台灣股市收盤資訊揭露制度與價格效率的關聯性

Information Transparency on the Closing Session and Price Efficiency in the Taiwan Stock Market

10.6504/JOM.2014.31.02.02

王子湄(Zi-Mei Wang)；蕭朝興(Chao-Shin Chiao)；丁信瑜(Hsing-Yu Ting)

市場透明度 ； 尾盤人為作價 ； 價格效率 ； transparency ； closing price manipulation ； price efficiency

管理學報

31卷2期（2014 / 06 / 01）

107 - 134

繁體中文

台灣股市過去在收盤5分鐘的集合競價階段並未揭露任何買賣資訊，導致最後收盤價可能與前一盤有所差距，亦即尾盤容易發生作價的情形。自2012年2月20日開始實施新的收盤揭示制度，收盤最後5分鐘每隔20秒，揭露模擬撮合後之最佳1檔買賣價格，同時也實施配套措施－個股收盤最後1分鐘漲跌幅超過3.5%時，暫緩2分鐘收盤。本文以台灣股市為研究對象，探討收盤資訊揭露制度與價格效率的關聯性。研究發現，尾盤透明度提升可以改善價格發現過程，不僅降低報酬波動，同時也增加價格的資訊效率性。更重要的是，新制在防止尾盤刻意拉抬或摜壓價格的成效，會隨個股規模而有所不同，對於中小型股而言，新制確實可以減少最後一盤人為作價的情形，但權值股尾盤作價並無顯著降低，大型股的期貨『結算行情』不受影響，同時也出現提前作價的傾向。

This paper examines price efficiency responding to the new rule posted by the Taiwan Stock Exchange (TSE), effective on 2/20/2012. To improve price efficiency, TSE has revised the rule of the closing session, starting from five minutes before the close, wherein real trades are replaced with a sequence of simulated call auctions. The best quotes and the indicative trading prices are disseminated on line, instead of ＂trading in dark＂ as before. If a stock’s final simulated price deviates from the previous trading price by 3.5%, the stock’s final auction will be postponed by two minutes. Evidence shows that the rising transparency overall improves price efficiency by lowering price volatility. More importantly, the improvement varies with firm size. That for small- and medium-cap stocks is more pronounced than that for large-cap stocks, tightly linked to the index futures. No obvious expiration-day effect on large-cap stocks exists; and price manipulations on them shift ahead of the closing session.

1. 林雅玲、馬黛、陳秀桂(2011)。透明度、資訊內涵及下單策略之實證研究。財務金融季刊，19(1)，1-32。
   連結：
2. 謝文良、曲靜芳(2009)。摩根台指期貨之到期日效應。管理評論，28(1)，1-22。
   連結：
3. Kang, J. and D. Lee, 2007. The Effect of a Transparency Change in the Pre-opening Session on Price Discovery, Working paper, KAIST Graduate school of business.
4. Suen W. and K. M. Wan, 2011. Sniping to Manipulate Closing Prices in Call Auctions: Evidence from the Hong Kong Stock Exchange, Working paper.
5. Hendershott, T. and C. M. Jones, 2003. Island Goes Dark: Transparency, Fragmentation, Liquidity Externalities, and Multimarket Regulation, working paper, University of California.
6. Aggarwal, R.,Wu, G.(2006).Stock Market Manipulations.Journal of Business,79(4),1915-1953.
7. Alkeback, P.,Hagelin, N.(2004).Expiration Day Effects of Index Futures and Options: Evidence from a Market with a Long Settlement Period.Applied Financial Economics,14(6),385-396.
8. Atkins, A. B.,Dyl, E. A.(1997).Transactions Costs and Holding Periods for Common Stocks.Journal of Finance,52(1),309-325.
9. Barush, S.(2005).Who Benefits from an Open Limit-order Book?.Journal of Business,78(4),1267-1306.
10. Bernhardt, D.,Davies, R.(2004).Painting the Tape: Aggregate Evidence.Economics Letters,89(3),306-311.
11. Bloomfield, R.,O'Hara, M.(1999).Market Transparency: Who Wins and Who Loses?.Review of Financial Studies,12(1),5-35.
12. Boehmer, E.,Saar, G.,Yu, L.(2005).Lifting the Veil: Analysis of Pre-trade Transparency at the NYSE.Journal of Finance,60(2),783-815.
13. Carhart, M. M.,Kanile, R.,Musto, D. K.,Reed, A. V.(2002).Learning for the Tape: Evidence of Gaming Behavior in Equity Mutual Funds.Journal of Finance,57(2),661-693.
14. Chang, R. P.,Rhee, G. S.,Stone, G. R.,Tang, N.(2008).How does the Call Market Method Affect Price Efficiency? Evidence from the Singapore Stock Market.Journal of Banking and Finance,32(10),2205-2219.
15. Chou, H. C.,Chen, W. N.,Chen, D. H.(2006).The Expiration Effects of Stock Index Derivatives: Empirical Evidence from the Taiwan Futures Exchange.Emerging Markets Finance and Trade,42(5),81-102.
16. Chow, Y. F.,Yung, H. H. M.,Zhang, H.(2003).Expiration Day Effects: the Case of Hong Kong.Journal of Futures Markets,23(1),67-86.
17. Chung, H.,Hseu, M.(2008).Expiration Day Effects of Taiwan Index Futures: The case of the Singapore and Taiwan Futures Exchanges.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,18(2),107-120.
18. Comerton-Forde, C.,Putnins, T. J.(2011).Measuring Closing Price Manipulation.Journal of Financial Intermediation,20(2),135-158.
19. Comerton-Forde, C.,Rydge, J.(2006).Call Auction Algorithm Design and Market Manipulation.Journal of Multinational Financial Management,16(2),184-198.
20. Corredor, P.,Lechon, P.,Santamaria, R.(2001).Option-expiration Effect in Small Markets: the Spanish Stock Exchange.Journal of Futures Markets,21(10),905-928.
21. Eom, K. S.,Lee, E. J.,Park, K. S.(2013).Microstructure-Based Manipulation: Strategic Behavior and Performance of Spoofing Traders.Journal of Financial Markets,16(2),227-252.
22. Eom, K. S.,Ok, J.,Park, J. H.(2007).Pre-trade Transparency and Market Quality.Journal of Financial Markets,10(4),319-341.
23. Flood, M. D.,Huisman, R.,Koedijk, K. G.,Mahieu, R. J.(1999).Quote Disclosure and Price Discovery in Multi-dealer Financial Markets.Review of Financial Studies,12(1),37-59.
24. Fricke, C.,Menkhoff, L.(2011).Does the "Bund" dominate price discovery in Euro bond futures? Examining information shares.Journal of Banking and Finance,35(5),1057-1072.
25. Fung, J. K. W.,Yung, H. H. M.(2009).Expiration-Day Effects-An Asian Twist.Journal of Futures Markets,29(5),430-450.
26. Goldstein, I.,Guembel, A.(2008).Manipulation and the Allocational Role of Prices.Review of Economic Studies,75(1),133-164.
27. Hillion, P.,Suominen, M.(2004).The Manipulation of Closing Prices.Journal of Financial Markets,7(4),351-375.
28. Hsieh, S. F.,Ma, T.(2008).Expiration-day Effects: Does Settlement Price Matter?.International Review of Economics and Finance,18(2),290-300.
29. Ju, S. E.,Lo, K. H.,Wang, K.(2008).Expiration Day Effects: Empirical Evidence from Taiwan.Journal of Global Business,2(2),51-62.
30. Lang, L. H. P.,Lee, Y. T.(1999).Performance of Various Transaction Frequencies under Call Markets: the case of Taiwan.Pacific-Basin Financial Journal,7(1),23-39.
31. Ma, T.,Lin, Y.,Chen, H. K.(2008).Are Investors More Aggressive in Transparent Markets?.Asia-Pacific Journal of Financial Studies,37(2),343-380.
32. Madhavan, A.(1996).Security Prices and Market Transparency.Journal of Financial Intermediation,5(3),255-283.
33. Madhavan, A.,Porter, D.,Weaver, D.(2005).Should Securities Markets be Transparent?.Journal of Financial Markets,8(3),265-287.
34. McInish, T. H.,Van Ness, B. F.,Van Ness, R. A.(1998).The Effect of the SEC's Order-handling Rules on Nasdaq.Journal of Financial Research,21,247-254.
35. Mizrach, B.,Neely, C. J.(2008).Information shares in the US Treasury market.Journal of Banking and Finance,32(7),1221-1233.
36. O'Hara, M.(1995).Market Microstructure Theory.Cambridge, Mass:Basil Blackwell.
37. Pagano, M.,Röell, A.(1996).Transparency and Liquidity: A Comparison of Auction and Dealer Markets with Informed Trading.Journal of Finance,51(2),579-611.
38. Stoll, H. R.,Whaley, R. E.(1991).Expiration Day Effects: What Has Changed?.Financial Analysts Journal,47(1),58-72.
39. Stoll, H. R.,Whaley, R. E.(1997).Expiration-day Effects of the All Ordinaries Share Price Index Futures: Empirical Evidence and Alternative Settlement Procedures.Australian Journal of Management,22(2),139-174.
40. Tian, G. G.,Gerace, D.,Frino, A.(2008).Call Auction Transparency and Market Liquidity: Evidence from the Shanghai Stock Exchange.PBFEAM 2008: 16th Annual Conference on Pacific Basin Finance Economics Accounting Management,Brisbane:
41. Wats, S.(2010).Impact of Expiration on Spot Market Volatility: A Study of NSE Nifty.Journal of Applied Finance,16(4),51-61.
42. 李見發、林裕榮、陳秀陵(2005)。台灣股價指數期貨及摩根台股期貨到期日效應之因素研究。財金論文叢刊，3，51-76。
43. 李怡宗、劉玉珍、王錦瑩、陳薇如、賴文弘(2009)。限價委託簿資訊透明度與市場品質。證券市場發展，21(1)，51-86。
44. 林秋發、林佳媛(2009)。實施揭露未成交五檔價量資訊對流動性的影響。全球商管研究，4(1)，61-78。
45. 林雅玲(2008)。博士論文(博士論文)。中山大學財務管理研究所。
46. 黃玉娟、陳培林、鄭堯任(2007)。交易機制改變對市場績效之影響：透明度與撮合頻率之探討。證券市場發展，19(1)，133-158。
47. 黃志宏(2009)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。中山大學財務管理研究所。

1. Wang, Kai-Li,Tseng, Yi-Heng,Chang, Chia-Ling,Wang, Kai-Li,Tseng, Yi-Heng,Chang, Chia-Ling(2017).Order Choices, Order Performance, and Price Discovery during Closing Call Auctions-A Case Study of Improved LOB Disclosure in Taiwan Stock Exchange.財務金融學刊,25(2),105-156.
2. 曾翊恆(2016)。集合競價、限價簿揭露資訊與委託積極度決策。證券市場發展季刊，28(1)，39-102。
3. 葉仕國、張森林、林丙輝(2017)。台灣衍生性金融商品市場實證與運用研究文獻回顧與展望。臺大管理論叢，27(2)，211-258。