台灣國際觀光旅館業效率與生產力之分析－由下而上分解法

Efficiency and Productivity Analysis of International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan: The Bottom-up Decomposition Approach

10.7086/TJAE.201209.0039

李文福(Wen-Fu Lee)；王媛慧(Yuan-Huei Wang)

國際觀光旅館 ； Malmquist生產力指數 ； 技術進步 ； 產出組合 ； 截斷最小絕對離差估計 ； International Tourist Hotels ； Malmquist Productivity Index ； Technical Progress ； Output Mix ； Censored Least Absolute Deviations Estimation

應用經濟論叢

2012生產力與效率特刊（2012 / 09 / 01）

39 - 89

繁體中文

本文探討2002至2008年58家台灣國際觀光旅館之生產力變動，利用Balk（2001）由下而上的分解法將Malmquist TFP指數分解為技術變動、純技術效率變動、規模效率變動及產出組合變動等效果。DEA實證結果顯示，2002-2008年平均之VRS產出距離函數值為91.47％。第二階段迴歸分析總技術效率之影響因素，結果顯示：總體GDP影響為正、旅館規模影響為正、北中南之旅館效率較東部為高、政府經濟服務支出有助效率提升、市場集中度與效率呈現正相關，品牌連鎖關係並未能導致較佳之效率。整體而言，研究期間總要素生產力平均每年成長1.56％，驅動力主要來自技術進步（1.43％），次為純技術效率提升（0.2％）。至於規模效率與產出組合變動效果，整體指數相對穩定於1附近，但對部分廠商或部分年度而言變動仍顯著，值得關注。營運績效管理矩陣顯示，超過三成五的國際觀光旅館目前具有競爭力與長期發展潛力。

This study analyzes productivity changes of fifty-eight Taiwanese international tourist hotels with data from 2002 to 2008. Utilizing the bottom-up approach of Balk (2001), we decompose the Malmquist TFP indexes into changes in technology, pure technical efficiency, scale efficiency, and output mix. At the end, the operational performance management matrix is used to study hotels' existing competitiveness and potentials of long-run development.Several results are obtained. DEA analysis indicates that within the sample periods, on average, the pure technical efficiency was 91.47%. Regression analysis shows that GDP, local government economic service expenditures, and market concentration were positively related to overall technical efficiency, while the chain system hotels did not perform better than others. TFPC increased by 1.56% annually, which could mainly be attributed to the improvements in technical change (1.43%) and in pure technical efficiency change (0.2%). As for scale efficiency and output mix effect, the change indexes were stable around unity. The operational performance management matrix suggests that more than 35% of the hotels were competitive presently and with potentials of long-run development.

1. 王媛慧,李文福(2004)。我國地區醫院技術效率之研究：DEA 方法的應用。經濟研究，40，61-95。
   連結：
2. 王媛慧,李文福,翁竹君(2007)。台灣國際觀光旅館業生產力與效率分析：隨機邊界距離函數之應用。經濟論文叢刊，35，55-86。
   連結：
3. 王斐青,洪維廷,尚瑞國(2005)。台灣地區國際觀光旅業生產力變動之研究。亞太經濟管理評論，9，129-126。
   連結：
4. 李文福,王媛慧,洪琬婷(2009)。技術變動、產出組合與台灣銀行產業生產力變動。經濟論文，37，495-524。
   連結：
5. 林億明,孔維新,張晉綸(2010)。準固定要素與台灣國際觀光旅業生產力之變動。應用經濟論叢，2009，191-225。
   連結：
6. Anderson, R. I.,Fok, R.,Scott, J.(2000).Hotel Industry Efficiency: An Advanced Linear Programming Examination.American Business Review,18,40-48.
7. Asaftei, G.(2008).The Contribution of Product Mix versus Efficiency and Technical Change in U.S. Banking.Journal of Banking and Finance,32,2336-2345.
8. Assaf, A.,Barros, C. P.,Josiassen, A.(2010).Hotel Efficiency: A Bootstrapped Metafrontier Approach.International Journal of Hospitality Management,29,468-475.
9. Balk, B. M.(2001).Scale Efficiency and Productivity Change.Journal of Productivity Analysis,15,159-183.
10. Banker, R. D.,Charnes, A.,Cooper, W. W.(1984).Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Inefficiencies in Data Envelopment Analysis.Management Science,30,1078-1092.
11. Barros, C. P.(2005).Evaluating the Efficiency of Small Hotel Chain with a Malmquist Productivity Index.International Journal of Tourism Research,7,173-184.
12. Barros, C. P.(2005).Measuring Efficiency in the Hotels: An Illustrative Example.Annals of Tourism Research,32,456-477.
13. Barros, C. P.(2006).Analyzing the Rate of Technical Change in Tourism Industry.Tourism Economics,12,325-346.
14. Barros, C. P.,Alves, P.(2004).Productivity in Tourism Industry.International Advance in Economic Research,10,215-225.
15. Barros, C. P.,Dieke, P. U. C.(2008).Technical Efficiency of African Hotels.International Journal of Hospitality Management,27,438-447.
16. Barros, C. P.,Santos, C. A.(2006).The Measurement of Efficiency in Portuguese Hotels with DEA.Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research,30,378-400.
17. Baumol, W. J.,Panzar, J. C.,Willig, R. D.(1982).Contestable Markets and the Theory of Industry Structure.San Diego, CA:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
18. Berger, A. N.,Humphrey, D. B.(1991).The Dominance of Inefficiencies over Scale and Product Mix Economies in Banking.Journal of Monetary Economics,28,117-148.
19. Berger, A. N.,Humphrey, D. B.,Pulley, L.(1996).Do Consumers Pay for One-stop Banking? Evidence from an Alternative Revenue Function.Journal of Banking and Finance,20,1601-1621.
20. Botti, L.,Briec, W.,Cliquet, G.(2009).Plural Forms versus Franchise and Company-owned Systems: A DEA Approach of Hotel Chain Performance.Omega,37,566-578.
21. Brown, J. R.,Ragsdale, C. T.(2002).The Competitive Market Efficiency of Hotel Brands: An Application of Data Envelopment Analysis.Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research,26,260-332.
22. Caves, D. W.,Christensen, L. R.,Diewert, W. E.(1982).The Economic Theory of Index Numbers and the Measurement of Input, Output, and Productivity.Econometrica,50,1393-1414.
23. Charnes, A.,Cooper, W. W.,Rhodes, E.(1978).Measuring the Efficiency of Decision Making Units.European Journal of Operational Research,2,429-444.
24. Chen, C.(2007).Applying Stochastic Frontier Approach to Measure Hotel Managerial Efficiency in Taiwan.Tourism Management,28,696-702.
25. Chen, T. H.(2009).Performance Measurement of an Enterprise and Business Units with an Application to a Taiwanese Hotel Chain.International Journal of Hospitality Management,28,415-422.
26. Chiang, W.,Tsai, H.,Wang, L.(2004).A DEA Evaluation of Taipei Hotels.Annals of Tourism Research,31,712-715.
27. Christensen, L. R.,Jorgenson, D. W.(1970).U.S. Real Product and Real Factor Input, 1929-1967.Review of Income and Wealth,16,19-50.
28. Coelli, T.,Rao, D. S. P.,O’Donnell, C. J.,Battese, G. E.(2005).An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity Analysis.New York:Springer Science.
29. Färe, R.,Grosskopf, S.(1996).Intertemporal Production Frontiers: With Dynamic DEA.Boston:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
30. Färe, R.,Grosskopf, S.,Lee, W. F.(2001).Productivity and Technical Change: The Case of Taiwan.Applied Economics,33,1911-1925.
31. Färe, R.,Grosskopf, S.,Norris, M.,Zhang, Z.(1994).Productivity Growth, Technical Progress, and Efficiency Changes in Industrialized Countries.American Economic Review,84,66-83.
32. Färe, R.,Primont, D.(1995).Multi-Output Production and Duality: Theory and Application.Boston:Kluwer Academic Publishers.
33. Farrell, M. J.(1957).The Measurement of Productive Efficiency.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,A120,253-290.
34. Fried, H. O.,Lovell, C. A. K\Schmidt, S. S.,Yaisawarng, S.(2002).Accounting for Effects and Statistical Noise in DEA.Journal of Productivity Analysis,17,157-174.
35. Grifell-Tatjé, E.,Lovell, C. A. K.(1999).Profits and Productivity.Management Science,45,1177-1193.
36. Hsieh, L. F.,Lin, L. H.(2010).A Performance Evaluation Model for International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan—An Application of the Relational Network DEA.International Journal of Hospitality Management,29,14-24.
37. Hu, J. L.,Chiu, C. N.,Shieh, H. S.,Huang, C. H.(2010).A Stochastic Cost Efficiency Analysis of International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan.International Journal of Hospitality Management,29,99-107.
38. Hwang, S. N.,Chang, T. Y.(2003).Using Data Envelopment Analysis to Measure Hotel Managerial Efficiency Change in Taiwan.Tourism Management,24,357-369.
39. Jorgenson, D. W.,Gollop, F. M.,Fraumeni, B. M.(1987).Productivity and U.S. Economic Growth.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
40. Jorgenson, D. W.,Griliches, Z.(1967).The Explanation of Productivity Change.Review of Economic Studies,34,249-282.
41. Kendrick, J. W.,Grossman, E. S.(1980).Productivity in the United States: Trends and Cycles.Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press.
42. Malmquist, S.(1953).Index Numbers and Indifference Surfaces.Trabajos de Estatistica,4,209-242.
43. Morey, R. C.,Dittman, D. A.(1995).Evaluating a Hotel GM's Performance: A Case Study in Benchmarking.Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly,36,30-35.
44. O’Donnell, C. J.(2010).Measuring and Decomposing Agricultural Productivity and Profitability Change.Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics,54,527-560.
45. Orea, L.(2002).Parametric Decomposition of a Generalized Malmquist Productivity Index.Journal of Productivity Analysis,18,5-22.
46. Pagan, A.,Ullah, A.(1999).Nonparametric Econometrics.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
47. Powell, J. L.(1984).Least Absolute Deviations Estimation for the Censored Regression Model.Journal of Econometrics,25,303-325.
48. Powell, J. L.(1986).Symmetrically Trimmed Least Squares Estimation for TOBIT Models.Econometrica,54,1435-1460.
49. Pulina, M.,Detotto, C.,Paba, A.(2010).An Investigation into the Relationship between Size and Efficiency of the Italian Hospitality Sector: A Window DEA Approach.European Journal of Operational Research,204,613-620.
50. Pulley, L. B.,Braunstein, Y. M.(1992).A Composite Cost Function for Multiproduct Firms with an Application to Economies of Scope in Banking.Review of Economics and Statistics,74,221-230.
51. Ray, S. C.,Desli, E.(1997).Productivity Growth, Technical Progress, and Efficiency Changes in Industrialized Countries: Comment.American Economic Review,87,1033-1039.
52. Reynolds, D.(2003).Hospitality Productivity Assessment Using Data Envelopment Analysis.Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly,44,130-137.
53. Shephard, R. W.(1970).The Theory of Cost and Production Functions.Princeton, New Jersey:Princeton University Press.
54. Simar, L.,Wilson, P. W.(2007).Estimation and Inference in Two-stage, Semi-parametric Models of Production Process.Journal of Econometrics,136,31-64.
55. Tsaur, S. H.(2001).The Operating Efficiency of International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan.Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research,6,73-81.
56. Tsaur, S. H.,Chiang, C. I.,Chang, T. Y.(1999).Evaluating the Operating Efficiency of International Tourist Hotels by Using Modified DEA Model.Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research,4,73-78.
57. UNWTO(2009).UNWTO, 2009, “2009 World Tourism Barometer Reports,” UNWTO World Tourism Barometer, 7: 1-52..
58. Wang, F. C.,Hung, W. T.,Shang, J. K.(2006).Measuring the Cost Efficiency of International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan.Tourism Economics,12,65-85.
59. Wang, F. C.,Hung, W. T.,Shang, J. K.(2006).Measuring Pure Managerial Efficiency of International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan.Service Industries Journal,26,59-71.
60. Wang, F. C.,Shang, J. K.,Hung, W. T.(2006).Productivity and Service Quality Changes of International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan.Annals of Tourism Research,33,571-574.
61. Weng, C. C.,Wang, K. L.(2006).Scale and Scope Economies of International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan.Tourism Management,27,25-33.
62. Yu, M. M.,Lee, B. C. Y.(2009).Efficiency and Effectiveness of Service Business: Evidence from International Tourist Hotels in Taiwan.Tourism Management,30,571-580.
63. 交通部觀光局，2003-2009，中華民國九十一~九十七年台灣地區國際觀旅館營運分析報告，台北：交通部觀光局。
64. 陳炳欽,葉源鎰(2001)。台灣地區連鎖型國際觀光旅館經營效率之研究。2001 休閒遊憩觀光研究成果研討會

1. Yang, Tzu-Yi,Li, Chung-Chih(2018).The Non-linear Impact of Labor Costs on the Nexus of Service Quality and Profitability in Taiwanese Hospitality Industry.應用經濟論叢,103,183-205.