大笑益生論：幽默的生命經濟與社會身體

Laughter as Therapy: The Animal Economy and the Social Body of Humor

10.6637/CWLQ.202009_49(3).0005

陳麒方(Chi-Fang Chen)

大笑 ； 生命經濟 ； 社會身體 ； 政體 ； 人本主義 ； 《項狄傳》 ； 《憨弗雷．克林克出遊記》 ； laughter ； animal economy ； social body ； body politic ； humanism ； Tristram Shandy ； Humphry Clinker

中外文學

49卷3期（2020 / 09 / 30）

105 - 144

繁體中文

今日風行於流行文化的「笑療法」，配合人本主義意識形態的思想遺產，已成為一個跨領域的文化工業。本文耙梳大笑養生思想的歷史文化起源，探討十八世紀生理論述如何為一個新興文化典範立基。在此體系中，「生命經濟」提供理解大笑行為的理路：藉由大笑引發的身體運動排除廢物、加速身體循環，並治療各種心疾，以促進健康。以此為基礎，「大笑益生論」試圖將個體健康平順地轉譯為社會健康，並成為文學和文化市場中自我指涉的商品：它將喜劇中反經濟的消耗、混亂轉為開懷的資源，規避其複雜社會衝突的政治文本。本文將閱讀《項狄傳》與《憨弗雷．克林克出遊記》以探究是類論述在文學語言的介質中所隱含的反諷與難題。

Laughter therapy, assisted by humanist ideologies, has become a massive cultural industry. This article traces the cultural origins of the idea of medicinal laughter in the eighteenth century, addressing the ways in which physiological discourse shaped an emergent cultural paradigm. In such system, ＂animal economy＂ laid a foundation for conceiving laughter in terms of bodily movement and circulation that were believed to promote physical and mental health. On this basis, laughter as therapy sought a smooth translation from personal health to social health. In this sense, it can be seen as a solution to the problems of comedy, transforming the waste and chaos in it into resources of mirth, while complex political texts of social conflict were sidestepped. In this way, laughter's status as a self-referential commodity was established in the literary and cultural market. This article reads The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy and The Expedition of Humphry Clinker to investigate the ironies and conundrums of such discourses in the medium of literary language.

1. The Comick Magazine; Or, Compleat Library of Mirth, Humour, Wit, Gaiety, and Entertainment. London, 1797.
2. Laugh and Be Fat; Or Food for All Parties. London, 1793.
3. Yorick’s Jests: Or, Wit’s Common-place Book, Arranged on a New Plan. London, 1783.
4. Addison, Joseph,Bond, Donald F.(Ed.)(1965).The Spectator.Oxford:Oxford UP.
5. Addison, Joseph,Bond, Donald F.(Ed.)(1965).The Spectator.Oxford:Oxford UP.
6. Addison, Joseph,Bond, Donald F.(Ed.)(1965).The Spectator.Oxford:Oxford UP.
7. Addison, Joseph,Bond, Donald F.(Ed.)(1965).The Spectator.Oxford:Oxford UP.
8. Addison, Joseph,Bond, Donald F.(Ed.)(1965).The Spectator.Oxford:Oxford UP.
9. Alves, Kathleen Tamayo(2015).‘What Pleasure We Scullers Have’: Humour, Menstruation and Literacy in Smollett’s Humphry Clinker.Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies,38,349-360.
10. Bakhtin, Mikhail,Iswolsky, Helene(Trans.)(1984).Rabelais and His World.Bloomington:Indiana UP.
11. Beattie, James. Dissertations Moral and Critical. London, 1783.
12. Beattie, James. Essay on Ludicrous Composition. 3rd ed. London, 1779.
13. Boswell, James,Hill, George B.(Ed.),Powell, L. F.(Ed.)(1934).Boswell’s Life of Johnson.Oxford:Oxford UP.
14. Butler, Samuel. Characters and Passages from Note-Books. Ed. A. R. Waller. Cambridge, 1908.
15. Chen, Chi-Fang(2017).U of Warwick.
16. Chesterfield, Philip Dormer Stanhope, 4th Earl of. Lord Chesterfield’s Advice to His Son, on Men and Manners: Or, a New System of Education. 2nd ed. London, 1775.
17. Cheyne, George. An Essay of Health and Long Life. London, 1725.
18. Cheyne, George. The English Malady. London, 1733.
19. Cumberland, Richard. A Treatise of the Laws of Nature. Trans. James Maxwell. London, 1727.
20. D’Israeli, Isaac. Flim-Flams! Or, The Life and Errors of My Uncle, and the Amours of my Aunt! With Illustrations and Obscurities, by Messieurs Tag, Rag, and Bobtail. With an Illuminating Index. 2nd ed. 3 vols. London: John Murray, 1806.
21. Descartes, Rene,Voss, Stephen H.(Trans.)(1989).The Passions of the Soul.Indianapolis:Hackett.
22. Farifteh, S.,Mohammadi-Aria, A.,Kiamanesh, A.,Mofid, B.(2014).The Impact of Laughter Yoga on the Stress of Cancer Patients before Chemotherapy.Iranian Journal of Cancer Prevention,7(4),179-183.
23. Fielding, Henry,Brooks-Davies, Douglas(Ed.)(1970).The History of the Adventures of Joseph Andrews and of His Friend Mr. Abraham Andrews; and, An Apology for the Life of Mrs. Shamela Andrews.Oxford:Oxford UP.
24. Franta, Andrew(2016).From Map to Network in Humphry Clinker.ELH,83,771-793.
25. Gatrell, Vic(2006).City of Laughter: Sex and Satire in Eighteenth-Century London.London:Atlantic.
26. George Cheyne(1991).The English Malady.London:Routledge.
27. Hobbes, Thomas,Tuck, Richard(Ed.)(1996).Leviathan.Cambridge:Cambridge UP.
28. Huneman, Philippe(2007).‘Animal Economy’: Anthropology and the Rise of Psychiatry from the ‘Encyclopedie’ to the Alienists.The Anthropology of the Enlightenment,Stanford:
29. Hutcheson, Francis. Reflection upon Laughter. Glasgow: Daniel Baxter, 1750.
30. Ione, Amy(2016).Art and the Brain: Plasticity, Embodiment, and the Unclosed Circle.Leiden:Brill.
31. Kames, Henry Home. Elements of Criticism. 2 vols. Edinburgh, 1762.
32. Kataria, Madan(1995).Laugh for No Reason.Mumbai:Madhuri International.
33. Kataria, Madan(2020).Laughter Yoga: Daily Laughter Practices for Health and Happiness.New York:Penguin.
34. Keymer, Thomas(2002).Sterne, the Moderns, and the Novel.Oxford:Oxford UP.
35. Landers, Matthew(2017).Anatomy, the Brain, and Memory in Tristram Shandy: A Forensic Examination of Sterne’s Narrative Structure.Configurations,25,397-414.
36. Lynes, L.,Kawar, L.,Valdez, R. M.(2019).Can Laughter Yoga Provide Stress Relief for Clinical Nurses?.Nursing Management,50(6),30-37.
37. Mandeville, Bernard. The Fable of the Bees: Or, Private Vices, Public Benefits. London, 1714.
38. McKeon, Michael(2003).Aestheticizing the Critique of Luxury: Smollett’s Humphry Clinker.Luxury in the Eighteenth Century: Debates, Desires and Delectable Goods,Basingstoke:
39. McNabb, Jody(2014).Thomas Willis: The Faculties and His Two Cognitive Frameworks.Brain and Cognition,91,131-137.
40. Mora-Ripoll, R.(2010).The Therapeutic Value of Laughter in Medicine.Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine,16(6),56-64.
41. Myer, Valerie Grosvenor(1984).Tristram and the Animal Spirit.Laurence Sterne: Riddles and Mysteries,London:
42. Pare, Ambroise. The Workes of That Famous Chirurgion Ambrose Parey. Trans. Thomas Johnson. London, 1634.
43. Parnell, J. T.(1994).Swift, Sterne, and the Skeptical Tradition.Studies in Eighteenth Century Culture,23,221-242.
44. Pasanek, Brad(2015).Metaphors of Mind: An Eighteenth-Century Dictionary.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins UP.
45. Poovey, Mary(1995).Making a Social Body: British Cultural Formation, 1830-1864.Chicago:U of Chicago P.
46. Porter, Roy(1984).Against the Spleen.Laurence Sterne: Riddles and Mysteries,London:
47. Porter, Roy(1991).English Society in the Eighteenth Century.London:Penguin.
48. Porter, Roy(1998).The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity.New York:Norton.
49. Porter, Roy(2001).Bodies Politic: Disease, Death, and Doctors in Britain, 1650-1900.Ithaca:Cornell UP.
50. Provine, Robert(2012).Curious Behavior: Yawning, Laughing, Hiccupping, and Beyond.London:Belknap.
51. Provine, Robert(2000).Laughter: A Scientific Investigation.New York:Viking.
52. Sekora, John(1977).Luxury: The Concept in Western Thought, Eden to Smollett.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins UP.
53. Sheridan, Richard Brinsley,Stern, Tiffany(Ed.)(2004).The Rivals.London:A & C Black.
54. Smollett, Tobias,Thorson, James L.(Ed.)(1983).The Expedition of Humphry Clinker.London:Norton.
55. Sterne, Laurence,New, Melvyn(Ed.),New, Joan(Ed.)(1997).The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman.London:Penguin.
56. Swift, Jonathan. A Tale of a Tub. London, 1704.
57. Sypher, Wylie(Ed.)(1956).Comedy.Hempstead:Doubleday Anchor.
58. Watts, Carol(2007).The Cultural Work of Empire: The Seven Year’s War and the Imagining of the Shandean State.Edinburgh:Edinburgh UP.
59. Whytt, Robert. On the Vital and Other Involuntary Motions of Animals. Edinburgh, 1751.