using Latent Variable Structural Equation Methods.Journal of Applied Psychology.
79. Williams, K. Y.,C. A. O'Reilly,B. M. Staw,R. M. Sutton(1998).Demography and Diversity in Organizations: A Review of 40 Years of Research.Research in Organizational Behavior.
80. Wood, R. E.,E. A. Locke(1987).The Relation of Selfefficacy and Grade Goals to Academic Performance.Educational and Psychological Measurement.
81. Zellars, K. L., W. A. Hochwarter, P. L. Perrewe, A. K. Miles,C. Kiewitz(2001).Beyond Self-efficacy: Interactive Effects of Role Conflict and Perceived Collective Efficacy.Journal of Management Issues.

1. 陳玉樹、郭銘茜(2013)。四向度成就目標對教師創意教學表現之影響：創意自我效能的中介效果與團隊學習行為的跨層級調節效果檢定。教育科學研究期刊，58(3)，85-120。
2. 陳玉樹、周志偉(2009)。目標導向對創造力訓練效果之影響：HLM成長模式分析。課程與教學，12(2)，19-45。
3. 高瑞新(2016)。知識性工作特徵與創新接受度關係之研究：轉換型領導與集體效能之跨層次調節效果。人力資源管理學報，16(4)，27-58。
4. 許高誌(2018)。團隊自主性對於創新行為影響之研究。國立虎尾科技大學學報，34(2)，13-24。
5. 黃櫻美、黃嘉雄、林淑姬(2008)。目標導向與角色拓展自我效能對諮詢網絡內向中心性的影響。臺大管理論叢，19(1)，29-50。
6. 廖茂宏、湯淑貞、陳雅柔、李怡禛(2011)。生涯成熟度與訓練遷移動機之關係：目標導向之調節效果。人力資源管理學報，11(4)，49-61。
7. 劉財龍、郭嘉珍(2011)。知識移轉績效之前因及其對顧客資本之影響。企業管理學報，91，61-105。
8. 劉士銘,胡訓立,任慶宗(2010)。跨層次觀點下價值觀共識度對社會資本與創新績效之影響。人力資源管理學報，10(3)，51-73。
9. 項維欣、陳意文、吳思華(2012)。專案團隊內創意構想守門能耐與體制規則概念建構及量表發展與驗證。中山管理評論，20(4)，1045-1104。
10. 嚴國晉,陳宇軒,莊璦嘉,李均揚(2019)。員工創造力研究之回顧與展望：臺灣與東亞的研究發現。臺大管理論叢，29(3)，39-82。
11. 張碩毅、張漢呈、張益誠(2008)。中小企業提升創新能力關鍵影響因素及對產業高值化影響之研究：以資訊服務業為例。臺灣企業績效學刊，1(2)，175-201。
12. (2009)。高中職創意競賽之團隊歷程—成員歧異度與團隊氣氛對團隊創造力的影響。教育與心理研究，32(4)，73-97。
13. (2020)。從個人風險特質與組織激勵措施探討公務人員之創新行為─以計畫行為理論為分析架構。空大行政學報，34，1-40。