共同基金處分效果、強化承諾與動能投資策略

The Disposition Effect, Escalation of Commitment and Momentum Strategy in Mutual Funds

10.6504/JOM.2013.30.02.03

林煜恩(Yu-En Lin)；池祥萱(Hsiang-Hsuan Chih)

處分效果 ； 強化承諾 ； 動能投資策略 ； 反向操作策略 ； 持股偏好 ； Disposition Effect ； Escalation of Commitment ； Momentum ； Contrarian ； Holdings Preference

管理學報

30卷2期（2013 / 04 / 01）

147 - 168

繁體中文

本文旨在探討在控制了動能投資策略後，處分效果與強化承諾對共同基金績效的影響是否仍然存在。首先採用相依分組的方式，先將共同基金依照動能投資風格進行分組，再檢驗不同動能風格投資組合下，處分效果與強化承諾投資組合的績效，第二，檢驗共同基金的持股偏好，探討在控制了股票的其他特徵後，共同基金的持股是否會受帳面利得或帳面損失所影響。結果如下，第一，處分效果與強化承諾對共同基金的績效有著負面影響；第二，控制了共同基金的動能投資風格後，處分效果與強化承諾對基金績效的負面影響依然存在；第三，共同基金持股確實受帳面利得或帳面損失影響而改變，顯示處分效果與強化承諾確實會影響共同基金的持股偏好。

This paper examines whether the impact of disposition effect and escalation of commitment holds after controlling the momentum investing style. First, this paper ranks the mutual fund into five groups by momentum measure, and we examine DISP and ESCA zero investment portfolios in each momentum style portfolio. Then, we investigate whether the paper gain ratio or paper loss ratio impact on holding preference after controlling other characteristics. Our results can be summarized as follow: first, disposition effect and escalation of commitment has negative impact on mutual fund performance. Second, the result still holds after controlling the momentum style of mutual funds. Finally, we find the disposition effect and escalation of commitment indeed have influence on holdings preference.

1. 池祥萱、林煜恩、周賓凰(2009)。處份效果、強化承諾與共同基金績效。管理評論，28(4)，1-18。
   連結：
2. 李春安、陳輝格、林慶章(2011)。基金經理人風險調整行為之研究─展望理論觀點。財務金融學刊，19(1)，33-61。
   連結：
3. 許培基、陳軒基、黃淑貞(2005)。基金經理人為何出現群集行為？。管理評論，24(4)，57-84。
   連結：
4. 游智賢、姚瑜忠(2000)。台灣共同基金操作策略之研究。財務金融學刊，8(2)，49-76。
   連結：
5. Odean, T., M. Strahilevitz, and B. M. Baber, 2004. Once Burned, Twice Shy: How native Learning and Counterfactuals Affect the Repurchase of Stocks Previously Sold, Working Paper.
6. Da Silva Rosa, R., H. M. To, and T. Walter, 2006. Tests of the Disposition Effect amongst UK Managed Funds, Working Paper.
7. Baker, M., L. Litov, J. Wachter, and J. Wurgler, 2009. Can Mutual Fund Managers Pick Stocks? Evidence Can Mutual Fund Managers Pick Stocks? Evidence from Their Trades Prior to Earnings Announcements, Working paper.
8. Cici, C., 2005. The Relation of the Disposition Effect to Mutual Fund Trades and Performance, Working paper.
9. Scherbina, A. and K. Jin, 2005. Change is Good or the Disposition Effect among Mutual Fund Managers, Working Paper.
10. Ang, A.,Hodrick, R.,Xing, Y.,Zhang, X.(2006).The Cross-Section of Volatility and Expected Returns.Journal of Finance,59(1),259-299.
11. Arkes, H. R.,Blumer, C.(1985).The Psychology of Sunk Cost.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,35(1),124-140.
12. Badrinath, S. G.,Gay, G. D.,Kale, J. R.(1989).Patterns of Institutional Investment, Prudence, and the Managerial 'Safety-Net' Hypothesis.Journal of Risk and Insurance,56(4),605-629.
13. Badrinath, S. G.,Kale, J. R.,Ryan, Jr.(1995).Characteristics of Common Stock Holdings of Insurance Companies.Journal of Risk and Insurance,63(1),49-76.
14. Baker, M.,Wurgler, J.(2006).Investor Sentiment and the Cross-Section of Stock Returns.Journal of Finance,61(4),1645-1680.
15. Baker, M.,Wurgler, J.(2007).Investor Sentiment in the Stock Market.Journal of Economic Perspective,21(2),129-151.
16. Bennett, J.,Sias, R.,Starks, L.(2003).Greener Pastures and the Impact of Dynamic Institutional Preferences.Review of Financial Studies,16(4),1203-1238.
17. Biyalogorsky, E.,Bounding, W.,Staelin, R.(2006).Stuck in the Past: Why Managers Persist with New Product Failures.Journal of Marketing,70(2),108-121.
18. Brown, P.,Chappel, N.,Da Silva Rosa, R.,Walter, T.(2006).The Reach of the Disposition Effect: Large Sample Evidence across Investor Classes.International Review of Finance,6(1-2),43-78.
19. Carhart, M. M.(1997).On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance.Journal of Finance,52(1),57-82.
20. Chan, L.,Chen, H.,Lakonshok, J.(2002).On Mutual Fund Investment Styles.Review of Financial Studies,15(5),1407-1437.
21. Chen, H. L.,Jegadeesh, N.,Wermers, R.(2000).The Value of Active Mutual Fund Management: An Examination of the Stockholdings and Trades of Fund Managers.Journal of Financial Quantitative Analysis,36(3),343-368.
22. Chen, J.,Hong, H.,Huang, M.,Kubik, J.(2004).Does Fund Size Erode Performance? Liquidity, Organizational Diseconomies and Active Money Management.American Economic Review,94(5),1276-1302.
23. Chow, C. W.,Harrison, P.,Lindquist, T.,Wu, A.(1997).Escalating Commitment to Unprofitable Projects: Replication and Cross-Cultural Extension.Management Accounting Research,8(3),347-361.
24. Conlon, E.,Leatherwood, M. L.(1989).Sunk Costs and Financial Decision Making: Integration and Implications.Advances in Financial Planning and Forecasting,3,37-61.
25. Daniel, K.,Grinblatt, M.,Titman, S.,Wermers, R.(1997).Measuring Mutual Fund Performance with Characteristic-based Benchmarks.Journal of Finance,52(3),1035-1058.
26. De Bondt, W.,Thaler, R.(1985).Does the Stock Market Overreact?.Journal of Finance,40(3),793-805.
27. De Bondt, W.,Thaler, R.(1987).Further Evidence on Investor Overreaction and Stock Market Seasonality.Journal of Finance,42(3),557-581.
28. Drucker, P. F.(1986).To End the Raiding Roulette Game.Across the Board,23(4),30-39.
29. Falkenstein, E. G.(1996).Preferences for Stocks Characteristics as Revealed by Mutual Fund Portfolio Holdings.Journal of Finance,51(1),111-135.
30. Fama, E. F.,French, K. R.(1993).Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Stocks and Bonds.Journal of Finance,33(1),3-56.
31. Ferris, S.,Haugen, R.,Makhija, A.(1988).Predicting Contemporary Volume with Historic Volume at Differential Price Levels: Evidence Supporting Disposition Effect.Journal of Finance,43(3),698-699.
32. Graves, S. B.,Waddock, S. A.(1990).Institutional Ownership and Control: Implication for Long-Term Corporate Strategy.Academy of Management Executive,4(1),75-83.
33. Grinblatt, M.,Han, B.(2005).Prospect Theory, Mental Accounting, and Momentum.Journal of Financial Economics,78(2),311-339.
34. Grinblatt, M.,Keloharju, M.(2001).What Makes Investors Trade?.Journal of Finance,56(2),589-616.
35. Grinblatt, M.,Titman, S.,Wermer, R.(1995).Momentum Investment Strategies, Portfolio Performance, and Herding: Herding: A Study of Mutual Fund Behavior.American Economic Review,85(5),1088-1105.
36. Haunschild, P. R.,Davis-Blake, A.,Fichman, M.(1994).Managerial Overcommitment in Corporate Acquisition Processes.Organization Science,5(4),528-540.
37. Jagadeesh, N.,Titman, S.(1993).Retums to Buying Winners and Selling Losers: Implication for Market Efficiency.Journal of finance,48(1),65-91.
38. Kaminsky, G.,Lyons, R.,Schmukler, S.(2004).Managers, Investors, and Crises: Mutual Fund Strategies in Emerging Markets.Journal of International Economics,64(1),113-134.
39. Kaustia, M.(2004).Market-Wide Impact of the Disposition Effect: Evidence from IPO Trading Volume.Journal of Financial Market,7(2),207-235.
40. Kim, W.,Nofsinger, J.(2005).Institutional Herding, Business Groups, and Economic Regimes: Evidence from Japan.Journal of Business,78(1),213-242.
41. Kim, W.,Wei, S.(2002).Foreign Portfolio Investor Before and During a Crisis.Journal of International Economics,56(1),77-96.
42. Lakonishok, J.,Shleifer, A.,Vishny, R.(1994).Contrarian Investment, Extrapolation, and Risk.Journal of Finance,49(5),1541-1578.
43. Merton, R. C.(1987).A Simple Model of Capital Market Equilibrium with Incomplete Information.Journal of Finance,42(3),483-510.
44. Nofsinger, J. R.,Sias, R. W.(1999).Herding and Feedback Trading by Institutional and Individual Investors.Journal of Finance,54(6),2263-2295.
45. Odean, T.(1998).Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses?.Journal of Finance,53(5),1775-1798.
46. Porter, M. E.(1992).Capital Disadvantage: America's Failing Capital Investment System.Harvard Business Review,70(5),65-82.
47. Repenning, N. P.(2001).Understanding Fire Fighting in New Product Development.Journal of Product Innovation Management,18(5),285-300.
48. Sapp, T.,Tiwari, A.(2004).Does Stock Return Momentum Explain the Smart Money Effect?.Journal of Finance,59(6),2605-2622.
49. Shefrin, H.,Statman, M.(1985).The Disposition to Sell Winners too Early and Ride Loser too Long: Theory and Evidence.Journal of Finance,40(3),777-792.
50. Staw, B. M.(1976).Knee-Deep in the Big Muddy: A Study of Escalating Commitment to a Chosen Course of Action.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,16,27-44.
51. Staw, B. M.,Hoang, H.(1995).Sunk Costs in the NBA: Why Draft Order Affects Playing Time and Survival in Professional Basketball.Administrative Science Quarterly,40(3),474-494.
52. Werber, M.,Camerer, C. F.(1998).The Disposition Effect in the Securities Trading: An Experimental Analysis.Journal economic behavior & organization,33(2),167-184.
53. 池祥萱、林煜恩、黃少宣、李婉真(2009)。過早賣出贏家股票與過晚賣出輸家股票一定是不理性的行為嗎？。中國金融國際年會，中國廣州:
54. 邱顯比、林清珮(1999)。共同基金分類與基金績效持續性之研究。財務金融學刊，7(2)，66-88。

1. 魏裕珍,洪慧玲,洪敬傑(2022)。共同基金的媒體聲譽對其績效表現之影響。證券市場發展季刊，34(3)，115-163。