愛是怎麼做？情慾之愛、友愛之愛、到關係即愛的倫理主體

What Is Love? The Ethical Subject from Eros, Philia, to Relation as Love

10.6637/CWLQ.2011.40(2).55-102

楊志偉(Julian Chih-Wei Yang)

愛的倫理主體 ； 愛的隱喻 ； 情慾之愛 ； 友愛之愛 ； 愛發生 ； 海德格 ； 關係即愛 ； 《達洛威夫人》 ； the ethical subject in love ； the metaphor of love ； eros ； philia ； aimance ； Heidegger ； relation as love ； Mrs Dalloway

中外文學

40卷2期（2011 / 06 / 01）

55 - 102

繁體中文

本文聚焦幾種關於愛的論述，討論不同的愛所涉及的倫理主體，以深究愛所具有的倫理質地，並擴充倫理與倫理主體的意涵。全文共分成五部份：第一部分討論何謂「愛的倫理主體」，說明「倫理」、「倫理主體」與「愛的倫理主體」等詞語在本文中的定義。第二至第四部分探討拉岡、德希達與海德格等人如何談論愛情，處理不同的愛諸如情慾之愛、友愛之愛與愛發生的問題，並推演出關係即愛此一命題與相對應的倫理主體。最後一部分引入吳爾芙的小說《達洛威夫人》，以說明如何具體實踐關係即愛的倫理主體，並同時希冀藉以豐富小說文本的詮釋路線。

This article broaches various accounts of love and ethical subjects so as to examine the ethical texture of love and to extend the scope of ethics and ethical subject to include love relationships. The argument divides into five sections: first, I stipulate the definition of ＂ethical subject in love, and clarify the meaning of ＂ethics＂ and ＂ethical subject＂ used in the present discussion. Next, in the following three sections, I remap the discursive encounters of Jacques Lacan, Jacques Derrida, and Martin Heidegger with love, examining different types of love, such as eros-love and philia-love, the implied ethics of these loves, and the question of ＂aimance,＂ to provide evidence for my thesis on relation as love and its ethical subjectivity. In conclusion, I draw upon Virginia Woolf’s novel Mrs Dalloway to illustrate how to apply the proposition of ethical subject in relation as love and thereby enrich one's reading of the literary text.

1. 沈志中(2011)。論愛情：精神分析觀點。中外文學，40(2)，103-35。
   連結：
2. “Have work cut out.” The Free Dictionary. By Farlex. 2011. Web. 1 June 2011.
3. “Work.” Entry 30. Oxford English Dictionary Online. Oxford UP. 2010. Web. 1 June 2011.
4. “Free.” Online Etymology Dictionary. 2001-10. Web. 3 June 2011.
5. “Friend.” Online Etymology Dictionary. 2001-10. Web. 3 June 2011.
6. “Friend.” The Merriam-Webster Online. 2011. Web. 3 June 2011.
7. Freud, Sigmund. Group Psychology and the Analysis of Ego. 1921.
8. “Have one's work cut out for one.” Wikitionary. 11 Feb. 2011. Web. 1 June 2011.
9. Aristotle,Crisp, Roger(Ed.)(2000).Nicomachean Ethics.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
10. Bishop, E. L.(1981).Toward the Far Side of Language: Virginia Woolf's Voyage Out.Twentieth Century Literature,27(4),343-61.
11. Deleuze, Gilles,Conley, Tom(Trans.)(1993).The Fold: Leibniz and the Baroque.Minneapolis, MN:U of Minnesota P.
12. Deleuze, Gilles,Guattari, Félix,Burchell, Graham(Trans.),Tomlinson, Hugh(Trans.)(1994).What Is Philosophy.London:Verso.
13. Derrida, Jacques,Collins, George(Trans.)(1994).The Politics of Friendship.London:Verso.
14. Evans, Dylan(1996).An Introductory Dictionary of Lacanian Psychoanalysis.New York:Routledge.
15. Freud, Sigmund,Strachey, James(Ed. trans.)(1955).The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud.London:Hogarth.
16. Fulton, Lorie Watkins(2006).A Direction of One's Own': Alienation in Mrs. Dalloway and Sula.African American Review,40(1),66-77.
17. Gillese, T. Virginia(1999).U of British Columbia.
18. Guignon, Charles(Ed.)(1993).The Cambridge Companion to Heidegger.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
19. Harris, Susan C.(1997).The Ethics of Indecency: Censorship, Sexuality, and the Voice of the Academy in the Narration of Jacob's Room.Twentieth Century Literature,43(4),420-38.
20. Heidegger, Martin,Capuzzi, Frank A.(Trans.),McNeill, William(Ed.)(1998).Pathmarks.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
21. Heidegger, Martin,Fried, Gregory(Trans.),Polt, Richard(Trans.)(2000).Introduction to Metaphysics.New Haven:Yale NB.
22. Heidegger, Martin,Hofstadter, Albert(Trans.)(1971).Poetry, Language, Thought.New York:Harper.
23. Heidegger, Martin,Macquarrie, John(Trans.),Robinson, Edward(Trans.)(1962).Being and Time.New York:Harper.
24. Hollander, Rachel(2007).Novel Ethics: Alterity and Form in Jacob's Room.Twentieth Century Literature,53(1),40-66.
25. Howatson, M. C.(ed.),Sheffield, Frisbee C. C.(ed.),Plato,Howatson, M. C.(Trans.)(2008).Symposium.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
26. Inwood, Michael(1999).A Heidegger Dictionary.Oxford:Blackwell.
27. Kavaloski, Joshua(2004).U of Virginia.
28. Kavaloski, Joshua(2004).The Fourth Dimension: Time in the Modernist Novel (Thomas Mann, Germany, Virginia Woolf, Franz Kafka, Austria, William Faulkner).DAI,65(4)
29. Lacan, Jacques(1966).Ecrits.Paris:Seuil.
30. Lacan, Jacques,Miller, Jacques-Alain(Texte établi)(2001).Le Séminaire, livre VIII: Le Transfert,Paris:
31. Lilienfeld, Jane(1977).The Deceptiveness of Beauty': Mother Love and Mother Hate in To the Lighthouse.Twentieth Century Literature,23(3),345-76.
32. Nancy, Jean-Luc,Richardson, Robert D.(Trans.),O''Byrne, Anne E.(Trans.)(2000).Being Singular Plural.Stanford:Stanford UP.
33. Nelson, E. S.(ed.),Kapust, Antje(ed.),Still, Kent(ed.)(2005).Addressing Levinas,Evanston, IL:
34. Raffoul, François(2005).Being and the Other: Ethics and Ontology in Levinas and Heidegger.Addressing Levinas,Evanston, IL:
35. Scott, Charles E(1990).The Question of Ethics: Nietzsche, Foucault, Heidegger.Bloomington:Indiana UP.
36. Smith, L. Victoria(2006).Ransacking the Language': Finding the Missing Goods in Virginia Woolf's Orlando.Journal of Modern Literature,29(4),57-75.
37. Spinoza, Baruch,Boyle, Andrew(Trans.),Parkinson, G. H. R.(Rev.)(1993).Ethics.Dent:Everyman.
38. Storl, Heide(2008).Heidegger in Woolf's Clothing.Philosophy and Literature,32(2),303-14.
39. Wood, David(2005).Some Questions for My Levinasian Friends.Addressing Levinas,Evanston, IL:
40. Woolf, Virginia,Bradshaw, David(Ed.)(1992).Mrs Dalloway.London:Vintage.
41. 伍曉明譯、Levinas, Emmnauel(2007)。是其之所是（essence）與無是／無私（désintéressement）。中外文學，36(4)，65-114。
42. 沈志中譯、王文基譯、Laplanche, Jean、Pontalis, J-B.(2000)。精神分析辭彙。台北:行人。
43. 孫周興譯、Heidegger, Martin(1998)。路標。台北:時報。
44. 孫梁譯、Woolf, Virginia、吳潛誠策劃、莫渝策劃(1994)。達洛衛夫人‧燈塔行。台北:桂冠。
45. 陳惠華譯、Woolf, Virginia(2000)。戴洛維夫人。台北:志文。
46. 劉紀蕙譯、廖朝陽譯、黃宗慧譯、龔卓軍譯、Evans, Dylan(2009)。拉岡精神分析辭彙。台北:巨流。

1. 謝世宗、謝世宗(2018)。航向蔡明亮的愛欲烏托邦：論《黑眼圈》及其他。臺大文史哲學報，89，117-149。