磁吸效果、委託型態與流動性供給的關聯性

Magnet Effect, Order Submission Behavior and Liquidity Supply

10.6504/JOM.2012.29.04.04

王子湄(Zi-Mei Wang)；蕭朝興(Chao-Shin Chiao)；林家光(Chia-Kuang Lin)

磁吸效果 ； 委託不均衡 ； 價格限制 ； 流動性供給 ； Magnet Effect ； Order Imbalance ； Price Limit ； Liquidity Supply

管理學報

29卷4期（2012 / 08 / 01）

373 - 398

繁體中文

價格限制一直是政府用來穩定股票市場的斷路措施之一，目的在於避免價格出現巨幅波動，但對市場品質的影響，仍是產官學界爭論之焦點。價格限制的負面影響中，磁吸效果（magnet effect）備受討論，此效果是指價格限制像一塊磁鐵，當股價接近漲跌停板時，會有加速靠近之傾向。過去研究大都聚焦磁吸效果是否存在以及何時發生，囿於資料限制，探討磁吸效果來源的研究並不多。本研究因取得臺灣證交所提供的逐筆委託與成交資料，可以更完整地探討磁吸效果的相關議題。研究發現：第一、台灣股市價格限制確實會造成磁吸效果，在到達漲跌停之前，股價出現明顯的加速現象。雖然個別投資人積極的買（賣）超是磁吸效果主要的價格壓力來源，但個股過去績效表現會改變各類投資人對磁吸效果的相對影響力，甚至是磁吸效果的強度。第二、價格限制會影響流動性供給者的下單策略，當價格接近漲跌停時，投資人會提高流動性需求，減少使用非可市價化限價單的頻率，轉而改下可市價化限價單，並且更頻繁地取消非可市價化限價單，尤其是個別投資人與自營商。這些下單策略的調整，造成市場流動性供給降低，使得股價波動加劇，因而產生磁吸效果。

Though the aim of setting price limit is to prevent excessive price variations, its role as circuit breakers is often doubted. Among the adverse effects of price limits, magnet effect continues to attract a lot of attention. It refers to the phenomenon that the price limit acts as a magnet for stock prices. Most previous studies focus on whether the magnet effect exists, yet the causes are not well explored. Applying order-and trade-level data, this paper examines the magnet effect in the Taiwan Stock Market. Evidence shows, first, that the price limit acts as a magnet and further pulls the price even closer to the limit. Although the price pressure before hitting the limit is mainly caused by the order imbalances by individual investors, the precious stock returns could change the relative influences of institutional and individual trading activities, and, thus, the strength of the magnet effect. Second, price limit affects investors' order submission behaviors. When approaching the price limit, order submission behaviors, especially of individuals and security dealers, become more aggressive by switching from nonmarketable to marketable limit orders and cancelling more frequently nonmarketable limit orders. These changes in investors' submission strategy reduce stock liquidity supply and raise volatility, leading to the so-called magnet effect.

1. 蕭朝興、王子湄(2008)。台灣股市三大法人委託型態與價格行為的實證分析。管理與系統，十五(一)，55-92。
   連結：
2. Harris, L. and V. Panchapagesan, 2002. The Information-content of the Limit Order Book: Evidence from Specialist Trading Decisions, Unpublished Manuscript, University of Southern California.
3. Harris, L., 1997. Optimal Dynamic Order Submission Strategies in Some Stylized Trading Problems, Working Paper, Pennsylvania State University
4. Nath, P. 2003. Do Price Limits Behave Like Magnets?, Unpublished Manuscript, Harvard University.
5. Wong, W. K. and E. Girardin, 2008. The Informativeness of Order Flow: The Role of Institutions versus Individuals, Unpublished Manuscript, Cardiff University.
6. Kim, K. A. and R. J. Sweeney, 2001. Effect of Price Limits on Information Revelation: Theory and Evidence, Working Paper, Georgetown University
7. Rock, K., 1990. The Specialist's Order Book and Price Anomalies, Unpublished Manuscript, Harvard University.
8. Aitken, M.,Almeida, N.,Harris, F. H.,Melnish, T. H.(2007).Liquidity Supply in Electronic Markets.Journal of Financial Markets,10(1),144-168.
9. Anand, A.,Chakravarty, S.,Martell, T.(2005).Empirical Evicence on the Evolution of Liquidity: Choice of Market versus Limit Orders by Informed and Uninformed Traders.Journal of Financial Markets,8(2),289-309.
10. Arak, M.,Cook, R. E.(1997).Do Daily Price Limits Act as Magnets? The case of Treasury Bond Futures.Journal of Financial Services Research,12(1),5-20.
11. Bacidore, J.,Battalio, R.,Jennings, R.(2003).Order Submission Strategies, Liquidity Supply, and Trading in Pennies on the New York Stock Exchange.Journal of Financial Markets,6(3),337-362.
12. Barber, B. M.,Lee, Y. T.,Liu, Y. J.,Odean, T.(2007).Is the Aggregate Investor Reluctant to Realise Losses: Evidence from Taiwan.European Financial Management,13(4),423-447.
13. Berkman, H.,Steenbeek, O.(1998).The Influence of Daily Price Limits on Trading in Nikkei Futures.Journal of Future Markets,18(2),265-279.
14. Biais, B.,Hillion, P.,Spatt, C.(1995).An Empirical Analysis of the Limit Order Book and the Order Flow in the Paris Bourse.Journal of Finance,50(5),1655-1689.
15. Blume, M. E.,MacKinley, A. C.,Terker, B.(1989).Order Imbalances and Stock Price Movements on October 19 and 20, 1987.Journal of Finance,44(3),827-848.
16. Brockman, P.,Chung, D. Y.(2008).Commonality under Market Stress: Evidence from an Order-driven Market.International Review of Economics and Finance,17(1),179-196.
17. Brockman, P.,Chung, D. Y.(1999).An Analysis of Depth Behavior in an Electronic, Order-driven Environment.Journal of Banking & Finance,23(6),1861-1886.
18. Chakravarty, S.(2001).Steakth Trading: Which Traders' Trades Move Stock Prices?.Journal of Financial Economics,61(2),289-307.
19. Chan, L. K. C.,Lakonishok, J.(1995).The Behavior of Stock Prices around Institutional Trades.Journal of Finances,50(4),1147-1174.
20. Chan, L. K. C.,Lakonishok, J.(1993).Institutional Trades and Intraday Stock Price Behavior.Journal of Financial Economics,33(1),173-199.
21. Chan, S. H.,Kim, K.,Rhee, S. G.(2005).Price Limit Performance: Evidence from Transactions Data and the Limit Order Book.Journal of Empirical Finance,12(2),269-290.
22. Chiao, C. S.,Wang, Z. M.(2009).Price Clustering Evidence Using Compehensive Limit-order Data.Financial Review,44(1),1-29.
23. Cho, D.,Russell, J.,George, T.,Tsay, R.(2003).The Magnet Effects of Price Limits: Evidence from High-frequency Data on Taiwan Stock Exchange.Journal of Empirical Finance,10(1),133-168.
24. Chordia T.,Roll, R.,Subrahmanyam, A.(2005).Evidence on the Speed of Convergence to Market Efficiency.Journal of Financial Economics,76(2),271-92.
25. Chordia T.,Roll, R.,Subrahmanyam, A.(2002).Order Imbalances, Liquidity and Market Returns.Journal of Financial Economics,65(1),111-130.
26. Cohen, K.,Maier, S.,Schwartz, R.,Whitcomb, D.(1978).Limit Orders, Market Structure, and the Return Generating Process.Journal of Finance,33(5),723-736.
27. Cohen, K.,Maier, S.,Schwartz, R.,Whitcomb, D.(1981).Transaction Costs, Order Placement Strategy, and the Existence of the Bid-ask Spread.Journal of Political Economy,89(2),287-305.
28. Cushing, D.,Madhavan, A.(2000).Stock Returns and Trading at the Close.Journal of Financial Markets,3(1),45-67.
29. DeLong, J. B.,Shleifer, A.,Summers, L. H.,Waldmann, R. J.(1990).Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets.Journal of Political Economy,98(3),703-738.
30. Demsetz, H.(1968).The Cost of Transacting.Quarterly Journal of Economics,82(1),33-53.
31. Dennis, P. J.,Strickland, D.(2002).Who Blinks In Volatilc Markets, Individuals or Institutions?.Journal of Finance,57(5),1923-1949.
32. Diacogiannis, G. P.,Patsalis, N.,Tsangarakis, N. V.,Tsiritakis, E. D.(2005).Price Limits and Overreaction in the Athens Stock Exchange.Financial Economics,15(2),53-61.
33. Du, D. Y.,Liu, Q.,Rhee, S. G.(2009).An Analysis of the Magnet Effect under Price Limits.International Review of Finance,9(2),83-110.
34. Fama, E. F.(1989).Perspectives on October 1987, or what did we Learn from the Crash? In Black Monday and the Future of the Financial Markets.Homewood:Dow Jones-Irwin, Inc..
35. Fernandes, M.,Santos, M. A. R.(2005).Are Price Limits on Futures Markets that Cool? Evidence from the Brazilian Merceantile and Futures Exchange.Journal of Futures Markets,9(2),321-335.
36. Forster, F.,Viswanathan, S.(1990).A Theory of Intraday Variations in Volume, Variance, and Trading Costs in Securities Markets.Review of Financial Studies,3(5),593-624.
37. Glosten, L.(1994).Is the Electronic Open Limit Order Book Inevitable?.Journal of Finance,49(5),1127-1161.
38. Goldstein, M. A.,Kavajecz, K. A.(2004).Trading Strategies during Circuit Breakers and Extreme Market Movements.Journal of Financial Markets,7(2),301-333.
39. Goldstein, M. A.,Kavajecz, K. A.(2000).Eighths, Sixteenths, and Market Depth, Changes in Tick Size and Liquidity Provision the NYSE.Journal of Financial Economics,56(2),125-149.
40. Grinblatt, M.,Titman, S.,Wermers, R.(1995).Momentum Investment Strategies, Portfolio Performance, and Herding: A Study of Mutual Fund Behavior.American Economic Review,85(5),1088-1105.
41. Hall, A. D.,Kofman, P.(2001).Limits to Linear Price Behaviour: Future Prices Regulated by Limits.Journal of Futures Markets,21(5),463-488.
42. Harris, L.,Hasbrouck, J.(1996).Market vs. Limit Orders: the SuperDOT Evidence on Order Submission Strategy.Journal of Finance and Quantitative Analysis,31(2),213-231.
43. Hasbrouck, J.(1991).The Summary Informativeness of Stock Trades: An Econometric Analysis.Review of Financial Studies,4(5),571-595.
44. Hsieh, P. H.,Kim, Y. H.,Yang, J. J.(2009).The Magnet Effect of Price Limits: A Logit Approach.Journal of Empirical Finance,16(5),830-837.
45. Kamesaka, A.,Nofsinger, J. R.,Kawakita, H.(2003).Investment Patterns and Performance of Investor Groups in Japan.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,11(1),1-22.
46. Khorana, A.(1996).Top Management Turnover: An Empirical Investigation of Mutual Fund Managers.Journal of Financial Economics,40(3),403-427.
47. Kim, K. A.(2001).Price Limits and Stock Volatility.Economic Letters,71(2),131-136.
48. Kim, K. A.,Limpaphayom, P.(2000).Characteristics of Stocks that frequently Hit Price Limits: Empirical Evidence from Taiwan and Thailand.Journal of Financial Markets,3(3),315-332.
49. Kim, K. A.,Rhee, S. G.(1997).Price Limit Performance: Evidence from the Tokyo Stock Exchange.Journal of Finance,52(5),885-901.
50. Lakonishok, J.,Shleifer, A.,Vishny, R. W.(1992).The Impact of Institutional Trading on Stock Prices.Journal of Financial Economics,32(1),32-44.
51. Lee, C.(1992).Earnings News and Small Traders: An Intraday Analysis.Journal of Accounting and Economics,15(2),265-302.
52. Lee, C.,Shleifer, A.,Thaler, R. H.(1991).Investors' Sentiment and the Closed-end Fund Puzzle.Journal of Finance,46(2),75-109.
53. Lee, S. B.,Kim, K. J.(1995).The Effect of Price Limits on Stock Price Volatility: Empirical Evidence in Korea.Journal of Business, Finance, and Accounting,22(2),257-267.
54. Lee, Y.,Liu, Y.,Roll, R.,Subrahmanyam, A.(2004).Order Imbalances and Market Efficiency: Evidence from the Taiwan Stock Exchange.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,39(3),327-341.
55. Lehmann, B. N.(1989).Commentary: Volatility, Price Resolution, and the Effectiveness of Price Limits.Journal of Financial Services Research,3(2),205-209.
56. Odean, T.(1998).Are Investors Reluctant to Realize their Losses?.Journal of Finance,53(6),1775-1798.
57. Ranaldo, A.(2004).Order Aggressiveness in Limit Order Book Markets.Journal of Financial Markets,7(2),53-74.
58. Scharfstein, D.,Stein, J.(1990).Herd Behavior and Investment.American Economic Review,80(4),465-479.
59. Shu, P. G.,Yeh, Y. H.,Chiu, S. B.,Chen, H. C.(2005).Are Taiwanese Individual Investors Reluctant to Realize their Losses?.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,13(2),201-223.
60. Stoll, H.(2000).Friction.Journal of Finance,55(4),1479-1514.
61. Subrahmanyam, A.(1994).Circuit Breakers and Market Volatility: A Theoretical Perspective.Journal of Finance,49(3),237-254.
62. Walther, B.(1997).Investor Sophistication and Market Earnings Expectations.Journal of Accounting Research,35(1),157-179.
63. Westerhoff, F.(2003).Speculative Markets and the Effectiveness of Price Limits.Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control,28(3),493-508.
64. Wong, W. K.,Chang, M. C.,Tu, A. H.(2009).Are Magnet Effects Caused by Uninformed Traders? Evidence from Taiwan Stock Exchange.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,17(1),28-40.

1. 張哲睿(2017)。漲跌幅限制變動對於磁吸效應的影響。中原大學財務金融學系學位論文。2017。1-32。