巴迪烏與安那其主義（錯失）的遭遇：一種唯／微物基進政治的思想實驗

Badiou's (Mis-)Encounter with Anarchism: A Micro-/materialist Thought Experiment on Radical Politics

10.6637/CWLQ.201809_47(3).0004

黃涵榆(Han-yu Huang)

暴動 ； 減除 ； 政治本體論 ； 事件 ； 安那其 ； 唯物論 ； riots ； subtraction ； political ontology ； event ； anarchism ； materialism

中外文學

47卷3期（2018 / 09 / 30）

89 - 118

繁體中文

即便巴迪烏以其六○、七○年代毛派馬列主義立場對於安那其主義多所批判，但本文主張透過關照他整體的政治本體論，開展他的思想和安那其思想與實踐之間的對話與交集。本文主要目的在於探究巴迪烏與安那其主義之間（錯失）的「遭遇」，這意味著彼此之間複多且不確定的關聯。本文將首先描繪當代安那其的理論情境，接著扼要地闡述巴迪烏的政治本體論，聚焦於事件與主體產生的條件。接下來討論巴迪烏如何回應、重訪包括巴黎公社和近年的「阿拉伯之春」，從這些起義、暴動和革命事件辨識新的政治主體、政治組織、甚至想像未來的可能性，不存在的如得以存在。最後我將以阿圖塞的機緣唯物論為轉接，探討巴迪烏與當代安那其行動組織「隱形委員會」（the Invisible Committee）是否有任何安那其同盟的可能。

Even though Badiou in the 1960s and 1970s voiced a fervent critique of anarchism from a Maoist, Marx-Leninist position, this essay argues for a more holistic view on his political ontology to tackle his potential dialogues with contemporary anarchist thought and praxis. This essays aims at Badiou's ＂(mis-)encounter＂ with anarchism, which implies multiple and uncertain intersections between them. The first part offers a comprehensive description of the situation of contemporary anarchism. The focus of the discussion then shifts to Badiou's political ontology centered on the emergence of the event and the subject. How Badiou responds to and revisits such insurrections as the Paris Commune and the Arab Spring will be explored regarding new political subjectivities, organizations, the imagination of futures and the existence of the inexistent. Althusser's aleatory materialism works as a pivot for carrying the micro-materialist thought experiment of this essay to the Invisible Committee and testing its alignment with Badiou.

1. (2010).New Perspectives on Anarchism.Latham, MD:Lexington Books.
2. Althusser, Louis,Goshgarian, G. M.(Trans.)(2006).Philosophy of the Encounter: Later Writings 1978-1987.London:Verso.
3. Ashton, Paul(ed.)(2006).The Praxis of Alain Badiou.Melbourne:re.press.
4. Badiou, Alain(2004).The Flux and the Party.Polygraph,15/16,75-92.
5. Badiou, Alain(2005).Metapolitics.London:Verso.
6. Badiou, Alain(2002).Ethics: An Essay on the Understanding.London:Verso.
7. Badiou, Alain,Bosteels, Bruno(Trans.)(2012).Philosophy for Militants.London:Verso.
8. Badiou, Alain,Braissier, Ray(trans.)(2003).Saint Paul: The Foundation of Universalism.Stanford:Stanford UP.
9. Badiou, Alain,Brassier, Ray(ed. trans.),Toscano, Alberto(ed. trans.)(2006).Theoretical Writings.London:Continuum.
10. Badiou, Alain,Elliott, Gregory(trans.)(2012).The Rebirth of History.London:Verso.
11. Badiou, Alain,Feltham, Oliver(Trans.)(2006).Being and Event.London:Continuum.
12. Badiou, Alain,Hallward, Peter(Trans.)(2002).Ethics: An Essay on the Understanding.London:Verso.
13. Badiou, Alain,Macey, David(Trans.),Corcoran, Steve(Trans.)(2010).The Communist Hypothesis.London:Verso.
14. Badiou, Alain,Toscano, Alberto(Trans.)(2007).The Century.Cambridge:Polity.
15. Badiou, Alain,Toscano, Alberto(Trans.)(2009).Logics of Worlds: Being and Event II.London:Continuum.
16. Bakunin, Mikhail(1953).The Political Philosophy of Bakunin: Scientific Anarchism.London:Free Press of Glencoe.
17. Bosteels, Bruno(2011).Badiou and Politics.Durham:Duke UP.
18. Bowden, Sean(ed.),Duffy, Simon(ed.)(2012).Badiou and Philosophy.Edinburgh:Edinburgh UP.
19. Critchley, Simon(2007).Infinitely Demanding: Ethics of Commitment, Politics of Resistance.London:Verso.
20. Difenbach, Katja(ed.)(2013).Encountering Althusser: Politics and Materialism in Contemporary Radical Thought.London:Bloomsbury.
21. Graeber, David(2004).Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology.Chicago:Prickly Paradigm Press.
22. Graeber, David(2012).Revolutions in Reverse: Essays on Politics, Violence, Art, and Imagination.Brooklyn:Minor Compositions.
23. Hallward, Peter(ed.)(2003).Badiou: A Subject to Truth.Minneapolis:U of Minnesota P.
24. Hewlett, Nick(2007).Badiou, Balibar, Rancière: Rethinking Emancipation.New York:Continuum.
25. Johnston, Adrian(2009).Badiou, Žižek, and Political Transformations: The Cadence of Change.Evanston:Northwestern UP.
26. Koch, Andrew M.(2011).Post-structuralism and the Epistemological Basis of Anarchism.Post-Anarchism: A Reader,London:
27. Kropotkin, Peter,Baldwin, Roger N.(Ed.)(1970).Anarchism: A Collection of Revolutionary Writings.Mineola, NY:Dover.
28. Marchart, Oliver(2007).Post-Foundational Political Thought: Political Difference in Nancy, Lefort, Badiou and Laclau.Edinburgh:Edinburgh UP.
29. Merrifield, Andy(2013).The Politics of the Encounter: Urban Theory and Protest under Planetary Urbanization.Athens:U of Georgia P.
30. Merrifield, Andy(2011).Magical Marxism: Subversive Politics and the Imagination.London:Pluto.
31. Newman, Saul(2011).The Politics of Postanarchism.Edinburgh:Edinburgh UP.
32. Noys, Benjamin(2008).Through a Glass Darkly: Alain Badiou's Critique of Anarchism.Anarchist Studies,16(2),107-120.
33. Pfeifer, Geoff(2015).The New Materialism: Althusser, Badiou, and Žižek.New York:Routledge.
34. Riera, Gabriel(ed.)(2005).Alain Badiou: Philosophy and Its Conditions.Albany:State U of New York.
35. Rousselle, Duane(ed.),Evren, Süreyyya(ed.)(2011).Post-Anarchism: A Reader.London:Pluto P.
36. The Invisible Committee(2009).The Coming Insurrection.Los Angeles:Semiotext(e).
37. The Invisible Committee(2015).To Our Friends.Los Angeles:Semiotext(e).
38. Tiqqun,Galloway, Alexander R.(trans.),Smith, Jason E.(trans.)(2010).Introduction to Civil War.Los Angeles:Semiotext(e).
39. Wilson, Japhy(ed.),Swyngedouw, Erik(ed.)(2015).The Post-political and Its Discontents: Spaces of Depoliticisation, Spectres of Radical Politics.Edinburgh:Edinburgh UP.
40. 松本哉, Hajime,陳炯霖（譯）, Chiung-lin(trans.)(2012).素人之亂.台北=Taipei:推守文化=Pushing Hanz.

1. 劉紀蕙(2018)。為什麼在台灣討論巴迪烏？。中外文學，47(3)，13-19。
2. 蘇偉貞(2019)。另類時間：童偉格《西北雨》、林俊頴《我不可告人的鄉愁》的（不）返鄉路徑。臺灣文學學報，35，1-33。