Sex Differences and the Modulating Effects of Gonad Intactness on Behavioral Conformity in a Mouse Model

10.4103/CJP.CJP_42_19

Chianfang G. Cherng；Lung Yu

Conformity ； decision-making behavior ； glucocorticoids ； operant conditioning ； orchidectomy ； ovariectomy ； sex difference

The Chinese Journal of Physiology

62卷6期（2019 / 12 / 31）

245 - 255

英文

Although gender differences in conformity are noticed in human studies, cultural norms and psychosocial factors inevitably affect such differences. Biological factors, especially the gonadal hormones and the brain regions involved, contributing to the sex differences in behavioral conformity remained scarcely explored. To prevent psychosocial and cultural norm confounds, intact and gonadectomized male and female mice were used to assess the modulating effects of gonadal hormones on behavioral conformity and such conformity-related brain regions using an approach of choice paradigm. Intact and gonadectomized mice' choices for the nonrewarded runway were assessed when these experimental mice were alone versus with a group, consisting of three same-sex noncagemates choosing the respective experimental mice' nonrewarded runway, in a double-J-shaped maze test. Although male and female mice exhibited comparable rewarded runway choices at the conclusion of the operant training procedures and in the test individually, male mice demonstrated greater conformity index as compared to female mice when group tested. Gonadectomy, done at their 4 or 9 weeks of age, decreased males' conformity index but did not affect females' when both sexes were group tested. Such gonadectomy did not affect the conditioning or conformity index when tested individually in either sex. Female mice had higher serum corticosterone (CORT) levels when group tested as compared to the female mice tested individually and male mice. Finally, the number of FOS-staining cells in high conformity-displaying mice was found less than it in the low conformity-performing mice in the nucleus accumbens. Taken together, we conclude that testis-derived hormones, at least, play a role in enhancing behavioral conformity in male mice. CORT and nucleus accumbal neuronal activity deserve further investigation for their involvement in behavioral conformity.

1. Altabbaa, G,Beran, T,Kaba, A(2014).Safety in numbers: Are physicians really being "helpful" by going with the flow?.Acad Med,89,1580-1581.
2. Anderson, LC,Petrovich, GD(2017).Sex specific recruitment of a medial prefrontal cortex-hippocampal-thalamic system during context-dependent renewal of responding to food cues in rats.Neurobiol Learn Mem,139,11-21.
3. Andreano, JM,Arjomandi, H,Cahill, L(2008).Menstrual cycle modulation of the relationship between cortisol and long-term memory.Psychoneuroendocrinology,33,874-882.
4. Andreano, JM,Cahill, L(2009).Sex influences on the neurobiology of learning and memory.Learn Mem,16,248-266.
5. Asch, SE(1956).Studies of independence and conformity. A minority of one against a unanimous majority.Psychol Monog,70,1-70.
6. Baron, RS,Hoppe, SI,Kao, CF,Brunsman, B,Linneweh, B,Rogers, D(1996).Social corroboration and opinion extremity.J Exp Soc Psychol,32,537-560.
7. Beran, T,Drefs, M,Kaba, A,Al Baz, N,Al Harbi, N(2015).Conformity of responses among graduate students in an online environment.Internet High Educ,25,63-69.
8. Beran, TN,Kaba, A,Caird, J,McLaughlin, K(2014).The good and bad of group conformity: A call for a new programme of research in medical education.Med Educ,48,851-859.
9. Beran, TN,McLaughlin, K,Al Ansari, A,Kassam, A(2013).Conformity of behaviors among medical students: Impact on performance of knee arthrocentesis in simulation.Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract,18,589-596.
10. Bond, CJ(2005).A culture of ill health: Public health or aboriginality?.Med J Aust,183,39-41.
11. Bond, MH,Smith, PB(1996).Cross-cultural social and organizational psychology.Annu Rev Psychol,47,205-235.
12. Bond, R,Smith, PB(1996).Culture and conformity: A meta-analysis of studies using Asch's (1952b, 1956) line judgment task.Psychol Bull,119,111.
13. Bowman, RE,Kelly, R(2012).Chronically stressed female rats show increased anxiety but no behavioral alterations in object recognition or placement memory: A preliminary examination.Stress,15,524-532.
14. Chen, LS,Tzeng, WY,Chuang, JY,Cherng, CG,Gean, PW,Yu, L(2014).Roles of testosterone and amygdaloid LTP induction in determining sex differences in fear memory magnitude.Horm Behav,66,498-508.
15. Cherng, CG,Wang, CY,Lai, YT,Tzeng, WY,Chen, LH,Tsai, YN(2014).Anticipated, intense risk enhances behavioral conformity in a mouse model.Ethology,120,1035-1043.
16. Chiang, CY,Cherng, CG,Lai, YT,Fan, HY,Chuang, JY,Kao, GS(2009).Medial prefrontal cortex and nucleus accumbens core are involved in retrieval of the methamphetamine-associated memory.Behav Brain Res,197,24-30.
17. Christov-Moore, L,Simpson, EA,Coudé, G,Grigaityte, K,Iacoboni, M,Ferrari, PF(2014).Empathy: Gender effects in brain and behavior.Neurosci Biobehav Rev,46(Pt 4),604-627.
18. Cooper, HM(1979).Statistically combining independent studies: A meta-analysis of sex differences in conformity research.J Pers Soc Psychol,37,131.
19. Dougherty, LR,Guillette, LM(2018).Linking personality and cognition: A meta-analysis.Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci,373(pii),20170282.
20. Eagly, AH,Carli, LL(1981).Sex of researchers and sex-typed communications as determinants of sex differences in influenceability: A meta analysis of social influence studies.Psychol Bull,90,1.
21. Foilb, AR,Bals, J,Sarlitto, MC,Christianson, JP(2018).Sex differences in fear discrimination do not manifest as differences in conditioned inhibition.Learn Mem,25,49-53.
22. Gosling, CJ,Moutier, S(2019).Is the framing effect a framing affect?.Q J Exp Psychol,72,1412-1421.
23. Grendar, J,Beran, T,Oddone-Paolucci, E.(2018).Experiences of pressure to conform in postgraduate medical education.BMC Med Educ,18,4.
24. Griskevicius, V,Goldstein, NJ,Mortensen, CR,Cialdini, RB,Kenrick, DT(2006).Going along versus going alone: When fundamental motives facilitate strategic (non) conformity.J Pers Soc Psychol,91,281-294.
25. Guetzkow, H(ed.)(1951).Leadership and Men.Pittsburgh, PA:Carnegie Press.
26. Hajali, V,Sheibani, V,Esmaeili-Mahani, S,Shabani, M(2012).Female rats are more susceptible to the deleterious effects of paradoxical sleep deprivation on cognitive performance.Behav Brain Res,228,311-318.
27. Ho, MC,Cherng, CG,Tsai, YP,Chiang, CY,Chuang, JY,Kao, SF(2009).Chronic treatment with monoamine oxidase-B inhibitors decreases cocaine reward in mice.Psychopharmacology,205,141-149.
28. Kaba, A,Beran, TN(2016).Impact of peer pressure on accuracy of reporting vital signs: An interprofessional comparison between nursing and medical students.J Interprof Care,30,116-122.
29. Kim, YB,Huh, N,Lee, H,Baeg, EH,Lee, D,Jung, MW(2007).Encoding of action history in the rat ventral striatum.J Neurophysiol,98,3548-3556.
30. Kroshus, E,Baugh, CM,Stein, CJ,Austin, SB,Calzo, JP(2017).Concussion reporting, sex, and conformity to traditional gender norms in young adults.J Adolesc,54,110-119.
31. Lewis, PJ,Tully, MP(2009).Uncomfortable prescribing decisions in hospitals: The impact of teamwork.J R Soc Med,102,481-488.
32. Luo, Y,Eickhoff, SB,Hétu, S,Feng, C(2018).Social comparison in the brain: A coordinate-based meta-analysis of functional brain imaging studies on the downward and upward comparisons.Hum Brain Mapp,39,440-458.
33. Panksepp, JB,Jochman, KA,Kim, JU,Koy, JJ,Wilson, ED,Chen, Q(2007).Affiliative behavior, ultrasonic communication and social reward are influenced by genetic variation in adolescent mice.PLoS One,2,e351.
34. Pizzimenti, CL,Navis, TM,Lattal, KM(2017).Persistent effects of acute stress on fear and drug-seeking in a novel model of the comorbidity between post-traumatic stress disorder and addiction.Learn Mem,24,422-431.
35. Rajab, E,Alqanbar, B,Naiser, MJ,Abdulla, HA,Al-Momen, MM,Kamal, A(2014).Sex differences in learning and memory following short-term dietary restriction in the rat.Int J Dev Neurosci,36,74-80.
36. Sherif M. A study of some social factors in perception. Arch Psychol 1935;187:60.
37. Shestakova, A,Rieskamp, J,Tugin, S,Ossadtchi, A,Krutitskaya, J,Klucharev, V(2013).Electrophysiological precursors of social conformity.Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci,8,756-763.
38. Shors, TJ,Chua, C,Falduto, J(2001).Sex differences and opposite effects of stress on dendritic spine density in the male versus female hippocampus.J Neurosci,21,6292-6297.
39. Sistrunk, F,McDavid, JW(1971).Sex variable in conforming behavior.J Person Soc Psychol,17,200.
40. Stanyon, R,Bigoni, F(2014).Sexual selection and the evolution of behavior, morphology, neuroanatomy and genes in humans and other primates.Neurosci Biobehav Rev,46P4,579-590.
41. Swami, V,Chamorro-Premuzic, T,Bridges, S,Furnham, A(2009).Acceptance of cosmetic surgery: Personality and individual difference predictors.Body Image,6,7-13.
42. Ter Horst, JP,Kentrop, J,Arp, M,Hubens, CJ,de Kloet, ER,Oitzl, MS(2013).Spatial learning of female mice: Arole of the mineralocorticoid receptor during stress and the estrous cycle.Front Behav Neurosci,7,56.
43. Thanos, PK,Malave, L,Delis, F,Mangine, P,Kane, K,Grunseich, A(2016).Knockout of p11 attenuates the acquisition and reinstatement of cocaine conditioned place preference in male but not in female mice.Synapse,70,293-301.
44. Tong, A,Sainsbury, P,Craig, JC(2008).Support interventions for caregivers of people with chronic kidney disease: A systematic review.Nephrol Dial Transplant,23,3960-3965.
45. Voulo, ME,Parsons, RG(2017).Response specific sex difference in the retention of fear extinction.Learn Mem,24,245-251.
46. Wentworth Eidsaune, CL,Hennessy, MB,Claflin, DI(2016).Short term, high-dose administration of corticosterone by injection facilitates trace eyeblink conditioning in young male rats.Behav Brain Res,298,62-68.
47. Wong, A,Lohfeld, L(2008).Recertifying as a doctor in Canada: International medical graduates and the journey from entry to adaptation.Med Educ,42,53-60.
48. Yang, Z,Fu, D,Qi, Y,Zheng, Y,Li, Q,Liu, X(2018).Humor affects fairness considerations in the gain and loss contexts.Front Psychol,9,2679.
49. Yokota, S,Suzuki, Y,Hamami, K,Harada, A,Komai, S(2017).Sex differences in avoidance behavior after perceiving potential risk in mice.Behav Brain Funct,13,9.
50. Young, S,Caisey, V(2010).Mind shift, mode shift: A lifestyle approach to reducing car ownership and use based on behavioural economics and social marketing.Perspect Public Health,130,136-142.
51. Yu, L,Kuo, Y,Cherng, CG,Chen, HH,Hsu, CH(2002).Ovarian hormones do not attenuate methamphetamine-induced dopaminergic neurotoxicity in mice gonadectomized at 4 weeks postpartum.Neuroendocrinology,75,282-287.