题名

利用公眾參與地理資訊系統協助環境資源經理中的風險溝通：以宜蘭縣無尾港水鳥保護區之社區監測為例

并列篇名

Using PPGIS to Enhance the Risk Communication in Environmental Management: A Case Study of Community-based Monitoring in the Wu-Wei-Kang Waterfowl Refuge, Yilan, Taiwan

DOI

10.6161/jgs.202012_(97).0003

作者

鍾明光(Ming-Kuang Chung)；盧道杰(Dau-Jye Lu)；蔡博文(Bor-Wen Tsai)；周桂田(Kuei-Tien Chou)；婁安琪(An-Chi Lou)；徐健銘(Chien-Ming Hsu)

关键词

風險溝通 ； 公眾參與地理資訊系統 ； 社區監測 ； 保護區經營管理 ； 公民科學 ； risk communication ； public participatory geographic information systems (PPGIS) ； community-based monitoring ； protected area management ； citizen science

期刊名称

地理學報

卷期/出版年月

97期（2020 / 12 / 01）

页次

77 - 113

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

自然保護區的設置，被視為現代國家在環境資源保育的績效指標。然而，現今自然保護區的經營多以菁英官僚與科學知識做為管理基礎，且決策具有排除在地權益關係人的傾向，甚至與在地社群產生衝突。保護區的經營管理體系與其所引發的衝突，體現了風險社會（risk society）的特徵。近年，保護區的經營管理出現典範轉移，主張多元主義、提倡權益關係人參與。鑒於風險治理也有類同的主張，本研究嘗試以風險溝通（risk communication）的角度，討論臺灣自然保護區經營管理中的環境資訊再現與傳播，及其對後續經營管理模式的影響，以在提倡公眾參與的氛圍中，提供另一個面向的思考。本文以宜蘭無尾港社區於2009至2012年間執行的兩個社區監測（community-based monitoring）及其公眾參與地理資訊系統（public participation geographic information systems, PPGIS）的應用案例為主，並利用參與觀察、深度訪談與主軸編碼等質性研究方法，進行案例內容的蒐集與探討。研究發現，PPGIS的應用取徑，能有效涵納社區監測成果、經營管理目標、潛在權益關係與在地知識等多重資訊，讓不同部門間的權益關係人，在共同的基礎上評估保護區的風險內涵與規模，並以監測資料為基礎提出具體的防控措施及分工。同時，PPGIS所涵構的風險溝通機制，亦持續轉譯社區監測成果，協助權益關係人評量風險管理的能效，有助建構公私部門間的信任及夥伴關係。
英文摘要

Modern state governments often establish protected areas as a risk management strategy for land use, and generally dominate and control their operation and management goals by. Government officials design the regulatory frameworks, based on their own understanding and on modern science and technology, to reflect the conservation needs of the state. However, this management style tends to neglect other stakeholders in decision making, endangering the local community's culture and way of life in the delineation of protected areas. This study examines two community monitoring activities in the Wu-Wei-Kang community from the viewpoint of risk communication, and discusses the use of Public Participatory Geographic Information Systems (PPGIS) by the local community. A PPGIS improves strategies for protected area management by assisting in the planning, implementation and interpretation of community-based monitoring, promoting communication and providing a consultation mechanism on the rights and interests of the protected area. This study concludes that PPGIS can be adopted as an integrated platform that applies geospatial information to assist in the reproduction of operational management risks. A PPGIS has multiple attributes, including management objectives, local knowledge and data monitoring, thus enabling the integration of rights and interests from the public sector, academia and civil society. Participants can jointly define the implications of possible risks and assist stakeholders in information sharing and communicating management issues, thus promoting a public-private partnership, and establishing essential management mechanisms and changes.
主题分类 人文學 > 地理及區域研究
参考文献
  1. 江舟峰, C. F.(2017)。台灣如何因應當前迫切的健康風險管理與溝通的問題。土壤及地下水污染整治，4(1)，1-15。
    連結：
  2. 何立德, L. D.,羅柳墀, L. X.,盧道杰, D. J.,陳維立, W. L.,徐嘉鴻, J. H.(2012)。臺南縣曾文溪口北岸黑面琵鷺野生動物保護區經營管理效能評估。地理學報，65，1-26。
    連結：
  3. 杜文苓, W. L.,何俊頤, J. Y.(2015)。壟斷的環境資訊解析高科技環境知識生產之制度困境。台灣社會研究季刊，99，79-137。
    連結：
  4. 周桂田, G. T.(2007)。新興風險治理典範之芻議。政治與社會哲學評論，22，179-233。
    連結：
  5. 林宜平, Y. P.(2011)。死了幾位電子廠女工之後: 有機溶劑的健康風險爭議。科技、醫療與社會，12，61-112。
    連結：
  6. 陳潁峰, Y. F.(2017)。科學事實建構與環評民主化: 五件環評專家會議的啟示。科技醫療與社會，24，49-90。
    連結：
  7. 黃浩榮, H. R.(2003)。風險社會下的大眾媒體：以公共新聞學作為重構策略。國家發展研究，3(1)，99-147。
    連結：
  8. 盧道杰, D. J.,王牧寧, M. N.,闕河嘉, H. J.(2008)。無尾港野生動物保護區經營管理效能評估-RAPPAM 的引進與適用。地理學報，54，51-78。
    連結：
  9. 盧道杰, D. J.,趙芝良, Z. L.,羅欣怡, X. Y.,高千雯, Q. W.,陳維立, W. L.,羅柳墀, L. C.,葉美智, M. Z.,何立德, L. D.,張弘毅, H. Y.,王中原, Z. Y.(2013)。臺灣海岸河口溼地型保護區經營管理效能評估。地理學報，68，19-42。
    連結：
  10. 盧道杰, D. J.,闕河嘉, H. C.,高千雯, C. W.,裴家騏, J. C.,顏家芝, J. J.,劉子銘, T. Z.,台邦．撒沙勒, S.,蔡博文, B. W.,趙芝良, C. L.(2011)。台灣保護區共管的情勢分析與挑戰。台灣原住民族研究，4(2)，1-37。
    連結：
  11. (2004).biodiversity issues for consideration in the planning, establishment and management of protected area sites and networks.Canada:Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity=SCBD.
  12. Arnstein, S. R.(1969).A ladder of citizen participation.Journal of the American Institute of Planners,35(4),216-224.
  13. Beck, U.(2015).Emancipatory catastrophism: What does it mean to climate change and risk society?.Current Sociology,63(1),75-88.
  14. Beck, U.(1999).World risk society.Cambridge:Polity Press.
  15. Beck, U.(2006).Living in the world risk society.Economy and Society,35(3),329-345.
  16. Beck, U.(1992).From industrial society to the risk society: Question of survival, social structure and ecological enlightement.Theory, Culture and Society,9,97-123.
  17. Beck, U.,Ritter, M.(Trans.)(1992).Risk society: Towards a new modernity.London:Sage.
  18. Berkes, F.(1999).Sacred ecology: Traditional ecological knowledge and resource management.Philadelphia:Taylor and Francis Press.
  19. Berkes, F.(2007).Understanding uncertainty and reducing vulnerability: Lessons from resilience thinking.Natural Hazards,41(2),283-295.
  20. Bishop, K.,Phillips, A.,Warren, L. M.(1997).Protected areas for the future: Models from the past.Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,40(1),81-110.
  21. Borrini-Feyerabend, G.,Dudley, N.,Jaeger, T.,Lassen, B.,Broome, N. P.,Phillips, A.,Sandwith, T.(2013).Borrini-Feyerabend, G., N. Dudley, T. Jaeger, B. Lassen, N. P. Broome, A. Phillips, and T. Sandwith. 2013. Governance of protected areas: From understanding to action. Best Practice Protected Area Guidelines Series No. 20. Switzerland: IUCN..
  22. Borrini-Feyerabend, G.,Hill, R.(2015).Governance for the conservation of nature.Protected area governance and management,Canberra:
  23. Brosius, J. P.,Tsing, A. L.,Zerner, C.(1998).Representing communities: Histories and politics of community-based natural resource management.Society and Natural Resources,11(2),157-168.
  24. Brown, G.,Brabyn, L.(2012).An analysis of the relationships between multiple values and physical landscapes at a regional scale using public participation GIS and landscape character classification.Landscape and Urban Planning,107(2),317-331.
  25. Brown, G.,Fagerholm, N.(2015).Empirical PPGIS/PGIS mapping of ecosystem services: A review and evaluation.Ecosystem Services,13,119-133.
  26. Brown, G.,Kangas, K.,Juutinen, A.,Tolvanen, A.(2017).Identifying environmental and natural eesource management conflict potential using participatory mapping.Society and Natural Resources,30(12),1458-1475.
  27. Brown, G.,Kyttä, M.(2014).Key issues and research priorities for public participation GIS (PPGIS): A synthesis based on empirical research.Applied Geography,46,122-136.
  28. Brown, G.,Raymond, C. M.(2014).Methods for identifying land use conflict potential using participatory mapping.Landscape and Urban Planning,122,196-208.
  29. Brown, G.,Schebella, M. F.,Weber, D.(2014).Using participatory GIS to measure physical activity and urban park benefits.Landsc. Urban Plan,121(2014),34-44.
  30. Brown, G.,Weber, D.(2011).Public Participation GIS: A new method for national park planning.Landscape and Urban Research,102(1),1-15.
  31. Brown, G.,Weber, D.,Zanon, D.,de Bie, K.(2012).Evaluation of an online (opt-in) panel for Public Participation Geographic Information Systems (PPGIS) surveys.International Journal of Public Opinion Research,24(4),534-545.
  32. Chorus, I.(ed.),Bartram, J.(ed.)(1999).Toxic Cyanobacteria in water. A guide to their public health consequences, monitoring and management.London:E & FN Spon.
  33. Chung, M. K.,Lu, D. J.,Tsai, B. W.,Chou, K. T.(2019).Assessing ectiveness of PPGIS on protected areas by governance quality: A case study of community-based monitoring in Wu-Wei-Kang Wildlife Refuge, Taiwan.Sustainability,11(15),41-54.
  34. Cinderby, S.(1999).Geographic information systems for participation: The future of environmental GIS?.International Journal of Environment and Pollution,11(3),304-315.
  35. Conrad, C. C.,Hilchey, K. G.(2011).A review of citizen science and community-based environmental monitoring: Issues and opportunities.Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,176,273-291.
  36. Cottle, S.(1998).Ulrich Beck, “risk society” and the media: A catastrophic view?.European Journal of Communication,13(1),5-32.
  37. Douglas, M.(1992).Risk and blame: Essays in cultural theory.New York:Routledge.
  38. Dudley, N.(ed.)(2008).Guidelines for applying protected area management categories.Gland, Switzerland:IUCN.
  39. Dunn, C. E.(2007).Participatory GIS: A people's GIS?.Progress in Human Geography,31,616-637.
  40. Elliot, J.(1991).Action research for education change.Philadelphia:Open University Press.
  41. Elwood, S. A.(2006).Participatory GIS and community planning-restructuring technologies, social processes, and future research in PPGIS.Collaborative Geographic Information Systems,London:
  42. Elwood, S. A.(2002).GIS use in community planning: A multidimensional analysis of empowerment.Environment and Planning A,34(5),905-922.
  43. Elwood, S. A.(2008).Grassroots groups as stakeholders in spatial data infrastructures: Challenges and opportunities for local data development and sharing.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,22(1),71-90.
  44. Freedman, B.(1995).Environmental ecology.San Diego:Academic Press.
  45. Frickel, S.,Gibbon., S.,Howard, J.,Kempner, J.,Ottinger, G.,Hess, D. J.(2010).Undone science: Charting social movement and civil society challenges to research agenda setting.Science, Technology, & Human Values,35(4),444-473.
  46. Funtowicz, S.,Ravetz, J. R.(1991).A new scientific methodology for global environmental issues.The ecological economics,NY:
  47. Gerrard, S.,Petts, J.(1998).Isolation or integration? The relationship between risk assessment and risk management.Risk assessment and risk management,UK:
  48. Giddens, A.(1991).Modernity and self-identity: Self and society in the late modern age.CA:Stanford University Press.
  49. Giddens, A.(1990).The consequences of modernity.Cambridge:Polity Press.
  50. Hanna, S.,Folke, C.,Mäler, K.G.(1996).Rights to nature: Ecological, economic, cultural, and political principles of institutions for the environment.Washington, D.C.:Island Press.
  51. Hellier, A.,Newton, A.,Gaona, S.(1999).Use of indigenous knowledge for rapidly assessing trends in biodiversity: A case study from Chiapa, Mexico.Biodiversity and Conservation,8,869-889.
  52. Hess, D. J.(2009).The potentials and limitations of civil society research: Getting undone science done.Sociological Inquiry,79(3),306-327.
  53. Hill, R.,Miller, C.,Newell, B.,Dunlop, M.,Gordon, I. J.(2015).Why biodiversity declines as protected areas increase: The effect of the power of governance regimes on sustainable landscapes.Sustainability Science,10,357-369.
  54. Holdgate, M.,Phillips, A.(1999).Protected areas in context.Integrated protected area management,U.K:
  55. IRGC(2017).Introduction to the IRGC risk governance framework.Lausanne:EPFL International Risk Governance Center.
  56. IUCN(1993).Parks and progress.Switzerland:IUCN.
  57. Jacobs, B.,Boronyak, L.,Mitchell, P.(2019).Application of risk-based, adaptive pathways to climate adaptation planning for public conservation areas in NSW, Australia.Climate,7(4),58.
  58. Klain, S. C.,Chan, K. M.(2012).Navigating coastal values: Participatory mapping of ecosystem services for spatial planning.Ecol. Econ,82(2012),104-113.
  59. Kyem, P. A. K.(2002).Promoting local community participation in forest management through a PPGIS application in Southern Ghana.Community participation and Geographic Information Systems,London:
  60. Leverington, F.,Costa, K. L.,Pavese, H.,Lisle, A.,Hockings, M.(2010).A global analysis of protected area management effectiveness.Environmental Management,46,685-698.
  61. Lockwood, M.(2010).Good governance for terrestrial protected areas: A framework, principles and performance outcomes.Journal of Environmental Management,91(3),754-766.
  62. McCall, M. K.,Dunn, C. E.(2012).Geo-information tools for participatory spatial planning: Fulfilling the criteria for ‘good’ governance?.Geoforum,43(2012),81-94.
  63. McKechnie, S.,Davies, S.(1999).Consumers and risk.Risk communication and public health,Oxford:
  64. McKinley, D. C.,Miller-Rushing, A. J.,Ballard, H. L.,Bonney, R.,Brown, H.,Cook-Patton, S. C.,Evans, D. M.,French, R. A.,Parrish, J. K.,Phillips, T. B.,Ryan, S. F.,Shanley, L. A.,Shirk, J. L.,Stepenuck, K. F.,Weltzin, J. F.,Wiggins, A.,Boyle, O. D.,Briggs, R. D.,Chapin, S. F.,Hewitt, D. A.,Preuss, P. W.,Soukup, M. A.(2017).Citizen science can improve conservation science, natural resource management, and environmental protection.Biological Conservation,208,15-28.
  65. McNeely, J. A.(1993).Parks for life: Report of the 4th world congress on national parks and protected areas.Gland:IUCN.
  66. McNeely, J. A.(1994).Protected areas for the 21st century: Working to provide benefits to society.Biodiversity and Conservation,3(5),390-405.
  67. Newig, J.,Fritsch, O.(2009).Environmental governance, multi-level -- and effective?.Environmental Policy and Governance,19,197-214.
  68. Niedziałkowski, K.,Paavola, J.,Jędrzejewska, B.(2012).Participation and protected areas governance: The impact of changing influence of local authorities on the conservation of the Białowieża Primeval Forest, Poland.Ecology and Society,17(1),2.
  69. Ostrom, E.(1990).Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  70. Phillips, A.(2003).Turning ideas on their head - The new paradigm for protected areas.Innovative governance-indigenous peoples, local communities and protected areas,India:
  71. Pidgeon, N.(2020).Engaging publics about environmental and technology risks: Frames, values and deliberation.Journal of Risk Research
  72. Pretty, J.(1995).Participatory learning for sustainable agriculture.World Development,23(8),1247-1263.
  73. Rambaldi, G.,Kyenm, P. A. K.,McCall, M.,Weiner, D.(2006).Participatory spatial information management and communication in developing countries.The Electronic Journal of Information Systems in Developing Countries,25,1-9.
  74. Raymond, C. M.,Fazey, I.,Reed, M. S.,Stringer, L. C.,Robinson, G. M.,Evely, A. C.(2010).Integrating local and scientific knowledge for environmental management.Journal of Environmental Management,91(8),1766-1777.
  75. Raymond, C. M.,Gottwald, S.,Kuoppa, J.,Kyttä, M.(2016).Integrating multiple elements of environmental justice into urban blue space planning using public participation geographic information systems.Landsc. Urban Plan,153(2016),198-208.
  76. Renn, O.(2006).Participatory processes for designing environmental policies.Land Use Policy,23,34-43.
  77. Renn, O.(2015).Stakeholder and public involvement in risk governance.International Journal of Disaster Risk Science,6(1),8-20.
  78. Renn, O.,Sellke, P.(2011).Risk, society and policy making: Risk governance in a complex world.International Journal of Performability Engineering,7(4),349-366.
  79. Rowe, G.,Frewer, L. J.(2005).A typology of public engagement mechanisms.Science Technology and Human Values,2005(30),251-290.
  80. Russell, D.,Harshbarger, C.(2003).Groundwork for community-based conservation: Strategies for social research.U.K.:Altamira press.
  81. Scheufele, D.(2014).Science communication as political communication.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,111,13585-13592.
  82. Shirk, J. L.,Ballard, H. L.,Wilderman, C. C.,Phillips, T.,Wiggins, A.,Jordan, R.,McCallie, E.,Minarchek, M.(2012).Public participation in scientific research: A framework for deliberate design.Ecology and Society,17,29.
  83. Sieber, R. E.(2002).Geographic information systems in the environmental movement.Community participation and Geographic Information Systems,London:
  84. Sieber, R. E.(2006).Public participation geographic information systems: A literature review and framework.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,96(3),491-507.
  85. Stevens, S.(1997).New alliances for conservation.Conservation through cultural survival- indigenous peoples and protected areas,Washington, DC:
  86. Stolton, S.,Shadie, P.,Dudley, N.(2013).Stolton, S., P. Shadie, and N. Dudley. 2013. Guidance on recognising protected areas and assigning management categories and governance types, best practice protected area guidelines series No. 21. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN..
  87. Sui, D. Z.,Goodchild, M. F.(2003).A tetradic analysis of GIS and society using McLuhan's law of the media.Canadian Geographer,47(1),5-18.
  88. Tang, Z. H.,Liu, T. T.(2015).Evaluating internet-based public participation GIS (PPGIS) and volunteered geographic information (VGI) in environmental planning and management.Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,59(6),1-18.
  89. Thompson, M. M.(2016).Upside-down GIS: The future of citizen science and community participation.The Cartographic Journal,53(4),326-334.
  90. Tosun, C.(1999).Towards a typology of community participation in the tourism development process.International Journal of Tourism and Hospitality,10,113-134.
  91. Treffny, R.,Beilin, R.(2011).Gaining legitimacy and losing trust: Stakeholder participation in ecological risk assessment for marine protected area management.Environmental Values,20,417-438.
  92. Tsai, B. W.,Lu, D. J.,Chung, M. K.,Lien, M. C.(2013).Evaluation of PPGIS empowerment: A case study of Meinong Yellow Butterfly Valley in Taiwan.Journal of Environmental Management,116,204-212.
  93. Watson, J. E. M.,Dudley, N.,Segan, D. B.,Hockings, M.(2014).The performance and potential of protected areas.Nature,515,67-73.
  94. Whitelaw, G.,Vaughan, H.,Craig, B.,Atkinson, D.(2003).Establishing the Canadian community monitoring network.Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,88,409-418.
  95. World Health Organization=WHO(2005).Food safety risk analysis - A guide for national food safety authorities.
  96. World Health Organization (WHO) 2012. Rapid risk assessment of acute public health events. http://whqlibdoc.who.int/hq/2012/WHO_HSE_GAR_ARO_2012.1_eng.pdf [last access 2020.05.15].
  97. Wright, R. G.,Mattson, D. J.(1996).The origin and purpose of national parks and protected areas.National parks and protected areas -Their role in environmental protection,Cambridge:
  98. Yarnell, P.,Gayton, D. V.(2003).Community-based ecosystem monitoring in British Columbia.Forest Research Extension Partnership,13,1-37.
  99. Zachmann, K.(2014).Risk in historical perspective: Concepts, contexts, and conjunctions.Risk - A multidisciplinary introduction,Cham:
  100. 內政部 [Ministry of the Interior] 2018。無尾港重要濕地 (國家級) 保育利用計畫書 [Wu wei gang zhong yao shi di guo jia ji bao yu li yong ji hua su]。https://wetland-tw.tcd.gov.tw/upload/file/20190604165430507.pdf (擷取日期：2020.07.10)。
  101. 行政院農業委員會林務局 [Forestry Bureau, COA, Executive Yuan] . 2019。澎湖縣望安島綠蠵龜產卵棲地保護區 [Peng hu xian wang an dao lü xi gui chan luan qi di bao hu qu]。https://conservation.forest.gov.tw/0000136 (擷取日期：2020.07.11)。
  102. 行政院農業委員會林務局 [Forestry Bureau, COA, Executive Yuan] 2018。自然保護區域總表 [Zi ran bao hu qu yu zong biao]。http://conservation.forest.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=3012&CtNode=758&mp=10 (擷取日期：2020.06.10)。
  103. 呂冠燁, K. H.(2018)。Taipei，臺灣大學森林環境暨資源學研究所=School of Forestry and Resource Conservation, National Taiwan University。
  104. 呂郁玟, Y. W.(2013)。Taipei，臺灣大學森林環境暨資源學研究所=School of Forestry and Resource Conservation, National Taiwan University。
  105. 李玲玲, L. L.,趙榮台, R. T.(2005)。行政院農業委員會林務局保育研究系列 94-23 號行政院農業委員會林務局保育研究系列 94-23 號,臺北=Taipei:行政院農業委員會林務局=Forestry Bureau,COA, Executive Yuan。
  106. 周桂田, G. T.(2003)。從「全球化風險」到「全球在地化風險」之研究進路：對貝克理論的批判思考。臺灣社會學刊，31，153-188。
  107. 周桂田, G. T.(2005)。開放性風險評估芻議－以歐盟科技決策評估程序之反省為討論。臺灣科技法律與政策論叢，2，73-104。
  108. 周桂田, G. T.(2001)。科學風險：多元共識之風險建構。第二現代-風險社會的出路？，臺北=Taipei:
  109. 周桂田, G. T.(2008)。新興科技與風險治理。科技發展政策報導，2，16-31。
  110. 周桂田, G. T.(2005)。全球化下風險社會之政治實踐。政治學及現代社會，新北=New Taipei City:
  111. 宜蘭縣政府=Yilan County Government(2015)。宜蘭縣政府 [Yilan County Government] 2015。無尾港水鳥保護區保育計畫 [Wu wei gang shui niao bao hu qu bao yu ji hua]。宜蘭[Yilan]：宜蘭縣政府 [Yilan County Government]。
  112. 宜蘭縣政府=Yilan County Government(2009)。宜蘭縣 99 年度國家重要濕地生態環境調查及復育計畫無尾港濕地全潮測量與社區監測成果報告書宜蘭縣 99 年度國家重要濕地生態環境調查及復育計畫無尾港濕地全潮測量與社區監測成果報告書,宜蘭=Yilan:宜蘭縣政府=Yilan County Government。
  113. 林雅, Y.(2010)。Taipei，國立臺灣大學地理環境資源學研究所=Department of Geography, National Taiwan University。
  114. 林銀河, Y. H.(2001)。宜蘭縣無尾港生態社區之發展與展望。2001 年全國富麗漁村展覽研習會，宜蘭=Yilan:
  115. 邵廣昭, G. Z.,賴昆祺, K. C.(2011)。臺灣海洋保護區的現況與挑戰。海洋事務與政策評論，1，65-90。
  116. 張隆盛、廖美麗 [Chang, L. S., and M. L. Liao] 2002。生態保育-世界保護區發展的趨勢 [Sheng tai bao yu - Shi jie bao hu qu fa zhan de qu shi]。http://old.npf.org.tw/PUBLICATION/SD/091/SD-R-091-031.htm (擷取日期：2012.3.15)。
  117. 陳鵬升, P. S.,齊士崢, S. J.(2015)。我國濕地劃設與衝突管理之初探。濕地學刊，4(1)，31-42。
  118. 彭安琪, A. C.(2011)。Taipei，國立臺灣大學森林環境暨資源學研究所=School of Forestry and Resource Conservation, National Taiwan University。
  119. 黃躍雯, Y. W.(1999)。臺灣國家公園原住民保留地政策－制度與空間觀點的檢視。國家公園學報，9(2)，182-198。
  120. 楊增泉, Z. Q.(2007)。Taipei，國立臺北藝術大學傳統藝術研究所=College of Cultural Resources, Graduate Institute of Folk Culture and Arts, Taipei National University of the Arts。
  121. 葉梁羽, L.Y.(2018)。Taipei，國立臺灣大學森林環境暨資源學研究所=School of Forestry and Resource Conservation, National Taiwan University。
  122. 趙芝良, Z. L.,葉美智, M. Z.,盧道杰, D. J.,陳瑋苓, W. L.,徐霈馨, P. X.(2010)。高美野生動物保護區之經營管理效能評估。國家公園學報，20(4)，33-44。
  123. 潘淑滿, S. M.(2003).質性研究：理論與應用.臺北=Taipei:心理出版社=Xin li chu ban she.
  124. 蔡美華（譯）, M. H.(Trans.),Mills, G. E.(2007).行動研究法第二版：教師研究者的指引.台北=Taipei:學富文化事業=Pro-Ed Publishing Company.
  125. 盧道杰, D. J.(2006)。從國家、市場到社區—在地的生物多樣性保育機制。生物多樣性概論，臺北=Taipei:
  126. 盧道杰, D. J.,吳雯菁, W. J.,裴家騏, J. Q.,台邦．撒沙勒, Sa Sha Le(2006)。建構社區保育、原住民族狩獵與野生動物資源經營管理間的連結。地理學報，46，1-29。
  127. 盧道杰, D. J.,施上粟, S. S.,黃國文, K. W.,楊勝崎, S. C.,游紫晴, Z. C.,蔡博文, B. W.,鍾明光, M. K.(2012)。宜蘭無尾港濕地全潮測量及陸化原因探討。農業工程學報，58(4)，41-50。
  128. 蕭新煌, H. H.,林宗弘, T. H.,許耿銘, K. M.(2019)。環境風險到社會實踐：氣候變遷下的風險知覺與公民參與環境行動。面對台灣風險社會：分析與策略，高雄市=Kaohsiung:
  129. 謝新誼, S. I.(2016)。化學物質的拼裝、風險與治理：台灣洗衣精的百滅寧防蟎爭議 (2013-2014)。科技醫療與社會，23，137-201。
print cancel