影響員工陞遷因素之探究－兼論兩性差異之分析

The Research on the Factors Influencing Promotion of Employees-Sex Differentials Analysis Included

10.6431/TWJHSS.200503.0145

張茹娟(Ru-Chuan Chang)；江建昌(Chien-Chang Chiang)

在職訓練 ； 性別差異 ； 社會歧視 ； 陞遷 ； On-the-job training ； Sex Differentials ； Social Discrimination ； Promotion

思與言：人文與社會科學期刊

43卷1期（2005 / 03 / 01）

145 - 193

繁體中文

本文針對國內一家以男性員工為主的電器業(N=189)，另一家以女性為主的紡織業(N=108)廠商進行研究，透過問卷調查的方式，了解影響員工陞遷事實以及影響員工未來陞遷期望之因素，並針對兩性之差異進行分析。研究結果顯示：年資、產業特性、性別與一般訓練的互動項、產業特性與一般訓練的互動項，是影響員工陞遷事實及陞遷期望之重要因素。另教育程度雖對員工陞遷事實與陞遷期望未直接產生顯著影響，但會透過在職訓練的參加與否間接產生影響。本研究發現參加男性為主的電器業之一般訓練的員工，其陞遷事實與陞遷期望皆多於參加女性為主的紡織業之一般訓練，並進一步發現就參加一般訓練的兩性而言，對男性陞遷事實與陞遷期望的影響效果大於女性，再就同一產業中，參加一般訓練的男性仍比女性有較多的陞遷事實與陞遷期望。其原因可能在於受到傳統性別角色刻板化印象的影響，致使女性多置身於女性集中的產業而較無陞遷機會外，也影響雇主的陞遷決定。因此，未來的研究可針對性別刻板化印象如何影響雇主陞遷決定的過程進行探討，並蒐集員工陞遷的資料以進一步分析。

This paper utilizes survey data from an incorporation primarily of male employees in domestic electric appliance industry (N=189), and another one of female employees in textile industry (N=108), to investigate the factors affect which employees is promoted, and the employees' expectation to be promoted or not in the future. Besides, the analysis of the difference between sexes is applied. The results show that the period of service, industrial character, sex and general training interaction term, industrial character and general training interaction term are the important factors to affect employees are promoted or not, and the expectation of promotion. Education is not direct influence on promotion, but through taking training to affect promotion. The research demonstrated that both taking general training employees, workers of male centralized domestic electric appliance industry than female centralized textile industry have more promotion and the expectations. Both taking general training employees, male workers than female workers have more promotion and the expectations in different industry and in the same industry. The reason is the stereotype of traditional sex roles that making female worker in female centralized industry, and effecting employer making decision about promotion. Therefore, the further research may examine how the process of selecting employees to be promotion is influenced by the stereotype, and collecting promotion data about employees.

1. Aldrich, H. J.,Nelson, D. F.(1984).Linear Probility, Logit, and Probit Models.Sage Publication.
2. Altonji, J. G.,Spletzer, J. R.(1991).Worker Characteristics, Job Characteristics and the Receipt of On-the-job Training.Industrial & Labor Relations Review,45(1),58-79.
3. Barron, J. M.,Berger, M. C.,Black, D. A.(1997).On-the-job Training.Kalamazoo, Michigan:W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
4. Becker, G. S.(1975).Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis with Special Reference to Education.New York:National Bureau of Economics Research.
5. Becker, G. S.(1964).Human Capital.New York:National Bureau of Economics Research.
6. Beere, C. A.(1990).Gender Roles-A Handbook of Tests and Measures.Greenwood Press, ING.
7. Bielby, D. D.(1992).Commitment to Work and Family.Annual Review of Sociology,18,281-302.
8. Blau, F. D.(1984).Sex Segregation in the Workplace.Washington D. C.:National Academy.
9. Blau, F. D.,Ferber, M. A.(1992).The Economics of Women, Men and Work.New Jersey:Prentice-Hall.
10. Corcoran, M.,Duncan, G. J.(1979).Work History, Labor Force Attachment, and Earnings Differences Between the Races and Sexes.Journal of Human Resources,14,3-20.
11. Dex, S.(1987).Women's Occupational Mobility－A Lifetime Perspective.New York:St. Martin's Press.
12. Duncan, G. J.,Hoffman, S.(1979).The Review pf Economics and Statistics.
13. Evertsson, M.(2004).European Sociological Review.
14. Fox, J.(1984).Linear Statistical Models & Related Methods－with Applications to Social Research.John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
15. Gronau, R.(1988).Sex-related Wage Differentrials and Women's Interrupted Labor Careers-the Chicken or the Egg.Journal of Labor Economics,6,277-301.
16. Handson, R.,Kaufman, R. L.(1982).Economic Dualism: A Review.American Sociological Review,47,727-739.
17. Kanter, R. M.(1977).Men and Women of the Corporation.New York:Basic Book.
18. Knoke, D.,Ishio, Y.(1998).The Gender Gap in Company Job Training.Work and Occupations,25,141-167.
19. Lloyd, C. B.,Niemi, B. T.(1979).The Economics of Sex Differencials.New York:Columbia University Press.
20. Lynch, L. M.(1992).Private-Sector Training and the Earnings of Young Workers.American Economic Review,82(1),299-312.
21. Mincer, J.,Polachek, S.(1974).Family Investments in Human Capital: Earnings of Women.Journal of Political Economy,17(1),3-24.
22. Moen, P.(1986).Women at Work: Commitment and Behavior over the Life course.Sociological Forum,1,50-75.
23. Olsen, R. N.,Sexton, E. A.(1996).Gender Differences in the Returns to and the Acquisition of On-the-Job Training.Industrail Relations,35,59-77.
24. Phelps, E. S.(1972).The Statistical Theory of Racism and Sexism.American Economic Review,62(4),659-661.
25. Roos, A. P.,Reskin, B. F.(1984).Sex Segregation in the Workplace.Washington D. C.:National Academy.
26. Rosenbaum, J. E.(1979).Organizational Career Mobility: Promotion Chances in a Corporation during Period of Growth and Contraction.American Journal of Sociology,85,21-84.
27. Rosenfeld, R. A.(1980).Race and Sex Differences in Career Dynamics.American Sociological Review,45,583-609.
28. Sorensen, A. B.(1975).The Structure of Intragenerational Mobility.American Sociological Review,40,456-471.
29. Spilerman, S.,Lunde, T.(1991).Features of Educational Attainment and Job Promotion Prospects.American Journal of Sociology,97(3),689-720.
30. Veum, J. R.(1993).Training among Young Adults: Who, What Kind, and for How Long?.Monthly Labor Review,116(8),27-32.
31. Wholey, D. R.(1990).The Effects of Formal and Informal Training on Tenure and Mobility in Manufacturing Firms.The Sociological Quarterly,31,37-57.
32. 王叢桂、羅國英(1992)。社會研究的資料處理。黎明文化。
33. 呂玉瑕(1980)。社會變遷中台灣婦女之事業觀。中央研究院民族學研究所集刊，50，25-66。
34. 呂寶靜(1989)。從婦女就業狀況談政府應有之政策。社區發展季刊
35. 李沛良(1992)。社會研究的統計分析。台北:巨流。
36. 李宗勳(1996)。性別對文官升遷、俸給之影響。人事月刊，22(5)，68-75。
37. 李金泉(1994)。SPSS/PC＋實務與應用統計分析。台北:松崗。
38. 李惠明(2002)。談公務人員升遷。公務人員月刊，73，2-3。
39. 林忠正(1993)。影響女性進入勞動市場不利因素之評估。勞工行政，63，16-20。
40. 林清山(1992)。心理與教育統計學。台北:東華。
41. 邱華君(1995)。公務人員升遷制度之研究。人事月刊，21(6)，56-65。
42. 施教讚(1970)。公務人員陞遷問題之研究。政治大學公共行政研究所。
43. 張苙雲(1988)。行政組織內個人事業生涯發展。中央研究院民族學研究所集刊，66，1-30。
44. 張晉芬(1991)。企業組織中升遷機會的決定及員工的期望：兼論內部勞動市場理論的應用。人文及社會科學集刊，6(1)，205-230。
45. 許嘉猷(1992)。社會階層化與社會流動。台北:三民。
46. 陳宇嘉、鄧明賢(1991)。性別與社會工作員地位取得。社會工作學刊，1，147-165。
47. 黃煥榮(2000)。組織中玻璃天花板效應之研究：行政院部會機關女性陞遷之實證分析。政治大學公共行政研究所。
48. 蔡秀涓(1998)。我國政府部門升遷現象之研究：從組織政治觀點分析。政治大學公共行政研究所。
49. 蔡淑鈴(1987)。職業隔離現象與教育成就：性別之比較研究。中國社會學刊，11，61-91。
50. 蕭鈺(1993)。從各國文官陞遷制度看我國公務人員陞遷制度之改革方向。人事行政，105，18-37。
51. 羅開仁(2002)。如何建立健全陞遷制度，以拔擢優秀人才之研究。人事行政，135