题名

當他被牠看著的時候，他是誰？在德希達那兒的貓

并列篇名

Who Is He When He Is Being Seen by It? The Cat chez Derrida

DOI

10.6637/CWLQ.2009.38(4).77-131

作者

梁孫傑(Sun-Chieh Liang)

关键词

德希達 ； 動物 ； 視覺 ； 深淵 ； 延異 ； 中動語態 ； 字動物 ； Derrida ； animal ； vision ； abyss ； difference ； middle voice ； l'animot

期刊名称

中外文學

卷期/出版年月

38卷4期（2009 / 12 / 01）

页次

77 - 131

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

德希達在1997年舍里西舉辦的研討會發表〈故我在跟隨的動物〉後，他的動物論述引發學者不少爭議，主要是著重在他論文裡呈現的那隻貓，是否真是他所謂的真實的貓，還是如其他哲學家所呈現的動物一樣，早已被文本化或哲學化了。本篇論文認為德希達以它者的眼光省視動物，並如此呈現動物，並以此為主軸，分成以下幾個討論方向：（1）簡述評論家對於德希達動物論述的批判，其中最主要的不滿，就是指責他劃地自限，無視真實動物的存在；（2）討論德希達對西方傳統視覺的批判和反思；（3）分析德希達在貓的凝視中所見到的解構思想和行動實踐的脫節，以及脫節的原因；（4）探究深淵的意義，並為德希達漠視動物的指責作辯護；（5）連結延異和動物的關係，呈現德希達對動物的關懷／凝視。
英文摘要

Since the 1997 Cerisy Conference where Jacques Derrida presented the paper, ＂L'animal que donc je suis,＂ his attitude towards animals has been a controversial issue among scholars. The controversy mainly revolves around the doubt: whether he really sees the cat presented in this paper as a real cat, or the cat is simply another textualized/philosophized cat, like the other animals presented by the philosophers before him. This paper contends that Derrida sees the animals from the eyes of the Other, and presents them as such. The argument is divided into five parts: (1) a brief introduction to the critics' discontent with Derrida's animal studies, focusing on their complaint that Derrida draws an uncrossable line between the animals and himself; (2) Derrida's critique of the traditional western account of the vision; (3) the disruption between deconstructive thinking and practical action when Derrida sees himself being seen by his cat, and the cause of this disruption; (4) the meaning of abyss, and my defense for Derrida's attitude towards animals; (5) the relationship between différance and animals, and Derrida's concern about the animals.
主题分类 人文學 > 中國文學
人文學 > 外國文學
参考文献
  1. 余德慧、石世明、夏淑怡(2006)。探討癌末處境「聖世界」的形成。生死學研究，3(1)，1-58。
    連結：
  2. 賴俊雄(2004)。「幽靈」與「朋友」：論晚期解構主義的政治轉向。中外文學，32(8)，77-112。
    連結：
  3. Also available from Nexis Database EBSCOhost
  4. Also available from Nexis Database EBSCOhost
  5. Adams, Carol J.(1990).The Sexual Politics of Meat: A Feminist-Vegetarian Critical Theory.New York:Continuum.
  6. Adams, Carol J.(1990).The Sexual Politics of Meat: A Feminist-Vegetarian Critical Theory.New York:Continuum.
  7. Adams, Michael Vannoy(2001).The Mythological Unconscious.New York:Karnac.
  8. Adams, Michael Vannoy(2001).The Mythological Unconscious.New York:Karnac.
  9. Following Derrida
  10. Following Derrida
  11. Barthes, Roland,Richard Macksey (ed.),Eugenio Donato (ed.)(1977).The Structuralist Controversy: The Languages of criticism and the Sciences of the Mind.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins UP.
  12. Barthes, Roland,Richard Macksey (ed.),Eugenio Donato (ed.)(1977).The Structuralist Controversy: The Languages of criticism and the Sciences of the Mind.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins UP.
  13. Bataille, Georges(1973).Théorie de Ia religion.Paris:Gallimard.
  14. Bataille, Georges(1973).Theorie de Ia religion.Paris:Gallimard.
  15. Bataille, Georges,Robert Hurley (Trans)(1992).Theory of Religion.New York:Zone.
  16. Bataille, Georges,Robert Hurley (Trans)(1992).Theory of Religion.New York:Zone.
  17. Berger, John.(1980).About Looking.New York:Pantheon.
  18. Berger, John.(1980).About Looking.New York:Pantheon.
  19. Getting It All Wrong
  20. Getting It All Wrong
  21. Braidotti, Rosi(2006).Posthuman, All Too Human: Towards a New Process Ontology.Theory Culture and Society,23,197-208.
  22. Bruns, Gerald L.(2008).Derrida's Cat (Who Am I?).Research in Phenomenology,38,404-423.
  23. Buber, Martin,Roland Gregor Smith (Trans)(1958).I and Thou.New York:Charles Scribner's Sons.
  24. Buber, Martin,Roland Gregor Smith (Trans)(1958).I and Thou.New York:Charles Scribner's Sons.
  25. Burt, Jonathan(2006).Morbidity and Vitalism: Derrida, Bergson, Deleuze, and Animal Film Imagery.Configurations,14,157-179.
  26. Burt, Jonathan(2006).Morbidity and Vitalism: Derrida, Bergson, Deleuze, and Animal Film Imagery.Configurations,14,157-179.
  27. Burt, Jonathan(2001).The illumination of the Animal Kingdom The Role of Light and Electricity in Animal Representation.Society and Representation,9(3),203-228.
  28. Burt, Jonathan(2001).The illumination of the Animal Kingdom The Role of Light and Electricity in Animal Representation.Society and Representation,9(3),203-228.
  29. Journal of Literary Studies
  30. Davis, Christopher A.(2000).Revelation.Joplin, MO:College P..
  31. Davis, Christopher A.(2000).Revelation.Joplin, MO:College P..
  32. Day, Robert A,Barbara Gastel(2006).How to Write and Publish a Scientific Paper.
  33. Day, Robert A,Barbara Gastel(2006).How to Write and Publish a Scientific Paper.
  34. Derrida, Jacques(1994).Politiques de l'amité.Paris:Galilee.
  35. Derrida, Jacques(1993).Donner la mort.Paris:Galilee.
  36. Derrida, Jacques(1993).Donner la mort.Paris:Galilee.
  37. Derrida, Jacques(2002).H. C pour la vie, c'est à dire.Paris:Galilee.
  38. Derrida, Jacques(1994).Politiques de l'amite.Paris:Galilee.
  39. Derrida, Jacques(2006).H. C. for Life, That Is to Say.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  40. Derrida, Jacques(2006).H. C. for Life, That Is to Say.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  41. Derrida, Jacques(1967).Le voix et le phenomene: Introduction au probleme du signe clans Ia phenomenologie de Husserl.Paris:PU de France.
  42. Derrida, Jacques(1993).Spectres de Marx.Paris:Galilee.
  43. Derrida, Jacques(1993).Spectres de Marx.Paris:Galilee.
  44. Derrida, Jacques(2002).H. C pour la vie, c'est a dire.Paris:Galilee.
  45. Derrida, Jacques(1967).Le voix et le phénomène: Introduction au problème du signe clans Ia phénoménologie de Husserl.Paris:PU de France.
  46. Derrida, Jacques,Alan Bass (Trans)(1972).Margins of Philosophy.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
  47. Derrida, Jacques,Alan Bass (Trans)(1978).Writing and Difference.London:Routledge.
  48. Derrida, Jacques,Alan Bass (Trans)(1972).Margins of Philosophy.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
  49. Derrida, Jacques,Alan Bass (Trans)(1978).Writing and Difference.London:Routledge.
  50. Derrida, Jacques,Anne Dufourmantelle,Rachel Bowlby (Trans)(2000).Of Hospitality.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  51. Derrida, Jacques,Anne Dufourmantelle,Rachel Bowlby (Trans)(2000).Of Hospitality.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  52. Derrida, Jacques,David B. Allison (Trans)(1973).Speech and Phenomenon: And Other Essays on Husserl's Theory of Signs.Evanston:Northwestern UP.
  53. Derrida, Jacques,David B. Allison (Trans)(1973).Speech and Phenomenon: And Other Essays on Husserl's Theory of Signs.Evanston:Northwestern UP.
  54. Derrida, Jacques,David Wills (Trans)(1995).The Gift of Death.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
  55. Derrida, Jacques,David Wills (Trans)(1995).The Gift of Death.Chicago:U of Chicago P..
  56. Derrida, Jacques,Elisabeth Roudinesco(2001).De quoi demain...: Dialogue.Paris:Galilee.
  57. Derrida, Jacques,Elisabeth Roudinesco(2001).De quoi demain...: Dialogue.Paris:Galilee.
  58. Derrida, Jacques,Elisabeth Roudinesco,Jeff Fort (Trans)(2004).For What Tomorrow...: A Dialogue.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  59. Derrida, Jacques,Elisabeth Roudinesco,Jeff Fort (Trans)(2004).For What Tomorrow...: A Dialogue.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  60. Derrida, Jacques,Elizabeth Weber (Ed.),Peggy Kamuf (Trans)(1995).Points: Interviews, 1974-1994.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  61. Derrida, Jacques,Elizabeth Weber (Ed.),Peggy Kamuf (Trans)(1995).Points: Interviews, 1974-1994.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  62. Derrida, Jacques,Jan Plug (Trans)(2004).Eyes of the University: Right to Philosophy 2.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  63. Derrida, Jacques,Jan Plug (Trans)(2004).Eyes of the University: Right to Philosophy 2.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  64. Derrida, Jacques,Marie-Louise Mallet (Ed.)(2006).L'animal que done je suis.Paris:Galilee.
  65. Derrida, Jacques,Marie-Louise Mallet (Ed.)(2006).L'animal que done je suis.Paris:Galilee.
  66. Derrida, Jacques,Marie-Louise Mallet (Ed.),David Wills (Trans)(2008).The Animal That Therefore I Am.New York:Fordham UP.
  67. Derrida, Jacques,Marie-Louise Mallet (Ed.),David Wills (Trans)(2008).The Animal That Therefore I Am.New York:Fordham UP.
  68. Derrida, Jacques,Maurice Blanchot (Trans),Elizabeth Rottenberg(2000).Demeure: Fiction and Testimony.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  69. Derrida, Jacques,Maurice Blanchot (Trans),Elizabeth Rottenberg(2000).Demeure: Fiction and Testimony.Stanford:Stanford UP.
  70. Derrida, Jacques,Peggy Kamuf (Trans)(1994).Specters of Marx: The State of the Debt, the Work of Mourning, and the New International.New York:Routledge.
  71. Derrida, Jacques,Peggy Kamuf (Trans)(1994).Specters of Marx: The State of the Debt, the Work of Mourning, and the New International.New York:Routledge.
  72. Donne, John.,Henry Alford (Ed.)(1839).The Works of John Donne, D. D.: Dean of Saint Paul's, 1621-1631. With a Memoir of His Life.London:John W. Parker, West Strand.
  73. Donne, John.,Henry Alford (Ed.)(1839).The Works of John Donne, D. D.: Dean of Saint Paul's, 1621-1631. With a Memoir of His Life.London:John W. Parker, West Strand.
  74. Dunayer, Joan(2001).Animal Equality: Language and Liberation.Derwood:Ryce.
  75. Dunayer, Joan(2001).Animal Equality: Language and Liberation.Derwood:Ryce.
  76. Fay, Jennifer(2008).Seeing/Loving Animals: André Bazin's Posthurnanism.Journal of Visual Culture,7(1),41-64.
  77. Fisher, Susan(2001).Animalia.Canadian Literature/Littérature canadienne: A Quarterly of Criticism and Review.
  78. Fisher, Susan(2001).Animalia.Canadian Literature/Litterature canadienne: A Quarterly of Criticism and Review.
  79. Fox, Michael Allen,Marc Bekoff (Ed.)(1998).Encyclopedia of Animal Rights and Animal Welfare.Greenwood:Connecticutt.
  80. Fox, Michael Allen,Marc Bekoff (Ed.)(1998).Encyclopedia of Animal Rights and Animal Welfare.Greenwood:Connecticutt.
  81. Geertz, Clifford(1973).The Interpretation of Cultures.New York:Basic.
  82. Geertz, Clifford(1973).The Interpretation of Cultures.New York:Basic.
  83. Gigliotti, Carol(2006).Leonardo's Choice: The Ethics of Artists Working with Genetic Technologies.AI & Soc,20,22-34.
  84. Gigliotti, Carol(2006).Leonardo's Choice: The Ethics of Artists Working with Genetic Technologies.AI & Soc,20,22-34.
  85. Greenfield, Joanna(1996).Hyena.The New Yorker,11,74-81.
  86. Greenfield, Joanna(1996).Hyena.The New Yorker,11,74-81.
  87. Grimm, Jacob,Wilhelm Grimm(1993).Die Märchen der Brüder Grimm.München:Goldmann Verlag.
  88. Grimm, Jacob,Wilhelm Grimm(1993).Die Marchen der Bruder Grimm.Munchen:Goldmann Verlag.
  89. Haraway, Donna(1991).Simians, Cyborgs and Women: The Reinvention of Nature.New York:Routledge.
  90. Haraway, Donna(2006).Encounters with Companion Species: Entangling Dogs, Baboons, Philosophers, and Biologists.Configurations,14,97-114.
  91. Haraway, Donna(1991).Simians, Cyborgs and Women: The Reinvention of Nature.New York:Routledge.
  92. Haraway, Donna(2006).Encounters with Companion Species: Entangling Dogs, Baboons, Philosophers, and Biologists.Configurations,14,97-114.
  93. Haraway, Donna,Nicholas Gane(2006).When We Have Never Been Human, What Is to Be Done?: Interview with Donna Haraway.Theory Culture Society,23(7-8),135-158.
  94. Heyward, Carter.(1976).A Priest Forever.New York:Harper & Row.
  95. Heyward, Carter.(1976).A Priest Forever.New York:Harper & Row.
  96. Husserl. Edmund(2001).Logical Investigations.New York:Routledge.
  97. Husserl. Edmund(1976).Ideen zu einer reinen Phanomenologie und phanomenologtrchen Philosophie.Den Haag:Nijhoff.
  98. Husserl. Edmund(1976).Ideen zu einer reinen Phänomenologie und phänomenologtrchen Philosophie.Den Haag:Nijhoff.
  99. Husserl. Edmund(2001).Logical Investigations.New York:Routledge.
  100. Husserl. Edmund,F. Kersten (Trans)(1982).Ideas Pertaining to a Pure Phenomenology and to a Phenomenological Philosophy.Boston:Martinus Nijhoff.
  101. Husserl. Edmund,F. Kersten (Trans)(1982).Ideas Pertaining to a Pure Phenomenology and to a Phenomenological Philosophy.Boston:Martinus Nijhoff.
  102. Ingraham, Catherine(2006).Architecture, Animal, Human: The Asymmetrical Condition.New York:Routledge.
  103. Ingraham, Catherine(2006).Architecture, Animal, Human: The Asymmetrical Condition.New York:Routledge.
  104. Kinnear, Jasmine(2007).Every Cat Has a Story: True Stories Exploring the Spiritual Connection of Felines with Their Beloved Owners.B.C.:CCB P..
  105. Kinnear, Jasmine(2007).Every Cat Has a Story: True Stories Exploring the Spiritual Connection of Felines with Their Beloved Owners.B.C.:CCB P..
  106. Lawlor, Leonard(2002).Derrida and Husserl: The Basic Problem of Phenomenology.Bloomington:Indiana UP.
  107. Lawlor, Leonard(2007).This Is Not Sufficient: An Essay on Animality and Human Nature in Derrida.New York:Columbia UP.
  108. Lawlor, Leonard(2002).Derrida and Husserl: The Basic Problem of Phenomenology.Bloomington:Indiana UP.
  109. Lawlor, Leonard(2007).This Is Not Sufficient: An Essay on Animality and Human Nature in Derrida.New York:Columbia UP.
  110. Lingis, Alphonso(1983).Excesses: Eros and Culture.New York:SUNY P..
  111. Lingis, Alphonso(1983).Excesses: Eros and Culture.New York:SUNY P..
  112. Lippit, Akira Mizuta(2002).The Death of an Animal.Film Quarterly,56,9-22.
  113. Southerly
  114. Southerly
  115. Llewelyn, John(1999).The Hypocritical Imagination: Between Kant and Levinas.New York:Routledge.
  116. Llewelyn, John(1999).The Hypocritical Imagination: Between Kant and Levinas.New York:Routledge.
  117. Lundblad, Michael(2004).The Animal Question.American Quarterly,56(4),1125-1134.
  118. Masó, Joana,Gabriela García Hubard,Javier Bassas Vila,Santiago Borja(2007).Echo-graphic Images': Writing or Piercing the Visible.Mosaic,40(2),213-230.
  119. Masó, Joana,Gabriela García Hubard,Javier Bassas Vila,Santiago Borja(2007).Echo-graphic Images': Writing or Piercing the Visible.Mosaic,40(2),213-230.
  120. McCumber, John,David Michael Levin (Ed.)(1993).Modernity and the Hegemony of Vision.Los Angeles:U of California.
  121. McCumber, John,David Michael Levin (Ed.)(1993).Modernity and the Hegemony of Vision.Los Angeles:U of California.
  122. Mitchell, W. J. T.(2002).Showing Seeing: A Critique of Visual Culture.Journal of Visual Culture,1,165-181.
  123. Naas, Michael(2007).Comme xi, comma ça: Phantasms of Self, State, and a Sovereign God.Mosaic,40(2),1-26.
  124. Naas, Michael(2007).Comme xi, comma ça: Phantasms of Self, State, and a Sovereign God.Mosaic,40(2),1-26.
  125. Nietzsche, Friedrich(1961).Thus Spoke Zarathustra.New York:Penguin.
  126. Nietzsche, Friedrich(1961).Thus Spoke Zarathustra.New York:Penguin.
  127. Oliver, Kelly(2006).Animal Pedagogy: The Origin of 'Man' in Rousseau and Herder.Culture, Theory & Critique,47(2),107-131.
  128. Payne, Michael (eds.),John Schad (eds.)(2003).Life. after. Theory.New York:Continuum.
  129. Payne, Michael (eds.),John Schad (eds.)(2003).Life. after. Theory.New York:Continuum.
  130. Rapaport, Herman(2003).Later Derrida: Reading the Recent Work.London:Routledge.
  131. Rapaport, Herman(2003).Later Derrida: Reading the Recent Work.London:Routledge.
  132. Kitikos
  133. Kitikos
  134. Segarra, Marta(2007).Friendship, Betrayal, and Translation: Cixous and Dethda.Mosaic,40(2),91-101.
  135. Segarra, Marta(2007).Friendship, Betrayal, and Translation: Cixous and Dethda.Mosaic,40(2),91-101.
  136. Segarra, Marta(2006).Hélène Cixous's Other Animal: The Half-Sunken Dog.New Literary History,37,119-134.
  137. Shakespeare, William,Harold Jenkins (Ed.)(1982).Hamlet.New York:Methuen.
  138. Shakespeare, William,Harold Jenkins (Ed.)(1982).Hamlet.New York:Methuen.
  139. Silverman, Hugh J.,Zeynep Direk (Ed.),Leonard Lawlor (Ed.)(2002).Jacques Derrida: Critical Assessments of Leading Philosophers.New York:Routledge.
  140. Silverman, Hugh J.,Zeynep Direk (Ed.),Leonard Lawlor (Ed.)(2002).Jacques Derrida: Critical Assessments of Leading Philosophers.New York:Routledge.
  141. Sullivan, Lawrence Eugene(2002).Native Religions and Cultures of Central and South America.New York:Continuum.
  142. Sullivan, Lawrence Eugene(2002).Native Religions and Cultures of Central and South America.New York:Continuum.
  143. Tyler, Tom(2007).Quia Ego Nomtnor Leo: Barthes, Stereotypes, and Aesop's Animals.Mosaic,40(1),45-59.
  144. Tyler, Tom(2007).Quia Ego Nomtnor Leo: Barthes, Stereotypes, and Aesop's Animals.Mosaic,40(1),45-59.
  145. Verhoeven, Deb(2006).Sheep and the Australian Cinema.Carlton, Vic.:Melbourne UP.
  146. Verhoeven, Deb(2006).Sheep and the Australian Cinema.Carlton, Vic.:Melbourne UP.
  147. Wills, David (trans),Jacques Derrida(2002).The Animal That Therefore I Am (More to Follow).Critical Inquiry,28(2),369-418.
  148. Wood, David(2002).Thinking after Heidegger.Cambridge:Polity.
  149. Greening Derrida: The Eleventh Plague
  150. Wood, David(2002).Thinking after Heidegger.Cambridge:Polity.
  151. Greening Derrida: The Eleventh Plague
  152. Wood, David,Christopher Norris (Ed.),David Roden (Ed.)(2003).Jacques Derrida.London:Sage.
  153. Wood, David,Christopher Norris (Ed.),David Roden (Ed.)(2003).Jacques Derrida.London:Sage.
  154. Wood, David,Matthew Calarco (Ed.),Peter Atterton (Ed.)(2004).Animal Philosophy: Essential Readings in Continental Thought.London:Continuum.
  155. Wood, David,Matthew Calarco (Ed.),Peter Atterton (Ed.)(2004).Animal Philosophy: Essential Readings in Continental Thought.London:Continuum.
  156. 方向紅(2003)。德里達「聲音」概念的起源。學海，1，138-142。
  157. 方向紅(2006)。Unheimlichkeit：幽靈與真理的契合點－德里達「幽靈」概念的譜系學研究。現代哲學，4，72-77。
  158. 方向紅(2003)。德里達「聲音」概念的起源。學海，1，138-142。
  159. 方向紅(2006)。Unheimlichkeit：幽靈與真理的契合點－德里達「幽靈」概念的譜系學研究。現代哲學，4，72-77。
  160. 史安賦譯、Jacques Derrida著、汪民安編(2006)。生產。桂林:廣西師範大學出版社。
  161. 史安賦譯、Jacques Derrida著、汪民安編(2006)。生產。桂林:廣西師範大學出版社。
  162. 朱玲琳譯、夏可君譯、Jacques Derrida著、夏可君編校、杜小真譯(2006)。解構與思想的未來。長春:吉林人民出版社。
  163. 朱玲琳譯、夏可君譯、Jacques Derrida著、夏可君編校、杜小真譯(2006)。解構與思想的未來。長春:吉林人民出版社。
  164. 何一譯、Jacques Derrida著(1999)。馬克思的幽靈：債務國家、哀悼活動和新國際。北京:中國人民大學。
  165. 何一譯、Jacques Derrida著(1999)。馬克思的幽靈：債務國家、哀悼活動和新國際。北京:中國人民大學。
  166. 從上出生
  167. 從上出生
  168. 杜小真譯、Jacques Derrida著(2002)。聲音與現象。北京:商務。
  169. 杜小真譯、Jacques Derrida著(2002)。聲音與現象。北京:商務。
  170. 汪民安譯、Jacques Derrida著(2002)。延異。外國文學，1，69-84。
  171. 汪民安譯、Jacques Derrida著(2002)。延異。外國文學，1，69-84。
  172. 汪堂家(2008)。汪堂家講德里達。北京:北京大學出版社。
  173. 汪堂家(2008)。汪堂家講德里達。北京:北京大學出版社。
  174. 框設女性身體
  175. 框設女性身體
  176. 法國哲學界對人文主義的新辯論
  177. 法國現象學運動的新轉折
  178. 法國哲學界對人文主義的新辯論
  179. 法國現象學運動的新轉折
  180. 張寧譯Jacques Derrida著(2001)。德里達談現象學。哲學譯叢，3，26-30。
  181. 張寧譯Jacques Derrida著(2004)。書寫與差異。台北:麥田。
  182. 張寧譯Jacques Derrida著(2004)。書寫與差異。台北:麥田。
  183. 張寧譯Jacques Derrida著(2001)。德里達談現象學。哲學譯叢，3，26-30。
  184. 聯合報(2007/03/16)
  185. 聯合報(2007/03/16)
  186. 文藝爭鳴
  187. 文藝爭鳴
  188. 黃冠閔(2004)。巴修拉論火的詩意象。揭諦，6(4)，163-194。
  189. 黃冠閔(2004)。巴修拉論火的詩意象。揭諦，6(4)，163-194。
  190. 《孟子·梁惠王》中的不忍心之仁政：「以牛祭鐘」以及「羊的替代」
  191. 《孟子·梁惠王》中的不忍心之仁政：「以牛祭鐘」以及「羊的替代」
  192. 劉北成譯、陳銀科譯、方海波譯、Jacques Derrida著(1998)。言語與現象。台北:桂冠。
  193. 劉北成譯、陳銀科譯、方海波譯、Jacques Derrida著(1998)。言語與現象。台北:桂冠。
  194. 劉惠媛譯、John Berger著(2002)。影像的閱讀。台北:遠流。
  195. 劉惠媛譯、John Berger著(2002)。影像的閱讀。台北:遠流。
  196. 詩歌饗宴：何等恩友
  197. 詩歌饗宴：何等恩友
  198. 盧貝松導(1997)。第五元素。台北:哥倫比亞。
  199. 盧貝松導(1997)。第五元素。台北:哥倫比亞。
  200. 賴俊雄(2005)。晚期解構主義。台北:揚智。
  201. 賴俊雄(2005)。晚期解構主義。台北:揚智。
  202. 蘇旭譯、Jacques Derrida著、Elisabeth Roudinesco著(2002)。明天會怎樣：對話錄。北京:中信。
  203. 蘇旭譯、Jacques Derrida著、Elisabeth Roudinesco著(2002)。明天會怎樣：對話錄。北京:中信。
被引用次数
  1. 黃宗潔(2009)。劉克襄動物小說中的自然觀。東華漢學，10，285-324。
print cancel