巴頓案與亨利八世的言論控制

Elizabeth Barton and Henry VIII's Censorship on Public Opinion

10.6243/BHR.2012.048.281

李若庸(Juo-Yung Lee)

伊莉莎白‧ 巴頓 ； 肯特郡的聖女 ； 政治預言 ； 言論控制 ； 亨利朝宗教改革 ； Elizabeth Barton ； The Holy Maid of Kent ； political prophecy ； censorship ； Henrician Reformation

臺灣師大歷史學報

48期（2012 / 12 / 01）

281 - 325

繁體中文

本文是「英格蘭宗教改革」研究之延續對話。迄今的研究成果強調「合作」為亨利八世朝「官方宗教改革」成功的原因， 本文主張在「合作」的面向外，英格蘭社會亦曾對亨利八世的改革政策發出過反對之聲。「肯特郡的聖女」伊莉莎白‧巴頓在一五三○年前後發表的「政治預言」就是很具代表性的例子。巴頓修女從肯特郡的一隅，透過教會、鄉誼等人際網絡，以口語及文字的形式，將她的反對預言穿越地域、階級，與性別地傳播出去，形成一股強大的異議之聲。亨利八世不久針對巴頓預言展開強力的整肅：除了巴頓與周邊人士被國王處決，所有與巴頓接觸過的關聯人士都遭到傳訊。亨利八世在「巴頓案」的處置展現了他對民間言論的高度掌握與控制。「掌握於事前，嚴懲於事後」，亨利八世對所有異議言論有效地打擊，使它們難以形成撼動王朝的力量。巴頓案展現了英格蘭民間的反對聲音，但也解釋了亨利八世王朝宗教改革的成功。

This paper is a continuation of the debate on the English Reformation. Present researches focus on ”cooperation”, considering which as the key factor for the success of ”the Official Reformation” held by Henry VIII. This paper asserts that apart from cooperating with the government, the English society has also expressed its opposition to the king's reformation policy. The political prophecy issued by Elizabeth Barton, the Holy Maid of Kent, was a good example. Barton, a nun living in a remote corner of Kent, by way of personal or ecclesiastical networks, disseminated her prophecy of opposition, in oral and written forms, to audience of different regions, ranks, and genders; Barton's prophecy in the end created a strong voice of opposition. Henry VIII soon went for Barton and her adherents: the nun and her ”accomplices” were executed, and everyone who had ever contacted with Barton was interrogated. In Barton's Case, Henry VIII showed his close surveillance over his subjects. ”To monitor beforehand and to punish afterwards”, the device successfully suppressed the sounds of opposition, which can hardly formed a strong enough power to shake the regime. Barton's case reveals the voice of disagreement coming from the English populace, but it also paradoxically explains the success of the Henrician Reformation.

1. 李若庸(2010)。忠君或虔信？知識菁英與亨利八世的對抗及妥協。成大歷史學報，38，53-88。
   連結：
2. 李若庸(2005)。英格蘭宗教改革後的服從論述。臺大歷史學報，36，317-356。
   連結：
3. Hall, The Triumphant Reigne of Kyng Henry VIII, vol. 2, p. 259
4. L.E. Whatmore, “The Sermon against the Holy Maid of Kent and Her Adherents,”English Historical Review vol.58 (1943), p. 466.
5. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 1460.
6. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 869
7. Thomas Wright, Three Chapters of Letters Relating to the Suppression of Monasteries (London: Printed for the Camden Society by John Bowyer Nichols and Son, 1843), p.14-16、p.18.
8. 25 Henry VIII c.12. Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 7, no. 522
9. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 1419
10. Martin A.S. Hume and others (eds.), Calendar of Letters, Despatches and State Papers, Relating to the Negotiation between England and Spain (London, 1862-1954), vol. 5, no. 22.
11. Statutes of the Realm, (London, 1810-1828), vol.3, pp. 449
12. George James Aungier, The History and Antiquities of Syon Monastery, the Parish of Isleworth and the Chapel of Hounslow; Compiled from Public Records, Ancient Manuscripts, Ecclesiastical and Other Authentic Documents (London, 1840), p. 84.
13. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 1369
14. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 7, no. 139.
15. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 7, no. 265.
16. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 7, no. 288
17. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol.6, no.1467
18. Martin A.S. Hume and others (eds.), Calendar of Letters, Despatches and State Papers, Relating to the Negotiation between England and Spain (London, 1862-1954), vol. 4:2, no. 1153.
19. (2004).Oxford Dictionary of National Biography.Oxford University Press.
20. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 1381(3).
21. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 1465
22. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 887
23. J. S. Brewer, J. Gairdner & R. H. Brodie (ed.), Letters and Papers, Foreign and Domestic, of the Reign of Henry VIII, 21 vols. and addenda (London: Longman & Co., 1862-1932), vol.4:2, no.4806.
24. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 7, no. 287.
25. 25 Henry VIII c.12.
26. Edward Hall, Hall's Chronicle; Containing The History of England, During the Reign of Henry the Fourth and the Succeeding Monarchs, to the End of the Reign of Henry the Eighth, in Which are Particularly Described the Manners and Customs of Those Periods (1548; London, 1809), pp. 806-807.
27. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol. 6, no. 1194
28. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII,, vol. 7, no. 72(2).
29. Henry Jenkyns, The Remains of Thomas Cranmer, D.D., Archbishop of Canterbury (Oxford, 1833), vol.1, pp. 79-89.
30. Letters and Papers, Henry VIII, vol.6, no.1468(5).
31. Cooper, J.P.D.(2003).Propaganda and the Tudor State: Political Culture in the Westcountry.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
32. Devereux, E.J.(1966).Elizabeth Barton and Tudor Censorship.Bulletin of the John Rylands Library,49,99.
33. Dunkel, Wilbur(1965).William Lambarde, Elizabethan Jurist 1536-1601.New Brunswick:
34. Ellis, Henry(1969).Original Letters illustrative of English History.London:Dawsons.
35. Jansen, Sharon L.(1996).Dangerous Talk and Strange Behavior.
36. Neame, Alan(1971).The Holy Maid of Kent: The Life of Elizabeth Barton, 1506-1534.London:Hodder and Stoughton.
37. Rex, Richard(1991).The Execution of the Holy Maid of Kent.The Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Research,64,216-20.
38. Rogers, Elizabeth F.(ed.)(1970).The Correspondence of Sir Thomas More.Freeport, N.Y.:Books for Libraries Press.
39. Ryrie(2009).The Age of Reformation: the Tudor and Stewart Realms 1485-1603.Pearson Longman.
40. Shagan, Ethan H.(2003).Popular Politics and the English Reformation.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
41. Warnicke, Retha M.(1973).William Lambarde: Elizabethan Antiquary 1536-1601.London:
42. 李若庸(2005)。評J.P.D. Cooper, Propaganda and the Tudor State: Political Culture in the Westcountry。新史學，16(4)，221-230。
43. 李若庸(2003)。評Ethan H. Shagan, Popular Politics and the English Reformation。新史學，14(3)，183-191。
44. 李若庸(2009)。十六世紀歐洲強權間的外交角力。帝國之禮國際學術研討會，臺北市:

1. (2017)。亨利八世的佈道管控與輿論偵防。新史學，28(2)，1-64。
2. (2021)。亨利八世的修院整頓。新史學，32(2)，57-123。