創業實作課程如何產生學習：創制研究取徑

Inquiring the Way Students Learn in Practice-Based Entrepreneurship Education-The Enactive Research Approach

10.6504/JOM.2017.34.02.01

王致遠(Jack Chih-Yuan Wang)；蔡敦浩(Stephen Dun-Hou Tsai)；吳孟珍(Esta Meng-Chen Wu)；李至昱(Roy Chih-Yu Lee)

開創 ； 創業學習 ； 創業實作教育 ； 創制研究 ； entrepreneuring ； entrepreneurial learning ； practice-based entrepreneurship education ； practice-based education ； enactive research

管理學報

34卷2期（2017 / 06 / 01）

147 - 166

繁體中文

本研究以創制研究法 (enactive research) 做為起點，從北歐開創觀點討論創業學習者如何在一個創業實作課程中學習？我們認為創業教育的目的應從實作中經驗到創造的歷程，進而帶來持續的流變與學習。我們發現，學習者之所以願意改變與開創，來自實作會將課程參與者凝聚成實踐共同體，成為實作開創中浮現的織組中脈絡。於織組中脈絡裡，學習者從開創學習裡產生認同，因為在實作連結而成的對話空間中持續經驗對問題即時改善，而讓學習者感受到實踐的力量與功能，而更願意改變。因為實作情境的召喚，驅動學習者立即的類比與拼創行動，並在行動結果的自我反思與觀察中，又產生新的即時回應。這樣的循環，讓學習者經歷獨特的實作開創經驗與轉變，而流變為新知識、新能力的使用者與學習者。

The purpose of this paper is to explore the practice-based approach to the entrepreneurship education by discussing a different learning perspective, learning as an entrepreneurial process, which aimed at infusing the entrepreneuring mindset and actions among students in the university setting. By experimenting the practice-based approach in the institute-level teaching into the curriculum, we applied the entrepreneuring perspective and the enactive research method to inquire how the students learn in practice. The analysis of data includes teachers' observations, written materials, such as students' learning journals and group discussion records. This study offers two levels of findings about how the students learned and changed in practice. At the collective level, students' learning roots in the ＂organizing context (OC).＂ At the individual level, the students in the OC create a dialogic space to change their self-identity in practice. In addition, the situations drive the students' call for analogy and bricolage to organize and re-organize their experiences to deal with problems. Finally, this cycling process allows a student to be in the becoming process from a learner to a user of new concepts and new skills.

1. Commission of the European Communities, 2003. Green Paper ： Entrepreneurship in Europe. http://ec.europa.eu/invest-in-research/pdf/download_en/entrepreneurship_europe.pdf. Accessed January 3, 2016.
2. Achtenhagen, L.,Johannisson, B.(2013).The making of an intercultural learning context for entrepreneuring.International Journal of Entrepreneurial Venturing,5(1),48-67.
3. Aronsson, M.(2004).Education matters-but does entrepreneurship education? An interview with David Birch.Academy of Management Learning and Education,3(3),289-292.
4. Arrow, K. J.(1962).The economic implications of learning by doing.Review of Economic Studies,29(3),155-173.
5. Becattini, G.(ed.),Bellandi, M.(ed.),De Propris, L.(ed.)(2009).Handbook of industrial districts.London:Edgar Elgar.
6. Berglund, K.(Ed.),Johannisson, B.(Ed.),Schwartz, B.(Ed.)(2012).Societal entrepreneurship: Positioning, penetrating, promoting.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
7. Brockhaus, R. H.(Ed.),Hills, G. E.(Ed.),Klandt, H.(Ed.),Welsch, H. P.(Ed.)(2001).Entrepreneurship education-A global view.Aldeshot:Ashgate.
8. Colebrook, C.(2002).Gilles deleuze.London:Routledge.
9. Cope, J.(2005).Toward a dynamic learning perspective of entrepreneurship.Entrepreneurship Theory & Practice,29(4),373-397.
10. Cross, R.,Sproull, L.(2004).More than an answer: Information relationships for actionable knowledge.Organization Science,15(4),446-462.
11. Donnellon, A.,Ollila, S.,Middleton, K. W.(2014).Constructing entrepreneurial identity in entrepreneurship education.The International Journal of Management Education,12(3),490-499.
12. Drucker, P. F.(1985).Innovation and entrepreneurship.New York:Harper & Row.
13. Elliott, J.(2005).Using narrative in social research: Qualitative and quantitative approaches.London:Sage Publications Ltd.
14. Fayolle, A.(2007).Handbook of research in entrepreneurship education: A general perspective.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
15. Fayolle, A.(Ed)(2007).Handbook of Research in Entrepreneurship Education - A General Perspective.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
16. Fiet, J. O.(2001).The pedagogical side of entrepreneurship theory.Journal of Business Venturing,16(2),101-117.
17. Fletcher, D. E.(2011).A curiosity for contexts: Entrepreneurship, enactive research and autoethnography.Entrepreneurship & Regional Development,23(1-2),65-76.
18. Gibb, A.(2011).Concepts into practice: Meeting the challenge of development of entrepreneurship educators around an innovative paradigm: The case of the international entrepreneurship educators' programme (IEEP).International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior& Research,17(2),146-165.
19. Giddens, A.(1991).Modernity and self-identity: Self and society in the late modern age.Stanford, CA:Stanford University Press.
20. Haase, A.,Lautenschläger, A.(2011).The teachability dilemma of entrepreneurship.International Entrepreneurship Management Journal,7(2),145-162.
21. Hamilton, E.(2011).Entrepreneurial learning in family business: A situated learning perspective.Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development,18(1),8-26.
22. Haynie, J. M.,Shepherd, D.,Mosakowski, E.,Earley, P. C.(2010).A situated metacognitive model of the entrepreneurial mindset.Journal of Business Venturing,25(2),217-229.
23. Hjorth, D.,Johannisson, B.(2009).Learning as an Entrepreneurial Process.Revue de l'Entrepreneuriat,8(2),57-78.
24. Johannisson, B.(2011).Towards a practice theory of entrepreneuring.Small Business Economics,36(2),135-150.
25. Johannisson, B.(2007).Enacting local economic development-theoretical and methodological challenges.Journal of Enterprising Communities: People and Places in the Global Economy,1(1),7-26.
26. Katz, J. A.(2003).The chronology and intellectual trajectory of american entrepreneurship education: 1876-1999.Journal of Business Venturing,18(2),283-300.
27. Kirby, D. A.(2004).Entrepreneurship education: Can business schools meet the challenge?.Education + Training,46(8/9),510-519.
28. Kuratko, D. F.(2005).The emergence of entrepreneurship education: Development, trends, and challenges.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,29(5),577-598.
29. Löbler, H.(2006).Learning entrepreneurship and innovative abilities from a constructivist perspective.Technology Analysis & Strategic Management,18(1),19-38.
30. Lourenco, F.,Jones, O.(2006).Developing entrepreneurship education: Comparing traditional and alternative teaching approaches.International Journal of Entrepreneurship Education,4,111-140.
31. Matlay, H.,Carey, C.(2007).Entrepreneurship education in the UK: A longitudinal perspective.Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development,14(2),252-263.
32. Mollo, V.,Falzon, P.(2004).Auto- and allo-confrontation as tools for reflective activities.Applied Ergonomics,35(6),531-540.
33. Neck, H. M.,Greene, P. G.(2011).Entrepreneurship education: Known worlds and new frontiers.Journal of Small Business Management,49(1),55-70.
34. Peterman, N. E.,Kennedy, J.(2003).Enterprise education: Influencing students' perceptions of entrepreneurship.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,28(2),129-144.
35. Pittaway, L.,Cope, J.(2007).Simulating entrepreneurial learning - integrating experiential and collaborative approaches to learning.Management Learning,38(2),211-233.
36. Polkinghorne, D. E.(1995).Narrative configuration in qualitative analysis.International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education,8(1),5-23.
37. Rasmussen, E. A.,Sørheim, R.(2006).Action-Based Entrepreneurship Education.Technovation,26(2),185-194.
38. Robinson, S.,Blenker, P.(2014).Tensions between rhetoric and practice in entrepreneurship education; an ethnography from Danish higher education European.European Journal of Higher education,4(1),80-93.
39. Steyaert, C.(2007).Entrepreneuring' as a conceptual attractor? A review of process theories in 20 years of entrepreneurship studies.Entrepreneurship & Regional Development,19(6),453-477.
40. Steyaert, C.(Ed),Hjorth, D.(Ed)(2006).Entrepreneurship as social change: A third movements in entrepreneurship book.Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar.
41. Terjesen, S.,Elam, A.(2009).Transnational entrepreneurs' venture internationalization strategies: A practice theory approach.Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,33(5),1093-1120.
42. Timmons, J. A.,Spinelli, S.(2004).New venture creation: Entrepreneurship for the 21st century.Boston:McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
43. Watson, T. J.(2013).Entrepreneurial action and the Euro-American social science tradition: Pragmatism, realism and looking beyond 'the entrepreneur'.Entrepreneurship & Regional Development,25(1-2),16-33.
44. Weick, K. E.,Sutcliffe, K. M.,Obstfeld, D.(2005).Organizing and the process of sensemaking.Organization Science,16(4),409-421.
45. Wenger, E.(1998).Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
46. Yakhlef, A.(2010).The corporeality of practice-based learning.Organization Studies,31(4),409-430.
47. 林茂昌譯、Crawford, M. B.(2010)。摩托車修理店的未來工作哲學：通往美好生活的手工精神與趨勢。台北:大塊文化。
48. 劉育忠(2015)。開創的教育學：在真實中體現的創造實踐。台北:漢世紀數位文化股份有限公司。

1. 蔡進士,陳威宇(2023)。臺灣創業教育發展歷程－在大學中打造創業之路。觀光產業與航空管理期刊，6(1)，38-66。
2. 陳冠宇,林士平(2021)。大學創業教育生態系統影響大學生創業警覺性養成之因素重要性研究。科技管理學刊，26(2)，55-76。
3. 謝如梅,蔡依倫(2022)。學生如何成為創業家？立基於制度的微觀層次探討。組織與管理，15(1)，1-45。
4. (2020)。混合式學習應用於實務型課程之學習成效研究：以「編輯設計與實務」課程為例。靜宜人文社會學報，14(2)，81-102。