傅柯倫理學中自我與他者之關係

The Self's Relations with Others in Foucault's Ethics

李俊增(Chiun-Zeng Lee)

傅柯 ； 生存美學 ； 自我實踐 ； 自由實踐 ； Foucault ； aesthetics of existence ； practice of the self ； practice of liberty

思與言：人文與社會科學期刊

53卷1期（2015 / 03 / 01）

109 - 150

繁體中文

傅柯（Michel Foucault）晚期著作經常被批判為自戀式的倫理個人主義，忽略了自我與他者之社會關係在自我構成、自我創造中扮演之關鍵角色。論者並批判認為其存在美學之立場與決斷主義緊密相連，而成為一種美學決斷主義。本文嘗試批判這些論點，並指出傅柯不曾漠視自我形成過程中與他者之互動關係此一重要面向。反之，傅柯倫理學中對於他者之關注或自我與他者之關係即蘊含於關注自我而呈現一體兩面。不僅如此，倫理學中並抱持美學以外之一定的價值立場，他明白指出最低限度宰制係倫理關懷之關鍵要務；對於不均衡、不可逆轉之宰制關係作出「真正難以忍受」的評價。從另一角度言之，這意味傅柯強調自我與他者之關係至少必須是可逆轉之頡頏關係：「一種同時相互激發與鬥爭的關係」。

Some critics tend to interprete later Foucault as some sort of proponent of anonymous individuality or narcissism. An awareness of the formation of the self through social interaction is absent from Foucault's later work. It has been argued also that the primacy of aestheticist implications translates into a normative stance in which descisionistic tendencies gain the upper hand. This paper tries to criticize such interpretations and argues that Foucault does not neglect the importance of the self's relations with others in the constitution of the self. Further, Foucault also recognizes that the relation between subjects needs to take the form of a reciprocity adapted, in light of the universiality of power, into a form of ＂agonism＂: the relationship which is at the same time reciprocal incitation and struggle.

1. 何乏筆(2010)。從權力技術到美學修養：關於傅柯理論發展的反思。哲學與文化，37(3)，85-102。
   連結：
2. Ashenden, Samantha(Ed.),Dwen, David(Ed.)(1999).Foucault Contra Habermas: Recasting the Dialogue between Genealogy and Critical Theory.London:SAGE Publications..
3. Bernauer, James(Ed.),Rasmussen, David(Ed.)(1988).The Final Foucault.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
4. Burchell, Graham(Ed.),Gordon, Colin(Ed.),Miller, Peter(Ed.)(1991).The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality.New York:Harvester Wheatsheaf.
5. Dreyfus, Hubert(ed.),Rabinow, Paul(ed.)(1982).Michael Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics.Brighton:Harvester.
6. Dumm, Thomas L.(1996).Michel Foucault and the Politics of Freedom.London:SAGE Pubications.
7. Foucault, Michel(1977).Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
8. Foucault, Michel(1988).Technologies of the Self: a Seminar with Michel Foucault.London:Tavistock Pbulications.
9. Foucault, Michel(1985).The History of Sexuality, Volume 2: The Use of Pleasure.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
10. Foucault, Michel(1984).The Foucault Reader.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
11. Foucault, Michel(1980).Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972-1977.New York:Harvester Wheatsheaf.
12. Foucault, Michel(1989).Foucault Live: Collected Interviews, 1961-1984.New York:Semiotext(e).
13. Foucault, Michel(1988).Politics, Philosophy, Culture: Interviews and Other Writings 1977-1984.London:Routledge.
14. Foucault, Michel(1972).The Archaeology of Knowledge.New York:Pantheon Books.
15. Foucault, Michel(1994).Ethics: Subjectivity and Truth.New York:The New Press.
16. Foucault, Michel(1988).The Final Foucault.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
17. Fraser, Nancy(1981).Foucault on Modern Power: Empirical Insight and Normative Confusions.Praxis International,3,272-287.
18. Gutting, Gary(Ed.)(1994).The Cambridge Campanion to Foucault.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
19. Gutting, Gary(Ed.)(1994).The Cambridge Campanion to Foucaul.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
20. Habermas, Jürgen,Lawrence, F.(trans.)(1987).The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
21. Hadot, Pierre(1992).Reflections on the Notion of the Cultivaton of the Self.Michel Foucault: Philosopher,New York:
22. Hooke, Alexander E.(1987).The Order of Others: Is Foucault's Antihumanism against Human Action?.Political Theory,15(1),38-60.
23. Hoy, David Couzens(Ed.)(1989).Foucanlt: A Critical Reader.Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
24. Kelly, Michael (Ed.)(1994).Critique and Power: Recasting the Foucault/Habermas Debate.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
25. McCarthy, Thomas(Ed.)(1991).Ideas and Illusions: On Reconstruction and Deconstruction in Contemporary Critical Theory.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
26. McNay, Lois(1994).Foucault: A Critical Introduction.Cambridge:Polity.
27. Moss, Jeremy(Ed.)(1998).The Later Foucault: Politics and Philosophy.London:SAGE Publications.
28. Pickett, Brent(2005).On the Use and Abuse of Foucault for Politics.New York:Lexington Books.
29. Prozorov, Sergei(2007).Foucault, Freedom and Sovereignty.Hampshire:ASHGATE.
30. Rabinow, Paul(Ed.)(1997).Ethics: Subjectivity and Truth.New York:The New Press.
31. Rochlitz, Rainer(1992).The Aesthetics of Existence: Post-Conventional Morality and the Theory of Power in Michel Foucault.Michel Foucault: Philosopher,New York:
32. Simons, Jon(1991).From Resistance to Polaesthics: Politics after Foucault.Philosophy and Social Criticism,18(1),41-55.
33. White, Stephen(1986).Foucault's Challenge to Critical Theory.American Political Science Review,80(2),419-432.
34. Wolin, Richard(1986).Foucault's Aesthetic Decisionism.Telos,67,71-86.
35. 高宣揚(2004)。傅柯的生存美學：西方思想的起點與終點。臺北:五南。
36. 黃瑞褀編(2003)。後學新論：後現代／後結構／後殖民。臺北:左岸。
37. 楊凱麟(2004)。自我的去作品化：主體性與問題化場域的傅柯難題。中山人文學報，18，29-47。

1. (2023)。從「鏡像」看台灣學界的中國外交研究。東亞研究，54(1)，77-116。