题名

科學鑑定證據憑信性之探討－以DNA鑑定證據為例

并列篇名

A Study of the Reliability of Forensic Science Evidence-Forensic DNA Evidence as an Example

DOI

10.6416/SLR.201004.0207

作者

施俊堯(Chun-Yao Shih)；徐健民(Chien-Min Hsu)

关键词

科學鑑定證據 ； 證據許容性 ； 證據憑信性 ； 證據調查 ； 證據判斷 ； 經驗法則 ； 論理法則 ； DNA鑑定證據 ； 聚合酶連鎖反應 ； 短串連重複序列 ； Forensic Science Evidence ； Admissibility of Evidence ； Reliability of evidence ； Investigation of Evidence ； Evaluation of Evidence ； logical Rule ； Experience Rule ； Forensic DNA Evidence ； Polymerase Chain Reaction PCR ； Short Tandem Repeats STR

期刊名称

東吳法律學報

卷期/出版年月

21卷4期（2010 / 04 / 01）

页次

207 - 274

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

認定犯罪事實必須依據證據。近年來各類科學鑑定證據逐漸被法院認為具備許容性用於認定犯罪事實，因此審查科學鑑定證據憑信性成為必須注意之重點。本文分析科學鑑定證據在實務運用情形，以及對於科學鑑定證據憑信性之調查與判斷。並以DNA鑑定證據為例，說明科學鑑定證據許容性與憑信性，解釋法院有審查科學鑑定證據許容性與憑信性之職責，且以一百零二位法律系學生對DNA基本知識與鑑定報告講解前後之認知理解問卷，運用Ttest統計分析，得知講解前後十個問題中有九個有顯著差異，結論之一為法學教育提供鑑定基本知識供日後審查科學鑑定證據憑信性之用，相當重要。
英文摘要

Conviction of crime based upon evidence. Over recent years, forensic science evidence has become gradually admissible by the Courts and used for conviction. Thus evaluating the reliability of forensic science has become very important. The study analyzed the use of forensic science evidence in Courts and discussed the investigation and evaluation method used to decide the reliability of forensic science evidence. DNA evidence was used as an example to discuss the method of evaluating the reliability. The role of the Court is important as they act as a gatekeeper for evaluating the admissibility and reliablity of forensic science evidence which was also discussed. The study looked at the effects of explaining essential DNA knowledge and DNA test reports. One hundred and two law students were subjects and were explained DNA knowledge. A t-test was used to test the significance of the results which showed that post-DNA explanation, students showed a significant improvement on nine out of ten questions. One of the conclusions was the providing basic forensic knowledge in law education is important in the future.
主题分类 社會科學 > 法律學
参考文献
  1. http://einshac.org/index.html, 02/06/2009.
  2. http://njirs.judicial.gov.tw/Index.htm，司法院網頁，98 年5 月24 日。
  3. http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/home.shtml, 25/05/2009.
  4. http://njirs.judicial.gov.tw/fjud/index_3.aspx，司法院網頁，2009 年4 月12 日。
  5. http://www.scu.edu.tw/forensic/，2009 年4 月19 日，東吳大學理學院鑑識科學學程網頁。
  6. http://www.judicial.gov.tw/juds/index1.htm，司法院統計網頁，2009 年4 月17 日。
  7. Abbott, H. Porter(2002).The Cambridge introduction to narrative.Cambridge University Press.
  8. Adler, Joanna R.(2004).Forensic psychology: Concepts, debates and practice.Willan.
  9. ahilton, Orduay(1993).Scientific Examination of Questioned Documents Revised Edition.CRC Press.
  10. Aitken, C. G. G.,Alan, David(1991).The Use of Statistics in Forensic Science.Ellis Horwood Ltd..
  11. Aitken, C.G.G.,Taroni, F.(2004).Statistics and the evaluation of evidence for forensics scientists.John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
  12. Amaratunga, D.,Cabrera, J.(2001).Analysis of Data From Viral DNA Microchips.Journal of the American Statistical Association,96,1161-1170.
  13. Andrade, L.,Bento, A.M.,Serra, A.,Carvalho, M.,Gamero, J.J.,Oliverira, C.,Batista, L.,Lopes, F.,Balsa, F.,Coete-Real, F.,Anjos, M.J.(2008).AmpFlSTR® MiniFilerTM PCR amplification kit: The new miniSTR multiplex kit.Forensic Science International,89-91.
  14. Andreassi, John L.(2006).Psychophysiology : Human Behavior and Physiological Response.Psychology Press.
  15. Ayoob, Massad(2007).The Gun Digest Book of Combat Handgunnery.Gun Digest Books.
  16. Balažic, Jože,Zupanič, Irena(1999).Quality control and quality assurance in DNA laboratories: legal, civil and ethical aspects.Forensic Science International,103(1),1-5.
  17. Balding, David J.(2005).Weight of evidence for forensic DNA profiles, statistics in practice.wiley Press.
  18. Beecher-Monas, Erica(2007).Evaluating scientific evidence: An Interdisciplinary Framework for Intellectual Due Process.Cambridge University Press.
  19. Benedict, Nathan(2004).Fingerprints and the Daubert Standard for Admission of Scientific Evidence: Why Fingerprints Fail and a Proposed Remedy.Arizona L. Rev.,46,519-541.
  20. Beveridge, Alexander(1998).Forensic Investigation of Explosions.Taylor & Francis CRC Press.
  21. Bianchi, Diana W.,Flint, Alan F.,Pizzimenti, Mary Frances,Knoll, Joan H. M.,Latt, Samue A.(1990).Isolation of fetal DNA from nucleated erythrocytes in maternal blood.Proc. Nati. Acad. Sci.,87,3279-3283.
  22. Blow, J. J.,Laskey, R.A.(1988).A role for the nuclear envrlope in controlling replication within the cell cycle,332(6164),546-548.
  23. Brown, Terence A.(2006).Gene cloning and DNA analysis: An Introduction Fifth edition.Blackwell.
  24. Buckleton, John S. ,Triggs, Christopher M.,Walsh, Simon J.(2005).Forensic DNA evidence interpretation.CRC Press.
  25. Burley, Justine,Harris, John(2002).A companion to genethics.Blackwell publishing.
  26. Butler, J. M.,Shen, Y.,McCord, B.R.(2003).The development of reduced size STR amplicons as tools for analysis of degraded DNA.Journal of forensic sciences,48(5),1054-1064.
  27. Butler, John Marshall(2001).Forensic DNA typing: Biology & Technology behind STR Markers.Academic Press.
  28. Caddy, B.(2000).Educating and training the forensic practitioner for the new millennium.Science & Justice,40(2),143-146.
  29. Cavoukian, Ann,Heslegrave, Ronald J.(1980).The admissibility of polygraph evidence in court.Law and Human Behavior,4(1-2),117-131.
  30. Christian, Karen(2001)."And the DNA Shall Set you Free": Issues Surrounding Post-conviction DNA Evidence and the Pursuit of Innocence.Ohio St. L.J.,62,1195-1241.
  31. Clark, David P.(2005).Molecular biology: Understanding the Genetic Revolution.Academic Press.
  32. Cole, Simon A.(2008).Out of the Daubert fire and into the Fryeing pan? self-validation, meta-expertise and the admissibility of latent print evidence in Frye Jurisdictions.Minn. J. L. Sci. & Tech.,9(2),453-542.
  33. Committee on DNA Forensic Science: An Update, National Research Council(1996).The Evaluation of Forensic DNA Evidence.The National Academies Press.
  34. Cook,Victoria J., Turenne, Christine Y.,Wolfe, Joyce,Pauls, Ryan,Kabani, Amin(2003).Conventional Methods versus 16S Ribosomal DNA Sequencing for Identification of Nontuberculous Mycobacteria: Cost Analysis.Journal of Clinical Microbiology,41(3),1010-1015.
  35. Cowell, Susan E.(2000).Pretrial Mediation of Complex Scientific Cases: A Proposal to Reduce Jury and Judicial Confusion.Chicago-Kent Law Review,75,981-1014.
  36. Coyle, Heather Miller(2004).Forensic botany: Principles and Applications to Criminal Casework.CRC Press.
  37. Dann, B. Michael,Hans, Valerie P.,Kaye, David H.(2007).Can jury trial innovations improve juror understanding of DNA evidence?.Judicature,90(4),152-156.
  38. Dix, Jay,Calaluce, Robert,Ernst, Mary Fran(1998).Guide to Forensic Pathology.CRC Press.
  39. Dudek, Ronald W.,Fix, James D.(2004).Embryology.Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
  40. Faigman, David L.(2002).Science and the Law: Is Science Different for Lawyers?.Science,297(5580),339-340.
  41. Findlay, Mark(2008).Juror comprehension and the hard case-Making forensic evidence simpler.International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice,36(1),15-53.
  42. Fisher, Barry A. J.(2004).Techniques of Crime Scene Investigation.CRC Press.
  43. Fisher, David R.,Fisher, Barry A. J.,Kolowski, Jason(2006).Forensics demystified: A Self-Teaching Guide.McGraw Hill.
  44. Fisher, U Barry A. J.,Leroy, D.(2003).Techniques of crime scene investigation.CRC press.
  45. Foster, K.R.,Huber, P.W.(1997).Judging science: Scientific knowledge and the federal courts.The MIT Press.
  46. Fung, Wing K.,Hu, Yue-Qing,Chung,Yuk-Ka(2006).On statistical analysis of forensic DNA: Theory, methods and computer programs.Forensic Science International,162(1-3),17-23.
  47. Fung, Wing Kam,Hu, Yue-Qing(2008).Statistical DNA Forensics: Thoery, Methods and Computation.Wiley.
  48. Giannelli, PC(1980).The admissibility of novel scientific evidence: Frye v. United States, a half-century later.Colum. L. Rev.,80,1223-1224.
  49. Girard, James(2007).Criminalistics: Forensic Science and Crime.Jones & Bartlett.
  50. Gjertson, David W.,Morris, Jeffrey W.(1995).Assessing probability of paternity and the product rule in DNA systems.Genetica,96(1-2),89-98.
  51. Gold, E. Richard(1999).Hope, Fear, and Genetics, Judicial responses to biotechnology.Judicature Genes and Justice, The Growing Impact of the New Genetics on the Courts,83(3),124.
  52. Goldstein, Alan M.,Weiner, Irving B.(2003).Handbook Of Psychology.John Wiley & Sons:Forensic Psychology.
  53. Goodwin, William,Linacre, Adrian(2007).An Introduction to Forensic Genetics.Wiley.
  54. Green, Bruce A.,Yaroshefsky, Ellen(2009).Prosecutorial Discretion and Post-Conviction Evidence of Innocence.Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law,6,467-516.
  55. Greene, Jack R.(2006).The encyclopedia of police science Third Edition.Routledge.
  56. Hammer, Rita M.,Moynihan, Barbara,Pagliaro, Elaine M.(2005).Forensic nursing: A Handbook for Practice.Jones & Bartlett Publishers.
  57. Hartl, Daniel L.,Jones, Elizabeth W.(2008).Genetics: Anaalysis of genes and genomes, seventh edition.
  58. Hawthorne, Mark R.(2008).Fingerprints: Analysis and Understanding.CRC Press.
  59. Henderson, J.P.(2002).The use of DNA statistics in criminal trials.Forensic Science International,128(3),183-186.
  60. Hoffmann, Diane E.,Rothenberg, Karen H.(2007).Judging Genes: Implications of the second generation of gentic tests in the courtroom.Maryland L. Rev.,858-922.
  61. Houck, Max M.(2003).Trace evidence analysis: More Cases in Mute Witnesses.Academic Press.
  62. Houck, Max M.(2007).Forensic science: Modern Methods of solving Crime.Praeger.
  63. Hoy, Marjorie A.(2003).Insect molecular genetics: An Introduction to Principles and Applications.Academic Press.
  64. Huber, Peter W(1993).Galileo's Revenge: Junk Science in the Courtroom.Basic Books.
  65. Huber, Peter,Foster, Kenneth(1999).Judging Science:Scientific Knowledge and the Federal Courts.MIT Press.
  66. Huber, Roy A.,Headriok, A. M.(1999).Handwriting Identification: Facts and Fundamentals.CRC Press.
  67. Hummel, Susanne(2003).Ancient DNA typing: Methods Strategies and Applications.Springer.
  68. James, Stauart H.(1999).Scientific and legal application of bloodstain pattern interpretation.CRC Press.
  69. James, Stuart H.,Eckert, William G.(1998).Interpretation of bloodstain evidence at crime scenes.CRC Press.
  70. James, Stuart H.,Erwin, Paul(2005).Principlesof bloodstain pattern analysis: Theory and Practic.CRC Press Taylor & Francis.
  71. James, Stuart H.,Nordby, Jon J.(2003).Forensic Science: an Introduction to Scientific and Investigative Techniques.CRC Press.
  72. Joh, Elizabeth E.(2006).Reclaiming "Abandoned" DNA: The Fourth Amendment and Genetic Privacy.Northwestern University L. Rev.,100(2),860-862.
  73. Kahn, Jonathan(2009).Race, Genes and Justice: A Call to Reform the Presentation of Forensic DNA Evidence in Criminalt Trials.Brooklyn L. Rev.,74(2),325-375.
  74. Kaye, D.H.(1995).The forensic debut of the NRC's DNA report: population structure, ceiling frequencies and the need for numbers.Genetica,99-105.
  75. Kaye, David H.(2008).The Role of Race in DNA Statistics: What Experts Say, What California Courts Allow.Southwestern University L. Rev.,37(2),304-322.
  76. Keer, Jacquie T.,Birch, Lyndsey(2008).Essentials of nucleic acid analysis : A Robust Approach, Royal Society of Chemistry.Royal Society.
  77. Kiely, Terrence F.(2005).Forensic evidence: Science and The Criminal Law Second Edition.CRC Press Taylor & Grancis.
  78. Koehler, J. J.(2002).When do courts think base rate statistics are relevant?.Jurimetrics Journal,42,373-402.
  79. Koehler, J. J.,Chia, A.,Lindsey, J. S.(1995).The random match probability (RMP) in DNA evidence: Irrelevant and prejudicial?.Jurimetrics Journal,35,201-219.
  80. Koehler, J. Jonathan(1996).On conveying the probative value of DNA evidence: Frequencies, likelihood ratios and error rates.University of Colorado L. Rev.,67,859-886.
  81. Koehler, Jonathan J.(1993).Error and exaggeration in the presentation of DNA evidence at trial.Jurimetrics Journal,34,21-39.
  82. Koehler, Jonathan J.(2001).When Are People Persuaded By DNA Match Statistics?.Law & Hum. Behav.,25(5),493-513.
  83. Kondo, LeRoy L.(2002).Untangling The Tangled Web: Federal Court Reform Through Specialization For Internet Law And Other High Technology Cases.UCLA J. L. & Tech.,1
  84. Koppenhaver, Katherine(2002).Attorney's guide to document examination.Quorum Books.
  85. Kreimer, Seth F.,Rudovsky, David(2002).Double Helix, Double Bind: Factual Innocence and Postconviction DNA Testing.U. Pa. L. Rev.,151,547-617.
  86. Lakowicz, Joseph R.,Geddes, Chris D.(2003).Topics in Fluorescence Spectroscopy: DNA technology.Kluwer Academic /Plenum.
  87. Lazer, David(2004).DNA and the criminal justice system: The Technology of Justice.The MIT Press.
  88. Lee, Henry C.,Gaensslen, R. E.(2001).Advances in Fingerprint Technology second sdition.CRC Press.
  89. Lee, Henry C.,Harris, Howard A.(2000).Physical Evidence in Forensic Science Second Edition.Lawyer & Judges Publishing Company, Inc..
  90. Lee, J.C.,Chen, C.H.,Tsai, L.C.,Linacre, A.,Chang, J.G.(1997).The screening of 13 short tandem repeat loci in the Chinese population.Forensic Science International,87(2),137-144.
  91. León, F. Puente(2006).Automated comparison of firearm bullets.Forensic Science International,156(1),40-50.
  92. Levinson, David(2002).Encyclopedia of Crime and Punishment Volume 1.Sage Publications, Inc..
  93. Li, B.,Gladden, A.D.,Altfeld, M.,Kaldor, J.M.,Cooper, D.A.(2007).Rapid Reversion of Sequence Polymorphisms Dominates Early HIV-1.Evolution J. Virol,81(1),193-201.
  94. Lincoln, Patrick J.,Thomson, Jim(1998).Forensic DNA profiling protocols.Humana Press.
  95. Matson, Jack V.,Daou, Suha F.,Soper, Jeffrey G.(2004).Effective expert witnessing Practices for the 21st Century Fourth Edition.CRC Press.
  96. McCartney, Carole(2006).Forensic identification and criminal justice.Willan.
  97. Mellon, Jennifer N.(2001).Manufacting convictions: Why defendants are entitled to the data underlying forensic DNA kits.Duke L. J.,51,1099-1113.
  98. Melton, Terry,Nelson, Kimberlyn(2001).Forensic Mitochondrial DNA Analysis: Two Years of Commercial Casework Experience in the United States.Croatian Medical Journal,42(3),298-303.
  99. Mendel, Gregor,Corcos, Alain F.,Monaghan, Floyd V.(1993).Gregor Mendel's Experiments on plant hybrids: A Guide Study.Rutgers University Press.
  100. Meyers, Robert A.(1995).Molecular Biology and Biotechnology: A Comprehensive Desk Reference.Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH.
  101. Mnookin, Jennifer L.(2001).The History of Handwriting Identification Evidence and the Judicial Construction of Reliability.Va. L. Rev.,87(8),1723-1845.
  102. Mnookin, Jennifer L.(2001).Fingerprint Evidence in an Age of DNA Profiling.Brook L. Rev.,67(1),14-71.
  103. Moore, Lisa Jean(1997).Sperm counts: Overcome by Man's most precious Fluid.New York:University Press.
  104. Mueller, Christopher B.,Kirkpatrick, Laird C.(1999).Evidence: Practice Under the Rules, Second Edition.Aspen Law & Business.
  105. Mueller, Laurence D.(1993).The Use of DNA Typing in Forensic Science.Accountability in Research,3,55-67.
  106. Mullis, K.B.(1990).Target amplification for DNA analysis by the polymerase chain reaction.Ann Biol Clin,48(8),579-82.
  107. Murray Kleiner(2002).Handbook of polygraph testing.Academic Press.
  108. Myers, Robert D., Reinstein, Ronald S.,Griller, Gordon M.(1999).Complex Scientific Evidence and the Jury.Judicature Genes and Justice, The Growing Impact of the New Genetics on the Courts,83(3),150.
  109. Nance, Dale A.,Morris, Scott B.(2005).Juror Understanding of DNA Evidence: An Empirical Assessment of Presentation Formats for Trace Evidence with a Relatively SmallRandom-Match Probability.The Journal of legal studies,34(2),395-444.
  110. Nerko, Charles J(2008).Assessing Fourth Amendment Challenges to DNA Extraction Statutes after Samson v. California.Fordham L. Rev.,77(2),917-948.
  111. Niessen, Wilfried M. A.(2006).Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry Third edition.Berlin:Springer.
  112. Olshaker, Jonathan S.,Jackson, M. Christine(2006).Forensic emergency medicine.Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
  113. Peitsch, M. C.,Polzar, B.,Stephan, H.,Crompton, T.,MacDonald, H. R.,Mannherz, H. G.,Tschopp, J.(1993).Characterization of the endogenous deoxyribonuclease involved in nuclear DNA degradation during apoptosis (programmed cell death).The EMBO Journal,12(1),371-377.
  114. Petkovski, E.,Kevser-Tracqui, C.,Hienne, R.,Ludes, B.(2005).SNPs and MALDI-TOF MS: tools for DNA typing in forensic paternity testing and anthropology.J Forensic Sci.,50(3),535-41.
  115. Plamondon, Réjean,Lorette, Guy(1989).Automatic signature verification and writer identification-the state of the art.Pattern Recognition,22(2),107-131.
  116. Podlas, Kimberlianne(2006)."The CSI Effect": Exposing the Media Myth.Fordham Intell.Prop. Media & Ent. L.J.,16,429-465.
  117. Price, Joseph M.,Rosenberg, Ellen S.(1998).The war against junk science: the use of expert panels in complex medical-legal scientific litigation.Biomaterials,19(16),1425-1432.
  118. Pu, C.E.,Wu, F.C.,Cheng, C.L.,Wu, K.C.,Chao, C.h.,LI, J.M.(1998).DNA short tandem repeat profiling of Chinese population in Taiwan determined by using an automated sequencer.Forensic Sci. Int.,97(1),47-51.
  119. Pu, Chang-En,Hsieh, Ching-Mei,Chen, Meng-Yi,Wu, Fang-Chin,Sun, Chien-Feng(1999).表單的頂端Genetic variation at nine STR loci in populations from the Philippines and Thailand living in Taiwan.Forensic Science International,106(1),1-6.
  120. Pye, Kenneth(2007).Geological and soil evidence Forensic Applications.CRC press.
  121. Pyrek, Kelly M.(2007).Forensic science under siege. The challenges of Forensic Laboratories and the Medico-Legal Investigation System.Academic Press.
  122. Rachlinski, Jeffrey J.(2000).Heuristics and Biases in the Courts: Ignorance or Adaptation?.Oregon L. Rev.,79(1),61-102.
  123. Ratha, N.K.,Karu, K.,Chen, Shaoyun,Jain, A.K,(1996).A real-time matching system for large fingerprint databases.IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,18(8),799-813.
  124. Redmayne, Mike(2001).Expert evidence and criminal justice.Oxford University Press.
  125. Reeder, Dennis J.(1999).Impact of DNA Typing on Standards and Practice in the Forensic Community.Archives of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine,123(11),1063-1065.
  126. Robertson, James ,Ross, A. M., Burgoyne, Leigh Alexander(1990).DNA in forensic science: thoery, techniques and applications.CRC Press.
  127. Ronald Huff, C.,Huff, Ronald,Killias, Martin,Killias, Martin(2008).Wrongful conviction: International perspectives on miscarriages of justice.Temple University Press.
  128. Rose, Philip(2003).Forensic Speaker Identification.Taylor & Francis Press.
  129. Rothstein, Mark A.(1999).The Impact of Behavioral Genetics on the Law and the Courts.Judicature,83(3),112.
  130. Rudin, Norah,Inman, Keith(2002).An introduction to forensic DNA analysis.CRC Press.
  131. Russ, John C.(2001).Forensic Uses of Digital Imaging.CRC Press.
  132. Saks, Michael J.(2003).The Legal and Scientific Evaluation of Forensic Science (Especially Fingerprint Expert Testimony).Seton Hall Law Review,33,115-1176.
  133. Sambrook, Joseph,Russell, David William(2001).Molecular cloning A Laboratory Manual.Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.
  134. Samocha-Bone, D.,Lewinl, L.M.,Weissenberg, R.,Madgar, Y.,Soffer, Y.,Shochat, L.,Golan, R.(1998).In-vitro human spermatozoa nuclear decondensation assessed byflow cytometry.Molecular Human Reproduction,4(2),133-137.
  135. Sandra, Hering, Ralf, Nixdorf,Jan, Dressler(2005).Identification of more sequence variations in the D8S1179 locus.Forensic science international,149(2-3),275-278.
  136. Semikhodskii, Andrei(2007).Dealing with DNA evidence: A legal Guide.Taylor & Francis.
  137. Singleton, Tommie,Singleton, Aaaron,Bologna, Jack,Lindquest, Robert(2006).Fraud auditing and forensic accounting.John Wiley & Sons, Inc..
  138. Sklar, Larry A.(2005).Flow cytometry for Biotechnology.Oxford University Press.
  139. Slesnick, Frank,Tinari, Frank D.(2001).Teaching Forensic Economics in the University Curriculum.Journal of Forensic Economics,14(3),243-260.
  140. Smejkal, Gary B.,Lazarev, Alexander(2006).Separation methods in proteomics.RC Taylor & Francis.
  141. Sombat, Jessica M.(2002).Daubert's impact on the evaluation of finger printidentification testimony.Fordham L. Rev.,70,2819-2868.
  142. Srihari, S.N.,Cha, S.H.,Arora, H.,Lee, S.(2002).Individuality of handwriting.J. Forensic Sci,856-72.
  143. Steiner, J. J.,Poklemba, C. J.,Fjellstrom, R. G. ,Elliott, L. F.(1995).A rapid one-tube genomic DNA extraction process for PCR and RAPD analyses.Nucl. Acids Res.,23,2569-2570.
  144. Steve, Hogan,,Swinton, Steve(2003).Meeting Defense Challenges to DNA Evidence.American Prosecutors Research Institute,8(1)
  145. Taroni, Franco,Aitken, Colin G. G.(2000).DNA evidence, probabilistic evaluation and collaborative tests.Forensic Science International,108(2),121-143.
  146. Taupin, J. M.(2004).Forensic hair morphology comparison-a dying art or junk science?.Science & Justice,44(2),95-100.
  147. The Justice Project Inc(2008).Improving the Practice and Use of Forensic Science A Policy Review.
  148. Thompson, William C.,Taroni, Franco,Aitken, Colin G. G.(2003).How the Probability of a False Positive Affects the Value of DNA Evidence.J Forensic Sci.,48(1),47-54.
  149. Trent, Ronald J.(2005).Molecular medicine.Academic Press.
  150. Turvey, Brent E.,Baeza, John J.(2002).Criminal profiling: An introduction to behavioral evidence analysis.Academic Press.
  151. U.S. Department of JusticeOffice of the Inspector General(2004).,未出版
  152. Vandesompele, J.,De Preter, K.,Pattyn, F.,Poppe, B.,Van Roy, N.,De Paepe, A.,Speleman, F.(2002).Accurate normalization of real-time quantitative RT-PCR data by geometric averaging of multiple internal control genes.Genome Biology,3(7),1-11.
  153. Vince, Joseph J.,Sherlock, William E.(2005).Evidence collection.Jones and Bartlett.
  154. Walker, Clive,Starmer, Keir(1999).Miscarriages of justice: A Review of Justice in Error.London:Blackstone Press.
  155. Walton, Richard H.(2006).Cold case homicides: practical investigative techniques.CRC Press.
  156. Wang, Sheng-Meng,Lin, Chih-Che,Li, Tien-Lai,Shih, Chun-Yao,Giang, Yun-Seng,Liu, Ray H.(2006).Distribution characteristics of methamphetamine and amphetamine in urine and hair specimens collected from alleged methamphetamine users in northern Taiwan.Analytica Chimica Acta,576(1),140-146.
  157. Wecht, Cyril H.,Rago, John T.(2006).Forensic science and law: Investigative Applications in Criminal, Civil, and Family Justice.CRC Press Taylor & Francis.
  158. White, Peter(2004).Crime scene to court: The essentials of Forensic science Second edition.Netherlands:Springer.
  159. Wolan´ska-Nowak, Paulina(2000).Application of subpopulation theory to evaluation of DNA evidence.Forensic Science International,113(1-3),63-69.
  160. Wolfe, Stephen L.,Russell, Peter J.,Hertz, Paul E.,Mcmilla, Starr(2007).Biology: The Dynamic Science.Thomson Brooks/Cole.
  161. Yegles, M.,Mersch, F.,Wennig, R.(1997).Detection of benzodiazepines and other psychotropic drugs in human hair by GC/MS.Forensic Science International,84(3),211-218.
  162. Zaritsky, Arno,Morley, Peter T.(2005).The Evidence Evaluation Process for the 2005 International Consensus Conference on Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care Science With Treatment Recommendations.Circulation,112,III-128-III-130.
  163. Zeichner, A.,Levin, N.(1995).Casework experience of GSR detection in Israel, on samples from hands, hair, and clothing using an autosearch SEM/EDX system.J Forensic Sci.,40(6),1082-5.
  164. Zweig, Franklin,Cowdrey, Diane E.(1999).Education Judges for adjudication of new life technologies.Judicature Genes and Justice, The Growing Impact of the New Genetics on the Courts,83(3),157.
  165. 小林充、植村立郎(2005)。重要判決50選刑事事認定重要判決50選（上）。東京都:立花書房。
  166. 小林秀之(1990)。証拠法。東京都:弘文堂。
  167. 山中俊夫(1991)。概說刑事訴訟法。京都市:?????書房。
  168. 井戶田侃(2000)。自白と補強証拠。立命館法学，2000(3‧4?上卷)，68-83。
  169. 井戶田侃(2005)。供述拒否権ガ刑事手続理論に及ばす影響。立命館法学，2005(2‧3?)，79-80。
  170. 木谷明編(2008)。刑事事実認定の基本問題。東京都:成文堂。
  171. 王兆鵬(2004)。美國刑事訴訟法。台北:元照。
  172. 王兆鵬(2008)。刑事訴訟法講義。台北:元照。
  173. 田口守一(2006)。刑事訴訟法第四版補正版。東京都:弘文堂。
  174. 石川多加子(2008)。裁判員制度に関する憲法的考察。金沢大学教育学部紀要人文科学社会科学編，57，57-70。
  175. 石井美和(2006)。法曹養成をめぐる制度と政策—法曹三者の力学を中心として。東北大学教育学部研究年報，55(1)，197-218。
  176. 安富潔(2007)。刑事訴訟法講義。東京都:慶?義塾大?出版?。
  177. 朱石炎(2007)。刑事訴訟法論。台北:三民。
  178. 西野喜一(2005)。日本国憲法と陪審制。法政理論，26-35。
  179. 何建志(2009)。台灣DNA親子鑑定管理規範檢討。法律與生命科學，3(1)，1-17。
  180. 宋慈、宋楚翹譯(2002)。洗冤集錄。香港:西北。
  181. 李俊億(1998)。刑事DNA實驗室之品質保證標準芻議。刑事科學，45，129-137。
  182. 李俊億、謝幸媚(2008)。親子鑑定的演算邏輯。台北:臺大。
  183. 岸盛一、横川敏雄(1960)。事実審理—集中審理と交互尋問の技術。東京都:有斐閣。
  184. 林永謀(2006)。刑事訴訟法釋論（中）。台北:林永謀。
  185. 林鈺雄(2007)。嚴格證明與刑事證據。台北:新學林。
  186. 長沼範良、寺崎嘉博、田中開(2007)。刑事訴訟法第2版。東京都:有斐閣???。
  187. 原増司(1987)。証拠調調べの話。東京都:社團法人?明協?。
  188. 唐淑美(2005)。刑事DNA資料庫之擴增與隱私權之探討。東海法學研究，23，88-92。
  189. 唐淑美、李介民(2004)。我國司法實務有關DNA鑑定對刑事犯罪認定有效性之分析。東海大學法學研究，21，54-55。
  190. 宮田裕(1985)。現代の裁判。東京都:放送大?教育振興?。
  191. 荒木伸怡(2004)。供述証拠の証明力評価ルールに関する一考察。立教法学，65，58-74。
  192. 張麗卿(2003)。驗證刑訴改革脈動。台北:五南。
  193. 張麗卿(2007)。刑事訴訟法理論與運用。台北:五南。
  194. 陳振銘(2006)。揭開十三年之謎—高鑑別度DNA鑑定法。刑事雙月刊，14，40-43。
  195. 陳運財(2003)。刑事程序DNA鑑定之研究。成大法學，5，85-120。
  196. 勝又義直(2008)。裁判所における科学鑑定評の評価について。法科学技術，13(1)，1-6。
  197. 渡部保夫(1992)。無罪の發見—証拠の分析と判基準—。東京都:勁草書房。
  198. 渡辺千原(2006)。司法改革論議における「常識」の位置。立命館法学，6，529-562。
  199. 渥美東洋(1996)。刑事訴訟法。東京都:青林書院。
  200. 黃朝義(2007)。刑事訴訟法增補一版。台北:一品。
  201. 蔡墩銘(1997)。鑑定之證據能力與證明力。臺大法學論叢，26(4)，161-171。
  202. 鴨良弼(1962)。刑事証拠法。東京都:日本評論新社。
  203. 簡孟輝(2005)。有看沒有懂的DNA鑑驗書。刑事雙月刊，6，32-39。
被引用次数
  1. (2015)。論圖案與印記證據之證據能力。中研院法學期刊，17，423-476。
print cancel