题名

趨同與趨異世界城市的範型與世界城市的假說

并列篇名

Convergence and Divergence World City Paradigm and the Word City Hypothesis

DOI

10.6161/jgs.2008.54.02

作者

簡博秀(Bo-Xiu Titan Jian)

关键词

世界城市全球城市 ； 世界城市的假說 ； 世界城市的範型 ； 空間再層域化 ； 非世界城市 ； world city global city ； world city hypothesis ； world city paradigm ； rescaling ； non-world city

期刊名称

地理學報

卷期/出版年月

54期（2008 / 12 / 01）

页次

27 - 49

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

「世界城市」的研究成爲近來西方都市與空間研究的熱門話題，本文引用Friedmann (1995)所建議的二個類型的分析：一是「世界城市的範型」，二是「世界城市的假說」。延伸這個分類的方法，本文認爲這二項不同的研究類型在後續的研究中給予不同名詞的定義：一是所謂的世界「城市」，主要在於討論城市所具有的世界城市特徵，以及在全球城市系統所佔有的地位；另一個研究定義則是所謂的全球化的城市，它所說明的是藉由不同的政治、社會、經濟和文化等面向提供城市研究的框架。若從研究標的所發展的取向而言，前者代表了藉由全球化所凝聚的趨同效果，它說明了將世界中的所有城市藉由全球城市體系的效果放置在不同層級和不同面向，卻同一定義的世界城市範疇中；後者則從個別的城市條件與動態出發，說明這些城市與全球性之間的糾葛與邏輯，以及邁向全球化的趨異過程，其中近來許多學者所提供的空間再層域化研究正代表了這個趨勢。本文的結論則藉由兩個不同類型研究的比較，建議在世界城市理論氛圍下發展「非世界城市」研究的可能性。
英文摘要

”World City” has dominated at the urban and spatial research in the West for a couple of decades, Friedmann (1995) grouped this empirical research into two groups: one is ”world city paradigm”; and the other is ”world city hypothesis”. Based on Friedmann's argument of these two theoretical frameworks, this paper tries to denominate and accentuate the two different research themes: one is so-called ”world city-ness”, mainly analyzing the condition of world city and evaluating the position of global urban system for each candidate city; and the other is ”globalizing city”, providing a research framework for urban study from different aspects, such as economy, politic, society, and culture etc.. The former delivers a result of convergence under globalization effectively, which embodies the qualified city an identity of world city, according to different global urban hierarchies, and different aspects, but same term; and the latter, starting from each city's policy dynamic, gives an account of complexities and logic between city and globalism, and a divergent process of going to global, thus introducing ”rescaling” as a sample. Beyond this comparison between these two divisions, this paper concludes by emphasizing the potential concepts of non-world city for exploring a new way in urban and regional studies.
主题分类 人文學 > 地理及區域研究
参考文献
  1. Abu-Lughod, J. L.,Knox, P. N.,Taylor, P. J. (eds.)(1995).World Cities: in a World-economy.Cambridge:Cambridge Univ. Press.
  2. Allen, J.,Lee, R.,Wills, J. (eds.)(1997).Geographies of Economies.London:Arnold.
  3. Beauregard, R. A.(1991).Capital restructuring and the new built environment of global cities: New York and Los Angeles.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,15(1),90-105.
  4. Beaverstock, J. V.,Smith, R. G.,Taylor, P. J.(2000).Geographies of globalization: United States law firms in world cities.Urban Geography,21(2),95-120.
  5. Beaverstock, J. V.,Smith, R. G.,Taylor, P. J.(2000).World-city network: a new meta-geography?.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,90(1),123-134.
  6. Beaverstock, J. V.,Taylor, P. J.,Smith, R. G.(1999).A roster of world cities.Cities,16(6),445-458.
  7. Borja, J.,Castells, M.(1997).Local and Global: Management of Cities in the Information Age.London:United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (Habitat) and Earth-scan Publications Limited.
  8. Boyne, G. A.,Paddison, R.,Lever, W. F. (eds.)(1997).International Perspectives in Urban Studies.London:Jessica Kingsley.
  9. Brade, I.,Rudolph, R.(2004).Moscow, the global city? The position of the Russian capital within the European system of metropolitan area.Area,36(1),69-80.
  10. Brenner, N.(2000).The urban question as a scale question: reflections on Henri Lefēbvre, urban theory and the politics of scale.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,24(2),361-378.
  11. Brenner, N.(1998).Global cities, global states: global city formation and state territorial restructuring in contemporary Europe.Review of International Political Economy,5,1-37.
  12. Brenner, N.(1999).Globalisation as reterritorialisation: the rescaling of urban governance in the European Union.Urban Studies,36,431-451.
  13. Brenner, N.(1997).State territorial restructuring and the production of spatial scale: urban and regional planning in the Federal Republic of Germany, 1960-1990.Political Geography,16(4),273-306.
  14. Brenner, N.,Jessop, B.,Jones, M.,MacLeod, G. (eds.)(2003).State/ Space: A Reader.Oxford:Blackwell.
  15. Brenner, N.,Keil, R. (eds.)(2006).The Global Cities Reader.New York:Roultedge.
  16. Carroll, W. K.(2007).Global cities in the global corporate network.Environment and Planning A,39,2279-2323.
  17. Castells, M.(1989).The Informational City.Oxford:Blackwell.
  18. Castells, M.(1996).The Rise of the Network Society.Oxford:Blackwell.
  19. Clark, D.(1996).Urban World/Global City.London:Routledge.
  20. Cochrane, A.,Jonas, A.(1999).Re-imagining Berlin: world city, national capital or ordinary place?.European Urban and Regional Studies,6(2),145-164.
  21. Cox, K. R.(2004).Globalization and the politics of local and regional development: the question of convergence.Transactions of Institution British Geographer,20,179-194.
  22. Davis, D. E.(2005).Cities in global context: a brief intellectual history.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,29(1),92-109.
  23. Derudder, B.,Taylor, P. J.,Witlox, F.,Catalano, G.(2003).Hierarchical tendencies and regional patterns in the world city network: a global urban analysis of 234 cities.Regional Studies,37(9),875-886.
  24. Derudder, B.,Witlox, F.,Taylor, P. J.(2007).U.S. cities in the world city network: comparing their positions using global origins and destinations of airline passages.Urban Geography,28(1),74-91.
  25. Dick, H. W.,Rimmer, P. J.(1998).Beyond the third word city: the new urban geography of Southeast Asia.Urban Studies,35(12),2303-2321.
  26. Douglass, M.(2000).Mega-urban regions and world city formation: globalization, the economic crisis and urban policy issues in Pacific Asia.Urban Studies,37(12),2315-2335.
  27. Douglass, M.(2000).The rise and fall of world cities in the changing space-economy of globalization: comment on Peter J. Taylor`s "world cities and territorial states under conditions of contemporary globalization.".Political Geography,19(1),43-49.
  28. Fincher, R.,Jacobs, J. M. (eds.)(1998).Cities of Difference.New York:Guilford.
  29. Friedmann, J.(2001).World cities revisited: a comment.Urban Studies,38(13),2535-2536.
  30. Friedmann, J.(1987).Reply to Korff`s critique.Development and Change,18(2),493-495.
  31. Friedmann, J.(1986).The world city hypothesis.Development and Change,17(1),69-83.
  32. Friedmann, J.,Bourne, L. S.,Simmons, J. W. (eds.)(1978).Systems of Cities.New York:Oxford University Press.
  33. Friedmann, J.,Knox, P. N.,Taylor, P. J. (eds.)(1995).World Cities: in a World-economy.Cambridge:Cambridge U. Press.
  34. Friedmann, J.,Wolff, G.(1982).World city formation: an agenda for research and action.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,6(3),309-344.
  35. Fujita, K.(1991).A world city and flexible specialization: restructuring the Tokyo metropolis.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,15(2),269-284.
  36. Glassman, J.(2001).From Seattle (and Ubon) to Bangkok: the scales of resistance to corporate globalization.Environment and Planning D,19,513-533.
  37. Godfrey, B. J.(1996).Restructuring and decentralization in a world city.The Geographic Review,85,436-457.
  38. Guiseppe, D.(1997).Globalization and regional integration: the case of the Italian system.Geojournal,43(4),331-338.
  39. Hall, P.(1996).The global city.International Social Science Journal,147,15-23.
  40. Hall, P.(1966).The World Cities.London:Heinemann.
  41. Hall, P.,Lo, F.-C.,Yeung, Y.-M. (eds.)(1998).Globalization and the World of Large Cities.Tokyo:The United Nation Univ. Press.
  42. Hall, P.,Scott, A. J. (ed.)(2001).Global City-Regions: Trends, Theory, Policy.New York:Oxford University Press.
  43. Harvey, D.(1989).The Condition of Post-Modernity.Oxford:Blackwell.
  44. Hill, R. C.,Kim, J. W.(2000).Global cities and developmental states: New York, Tokyo and Seoul.Urban Studies,37(1),2167-2195.
  45. Hill, R. C.,Kim, J. W.(2001).Reply to Friedmann and Sassen.Urban Studies,38(13),2541-2542.
  46. Jessop, B.(2002).The Future of the Capitalist State.Cambridge:Polity Press.
  47. Jessop, B.(2000).The crisis of the national spatio-temporal fix and the tendential ecological dominance of globalizing capitalism.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,24(2),323-360.
  48. Jessop, B.,Amin, A. (ed.)(1994).Post-Fordism.Oxford:Blackwell.
  49. Jessop, B.,Sum, N.(2000).An entrepreneurial city in action: Hong Kong's emerging strategies in and for (inter) urban competition.Urban Studies,37(12),2287-2313.
  50. Keil, R.(1998).Globalization makes states: perspectives on local governance in the age of the world city.Review of International Political Economy,5(4),616-646.
  51. Knox, P. L.,Knox, P. N.,Taylor, P. J. (eds.)(1995).World Cities: in a World-economy.Cambridge:Cambridge Univ. Press.
  52. Knox, P. L.,Taylor, P. J. (eds.)(1995).World Cities in a World-system.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  53. Knox, P. N.,Taylor, P. J. (eds.)(1995).World Cities: in a World-economy.Cambridge:Cambridge Univ. Press.
  54. Kong, L.(2000).Introduction: Culture, economy, policy: trends and developments.Geoforum,31,285-390.
  55. Korff, R.(1987).The world city hypothesis.Development and Change,18,483-495.
  56. Krätke, S.(2001).Berlin: towards a global city?.Urban Studies,38(10),1777-1799.
  57. Lee, Y.-S.,Yeoh, B. S. A. (eds.)(2006).Globalization and the Politics of Forgetting.New York:Routledge.
  58. Lever, W. F.,Turok, I.(1999).Competitive cities: introduction to the review.Urban Studies,36(5-6),791-793.
  59. Machimura, T.(1992).The urban restructuring process in Tokyo in the 1980s: transforming Tokyo into a world city.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,16(1),114-128.
  60. Mansfield, B.(2001).Thinking through scale: the role of state governance in globalizing North Pacific fisheries.Environment and Planning A,33,1807-1827.
  61. Marcuse, P.,van Kempen, R.(2000).Globaling Cities: A New Order?.Oxford:Blackwell.
  62. Markusen, A.(1999).Fuzzy concepts, scanty evidence, policy distance: the case for rigor and policy relevance in critical regional studies.Regional Studies,33,869-884.
  63. Markusen, A.,Lee, Y.-S.,Yeoh, B. S. A. (eds.)(2006).Globalisatin and the Politics of Forgetting.New York:Routledge.
  64. Massey, D.,Bird, J.,Curtis, B.,Putnam, T.,Robertson, G.,Tickner, L. (eds.)(1993).Mapping the Future: Local Cultures, Global Change.London:Routledge.
  65. McCann, E. J.(2004).Urban political economy beyond the global city.Urban Studies,41(12),2315-2333.
  66. McDowell, L.,Perrons, D.,Fagan, C.,Ray, K.,Ward, K.(2005).The contradiction and intersections of class and gender in a global city: placing working women`s lives on the research agenda.Environment and Planning A,37,441-461.
  67. McGuirk, P. M.(2004).State, strategy and scale in the competitive city: a neo-Gramscian analysis of the governance of global Sydney.Environment and Planning A,36,1019-1043.
  68. McNeill, D.(2003).Rome, global city? Church, state and Jubilee 2000.Political Geography,22,535-556.
  69. McNeill, D.,Dowling, R.,Fagan, B.(2005).Sydney/global/city: an exploration.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,29(4),935-944.
  70. Ng, M. K.,Hills, P.(2003).World cities or great cities? A comparative study of five Asia metropolises.Cities,20(3),151-165.
  71. Nijman, J.(2007).Place-particularity and "deep analogies": a comparative essay on Miami`s rise as a world city.Urban Geography,28,92-107.
  72. Ohmae, K.(1995).The End of the Nation State.New York:The Free Press.
  73. Olds, K.(1998).Globalization and urban change: tales from Vancouver via Hong Kong.Urban Geography,19,360-385.
  74. Olds, K.(1995).Globalization and the production of new urban space: Pacific Rim mega-projects in the 20th century.Environment and Planning A,27,1713-1743.
  75. Paul, D. E.(2002).Re-scaling IPE: sub-national states and the regulation of the global political economy.Review of International Political Economy,9(3),465-489.
  76. Paul, D. E.(2005).The local politics of ‘going global': making and unmaking Minneapolis-St. Paul as a world city.Urban Studies,42(12),2103-2122.
  77. Paul, D. E.(2004).World cities as hegemonic projects: the politics of global imagineering in Montreal.Political Geography,23(3),571-596.
  78. Porter, M.(1998).On Competition.Boston:Harvard Univ. Press.
  79. Powell, W. W.(1990).Neither market nor hierarchy: network forms of organization.Research in Organizational Behavior,12,295-336.
  80. Pryke, M.(1991).An international city going 'global': spatial change in the city of London.Environment and Planning D,9(2),197-222.
  81. Purcell, M.(2002).Politics in global cities: Los Angeles charter reform and the new social movements.Environment and Planning A,34,123-142.
  82. Purcell, M.(2003).Citizenship and the right to the global city: reimagining the capitalist world order.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,20(4),697-717.
  83. Robinson, J.(2002).Global and world cities: a view from off the map.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,26(3),531-554.
  84. Robinson, J.(2005).Urban geography: world cities, or a world of cities.Progress in Human Geography,29(6),757-765.
  85. Saito, A.(2003).Global city formation in a capitalist developmental state: Tokyo and waterfront sub-centre project.Urban Studies,40(2),283-308.
  86. Sandercock, L.(1998).Towards Cosmopolis: Planning for Multicultural Cities.Toronto:John Wiley and Sons.
  87. Sassen, S.(1994).Cities in a World Economy.Thousand Oaks, CA:Pine Forge Press.
  88. Sassen, S.(2001).The Global City.Princeton, N.J.:Princeton Univ. Press.
  89. Sassen, S.(2001).Global cities and developmentalist states: how to derail what could be an interesting debate: a response to Hill and Kim.Urban Studies,38(13),2537-2540.
  90. Sassen, S.,Holston, J. (ed.)(1999).Cities and Citizenship.Durham, NC:Duke University Press.
  91. Sassen, S.,Isin, E. F. (ed.)(2000).Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  92. Sassen, S.,Scott, A. J. (ed.)(2001).Global City-Regions: Trends, Theory, Policy.New York:Oxford University Press.
  93. Sassen, S.,Yaeger, P. (ed.)(1996).The Geography of Identity.Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press.
  94. Satio, A.,Thornley, A.(2003).Shifts in Tokyo`s world city status and the urban planning response.Urban Studies,40(4),665-685.
  95. Scott, A.(1996).Regional motors of the global economy.Future,28(5),391-411.
  96. Scott, A. (ed.)(2001).Global City-Region: Trends, Theory, Policy.New York:Oxford.
  97. Shachar, A.(1994).Randstad Holland: a 'world city'?.Urban Studies,31(3),381-400.
  98. Shin, K.,Timberlake, M.(2000).World cities in Asia: cliques, centrality and connectedness.Urban Studies,37(12),2257-2285.
  99. Short, J. R.,Kim, Y.,Kuus, M.,Wells, H.(1996).The dirty little secret of world cities research: data problems in comparative analysis.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,20(4),697-717.
  100. Short, J. R.,Kim, Y.-H.(1999).Globalization and the City.Harlow:Longman.
  101. Silk, M.(2002).'Bangsa Malaysia': a global sport, the city and the mediated refurbishment of local identities.Media, Culture and Society,24,775-794.
  102. Smith, D. A.,Timberlake, M.(1995).Conceptualising and mapping the structure of the world system`s city system.Urban Studies,32(2),287-302.
  103. Smith, N.,Eskelinen, H.,Snickars, F. (eds.)(1995).Competition European Peripheries.Berlin:Springer Verlag.
  104. Smith, R. G.(2003).World city actor-networks.Progress in Human Geography,27(1),25-44.
  105. GAWC Research Bulletin 45
  106. Stoper, M.(1997).The Regional World: Territorial Development in a Global Economy.New York:Guilford.
  107. Storper, M.(1987).The post-enlightenment challenge to Marxist urban studies.Environment and Planning D,6,418-426.
  108. Swyngedouw, E.(2000).Authoritarian governance, power, and the politics of rescaling.Environment and Planning D,18,63-76.
  109. Swyngedouw, E.(1996).Reconstructing citizenship, the re-scaling of the state and the new authoritarianism: closing the Belgian miles.Urban Studies,37(12),2287-2313.
  110. Swyngedouw, E.,Cox, K. (ed.)(1997).Spaces of Globalization.New York:Guilford Press.
  111. Taylor, P. J.(2005).Leading world cities: empirical evaluations of urban nodes in multiple networks.Urban Studies,42(9),1593-1608.
  112. Taylor, P. J.(2001).Specification of the world city network.Geographical Analysis,33,181-194.
  113. Taylor, P. J.(2000).World cities and territorial states under conditions of contemporary globalization.Political Geography,19(1),5-32.
  114. Taylor, P. J.(2005).New political geographies: global civil society and global governance through world city networks.Political Geography,24(3),703-730.
  115. Taylor, P. J.(2004).World City Network: A Global Urban Analysis.London:Rouledge.
  116. Taylor, P. J.(1997).Hierarchical tendencies amongst world cities: a global research proposal.Cities,14(6),323-332.
  117. Taylor, P. J.(1999).So-called 'world cities': the evidential structure within a literature.Environment and Planning A,31,1901-1904.
  118. Taylor, P. J.,Catalano, G.,Walker, D. R. F.(2002).Measurement of the world city network.Urban Studies,39,2367-2376.
  119. Taylor, P. J.,Catalano, G.,Walker, D. R. F.(2004).Multiple globalizations: regional, global business services through world cities.The Service industries Journal,24,64-82.
  120. Taylor, P. J.,Catalano, G.,Walker, D. R. F.(2002).Exploratory analysis of world city network.Urban Studies,39,2377-2394.
  121. Taylor, P. J.,Walker, D. R. F.(2001).World cities: a first multivariate analysis of their service complexes.Urban Studies,38(1),23-47.
  122. Taylor, P. J.,Walker, D. R. F.,Catalano, G.,Hoyler, M.(2002).Diversity and power in the world city network.Cities,19(4),231-241.
  123. Todd, G.,Knox, P. N.,Taylor, P. J. (eds.)(1995).World Cities: in a World-economy.Cambridge:Cambridge Univ. Press.
  124. Tyner, J. A.(2000).Global cities and circuits of global labour: the case of Manila, Philippines.Professional Geographer,52,61-74.
  125. Uitermark, J.(2002).Re-scaling, ‘scale fragmentation' and the regulation of antagonistic relationships.Progress in Human Geography,26(6),743-765.
  126. Varsanyi, M. W.(2000).Global cities from the ground up: a response to Peter Taylor.Political Geography,19(1),33-38.
  127. Waley, P.(2007).Tokyo-as-world-city: reassessing the role of capital and the state in urban restructuring.Urban Studies,44(8),1465-1490.
  128. Walker, R. A.(2001).The social ecology of the post-Fordist/global city? Economic restructuring and socio-spatial polarization in the Toronto urban region.Urban Studies,38(3),407-447.
  129. Wang, C. H.(2003).Taipei as a global city: a theoretical and empirical examination.Urban Studies,40(2),309-334.
  130. Wang, J. H.(2004).World city formation, geopolitics and local political process: Taipei`s ambiguous development.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,28(2),384-400.
  131. Watkins, H.,Herbert, D.(2003).Cultural policy and place promotion: Swansea and Dylan Thomas.Geoforum,34,249-266.
  132. White, J. W.(1998).Old, wine, cracked bottle? Tokyo, Paris, and the global city hypothesis.Urban Affairs Review,33(4),451-461.
  133. Yeoh, B. S. A.(2005).The global culture city? spatial imagineering and politics in the (Multi) culture marketplaces of South-east Asia.Urban Studies,42(5/6),945-958.
  134. Yeoh, B. S. A.(1999).Global/ globalizing cities.Progress in Human Geography,23(4),607-616.
  135. Yeung, Y.-M.(1996).An Asia perspective on the global city.International Social Science Journal,147,25-31.
  136. Zukin, S.(1992).The best of cities, the world cities.Contemporary Sociology,21,481-484.
被引用次数
  1. 黃子倫(2021)。都市研究之後殖民都市主義取徑－理論、啟發與應用。地理學報，100，101-119。
print cancel