题名

The Impact of Strategic Leadership Turnover on Governance Effectiveness: The Moderating Perspective of Industry Effect

并列篇名

策略領導更替對公司治理效能之影響：產業干擾效果之研究

DOI

10.6504/JOM.2010.27.04.02

作者

田正利(Cheng-Li Tien)；邱宏仁(Hong-Jen Charles Chiu)

关键词

公司治理 ； 策略領導 ； 執行長更替 ； 服務葉 ； 製造業 ； Corporate Governance ； Strategic Leadership ； CEO Turnover ； Service Sector ； Manufacturing Sector

期刊名称

管理學報

卷期/出版年月

27卷4期（2010 / 08 / 01）

页次

337 - 354

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

本研究主題主要是在探討企業策略領導者之更替對公司治理效能之影響及不同產業別所造成干擾效果之研究。在一企業中，策略領導者在公司治理成效上扮演著一個極為重要且關鍵之角色，也因此企業治理成效不彰，企業領導者便可能面臨更換，但更換地太頻繁是否對企業之表現反而會有負面之影響？不同之產業特性是否亦會造成任何干擾效果？過去諸多研究主要是針對企業領導者繼承與公司績效間之關係作探討，鮮少針對領導者更替頻繁與否與公司治理間之關係作探討，本研究因此針對此議題作進一步的探究，並以美國S&P 500中之268家公司為樣本，所作之研究結果得知：企業中策略領導者之更替次數對公司治理效能會產生正向之影響，此外服務業相較於製造業所產生之干擾效果會更大。此研究結果將有助於企業董事會對企業領導者或執行長之繼承或更替所可能造成的影響有更深層之認識與瞭解。
英文摘要

This study researches issues relating to corporate governance to determine the relationship between strategic leadership turnover and governance effectiveness and to further test any moderating influences from the industry factor. To improve governance effectiveness, the boards may change a CEO for poor performance: however, firms should discourage frequent CEO changes for loyalty, and commitment. Hence, a CEO change may create uncertainty which implies that strategic leadership change can be a double-edged sword to a firm. This study offers models based on the logic of transaction cost theory and organizational learning to test the hypotheses using data from 268 firms on the S& P 500 in the United .States. Results indicate that strategic leadership turnover is positively related to governance effectiveness and that firms in the service sector can improve governance effectiveness more than firms in the manufacturing sector. The findings provide boards of directors with evidence as to how CEO succession influences corporate governance and how the industry effect changes such influence.
主题分类 社會科學 > 管理學
参考文献
  1. Chen, Yenn-Ru,Ho, Chen-Yin(2009).The Impact of Family Control and Board Characteristics on Corporate Policies.Journal of Small Business,26(1),1-16.
    連結：
  2. Shieh, Jiin-Tarng(2009).The Empirical Examination of Theoretical Model for the Functions of Board of Directors: Evidences from Director's Perception of Listed Companies in Taiwan.Journal of Management,26(2),127-144.
    連結：
  3. Ting, Hsiu-I(2009).Does Corporate Governance Matter to Institutional Investors?.Journal of Management,26(3),233-253.
    連結：
  4. ViamInvest, 2010. Transaction Cost Economics, http://e.viaminvest.com/B11TransactionCostEconomics.asp
  5. Coase, Ronald H., 1937. The Nature of the Firm. Economica, 4(16), 386-405.
  6. Zingales, Luigi, 1997. Corporate Governance, Working Paper, The National Bureau of Economic Research.
  7. Abdullah, Shamsul N.(2006).Directors' Remuneration, Firm's Performance and Corporate Governance in Malaysia among Distressed Companies.Corporate Governance,6(2),162-174.
  8. Alien, John(1988).Service Industries: Uneven Development and Uneven Knowledge.Area,20(1),15-22.
  9. Alien, John(ed.),Massey, Doreen(ed.)(1988).The Economy in Question-Restructuring Britain.London:Sage Publications.
  10. Anderson, Ronald C.,Bates, Thomas W.,Bizjak, John M.,Lemmon, Michael L.(2000).Corporate Governance and Firm Diversification.Financial Management,29(1),5-22.
  11. Argote, Linda(1999).Organizational Learning: Creating, Retaining and Transferring Knowledge.Boston:Kluwer Academic.
  12. Argote, Linda,Insko, Chester A.,Yovetich, Nancy,Romero, Anna A.(1995).Group Learning Curves: The Effects of Turnover and Task Complexity on Group Performance.Journal of Applied Social Psychology,25(6),512-529.
  13. Ariff, Akmalia M.,Ibrahim, Muhd K.,Othman, Radiah(2007).Determinants of Firm Level Governance: Malaysian Evidence.Corporate Governance,7(5),562-573.
  14. Arjoon, Surendra(2006).Striking a Balance between Rules and Principles-Based Approaches for Effective Governance: A Risks-Based Approach.Journal of Business Ethics,68(1),53-82.
  15. Arrow, Kenneth J.(1974).The Limits of Organization.New York:W. W. Norton.
  16. Bass, Bernard M.(2007).Executive and Strategic Leadership.International Journal of Business,12(1),34-52.
  17. Bird, Frederick(2001).Good Governance: A Philosophical Discussion of the Responsibilities and Practices of Organizational Governors.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,18(4),298-312.
  18. Birley, Sue,Westhead, Paul(1994).New Producer Services Businesses: Are They Any Different From New Manufacturing Ventures?.The Service Industries Journal,14(4),455-481.
  19. Bonache Pérez, Jaime,Pia-Barber, José(2005).When Are International Managers a Cost Effective Solution? The Rationale of Transaction Cost Economics Applied to Staffing Decisions in MNCs.Journal of Business Research,58(10),1320-1329.
  20. Bontis, Nick(1998).Intellectual Capital: An Exploratory Study That Develops Measures and Models.Management Decision,36(2),63-76.
  21. Bozec, Yves,Richard Bozec(2007).Ownership Concentration and Corporate Governance Practices: Substitution or Expropriation Effects?.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,24(3),182-195.
  22. Brav, Alon,Jiang, Wei,Partnoy, Frank,Thomas, Randall(2008).Hedge Fund Activism, Corporate Governance, and Firm Performance.The Journal of Finance,63(4),1729-1775.
  23. Brown, M. Craig(1982).Administrative Succession and Organizational Performance: The Succession Effect.Administrative Science Quarterly,27(1),1-16.
  24. Brubakk, Bjorn,Wilkinson, Adrian(1996).Agents of Change? Bank Branch Managers and the Management of Corporate Culture Change.International Journal of Service Industry Management,7(2),21-43.
  25. Carlson, Dawn S.,Upton, Nancy,Seaman, Samuel(2006).The Impact of Human Resource Practices and Compensation Design on Performance: An Analysis of Family-Owned SMEs.Journal of Small Business Management,44(4),531-543.
  26. Claessens, Stijn,Djankov, Simeon,Pohl, Gerhard(1996).Ownership and Corporate Governance: Evidence from tire Czech Republic.International Symposium on Capital Markets and Enterprise Reform,Beijing:
  27. Coase, Ronald H.(1988).The Firm, the Market, and the Law.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
  28. Cyert, Richard M.,March, James G.(1963).A Behavioral Theory of the Firm.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
  29. David, Robert J.,Han, Shin-Kap(2003).A Systematic Assessment of the Empirical Support for Transaction Cost Economics.Strategic Management Journal,25(1),39-58.
  30. Defond, Mark L.,Hung, Mingyi(2004).Investor Protection and Corporate Governance: Evidence from Worldwide CEO Turnover.Journal of Accounting Research,42(2),269-312.
  31. Devadas Rao, Rukmini,Argote, Linda(2006).Organizational Learning and Forgetting: The Effects of Turnover and Structure.European Management Review,3(2),77-85.
  32. Dierickx, Ingemar,Cool, Karel(1989).Asset Stock Accumulation and Sustainability of Competitive Advantage.Management Science,35(12),1504-1511.
  33. Evans, Jo,Weir, Charlie(1995).Decision Processes, Monitoring, Incentives and Large Firm Performance in the UK.Management Decision,33(6),32-38.
  34. Filatotchev, lgor,Stephan, Johannes,Jindra, Björn(2008).Ownership Structure, Strategic Controls and Export Intensity of Foreign-Invested Firms in Transition Economies.Journal of International Business Studies,39(7),1133-1148.
  35. Finkelstein, Sydney,Hambrick, Donald C.(1996).Strategic Leadership: Top Executives and Their Effects on Organizations.Minneapolis/St. Paul:West Publishing Company.
  36. Firth, Michael,Fung, Peter M. Y.,Rui, Oliver M.(2006).Firm Performance, Governance Structure, and Top Management Turnover in a Transitional Economy.Journal of Management Studies,43(6),1289-1330.
  37. Fizel, John L.,Louie, Kenneth K. T.(1990).CEO Retention, Finn Performance and Corporate Governance.Managerial and Decision Economics,11(3),167-176.
  38. Gatignon, Hubert,Anderson, Erin(1988).The Multinational Corporation's Degree of Control over Foreign Subsidiaries: An Empirical Test of a Transaction Cost Explanation.Tire Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization,4(2),305-336.
  39. Geyskens, Inge,Steenkamp, Jan-Benedict E. M.,Kumar, Nirmalya(2006).Make, Buy, or Ally: A Transaction Cost Theory Meta-Analysis.The Academy of Management Journal,49(3),519-543.
  40. Giambatista, Robert C.(2004).Jumping through Hoops: A Longitudinal Study of Leader Life Cycles in the NBA.The Leadership Quarterly,15(5),607-624.
  41. Gibson, Michael S.(2003).Is Corporate Governance Ineffective in Emerging Markets?.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,38(1),231-250.
  42. Goddard, John A.,Wilson, John O. S.(1996).Persistence of Profits for UK Manufacturing and Service Sector Firms.The Service Industries Journal,16(2),105-117.
  43. Gruszczynski, Marek(2006).Corporate Governance and Financial Performance of Companies in Poland.International Advances in Economic Research,12(2),251-259.
  44. Hennart, Jean-François,Roehl, Thomas,Zietlow, Dixie S.(1999).'Trojan Horse' or 'Workhorse'? The Evolution of U.S.-Japanese Joint Ventures in the United States.Strategic Management Journal,20(1),15-29.
  45. Hillier, David,Linn, Scott C.,McColgan, Patrick(2005).Equity Issuance, CEO Turnover and Corporate Governance.European Financial Management,11(4),515-538.
  46. Hom, Peter W.,Kinicki, Angelo J.(2001).Toward a Greater Understanding of How Dissatisfaction Drives Employee Turnover.The Academy of Management Journal,44(5),975-987.
  47. Jensen, Michael C.,Meckling, William H.(1976).Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure.Journal of Financial Economics,3(4),305-360.
  48. Joshi, Ashwin W.,Stump, Rodney L.(1999).Determinants of Commitment and Opportunism: Integrating and Extending Insights from Transaction Cost Analysis and Relational Exchange Theory.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,16(4),334-352.
  49. Kitchell, Susan(1997).CEO Characteristics and Technological Innovativeness: A Canadian Perspective.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,14(2),111-125.
  50. Kyereboah-Coleman, Anthony,Biekpe, Nicholas(2006).The Link between Corporate Governance and Performance of the Non-Traditional Export Sector: Evidence from Ghana.Corporate Governance,6(5),609-623.
  51. Lin, Ying-Fen(2006).Corporate Governance, Excess Compensation, and CEO Turnover in Family and Non-Family Business.Corporate Ownership & Control,4(2),46-52.
  52. Lorence, Jon(1991).Growth in Service Sector Employment and MSA Gender Earnings Inequality: 1970-1980.Social Forces,69(3),763-783.
  53. Markovitch, Dmitri G.,Steckel, Joel H.,Yeung, Bernard(2005).Using Capital Markets as Market Intelligence: Evidence from the Pharmaceutical Industry.Management Science,51(10),1467-1480.
  54. Masters, John K.,Miles, Grant(2002).Predicting the Use of External Labor Arrangements: A Test of the Transaction Costs Perspective.The Academy of Management Journal,45(2),431-442.
  55. Maury, Benjamin(2006).Corporate Performance, Corporate Governance and Top Executive Turnover in Finland.European Financial Management,12(2),221-248.
  56. Mayer, Colin(1997).Corporate Governance, Competition, and Performance.Journal of Law and Society,24(1),152-176.
  57. Metrick, Andrew,Ishii, Joy(2002).Firm-Level Corporate Governance.Global Corporate Governance Forum, Research Network Meeting,Washington, D.C.:
  58. Mir, Ali E.,Seboui, Souad(2008).Corporate Governance and the Relationship between EVA and Created Shareholder Value.Corporate Governance,8(1),46-58.
  59. Miranti, Paul J.(2008).Chandler's Paths of Learning.Business History Review,82(2),293-300.
  60. Niu, Flora F.(2006).Corporate Governance and the Quality of Accounting Earnings: A Canadian Perspective.International Journal of Managerial Finance,2(4),302-327.
  61. O''Farrell, P. N.,Hitchens, D. M.(1990).Producer Services and Regional Development: Key Conceptual Issues of Taxonomy and Quality Measurement.Regional Studies,24(2),163-171.
  62. Oliva, Rogelio,Sterman, John D.(2001).Cutting Corners and Working Overtime: Quality Erosion in the Service Industry.Management Science,47(7),894-914.
  63. Ouchi, William G.(1980).Markets, Bureaucracies, and Clans.Administrative Science Quarterly,25(1),129-141.
  64. Park, Choelsoon,Kim, Seonghoon(2008).Corporate Governance, Regulatory Changes, and Corporate Restructuring in Korea, 1993-2004.Journal of World Business,43(1),66-84.
  65. Peng, Mike W.,Buck, Trevor,Filatotchev, Igor(2003).Do Outside Directors and New Managers Help Improve Firm Performance? An Exploratory Study in Russian Privatization.Journal of World Business,38(4),348-360.
  66. Pfeffer, Jeffrey,Davis-Blake, Alison(1986).Administrative Success ion and Organizational Performance: How Administrator Experience Mediates the Success ion Effect.The Academy of Management Journal,29(1),72-83.
  67. Prajogo, Daniel I.(2005).The Comparative Analysis of TQM Practices and Quality Performance between Manufacturing and Service Firms.International Journal of Service Industry Management,16(3),217-228.
  68. Preece, Christopher,Male, Steven(1997).Promotional Literature for Competitive Advantage in UK Construction Firms.Construction Management and Economics,15(1),59-69.
  69. Prime, Penelope B.(2007).Firm Performance and CEO Turnover in China: Implications for Chinese Equity Markets and Corporate Governance.The Academy of Management Perspectives,21(2),78-79.
  70. Quinn, James B.(1985).Managing Innovation: Controlled Chaos.Harvard Business Review,63(3),73-84.
  71. Reitenga, Austin L.,Tearney, Michael G.(2003).Mandatory CEO Retirements, Discretionary Accruals, and Corporate Governance Mechanisms.Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance,18(2),255-280.
  72. Roberts, Peter W.,Dowling, Grahame R.(2002).Corporate Reputation and Sustained Superior Financial Performance.Strategic Management Journal,23(12),1077-1093.
  73. Rowe, W. Glenn,Cannella, Albert A., Jr.,Rankin, Debra,Gorman, Doug(2005).Leader Succession and Organizational Performance: Integrating the Common-Sense, Ritual Scapegoating, and Vicious-Circle Succession Theories.The Leadership Quarterly,16(2),197-219.
  74. Sanders, Wm. Gerard,Boivie, Steven(2004).Sorting Things Out: Valuation of New Firms in Uncertain Markets.Strategic Management Journal,25(2),167-186.
  75. Shaw, Jason D.,Gupta, Nina,Delery, John E.(2005).Alternative Conceptualizations of the Relationship between Voluntary Turnover and Organizational Performance.The Academy of Management Journal,48(1),50-68.
  76. Small, Ken,Ionici, Octavian,Zhu, Hong(2007).Size Does Matter: An Examination of the Economic Impact of Sarbanes-Oxley.Review of Business,27(Spring-Summer),47-55.
  77. Tannous, George F.,Cheng, Bin(2007).Canadian Takeover Announcements and the Job Security of Top Managers.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences,24(4),250-267.
  78. Teece, David J.(1982).Towards an Economic Theory of the Multiproduct Firm.Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,3(1),39-63.
  79. Townsend, Alan,Kirby, David(1994).New Statistical Dimensions of Services in Britain.The Service Industries Journal,14(1),20-33.
  80. Voss, Zannie G.,Cable, Daniel M.,Voss, Glenn B.(2006).Organizational Identity and Firm Performance: What Happens When Leaders Disagree about "Who We Are?".Organization Science,17(6),741-755.
  81. Walker, Richard A.(1985).Is There a Service Economy? The Changing Capitalist Division of Labor.Science & Society,49(1),42-83.
  82. Wanyama, Simeon,Burton, Bruce,Helliar, Christine(2009).Frameworks Underpinning Corporate Governance: Evidence on Ugandan Perceptions.Corporate Governance: All International Review,17(2),159-175.
  83. Williamson, Oliver E.(1991).Comparative Economic Organization: The Analysis of Discrete Structural Alternatives.Administrative Science Quarterly,36(2),269-296.
  84. Williamson, Oliver E.(1975).Market and Hierarchies, Analysis and Antitrust Implications: A Study in the Economics of Internal Organization.New York:Free Press.
  85. Williamson, Oliver E.(1979).Transaction-Cost Economics: The Governance of Contractual Relations.Journal of Law and Economics,22(2),233-261.
  86. Williamson, Oliver E.(1971).The Vertical Integration of Production: Market Failure Considerations.The American Economic Review,61(2),112-123.
  87. Williamson, Oliver E.(1985).The Economic Institutions of Capitalism: Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting.New York:Free Press.
  88. Williamson, Oliver E.(1996).The Mechanisms of Governance.New York:Oxford University Press.
  89. Wilson, John O. S.,Morris, Jeanne E.(2000).The Size and Growth of UK Manufacturing and Service Firms.The Service Industries Journal,20(2),25-38.
  90. Woodcock. C. Patrick,Beamish, Paul W.,Makino, Shige(1994).Ownership-Based Entry Mode Strategies and International Performance.Journal of International Business Studies,25(2),253-273.
  91. Yukl, Gary A.(1998).Leadership in Organizations 4th ed..NJ:Prentice Hall.
  92. Zaccaro, Stephen J.(1996).Models and Theories of Executive Leadership: A Conceptual/Empirical Review and Integration.Alexandria, VA:U.S. Army Research Institute for the Behavioral and Social Sciences.
  93. Zahra, Shaker A.(1996).Governance, Ownership, and Corporate Entrepreneurship: The Moderating Impact of Industry Technological Opportunities.The Academy of Management Journal,39(6),1713-1735.
  94. Zhang, Yan,Rajagopalan, Nandini(2004).When the Known Devil Is Better than an Unknown God: An Empirical Study of the Antecedents and Consequences of Relay CEO Successions.The Academy of Management Journal,47(4),483-500.
被引用次数
  1. 黃振豊,周純伊,孔繁華(2019)。環境策略、環境管理、公司治理關聯性之研究－以台灣上市櫃製造業為例。商略學報，11(2)，151-168。
  2. 劉仲矩,廖淑華(2020)。公司治理美學資本與組織文化、利害關係人認同關聯之研究。輔仁管理評論，27(2)，69-102。
print cancel