雁行理論的研究軌跡：兼為雁行理論駁誤

A Delineation of the Research Trajectory of the Flying Geese Theory and Some Responses to Critics

10.6431/TWJHSS.200612.0115

王佳煌(Chia-Huang Wang)

雁行理論 ； 外人直接投資 ； 顯示性比較優勢 ； 政治經濟 ； 學術審查或同儕審查 ； Flying Geese Theory ； Foreign Direct Investment FDI ； Revealed Comparative Advantage RCA ； Political Economy ； Peer Review

思與言：人文與社會科學期刊

44卷4期（2006 / 12 / 01）

115 - 152

繁體中文

本文說明國內外雁行理論的研究軌跡，兼為雁行理論駁誤。國外雁行理論的研究論著所在多有，國內部分學者與批評者卻始終有諸多誤解與扭曲，導致國內缺乏雁行理論的研究與論辯空間。本文擬藉由國內外雁行研究論著軌跡的勾勒，指出國內批評者的盲點與局限。本文首先再次簡介赤松要古典雁行理論的內涵與命題，介紹當代雁行理論研究的焦點與趨勢。其次針對筆者遭遇的審查意見與評論，提出澄清與反駁，強調外人直接投資與貿易指數分析在雁行研究中的重要性。結論部分摘述本文重點，並提出改進國內學術審查制度的建議，以期拋磚引玉，共同思考如何建構更完善的學術審查制度與環境。

This research note describes the research trajectory of the flying geese theory and refutes the critiques made by some academic reviewers. The paper introduces the classic version of the theory, delineates contemporary studies and debates revolving around the theory, as well as reveals the distortions and biases emerging from the critiques of some Taiwanese academic reviewers. The paper argues that, in Taiwan, the institutional practice of peer review is problematic and needs radical reforms.

1. 王佳煌(2004)。雁行理論與日本的東亞經驗。問題與研究，43(1)，1-31。
   連結：
2. 王佳煌(2001)。評「知識經濟」一兼論臺灣的國家發展策略。台灣社會研究季刊，44，201-241。
   連結：
3. 金榮勇(1998)。東南亞金融風暴的起因、影響與展望。問題與研究，37(1)，1-14+73。
   連結：
4. Akamatsu,Kaname(1962).A Historical Pattern of Economic Growth in Developing Countries.The Developing Economies,1(1),3-25.
5. Akamatsu,Kaname(1961).A Theory of Unbalanced Growth in the World Economy.Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,86,196-215.
6. Bernard,Mitchell(1996).Regions in the Global Political Economy: Beyond the Local-Global Divide in the Formation of the Eastern Asian Region.New Political Economy,1(3),335-53.
7. Bernard,Mitchell,John Ravenhill(1995).Beyond Product Cycles and Flying Geese--Regionalization, Hierarchy, and the Industrialization of East Asia.World Politics,47(2),171-209.
8. Blomqvist,Hans C.(1996).The `Flying Geese` Model of Regional Development: A Constructive Interpretation.Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy,1(2),215-231.
9. Burkett,Paul,Martin Hart-Landsberg(2000).Alternative Perspectives on Late Industrialization in East Asia: A Critical Survey.Review of Radical Political Economies,32(2),222-264.
10. Burkett,Paul,Martin Hart-Landsberg(2000).Development, Crisis, and Class Struggle: Learning from Japan and East Asia
11. Cai, Kevin(1999).The Political Economy of Economic Regionalism in Northeast Asia: A Unique and Dynamic Pattern.East Asia,17(2),6-46.
12. Carolan, T.,N. Singh N.,C. Talati(1998).The Composition of U. S.-East Asia Trade and Changing Comparative Advantage.Journal of Development Economics,57(2),361-389.
13. Cutler, H.,D. J. Bern,T. Ozawa(2003).Market Recycling in Labor-Intensive Goods, Flying Geese Style: An Empirical Analysis of East Asian Exports to the U. S..Journal of Asian Economics,14(1),35-50.
14. Das, Dilip K.(1996).The Asia-Pacific Economy
15. Defraigne, J. C.(2005).The Prospects of Chinese Firms in an Opening Economy: Breaking Away from the `Flying Geese` Pattern or Turn into Another Case of East Asian Ersatz Capitalism?.Belgeo,3,275-306.
16. Dowling, Malcolm,Chia Tien Cheang(2000).Shifting Comparative Advantage in Asia: New Tests of the `Flying Geese` Model.Journal of Asian Economics,11(4),443-463.
17. Edgington, David W.,Roger Hayter(2000).Foreign Direct Investment and the Flying Geese Model: Japanese Electronics Firms in Asia-Pacific.Environment & Planning A,32(2),281-304.
18. Erturk, Korkut A.(2001).Overcapacity and the East Asian Crisis.Journals of Post Keynesian Economics,24(2),253-275.
19. Filippini,Carlo(2004).Volano ancora le anatre? Appunti sullo sviluppo dell` Asia.Are the Geese Still Flying? Notes on the East Asian Development Process.” L` Industria, Nuova Serie,25(1),7-32.
20. Fujita, Kuniko,Richard Child Hill(1997).Auto Industrialization in Southeast Asia: National Strategies and Local Development.ASEAN Economic Bulletin,13(3),312-33.
21. Fujita, Masahisa,Tomoya Mori(1998).On the Dynamics of Frontier Economies: Endogenous Growth or the Self-Organization of a Dissipative System.The Annals of Regional Science,32(1),39-62.
22. Ginzburg, Andrea,Annamaria Simonazzi(2005).Patterns of Industrialization and the Flying Geese Model: The Case of Electronics in East Asia.Journal of Asian Economics,15(6),1051-1078.
23. Gore,Charles(1996).Methodological Nationalism and the Misunderstanding of East Asian Industrialisation.European Journal of Development Research,8(1),77-122.
24. Hart-Landsberg, Martin,Paul Burkett(1998).Contradictions of Capitalist Industrialization in East Asia: A Critique of `Flying Geese` Theories of Development.Economic Geography,74(2),87-110.
25. Hatch, Walter,Kozo Yamamura(1996).Asia in Japan`s Embrace--Building a Regional Production Alliance
26. Hiley,Mark(1999).The Dynamics of Changing Comparative Advantage in the Asia-Pacific Region.Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy,43(3),446-447.
27. Hill, Child Richard,Kuniko Fujita(1995).Product Cycles and International Divisions of Labor: Contrasts between the United States and Japan.A New World Order?--Global Transformations in the Late Twentieth Century,91-108.
28. Hill, Richard Child,Kuniko Fujita(1996).Economic Governance & Flexible Production: Matsushita in Southeast Asia.Paper presented at the Workshop on Economic Governance & Flexible Production in East Asia
29. Hill, Richard Child,Kuniko Fujita(1996).Flying Geese, Swarming Sparrows or Preying Hawks? Perspectives on East Asian Industrialization.Competition and Change--The Journal of Global Business and Political Economy,1(3),285-97.
30. Hill, Richard,Yong-Joo Lee(1994).Japanese Multinationals and East Asian Development--The Case of the Automobile Industry.Capitalism and Development,289-315.
31. Hobday,Mike(1995).Innovation in East Asia: Diversity and Development.Technovation,15(2),55-63.
32. Kalotay,Kalman(2004).The European Flying Geese: New FDI Patterns for the Old Continent.Research in International Business and Finance,18,27-49.
33. Kettunen, E.,K. Korhonen(1996).East and Southeast Asia`s Growing Economies: Will International Trade and Investments Lead Towards Regionalism.Terra,108(4),233-243.
34. Kiminami, Lily Y.,Akira Kiminami(1999).Intra-Asia Trade and Foreign Direct Investment.Papers in Regional Science,78(3),229-242.
35. Kojima,Kiyoshi(2000).The `Flying Geese` Model of Asian Economic Development: Origin, Theoretical Extensions, and Regional Policy Implications.Journal of Asian Economics,11(4),375-401.
36. Korhonen,Pekka(1994).The Theory of Flying Geese Pattern of Development and Its Interpretations.Journal of Peace Research,31(1),93-108.
37. Kosai, Yutaka,Tran Van Tho(1994).Japan and Industrialization in Asia: An Essay in Memory of Dr. Saburo Okita.Journal of Asian Economics,5(2),155-176.
38. Kwan, Chi Hung(1994).Economic Interdependence in the Asia-Pacific Region--Towards a Yen Bloc
39. Linden, G.,J. Hart,S. A. Lenway,T. P. Murtha(1998).Flying Geese as Moving Targets: Are Korea and Taiwan Catching up with Japan in Advanced Display.Industry and Innovation,5(1),32-34.
40. Lloyd, P. J.(1996).The Role of Foreign Investment in the Success of Asian Industrialization.Journal of Asian Economics,7(3),407-433.
41. Masina,Pietro(2002).Vietnam and the Regional Crisis: The Case of a `Late Late-Corner.`.European Journal of East Asian Studies,1(2),199-220.
42. Matsuyama,Kiminori(2002).The Rise of Mass Consumption Societies.Journal of Political Economy,110(5),1035-1070.
43. Mortimore,Michael(1993).Flying Geese or Sitting Ducks? Transnationals and Industry in Developing Countries.CEPAL Review,51,15-34.
44. Mortimore,Michael(1995).Transforming Sitting Ducks into Flying Geese: the Mexican Automobile Industry.
45. Ozawa,Terutomo(1999).Pacific Economic Integration and the `Flying Geese` Paradigm.Deepening Integration in the Pacific Economies,55-91.
46. Ozawa,Terutomo(2001).The Internet Revolution, Networking, and the ‘Flying Geese’ Paradigm of Structural Upgrading.Global Economic Quarterly,2(1),1-18.
47. Ozawa,Terutomo(2003).Pax American-Led Macro-Clustering and Flying-Geese-Style Catch-up in East Asia: Mechanisms of Regionalized Endogenous Growth.Journal of Asian Economics,13(6),699-713.
48. Ozawa,Terutomo(2000).The `Flying-Geese` Paradigm: Toward a Co-evolutionary Theory of MNC-Assisted Growth.The New World Order: Internationalism, Regionalism and the Multinational Corporations,209-223.
49. Ozawa,Terutomo(2001).The `Hidden` Side of the `Flying Geese` Catch-up Model: Japan`s dirigiste Institutional Setup and a Deepening Financial Morass.Journal of Asian Economics,12(4),471-491.
50. Peng,Dajin(2002).Invisible Linkages: A Regional Perspective of East Asian Political Economy.International Studies Quarterly,46(3),423-447.
51. Rana,Pradumna B.(1990).Shifting Comparative Advantage among Asian and Pacific Countries.The International Trade Journal,4(3),243-258.
52. Rasiah,Rajah(2000).Globalization and Private Capital Movements.Third World Quarterly,21(6),943-961.
53. Ray,Pradeep Kanta,Masahiro Ida,Chung-Sok Suh,Shams-Ur Rhaman(2004).Dynamic Capabilities of Japanese and Korean Enterprises and the `Flying Geese` of International Competitiveness.Asia Pacific Business Review,10(3/4),463-484.
54. Reynolds,Christopher(2001).A Conceptual Model of Global Business Growth in Southeast Asia.Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy,6(1),76-98.
55. Rose,Andrew(1997).Dynamic Measures of Competitiveness: Are the Geese Still Flying in Formation.FRBSF Economic Letter,97(17),1-3.
56. Shinohara,Miyohei(1996).The Flying Geese Model Revisited: Foreign Direct Investment, Trade in Machinery and the `Boomerang Effect`.Journal of the Asian Pacific Economy,1(3),411-419.
57. Shrank, A.(2003).Foreign Investors, `Flying Geese,` and the Limits to Export-led Industrialization in the Dominican Republic.Theory and Society,32(4),415-443.
58. Sikorski,Douglas,Thomas Menkhoff(2000).Internationlalisation of Asian Business.Singapore Management Review,22(1),1-17.
59. Terry,Edith,(1996).An East Asian Paradigm.Atlantic Economic Journal,24(3),183-198.
60. Tsui-Auch,Lai-Si(1999).Regional Production Relationships and Developmental Impacts: A Comparative Study of Three Production Networks.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,6(1),345-359.
61. Tung, An-Chi(2003).Beyond Flying Geese: The Expansion of East Asia`s Electronic Trade.German Economic Review,4(1),35-51.
62. Yamazawa,Ippei(1990).Economic Development and International Trade: The Japanese Model
63. Yamazawa,Ippei(1993).Trade Policy Issues in the Asian-Pacific Region: The Case of the Textile and Clothing Industry.Asian-Pacific Economic Literature,7(1),1-8.
64. Yao, S. C.,J. Chou,S. L. Peng,M. M. Tretyakov(2005).An Analysis on the Development of Taiwan`s Textile Industry Using Flying Geese Model and Ladder Model.Taiwan Textile Research Journal,15(2),9-16.
65. 小島清(2002)。雁行型経濟発展の國際的伝播（下）。駿河台經濟論集，11(2)，1-35。
66. 小島清(2003)。雁行型經濟發展論
67. 小島清(2001)。雁行型経濟発展の國際的伝播（上）。駿河台經濟論集，11(1)，19-45。
68. 五味紀男(2000)。電氣輭業に見るアジアの棲み分けと競爭。輭業学会年報，16，127-142。
69. 任燿廷(2005)。從競爭力結構看日本與東亞國家的經濟發展關係（下）。臺灣經濟金融月刊，41(11)，86-109。
70. 任燿廷(2005)。臺灣、中國、日本與美國間的「層疊J追趕－從RCA結構的觀察。臺灣銀行季刊，56(4)，102-138。
71. 任燿廷(2005)。兩岸與日美經濟競爭力結構的演變(1980-2002)。臺灣經濟金融月刊，41(7)，47-66。
72. 任燿廷(2005)。從競爭力結構看日本與東亞國家的經濟發展關係（上）。臺灣經濟金融月刊，41(10)，47-66。
73. 朱雲鵬｜王旭堂｜王塗發｜李秉正｜周濟｜林師模｜徐世勳｜廖如敏(1999)。關於雁行理論的一個檢視：GTAP資料應用於東亞貿易與產業結構變遷之研究。台灣經濟學會年會」學術研討會
74. 朱雲鵬｜吳進泰(2000)。知識經濟時代的傳統產業提昇。知識經濟之路
75. 朱雲鵬｜林美萱(2002)。雁行理論是否仍適用於東亞發展。國家政策論壇，2(3)，162-170。
76. 吳進泰(2001)。兩岸產業國際競爭力消長：以雁行理論說明。台灣經濟研究月刊，24(5)，91-97。
77. 陳明訓(2003)。從雁行理論看東南亞經濟發展。2003台灣的東南亞區域研究年度研討會
78. 董安琪(2003)。台灣的電子業貿易與「雁行型態」經濟發展。思與言，41(3)，1-30。
79. 董安琪(2003)。雁行型態的極限：東亞的紡織與電子出口。國科會補助專題研究計畫，計畫編號NSC91-2415-H-001-023
80. 蔡宏政(2004)。臺灣人口移入的區域政治經濟學分析。全球政治評論，7，111-130。
81. 蔡東杰(2004)。東亞雁行結構的調整與變遷。全球政治評論，7，1-18。
82. 瞿宛文(2003)。全球化下的台灣經濟

1. 黃財源,江和華(2016)。雁行理論之限制與後雁行時代。弘光學報，77，81-91。
2. 江和華(2015)。東亞雁行理論與兩岸經濟發展。東亞論壇，489，61-72。
3. 江和華(2016)。台灣經濟奇蹟之詮釋架構：雁行理論。東亞論壇，491，53-64。
4. 林香吟、江和華(2014)。東亞區域經濟整合與雁行理論：台灣經濟發展之展望。東亞論壇，486，67-78。
5. 謝宏仁、劉書羽、辛年豐(2012)。從中國山寨手機產業看「發展型國家理論」之中央與地方政府關係。東亞研究，43(2)，59-100。
6. 徐慧鈺,林廣一,沈雅文(2019)。清代臺灣竹枝詞的風華再現與通識人文教育之落實。通識教育學刊，23，39-77。