Low-Intensity Exercise with Blood Flow Restriction Increases Muscle Strength without Altering hsCRP and Fibrinogen Levels in Healthy Subjects

10.4077/CJP.2018.BAG567

Hening Laswati；David Sugiarto；Dewi Poerwandari；Jahja Alex Pangkahila；Hiroaki Kimura

blood flow restriction ； fibrinogen ； hsCRP ； muscle strength ； resistance training

The Chinese Journal of Physiology

61卷3期（2018 / 06 / 30）

188 - 195

英文

Strengthening exercise combined with blood flow restriction potentially increases muscle strength. This type of exercise does not require heavy weight liftings and is a feasible method to be performed by persons suffering illnesses. However, strengthening exercise may induce inflammatory responses due to muscle and vascular endothelial damage. This study aimed to investigate alterations of high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP) and fibrinogen levels in healthy subjects after five weeks of low intensity resistance training (LIRT) with blood flow restriction (BFR) on increasing strength in comparison with high intensity resistance training (HIRT) and LIRT alone, and to evaluate aspects related to the relative safety of LIRT + BFR. Eighteen healthy subjects were randomized into 3 groups. The HIRT group: 70% of One-Repetition Maximum (1-RM); LIRT + BFR group: 30% of 1-RM with BFR (a modified 13-cm wide cuff was used); LIRT group: 30% of 1-RM. The peak torque of isokinetic contraction of the left elbow flexor in each subject was measured before and after 5 weeks of resistance exercises to determine any increases in the left biceps brachii muscle strength. Blood markers of homeostasis (fibrinogen) and inflammation (hsCRP) were also measured before and after five weeks of training. Significant increases of strength were demonstrated between the five weeks of resistance exercises in the HIRT group (P = 0.003) and the LIRT + BFR group (P = 0.001). Peak torque of isokinetic contraction of the left flexor elbow joint at 60° per second angular velocity showed that the LIRT + BFR group produced the greatest peak torque increase than the HIRT group. There were no significant changes in the hsCRP levels in all the groups (P ＞ 0.05) after five weeks of intervention. No significant differences of fibrinogen levels were found in the HIRT group (P = 0.500) and the LIRT + BFR group (P = 0.405), but significant decreases were found in the fibrinogen levels in the LIRT group (P = 0.017). The LIRT + BFR increases in the muscle strength were as significant as in HIRT without altering the fibrinogen and hsCRP levels in the healthy subjects. In this study, LIRT + BFR showed increase muscle strength without any vascular problems.

1. Bizheh, N.,Jaafari, M.(2011).The effect of a single bout circuit resistance exercise on homocysteine, hs-CRP and fibrinogen in sedentary middle aged men.Irian. J. Basic Med. Sci.,14,568-573.
2. Clark, B.C.,Manini, T.M.,Hoffman, R.L.,Williams, P.S.,Guiler, M.K.,Knutson, M.J.,McGLynn, M.L.,Kushnick, M.R.(2011).Relative safety of 4 weeks of blood flow-restricted resistance exercise in young, healthy adults.Scand. J. Med. Sci. Sports,21,653-662.
3. Corban, M.T.,Hung, O.Y.,Mekonnen, G.,Eshtehardi, P.,Eapen, D.J.,Rasoul-Arzumly, E.,Kassem, H.A.,Manocha, P.,Ko, Y.A.,Sperling, L.S.,Quyyumi, A.A.,Samady, H.(2016).Elevated levels of serum fibrin and fibrinogen degradation products are independent predictors of larger coronary plaques and greater plaques necrotic core.Circ. J.,80,931-937.
4. Horiuchi, M.,Okita, K.(2012).Blood flow restricted exercise and vascular function.Int. J. Vasc. Med.,2012,17.
5. Kasapis, C.,Thompson, P.D.(2005).The effects of physical activity on serum C-reactive protein and inflammatory markers.J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.,45,1563-1569.
6. Kawada, S.(2005).What phenomena do occur in blood flow-restricted muscle?.Int. J. KAATSU Training Res.,1,37-44.
7. Kubota, A.,Sakuraba, K.,Koh, S.,Ogura, Y.,Tamura, Y.(2011).Blood flow restriction by low compressive force prevents disuse muscular weakness.J. Sci. Med. Sport,14,95-99.
8. Loenneke, J.P.,Wilson, J.M.,Wilson, G.J.,Pujol, T.J.,Bemben, M.G.(2011).Potential safety issues with blood flow restriction training.Scand. J. Med. Sci. Sports,21,510-518.
9. Madarame, H.,Kurano, M.,Fuku mura, K.,Fukuda, T.,Nakajima, T.(2013).Haemostatic and inflammatory responses to blood flow-restricted exercise in patients with ischaemic heart disease: a pilot study.Clin. Physiol. Funct. Imaging,33,11-17.
10. Nakajima, T.,Kurano, M.,Iida, H.,Takano, H.,Oonuma, H.,Morita, T.,Meguro, K.,Sato, Y.,Nagata, T.,KATTSU Training Group(2006).Use and safety of KAATSU training: Results of a national survey.Int. J. KAATSU Training Res.,2,5-13.
11. Park, S.,Lakatta, E.G.(2012).Role of inflammation in the pathogenesis of arterial stiffness.Yonsei Med. J.,53,258-261.
12. Reihart, W.H.(2003).Fibrinogen-marker or mediator of vascular disease?.Vasc. Med.,8,211-216.
13. Schott, J.,McCully, K.,Rutherford, O.M.(1995).The role of metabolites in strength training. II. Short versus long isometric contractions.Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. Occup. Physiol.,71,337-341.
14. Scott, B.R.,Loenneke, J.P.,Slattery, K.M.,Dascombe, B.J.(2015).Exercise with blood flow restriction: an updated evidence-based approach for enhanced muscular development.Sports Med.,45,313-325.
15. Spronk, H.M.H.,van der Voort, D.,ten Cate, H.(2004).Blood coagulation and the risk of atherothrombosis: a complex relationship.Thromb. J.,2,12.
16. Sugiarto, D.,Andriati, A.,Laswati, H.,Kimura, H.(2017).Comparison of the increase of both muscle strength and hypertrophy of biceps brachii muscle in strengthening exercise with lowintensity resistance training with and without the application of blood flow restriction and high-intensity resistance training.Bali Med. J.,6,251-257.
17. Sumide, T.,Sakuraba, K.,Sawakib, K.,Ohmurac, H.,Tamurad, Y.(2009).Effect of resistance exercise training combined with relatively low vascular occlusion.J. Sci. Med. Sport,12,107-112.
18. Yasuda, T.,Fukumura, K.,Tomaru, T.,Nakajima, T.(2016).Thigh muscle size and vascular function after blood flow-restricted elastic band training in older women.Oncotarget,7,33595-33607.