台灣股票市場權益風險溢酬之分析

The analysis of equity risk premium with the consideration of prospect theory: A case of Taiwan stock market

林育秀(Yu-Hsiu Lin)

風險溢酬 ； 展望理論 ； 損失趨避 ； Equity Premium ； Prospect Theory ； Loss Aversion

東吳經濟商學學報

100期（2020 / 06 / 01）

61 - 94

繁體中文

本文探討台灣股市的權益風險溢酬，使用理性消費模型與考量展望理論的跨期消費模型，以1976-2016年的資料估算風險溢酬，並與歷史風險溢酬做比較。本文實證發現，在全樣本期間、1976-1995與1996-2016的子樣本期間，台灣股票市場的風險溢酬歷史平均值分別為13.8800%、20.7272%與7.3589%，理性消費模型估算的風險溢酬則分別為0.2792%、0.5474%和0.2331%，理性模型高估無風險利率並低估股票期望報酬率。加入展望理論的模型有助於解釋風險溢酬，且能同時解釋低無風險利率和高風險溢酬的現象：當相對風險趨避係數為0.1971時，無風險利率估算值將等於歷史平均值2.9897%，在此風險趨避係數值之下，對應不同的價值函數相對比重，可以找到合理的損失趨避係數數值，使得股票期望報酬率與風險溢酬的估算值也等於歷史平均值。

The aim of this paper is to analyze the equity premium in Taiwan stock market. The consumption-based model with and without the consideration of prospect theory is utilized to estimate the equity premium. The estimated premia are then compared with the historical values. The empirical results reveal that in Taiwan stock market, the historical average values of equity premia are 13.8800%, 20.7272% and 7.3589% during the 1976-2016, 1976-1995 and 1996-2016 sample period, respectively. The corresponding premia estimated by the rational consumption-based model are 0.2792%, 0.5474% and 0.2331%. The rational model overestimates the riskfree rate and underestimates the expected return of stocks which results in a serious underestimation of equity premium. With the consideration of prospect theory, the augmented model generates higher estimated equity premium and can simultaneously explain the phenomena of historical low riskfree rate and high equity premium. It is found that as the coefficient of relative risk aversion is 0.1971, the estimated riskfree rate would be equal to the historical average riskfree rate 2.9897%. Given this coefficient value and corresponding to various relative weights of value function, we can find reasonable values of the coefficient of loss aver sion such that the estimated stock return and risk premium equal their historical average values.

1. 王韻怡,池祥萱,周冠男(2016)。行為財務學文獻回顧與展望: 台灣市場之研究。經濟論文叢刊，44(1)，1-55。
   連結：
2. 林美珍,楊念慈(2017)。行為財務學與資產訂價異常現象:文獻回顧與展望。證券市場發展季刊，29(4)，1-62。
   連結：
3. Abel, A.B.(1990).Asset Prices under Habit Formation and Catching up with the Joneses.American Economic Review,80,38-42.
4. Andreasen, M. M.,Jorgensen, K.(2019).The Importance of Timing Attitudes in Consumption Based Asset Pricing Models.Journal of Monetary Economics
5. Bansal, R.,Yaron, A.(2004).Risks for the Long Run: A Potential Resulution of Asset Pricing Puzzles.Journal of Finance,59,1481-1509.
6. Barberis, N.,Huang, M.,Santos, T.(2001).Prospect Theory and Asset Prices.Quarterly Journal of Economics,116,1-53.
7. Barro, R.(2006).Rare Disasters and Asset Markets in the Twentieth Century.Quarterly Journal ofEconomics,121,823-866.
8. Benartzi, S.,Thaler, R.(1995).Myopic Loss Aversion and the Equity Premium Puzzle.Quarterly Journal of Economics,110,73-92.
9. Boldrin, M.,Christiano, L.,Fisher, J.(2001).Habit Persistence, Asset Returns, and the BusinessCycle.American Economic Review,91,149-166.
10. Boldrin, M.,Christiano, L.,Fisher, J.(1997).Habit Persistence and Asset Returns in an ExchangeEconomy.Macroeconomic Dynamics,1,312-332.
11. Brown, S.,Goetzmann, W.,Ross, S.(1995).Survival.Journal of Finance,50(2),853-873.
12. Campbell, J.Y.,Cochrane, J.(1999).By Force of Habit: A Consumption-Based Explanation of Aggregate Stock Market Behavior.Journal of Political Economy,107,205-251.
13. Constantinides, G.(1990).Habit Formation: A Resolution of the Equity Premium Puzzle.Journal of Political Economy,98,519-543.
14. Constantinides, G.M.,Donaldson, J.B.,Mehra, R.(2002).Junior Can’t Borrow: A New Perspective on the Equity Premium Puzzle.Quarterly Journal of Economics,118,269-296.
15. Constantinides, George(ed.),Harris, Milt(ed.),Stulz, Rene(ed.)(2003).Handbook of the Economicsof Finance.Elservier Inc..
16. Croce, M. M.(2014).Long-Run Productivity Risk: A New Hope for Production-Based Asset Pricing?.Journal of Monetary Economics,66,13-31.
17. Epstein, L. G.,Zin, S. E.(1989).Substitution, Risk Aversion, and the Temporal Behavior of Consumption and Asset Returns: A Theoretical Framework.Econometrica,57(4),937-969.
18. Epstein, L.G.,Farhi, E.,Strzalecki, T.(2014).How Much Would You Pay to Resolve Long-Run Risk.American Economic Review,104(9),2680-2697.
19. Fama, E.,French, K.(2002).The Equity Premium.Journal of Finance,57,637-659.
20. Heaton, J.,Lucas, D.(1997).Market Frictions, Saving Behavior and Portfolio Choice.Journalof Macroeconomic Dynamics,1,76-101.
21. Huang, A.G.,Hughson, E. N.,Leach, J. C.(2016).Generational Asset Pricing, Equity Puzzles, andCyclicality.Review of Economic Dynamics,22,52-71.
22. Jacobs, K.,Pallage, S.,Robe, M.A.(2013).Market Incompleteness and the Equity Premium Puzzle:Evidence from State-Level Data.Journal of Banking and Finance,37,378-388.
23. Jermann, U.(1998).Asset Pricing in Production Economies.Journal of Monetary Economics,41,257-275.
24. Kahneman, D.,Tversky, A.(1979).Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk.Econometrica,47,263-291.
25. Kocherlakota, N.(1996).The Equity Premium: It’s Still a Puzzle.Journal of Economic Literature,34(1),42-71.
26. LeRoy, S.,Porter, R.(1981).The Present Value Relation: Tests Based on Implied Variance Bounds.Econometrica,49,555-674.
27. Mankiw, N.,Zeldes, S.(1991).The Consumption of Stockholders and Nonstockholders.Journalof Financial Economics,29,97-112.
28. Mehra, R.,Prescott, E.(1985).The Equity Premium: A Puzzle.Journal of MonetaryEconomics,15,145-161.
29. Mehra, R.,Sah, R.(2002).Mood Fluctuations, Projection Bias, and Volatility of Equity Prices.Journal of Economic Dynamic and Control,26,869-887.
30. Mehra, Rajnish(ed.)(2008).Handbookof the Equity Premium.Elservier B.V..
31. Melino, A.,Yang, A. X.(2003).State Dependent Preferences Can Explain the Equity PremiumPuzzle.Review of Economic Dynamics,6(2),806-830.
32. Otrok, C,Ravikumar, B.,Whiteman, C.H.(2002).Habit Formation: a Resolution of the Equity Premium Puzzle?.Journal of Monetary Economics,49,1261-1288.
33. Reitz, T.(1988).The Equity Risk Premium: A Solution.Journal of Monetary Economics,22,117-131.
34. Shiller, R.(1981).Do Stock Prices Move Too Much to Be Justified by Subsequent Changes in Dividends?.American Economic Review,71,421-436.
35. Szyszka, Adam(2013).Behavioral Finance and Capital Markets, Palgrave Macmillan, a division ofSt.Martin’s Press LLC.
36. Thimme, J.,Volkert, Clemens(2015).High Order Smooth Ambiguity Preferences and Asset Prices.Review of Financial Economics,27,1-15.
37. Tversky, A.,Kahneman, D.(1992).Advances in Prospect Theory: Cumulative Representation ofUncertainty.Journal of Risk and Uncertrainty,5,297-323.
38. Tversky, A.,Kahneman, D.(1991).Loss Aversion in Riskless Choices: A Reference-DependentModel.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,106(4),1039-1061.
39. Weil, P.(1989).The Equity Premium Puzzle and the Risk-Free Rate Puzzle.Journal of MonetrayEconomics,24,401-421.
40. Weitzman, M.(2007).Subjective Expectations and Asset Return Puzzles.American EconomicReview,97(4),1102-1130.
41. Zhan, Shi(2019).Time-Varying Ambiguity, Credit Spreads, and the Levered Equity Premium.Journal of Financial Economics,134,617-646.
42. 莊英琴(2009)。國立高雄第一科技大學財務管理所。
43. 簡瑞璞(2004)。國立政治大學商學院經營管理碩士學程金融組。

1. 羅新興,黃于庭,王彥蓁(2022)。不同賺賠狀態的股票賣出傾向：資金籌碼與損失規避之調節。東吳經濟商學學報，104，81-104。