不同匯率制度下之資本移動性、定價行為與福利表現

Capital Mobility, Price-Setting Behavior and the Welfare Performance under Alternative Exchange Rate Regimes

賴宗福(Chung-Fu Lai)

新開放總體經濟學 ； 匯率制度抉擇 ； 資本移動性 ； 不完全競爭市場 ； 定價行為 ； New Open Economy Macroeconomics ； the Choice of Exchange Rate Regimes ； Capital Mobility ； Imperfectly Competitive Market ； Price-Setting Behavior

應用經濟論叢

93期（2013 / 06 / 01）

149 - 207

繁體中文

本文採用新開放總體經濟學作為分析基礎，延伸Devereux and Engel（1998）的理論架構，探究實行不同匯率制度的經濟體系，在遭受國外貨幣面衝擊時，對本國消費波動、期望消費以及福利水準的影響，並討論資本移動性、定價行為與不完全競爭市場結構在匯率制度抉擇議題中所扮演的角色。經由理論推導與模擬結果，本文的結論是：（1）浮動匯率制度且按消費者貨幣定價（PTM模型）的消費波動程度最小，而浮動匯率制度並按生產者貨幣定價（PCP模型）的消費波動程度則取決於資本移動程度以及國家規模的大小而定；（2）從期望消費的角度來看，固定匯率制度優於浮動匯率制度；（3）隨著資本移動程度愈低或勞動市場壟斷程度愈高，固定匯率制度的福利水準愈高。

Based on the framework of New Open Economy Macroeconomics, this paper extends the model setup of Devereux and Engel (1998) to investigate how capital mobility, price setting, and imperfectly competitive market structure affect consumption volatility, expected level of consumption, and the welfare performance under alternative exchange rate regimes for a country facing foreign monetary shocks, and analyzes the question of the choice of exchange rate regimes. According to theoretical analysis and simulation results, the following conclusions were made. Firstly, pricing to market (PTM) model has the lowest variance of domestic consumption, and the variance of domestic consumption with producer-currency pricing (PCP) model depends on the degree of capital mobility and the country size. Secondly, the fixed exchange rate will dominate floating exchange rate in terms of the expected level of consumption. Finally, from the perspective of welfare performance, fixed exchange rate is preferable to floating exchange rate with the lower degree of capital mobility or the greater monopoly power of labor market.

1. 方中柔、陳孟甫(2010)。匯率目標區體制下匯率與利率差之波動：異質民眾預期的研究。應用經濟論叢，87，1-43。
   連結：
2. 張瑞娟、欉清全(2009)。貨幣政策與匯率轉嫁之探討─台灣之實證分析。應用經濟論叢，86，37-67。
   連結：
3. Ghironi, F., 1999, “Alternative Monetary Rules for a Small Open Economy: The Case of Canada,” Retrieved from http://home.earthlink.net/~ghiro/canada.pdf.
4. Agénor, P. R.,Bhandari, J. S.,Flood, R. P.(1992).Speculative Attacks and Models of Balance-of-Payments Crises.IMF Staff Papers,39,357-394.
5. Aizenman, J.(1994).Monetary and Real Shocks, Productive Capacity and Exchange-rate Regimes.Economica,61,407-434.
6. Aizenman, J.,Frenkel, J. A.(1985).Optimal Wage Indexation, Foreign Exchange Intervention and Monetary Policy.American Economic Review,75,402-423.
7. Angrist, J. D.(1995).The Economic Returns to Schooling in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.American Economic Review,85,1065-1087.
8. Arellano, J. P.(1982).Macroeconomic Stability and the Optimal Degree of Capital Mobility.Journal of Development Economic,10,377-393.
9. Autor, D. H.,Lawrence, F. K.,Krueger, A. B.(1998).Computing Inequality: Have Computers Changed the Labor Market?.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,113,1169-1213.
10. Bayoumi, T.,Eichengreen, B.(1993).Shocking Aspects of European Monetary Integration.Adjustment and Growth in the European Monetary Union,New York:
11. Benigno, P.(2001).CEPR Discussion Papers, No. 2854CEPR Discussion Papers, No. 2854,未出版
12. Bergin, P. R.(2003).Putting the 'New Open Economy Macroeconomics' to a Test.Journal of International Economics,60,3-34.
13. Bergin, P. R.,Shin, H. C.,Tchakarov, I.(2007).Does Exchange Rate Variability Matter for Welfare? A Quantitative Investigation of Stabilization Policies.European Economic Review,51,1041-1058.
14. Betts, C.,Devereux, M. B.(1996).The Exchange Rate in a Model of Pricing-to-market.European Economic Review,40,1007-1021.
15. Betts, C.,Devereux, M. B.(2000).Exchange Rate Dynamics in a Model of Pricing-to-market.Journal of International Economics,50,215-244.
16. Bhandari, J. S.(1981).Exchange Rate Overshooting Revisited.The Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies,49,165-172.
17. Bodie, Z.,Kane, A.,Marcus, A. J.(1999).Investments.Chicago:Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
18. Chen, C. N.,Tsaur, T. W.(1983).Currency Substitution and Foreign Inflation.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,98,177-184.
19. Chin, D. M.,Miller, P. J.(1998).Fixed v.s. Floating Rates: A Dynamic General Equilibrium Analysis.European Economic Review,42,1221-1249.
20. Corsetti, G.(2006).Openness and the Case for Flexible Exchange Rates.Research in Economics,60,1-21.
21. Corsetti, G.,Pesenti, P.(2001).Welfare and Macroeconomic Interdependence.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,116,421-445.
22. Cristadoro, R.,Gerali, A.,Neri, S.,Pisani, M.(2006).The Dynamics of the Real Exchange Rate: A Bayesian DSGE Approach.7th Workshop of the EABCN on Estimation and Empirical Validation of Structural Models for Business Cycle Analysis,Zurich:
23. Devereux, M. B.,Engel, C.(1998).NBER Working Paper, No. 6867NBER Working Paper, No. 6867,未出版
24. Devereux, M. B.,Engel, C.(2003).Monetary Policy in the Open Economy Revisited: Price Setting and Exchange Rate Flexibility.Review of Economic Studies,70,765-783.
25. Devereux, M. B.,Shi, K.,Xu, J.(2005).Friedman Redux: Restricting Monetary Policy Rules to Support Flexible Exchange Rates.Economics Letters,87,291-299.
26. Dixon, H.(1987).A Simple Model of Imperfect Competition with Walrasian Features.Oxford Economic Papers,39,134-160.
27. Dooley, M.,Isard, P.(1980).Capital Controls, Political Risk and Deviations from Interest-rate Parity.The Journal of Political Economy,88,370-384.
28. Dornbusch, R.(1976).Expectations and Exchange Rate Dynamics.The Journal of Political Economy,84,1161-1176.
29. Duarte, M.,Obstfeld, M.(2008).Monetary Policy in the Open Economy Revisited: The Case for Exchange-rate Flexibility Restored.Journal of International Money and Finance,27,949-957.
30. Elekdag, S.,Tchakarov, I.(2007).Balance Sheets, Exchange Rate Policy, and Welfare.Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control,31,3986-4015.
31. Engel, C.(1993).Real Exchange Rates and Relative Prices: An Empirical Investigation.Journal of Monetary Economics,32,35-50.
32. Fleming, J. M.(1962).Domestic Financial Policies under Fixed and under Floating Exchange Rates.International Monetary Fund Staff Papers,9,369-379.
33. Flood, R. P.(1979).Capital Mobility and the Choice of Exchange Rate System.International Economic Review,20,405-416.
34. Flood, R. P.,Garber, P. M.(1984).Collapsing Exchange Rate Regimes: Some Linear Examples.Journal of International Economics,17,1-13.
35. Flood, R. P.,Marion, N. P.(1982).The Transmission of Disturbances under Alternative Exchange-rate Regimes with Optimal Indexing.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,97,43-66.
36. Frankel, J. A.(1992).Measuring International Capital Mobility: A Review.The American Economic Review,82,197-202.
37. Frankel, J. A.,Rose, A. K.(1996).Currency Crashes in Emerging Markets: An Empirical Treatment.Journal of International Economics,41,351-366.
38. Frankel, J. A.,Rose, A. K.(1998).The Endogeneity of the Optimum Currency Area Criteria.The Economic Journal,108,1009-1025.
39. Frenkel, J. A.,Rodriguez, C. A.(1982).Exchange Rate Dynamics and the Overshooting Hypothesis.IMF Staff Paper,29,1-30.
40. Frenkel, M.,Nickel, C.,Schmidt, G.,Stadtmann, G.(2001).IMF Working Paper, No. 187IMF Working Paper, No. 187,未出版
41. Friedman, M.(ed.)(1953).Essays in Positive Economics.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
42. Friend, I.,Blume, M. E.(1975).The Demand for Risky Assets.The American Economic Review,65,900-922.
43. Galí, J.,Gertler, M.,Lopez-Salido, J. D.(2001).European Inflation Dynamics.European Economic Review,45,1237-1270.
44. Glick, R.,Wihlborg, C.(1990).Real Exchange Rate Effects of Monetary Shocks under Fixed and Flexible Exchange Rates.Journal of International Economics,28,267-290.
45. Grossman, S. J.,Shiller, R. J.(1981).NBER Working Papers, No. 0564NBER Working Papers, No. 0564,未出版
46. Hamada, K.,Sakurai, M.(1978).International Transmission of Stagflation under Fixed and Flexible Exchange Rates.The Journal of Political Economy,86,877-895.
47. Hansen, L.,Hodrick, R.(1980).Forward Exchange Rates as Optimal Predictors of Future Spot Rates: An Econometric Analysis.Journal of Political Economy,88,829-853.
48. Helpman, E.(1981).An Exploration in the Theory of Exchange Rate-Regimes.Journal of Political Economy,89,865-890.
49. Helpman, E.,Razin, A.(1982).A Comparison of Exchange Rate Regimes in the Presence of Imperfect Capital Market.International Economic Review,23,365-388.
50. Kenen, P. B.(1969).The Theory of Optimum Currency Areas: An Eclectic View.Monetary Problems of the International Economy,Chicago:
51. Kimbrough, K. P.(1983).The Information Content of the Exchange Rate and the Stability of Real Output under Alternative Exchange Rate Regimes.Journal of International Money and Finance,2,27-38.
52. Lai, C. C.,Chang, W. Y.(1987).Flexible Exchange Rates, Capital Mobility Control and Macroeconomic Policies.Journal of Economic Development,12,183-188.
53. Lapan, H. E.,Enders, W.(1980).Random Disturbances and the Choice of Exchange Rate Regimes in an Intergenerational Model.Journal of International Economics,10,263-283.
54. Leith, C.,Malley, J.(2007).Estimated Open Economy Phillips Curves for the G7.Open Economies Review,18,405-426.
55. Lubik, T.,Schorfheide, F.(2005).A Bayesian Look at New Open Economy Macroeconomics.NBER Macroeconomics Annual,20,313-366.
56. McKinnon, R. I.(1963).Optimum Currency Areas.American Economic Review,53,717-725.
57. Mohanty, M.,Turner, P.(2008).Monetary Policy Transmission in Emerging Market Economies: What is New?.BIS Papers,35
58. Mundell, R. A.(1961).Flexible Exchange Rates and Employment Policy.Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science,27,509-517.
59. Mundell, R. A.(1963).Capital Mobility and Stabilization Policy under Fixed and Flexible Exchange Rates.The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science,29,475-485.
60. Mundell, R. A.(1961).A Theory of Optimum Currency Areas.The American Economic Review,51,657-665.
61. Mundell, R. A.(1960).The Monetary Dynamics of International Adjustment under Fixed and Flexible Exchange Rates.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,74,227-257.
62. Neumeyer, P. A.(1998).Currencies and the Allocation of Risk: The Welfare Effects of a Monetary Union.American Economic Review,88,246-259.
63. Obstfeld, M.(2006).NBER Working Paper, No. 12699NBER Working Paper, No. 12699,未出版
64. Obstfeld, M.,Rogoff, K.(2002).Global Implications of Self-oriented National Monetary Rules.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,117,503-535.
65. Obstfeld, M.,Rogoff, K.(1995).Exchange Rate Dynamics Redux.Journal of Political Economy,103,624-660.
66. Obstfeld, M.,Rogoff, K.(2000).New Directions for Stochastic Open Economy Models.Journal of International Economics,50,117-153.
67. Parsley, D. C.,Wei, S. J.(2001).Explaining the Border Effect: The Role of Exchange Rate Variability, Shipping Costs, and Geography.Journal of International Economics,55,87-105.
68. Piazzesi, M.,Swanson, E. T.(2008).Futures Prices as Risk-adjusted Forecasts of Monetary Policy.Journal of Monetary Economics,55,677-691.
69. Roper, D. E.,Turnovsky, S. J.(1980).Optimal Exchange Market Intervention in a Simple Stochastic Macro Model.Canadian Journal of Economics,13,296-309.
70. Rudebusch, G. D.,Sack, B. P.,Swanson, E. T.(2007).Macroeconomic Implications of Changes in the Term Premium.Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, Review,89,241-269.
71. Schmitt-Grohé, S.,Uribe, M.(2003).Closing Small Open Economy Models.Journal of International Economics,61,163-185.
72. Schmitt-Grohé, S.,Uribe, M.(2001).Stabilization Policy and the Costs of Dollarization.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,33,482-509.
73. Thoenissen, C.(2006).CDMA Working Paper, No. 0609.CDMA Working Paper, No. 0609.,未出版
74. Turnovsky, S. J.(1983).Wage Indexation and Exchange Market Intervention in a Small Open Economy.Canadian Journal of Economics,16,574-592.
75. Turnovsky, S. J.(1976).The Relative Stability of Alternative Exchange Rate Systems in the Presence of Random Disturbances.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,8,29-50.
76. Weber, W. E.(1981).Output Variability under Monetary Policy and Exchange-rate Rules.Journal of Political Economy,89,733-751.
77. 賴宗福(2007)。博士論文(博士論文)。中國文化大學經濟學系研究所。
78. 賴宗福(2009)。國科會計畫期中成果報告國科會計畫期中成果報告,國科會。