Sex Difference in Draft-Legal Ultra-Distance Events- A Comparison between Ultra-Swimming and Ultra-Cycling

10.4077/CJP.2016.BAE373

Lejla Salihu；Christoph Alexander Rüst；Thomas Rosemann；Beat Knechtle

athlete ； performance ； sex difference ； swimming

The Chinese Journal of Physiology

59卷2期（2016 / 04 / 30）

87 - 99

英文

Recent studies reported that the sex difference in performance in ultra-endurance sports such as swimming and cycling changed over the years. However, the aspect of drafting in draft-legal ultraendurance races has not yet been investigated. This study investigates the sex difference in ultraswimming and ultra-cycling draft-legal races where drafting- swimming or cycling behind other participants to save energy and have more power at the end of the race to overtake them, is allowed. The change in performance of the annual best and the annual three best in an ultra-endurance swimming race (16-km 'Faros Swim Marathon') over 38 years and in a 24-h ultra-cycling race ('World Cycling Race') over 13 years were compared and analysed with respect to sex difference. Furthermore, performances of the fastest female and male finishers ever were compared. In the swimming event, the sex difference of the annual best male and female decreased non-significantly (P = 0.262) from 5.3% (1976) to 1.0% (2013). The sex gap of speed in the annual three fastest swimmers decreased significantly (P = 0.043) from 5.9 ± 1.6% (1979) to 4.7 ± 3.1% (2013). In the cycling event, the difference in cycling speed between the annual best male and female decreased significantly (P = 0.026) from 33.31% (1999) to 10.89% (2011). The sex gap of speed in the annual three fastest decreased significantly (P = 0.001) from 32.9 ± 0.6% (1999) to 16.4 ± 5.9% (2011). The fastest male swimmer ever (swimming speed 5.3 km/h, race time: 03:01:55 h:min:s) was 1.5% faster than the fastest female swimmer (swimming speed 5.2 km/h, race time: 03:04:09 h:min:s). The three fastest male swimmers ever (mean 5.27 ± 0.13 km/h) were 4.4% faster than the three fastest female swimmers (mean 5.05 ± 0.20 km/h) (P ＜ 0.05). In the cycling event, the best male ever (cycling speed 45.8 km/h) was 26.4% faster than the best female (cycling speed 36.1 km/h). The three fastest male cyclists ever (45.9 km/h) (mean 45.85 ± 0.05 km/h) were 32.1% faster (P ＜ 0.05) than the three fastest female cyclists ever (34.7 km/h) (mean 34.70 ± 1.87 km/h). In summary, in draft-legal ultra-distance events such as swimming and cycling, the sex difference in the annual top and annual top three swimmers and cyclists decreased (i.e. non-linearly in swimmers and linearly in cyclists) over the years. The sex difference of the fastest athletes ever was smaller in swimming (1.5%) than in cycling (26.4%). This finding is different from reports about races where drafting was not possible or even prohibited and where the sex difference remained stable over years.

1. Herbst, L.,Knechtle, B.,Lopez, C.L.,Andonie, J.L.,Fraire, O.S.,Kohler, G.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.(2011).Pacing strategy and change in body composition during a Deca Iron triathlon.Chinese J. Physiol.,54,255-263.
   連結：
2. Knechtle, B.,Knechtle, P.,Rosemann, T.(2011).No case of exerciseassociated hyponatremia in male ultra-endurance mountain bikers in the 'Swiss Bike Masters'.Chinese J. Physiol.,54,379-384.
   連結：
3. Knechtle, B.,Wirth, A.,Knechtle, P.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2012).No improvement in race performance by naps in male ultra-endurance cyclists in a 600-km ultra-cycling race.Chinese J. Physiol.,55,125-133.
   連結：
4. Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, B.,Knechtle, P.,Rosemann, T.(2012).Higher prevalence of exercise-associated hyponatremia in triple iron ultra-triathletes than reported for ironman triathletes.Chinese J. Physiol.,55,147-155.
   連結：
5. Brannigan, D.,Rogers, I.R.,Jacobs, I.,Montgomery, A.,Williams, A.,Khangure N.(2009).Hypothermia is a significant medical risk of mass participation long-distance open water swimming.Wilderness Environ. Med.,20,14-18.
6. Cheuvront, S.N.,Carter, R.,Deruisseau, K.C.,Moffatt, R.J.(2005).Running performance differences between men and women: an update.Sports Med.,35,1017-1024.
7. Coast, J.R.,Blevins, J.S.,Wilson, B.A.(2004).Do gender differences in running performance disappear with distance?.Can. J. Appl. Physiol.,29,139-145.
8. Da Fonseca-Engelhardt, K.,Knechtle, B.,Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, P.,Lepers, R.,Rosemann, T.(2013).Participation and performance trends in ultra-endurance running races under extreme conditions - 'Spartathlon' versus 'Badwater'.Extrem. Physiol. Med.,2,15.
9. Deaner, R.O.(2013).Distance running as an ideal domain for showing a sex difference in competitiveness.Arch. Sex. Behav.,42,413-428.
10. Deaner, R.O.(2011).More men run relatively fast in U.S. road races, 1981-2006: a stable sex difference in non-elite runners.Evol. Psychol.,9,600-621.
11. Eichenberger, E.,Knechtle, B.,Knechtle, P.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2012).Best performances by men and women openwater swimmers during the 'English Channel Swim' from 1900 to 2010.J. Sports Sci.,30,1295-1301.
12. Eichenberger, E.,Knechtle, B.,Knechtle, P.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.,Senn, O.(2013).Sex difference in open-water ultraswim performance in the longest freshwater lake swim in Europe.J. Strength Cond. Res.,27,1362-1369.
13. Eichenberger, E.,Knechtle, B.,Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, P.,Lepers, R.,Rosemann, T.(2012).No gender difference in peak performance in ultra-endurance swimming performance - analysis of the 'Zurich 12-h Swim' from 1996 to 2010.Chinese J. Physiol.,55,346-351.
14. Fischer, G.,Knechtle, B.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.(2013).Male swimmers cross the English Channel faster than female swimmers.Scand. J. Med. Sci. Sports.,23,e48-e55.
15. Gallmann, D.,Knechtle, B.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2014).Elite triathletes in 'Ironman Hawaii' get older but faster.Age,36,407-416.
16. Hoffman, M.D.(2010).Performance trends in 161-km ultramarathons.Int. J. Sports Med.,31,31-37.
17. Jürgens, D.,Knechtle, B.,Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, P.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2012).An analysis of participation and performance by nationality at 'Ironman Switzerland' from 1995 to 2011.J. Sci. Cycling,1,10-20.
18. Keatinge, W.R.,Khartchenko, M.,Lando, N.,Lioutov, V.(2001).Hypothermia during sports swimming in water below 11 degrees C.Brit. J. Sports Med.,35,352-353.
19. Knechtle, B.,Baumann, B.,Knechtle, P.,Rosemann, T.(2010).Speed during training and anthropometric measures in relation to raceperformance by male and female open-water ultra-endurance swimmers.Percept. Mot. Skills,111,463-474.
20. Knechtle, B.,Christinger, N.,Kohler, G.,Knechtle, P.,Rosemann, T.(2009).Swimming in ice cold water.Ir. J. Med. Sci.,178,507-511.
21. Knechtle, B.,Knechtle, P.,Lepers, R.(2011).Participation and performance trends in ultra-triathlons from 1985 to 2009.Scand. J. Med. Sci. Sports.,21,82-90.
22. Knechtle, B.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.,Rüst, C.A.(2014).Women outperform men in ultra-distance swimming - The 'Manhattan Island Marathon Swim' from 1983 to 2013.Int. J. Sports Physiol. Perform.,9,913-924.
23. Krouse, R.Z.,Ransdell, L.B.,Lucas, S.M.,Pritchard, M.E.(2011).Motivation, goal orientation, coaching, and training habits of women ultrarunners.J. Strength Cond. Res.,25,2835-2842.
24. Lavoie, J.M.,Montpetit, R.R.(1986).Applied physiology of swimming.Sports Med.,3,165-189.
25. Lepers, R.(2008).Analysis of Hawaii ironman performances in elite triathletes from 1981 to 2007.Med. Sci. Sports Exerc.,40,1828-1834.
26. Lepers, R.,Maffiuletti, N.A.(2011).Age and gender interactions in ultraendurance performance: insight from the triathlon.Med. Sci. Sports Exerc.,43,134-139.
27. Lynch, S.L.,Hoch, A.Z.(2010).The female runner: gender specifics.Clin. Sports Med.,29,477-498.
28. McLean, S.P.,Hinrichs, R.N.(1998).Sex differences in the centre of buoyancy location of competitive swimmers.J. Sports Sci.,16,373-383.
29. Pate, R.R.,Sparling, P.B.,Wilson, G.E.,Cureton, K.J.,Miller, B.J.(1987).Cardiorespiratory and metabolic responses to submaximal and maximal exercise in elite women distance runners.Int. J. Sports Med.,8,91-95.
30. Pendergast, D.R.,Di Prampero, P.E.,Craig, A.B.,Wilson, D.R.,Rennie, D.W.(1977).Quantitative analysis of the front crawl in men and women.J. Appl. Physiol.,43,475-479.
31. Pyne, D.B.,Trewin, C.B.,Hopkins, W.G.(2004).Progression and variability of competitive performance of Olympic swimmers.J. Sports Sci.,22,613-620.
32. Reaburn, P.,Dascombe, B.(2008).Endurance performance in masters athletes.Eur. Rev. Aging Phys. Act.,5,31-42.
33. Reinboud, W.(2004).Linear models can't keep up with sport gender gap.Nature,432,147.
34. Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, B.,Knechtle. P.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2013).Sex differences in ultra-triathlon performance at increasing race distance.Percept. Mot. Skills,116,1-17.
35. Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, B.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2014).Women reduced the sex difference in open-water ultra-distance swimming. La Traversée international du Lac St-Jean1955-2012.Appl. Physiol. Nutr. Metab.,39,270-273.
36. Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, B.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2013).Men cross America faster than women - the 'Race across America' (RAAM) from 1982 to 2012.Int. J. Sports Physiol. Perform.,8,611-617.
37. Rüst, C.A.,Lepers, R.,Rosemann, T.,Knechtle, B.(2014).Will women soon outperform men in open-water ultra-distance swimming in the 'Maratona del Golfo Capri-Napoli'?.Springerplus,3,86.
38. Rüst, C.A.,Lepers, R.,Stiefel, M.,Rosemann, T.,Knechtle, B.(2013).Performance in Olympic triathlon: changes in performance of elite female and male triathletes in the ITU World Triathlon Series from 2009 to 2012.Springerplus,2,685.
39. Tanaka, H.,Seals, D.R.(1997).Age and gender interactions in physiological functional capacity: insight from swimming performance.J. Appl. Physiol.,82,846-851.
40. Teutsch, A.,Rüst, C.A.,Knechtle, B.,Knechtle, P.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2013).Differences in age and performance in 12-h and 24-h ultra-runners.Adapt. Med.,5,138-146.
41. Thibault, V.,Guillaume, M.,Berthelot, G.,El Helou, N.,Schaal, K.,Quinquis, L.,Nassif, H.,Tafflet, M.,Escolano, S.,Hermine, O.,Toussaint, J.F.(2010).Women and men in sport performance: the gender gap has not evolved since 1983.J. Sports Sci. Med.,9,214-223.
42. Toussaint, H.M.,de Groot, G.,Savelberg, H.H.,Vervoorn, K.,Hollander, A.P.,van Ingen Schenau, G.J.(1988).Active drag related to velocity in male and female swimmers.J. Biomech.,21,435-438.
43. Weitkunat, T.,Knechtle, B.,Knechtle, P.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.(2012).Body composition and hydration status changes in male and female open-water swimmers during an ultra-endurance event.J. Sports Sci.,30,1003-1013.
44. Zamparo, P.(2006).Effects of age and gender on the propelling efficiency of the arm stroke.Eur. J. Appl. Physiol.,97,52-58.
45. Zingg, M.,Knechtle, B.,Rüst, C.A.,Rosemann, T.,Lepers, R.(2013).Age and gender difference in non-drafting ultra-endurance cycling performance - the 'Swiss Cycling Marathon'.Extrem. Physiol. Med.,2,18.
46. Zouhal, H.,Ben Abderrahman, A.,Prioux, J.,Knechtle, B.,Bounguerra, L.,Kebsi, W.,Noakes, T.D.(2015).Drafting's improvement of 3000-m running performance in elite athletes: is it a placebo effect?.Int. J. Sports Physiol. Perform.,10,147-152.