經營效率與KMV模型於信用風險管理機制有效性之研究

The Effectiveness of Operating Efficiency and KMV Model on the Credit Risk Evaluation Model

10.7086/TJAE.201209.0241

卓翠月(Tsui-Yueh Cho)；黃明祥(Ming-Hsiang Huang)

KMV模型 ； 三階段資料包絡分析法 ； 信用風險 ； KMV Model ； Three-stage Data Envelopment Analysis ； Credit Risk Evaluation

應用經濟論叢

2012生產力與效率特刊（2012 / 09 / 01）

241 - 278

繁體中文

過去許多學者利用財務、非財務變數來預測公司財務危機，但卻沒有研究將經營效率與違約機率同時納入信用風險管理機制模式中，以檢驗是否能提升信用風險評估之準確率。因此，本文以2005～2009年發生危機事件的54家台灣資訊電子業公司及108家正常公司做為研究對象，建立總共162家公司的研究樣本。實證分析分為三個步驟：首先，利用KMV模型計算樣本公司的預期違約機率（expected default frequency, EDF）；其次，以三階段資料包絡分析法（data envelopment analysis, DEA）計算樣本公司之總技術效率、純技術效率與規模效率；最後，將各財務變數、EDF及三階段DEA所計算的效率值納入logit模型中，以建構完整的信用風險管理模型。實證結果發現：第一階段與第三階段DEA所計算之效率值明顯不同，且危機公司與正常公司之財務變數、KMV模型之EDF及三階段DEA之效率值確實存在顯著差異；而在logit迴歸分析方面則發現，於危機事件發生前一年，EDF及三階段DEA之效率變數具有顯著之解釋能力，再者，納入三階段DEA效率變數及EDF後之模型，其預測準確率較純財務變數模型之準確率提高，顯示將三階段DEA效率變數與EDF納入信用風險管理模型中，將可提高模型之準確性。

Many researchers used various financial and non-financial data to predict a firm's financial crisis, but there was not a study taking the impact of operating efficiency and expected default frequency (EDF) into consideration. Adopting the sample data of Taiwan electronic industry from 2005-2009, we select 54 financially shaky firms and 108 normal ones as match firms in the empirical implementation. The empirical analysis proceeds in three stages. First, we use KMV model to estimate the EDF of sample companies and then we estimate over-efficiency, technical efficiency and scale efficiency by means of three-stage data envelopment analysis (DEA). Finally, we incorporate the financial variables, EDF and operating efficiency variables into logit regression model to establish a credit risk evaluation model. Experimental results indicate that the efficiency measured by one-stage DEA obviously differs from the one measured by three-stage DEA. Furthermore, there exists differences between shaky firms and normal ones when applied to the financial variables, EDF, and three-stage DEA efficiency variables. In the results of logit regression, we find that the EDF and operating variables have significant explanatory power in one year prior to the financial crises of sample firms. Moreover, the predictive results indicates that the models used financial variables with EDF or financial variables with three-stage DEA efficiency variables are more correct than the model used only financial variables. Thus, the incorporation of operating efficiency and EDF into the credit risk evaluation model proves to enhance its overall accuracy.

1. 張美玲,王國樑(2004)。有線電視系統業者經營效率之探討。管理評論，23，45-64。
   連結：
2. 許鎦響(2009)。台灣 IC 設計產業生產效率評估/三階段 DEA 法之應用。商管科技季刊，10，439-463。
   連結：
3. 黃劭彥,李超雄,洪光宏,吳東憲(2006)。以經營效率觀點建立台灣資訊電子業財務危機預警模型。交大商管學報，11，1-20。
   連結：
4. 盧永祥,傅祖壇(2007)。產出品質、組織特性與台灣高等技職院校之經營效率。管理評論，26，1-21。
   連結：
5. Abbott, M.,Doucouliagos, C.(2003).The Efficiency of Australian Universities: A Data Envelopment Analysis.Economics of Education Review,22,89-97.
6. Altman, E. I.(1968).Financial Ratios, Discriminate Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy.Journal of Finance,23,589-609.
7. Banker, R. D.,Charnes, A.,Cooper, W. W.(1984).Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Inefficiencies in Data Envelop Analysis.Management Science,30,1078-1092.
8. Banker, R. D.,Morey, R.(1986).Efficiency Analysis for Exogenously Fixed Inputs and Outputs.Operations Research,34,513-521.
9. Becchetti, L.,Sierra, J.(2003).Bankruptcy Risk and Productive Efficiency in Manufacturing Firms.Journal of Banking and Finance,27,2099-2120.
10. Black, F.,Scholes, M.(1973).The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities.Journal of Political Economy,81,637-654.
11. Bohn, J. R.(1999).Using Market Data to Value Credit Risky Instruments.KMV LLC.
12. Charnes, A.,Cooper, W. W.,Rhodes, E.(1978).Measuring the Efficiency of Decision Making Units.European Journal of Operational Research,2,429-444.
13. Chen, C. J.,Yeh, Q. J.(2005).A Comparative Performance Evaluation of Taiwan’s High-tech Industries.Business Performance Management,7,16-33.
14. Cielen, A.,Peeters, L.,Vanhoof, K.(2004).Bankruptcy Prediction Using a Data Envelopment Analysis.European Journal of Operation Research,154,526-532.
15. Farrell. M. J.(1957).The Measurement of Productive Efficiency.Journal of Royal Statistical Society,A120,253-290.
16. Finger, C. C.(2002).Credit Grades Technical Document.New York:Risk Metrics Group, Inc..
17. Fried, H. O.,Lovell, C. A. K,Schmidt, S. S.,Yaisawarmg, S.(2002).Accounting for Environmental Effects and Statistical Noise in Data Envelopment Analysis.Journal of Productivity Analysis,17,157-174.
18. Fried, H. O.,Schmidt, S. S.,Yaisawarmg, S.(1999).Incorporating the Operating Environment into a Nonparametric Measure of Technical Efficiency.Journal of Productivity Analysis,12,249-267.
19. Gestel, T. V.,Baesens, B.,Suykens, J.,Poel, D. V.,Baestaens, D. E.,Willekens, M.(2006).Bayesian Kernel Based Classification for Financial Distress Detection.European Journal of Operational Research,172,979-1003.
20. Glass, J. C.,McGallion, G.,McKillop, D. G.,Stringer, K.(2006).A Techically Level Playing-field Profit Efficiency Analysis of Enforced Competition between Publicly Funded Institutions.European Economic Review,50,1601-1626.
21. Golany, B.,Roll, Y.(1993).Some Extension of Techniques to Handle Non-discretionary Factors in Data Envelopment Analysis.Journal of Productivity Analysis,4,419-432.
22. Jarrow, R.,Turnbull, S.(1995).Pricing Derivatives on Financial Securities Subject to Credit Risk.Journal of Finance,50,53-85.
23. Kealhofer S.,Kurbat, M.(2001).The Default Prediction Power of the Merton Approach Relative to Debt Ratings and Accounting Variables.San Francisco, CA:Monograph, KMV Corporation.
24. Keasey, K.,Waston, R.(1987).Non-financial Symptoms and the Prediction of Small Company Failure: A Test of Argent’s Hypotheses.Journal of Business Finance and Accounting,14,335-354.
25. Lee, J. Y.(2008).Application of the Three-stage DEA in Measuring Efficiency: An Empirical Evidence.Applied Economics Letters,15,49-52.
26. Lovell, C. A. K.(1993).The Measurement of Productive Efficiency: Techniques and Applications.New York:Oxford University Press.
27. Martin, D.(1977).Early Warning of Banking Failure: A Logit Regression Approach.Journal of Banking and Finance,1,249-276.
28. Mensah Y. M.(1984).An Examination of the Stationarity of Multivariate Bankruptcy Prediction Models: A Methodological Study.Journal of Accounting Research,22,380-395.
29. Merton, R. C.(1974).On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: The Risk Structure of Interest Rates.Journal of Finance,29,449-470.
30. Ohlson, J. A.(1980).Financial Ratios and the Probabilistic Prediction of Bankruptcy.Journal of Accounting Research,18,109-131.
31. Paradi, J. C.,Asmild, M.,Simak, P. C.(2004).Using DEA and Worst Practice DEA in Credit Risk Evaluation.Journal of Productivity Analysis,21,153-165.
32. Psillaki, M.,Tsolas, I. E.,Margaritis, D.(2010).Evaluation of Credit Risk Based on Firm Performance.European Journal of Operational Research,201,873-881.
33. Rezaee, Z.(2005).Causes, Consequences, and Deterence of Financial Statement Fraud.Critical Perspective on Accounting,16,277-298.
34. Rhee, K. H.,Pyo, H. K.(2010).Financial Crisis and Relative Productivity Dynamics in Korea: Evidence from Firm-level Data (1992-2003).Journal of Productivity Analysis,34,111-131.
35. Saunders, A.,Cornett, M.(2007).Financial Markets and Institutions: An Introduction to the Risk Management Approach.New York:McGraw-Hill.
36. Shang, J. K.,Hung, W. T.,Lo, C. F.,Wang, F. C.(2008).Ecommerce and Hotel Performance: Three-stage DEA Analysis.The Service Industries Journal,28,529-540.
37. Stiglitz, J. E.(1972).Some Aspects of the Pure Theory of Corporate Finance: Bankruptcies and Take-overs.The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science,3,458-482.
38. Thore, S.,Phillips, F.,Ruefli, T. W.,Yue, P.(1996).DEA and the Management of the Product Cycle: The U. S. Computer Industry.Computers and Operations Research,23,341-356.
39. Timmer, C. P.(1971).Using a Probabilistic Frontier Production Function to Measure Technical Efficiency.Journal of Political Economy,79,776-794.
40. Tinsley, P. A.(1970).Capital Structure, Precautionary Balances, and Valuation of the Firm: The Problem of Financial Risk.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,5,33-62.
41. Wang, E. C.,Huang, W.(2007).Relative Efficiency of R&D Activities: A Cross-Country Study Accounting for Environmental Factors in the DEA Approach.Research Policy,36,260-273.
42. Zavgren, C. V.(1985).Assessing the Vulnerability to Failure of American Industrial Frims: A Logistic Analysis.Journal of Business Finance and Accounting,12,19-45.
43. Zmijewski, M. E.(1984).Methodological Issues Related to the Estimation of Financial Distress Prediction Models.Journal of Accounting Research,22,59-82.
44. 李沃,許峻賓(2004)。KMV 模型於預警系統之實證研究。真理大學財經研討會，台北:
45. 黃台心,陳盈秀(2005)。應用三階段估計法探討台灣地區銀行業經營效率。貨幣市場，9，1-27。
46. 黃明祥,許光華,黃榮彬,陳鈺玲(2005)。KMV 模型在台灣金融機構信用風險管理機制有效性之研究。財金論文叢刊，3，29-50。
47. 黃鏡如,傅祖壇,黃美瑛(2008).績效評估：效率與生產力之理論與應用.台北:新陸書局.