清潔發展機制（CDM）對溫室氣體之減量效果分析

The Impact of Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) on Greenhouse Gas Emissions Abatement

陳香梅(Shine-May Chen)；陳文典(Wen-Den Chen)；游懷萱(Huai-Hsuan Yu)

清潔發展機制 ； 二氧化碳 ； 全球暖化 ； 固定效果模型 ； 工具變數 ； Clean Development Mechanism ； Carbon Dioxide ； Global Warming ； Fixed Effects Model ； Instrumental Variable

應用經濟論叢

94期（2013 / 12 / 01）

75 - 112

繁體中文

近年來，全球氣候變遷問題已嚴重影響人類生活，而世界各國也逐漸意識到已開發國家和開發中國家必須共同合作以解決此問題。京都議定書中的清潔發展機制（CDM）即是讓已開發國家與開發中國家共同實踐減量目標的一種彈性減量機制，然而過去文獻對於其減排成效的看法並不一致。有鑒於此，本文以參與CDM計畫的20個開發中國家和16個已開發國家為研究對象，探討CDM計畫對其2003至2008年二氧化碳減量之影響。根據兩階段最小平方法之固定效果模型的實證結果顯示，CDM計畫能減少開發中國家的二氧化碳排放量，但經認證的排放減量額度（CERs）有被過量核發之現象；另一方面，CDM計畫對已開發國家的減排效果則無影響。

In recent years, global climate change problem has seriously affected humans' life. There is a consensus that the developed and developing countries have to work together to solve the problem. Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) is one of the flexibility mechanisms defined in the Kyoto Protocol, and it allows the developed countries, in cooperation with developing countries, to fulfill the emission-reduction targets. However, the emissions abatement effects of CDM in the literatures are diverse. Accordingly, this paper uses 20 developed countries and 16 developing countries as an empirical case to examine the impact of CDM on carbon dioxide emissions abatement from 2003 to 2008. According to the fixed effects and two-stage least squares model, CDM projects did reduce the carbon dioxide emissions of developing countries, but the certified emissions reductions (CERs) were excessively issued. On the other hand, CDM projects didn't have an impact on the home countries' emissions of developed partners.

1. 劉錦龍、鄒孟文、劉錦添(2002)。環境管制與空汙排放量：台灣製造業廠商之實證。經濟論文叢刊，303，361-382。
   連結：
2. Hagem, C. and B. Holtsmark, 2009, “Does the Clean Development Mechanism Have a Viable Future?” Research Department of Statistics Norway, Discussion Papers, No. 577.
3. Michaelowa, A. and K. Umamaheswaran, 2006, “Additionality and Sustainable Development Issues Regarding CDM Projects in Energy Efficiency Sector,” HWWA Discussion Paper, No. 346.
4. Selvaretnam, G. and K. Thampanishvong, 2010, “Future of the Clean Development Mechanism in Tackling Climate Change,” Discussion Paper Series, No. 0808, School of Economics and Finance, University of St. Andrews.
5. Schneider, L., 2008, “A Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) with Atmospheric Benefits for a Post-2012 Climate Regime,” Discussion Paper, Öko-Institut, Berlin.
6. Alexeew, J.,Bergset, L.,Meyer, K.,Petersen, J.,Schneider, L.,Unger, C.(2010).An Analysis of the Relationship between the Additionality of CDM Projects and Their Contribution to Sustainable Development.International Environmental Agreements,10,233-248.
7. Amatayakul, W.,Berndes, G.(2007).Fuel Ethanol Program in Thailand: Energy, Agricultural, and Environmental Trade-offs and Prospects for CO2 Abatement.Energy for Sustainable Development,11,51-66.
8. Asuka, J.,Takeuchi, K.(2004).Additionality Reconsidered: Lax Criteria May Not Benefit Developing Countries.Climate Policy,4,177-192.
9. Baltagi, B. H.(2005).Econometric Analysis of Panel Data.Chichester, England:John Wiley & Sons.
10. Böhringer, C.,Conrad, K.,Löschel, A.(2003).Carbon Taxes and Joint Implementation. An Applied General Equilibrium Analysis for Germany and India.Environmental and Resource Economics,24,49-76.
11. Bruvoll, A.,Larsen, B. M.(2004).Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Norway: Do Carbon Taxes Work?.Energy Policy,32,493-505.
12. Bruvoll, A.,Medin, H.(2003).Factors behind the Environmental Kuznets Curve. A Decomposition of the Changes in Air Pollution.Environmental and Resource Economics,24,27-48.
13. Diekmann, A.,Franzen, A.(1999).The Wealth of Nations and Environmental Concern.Environment and Behavior,31,540-549.
14. Dinda, S.,Coondoo, D.,Pal, M.(2000).Air Quality and Economic Growth: An Empirical Study.Ecological Economics,34,409-423.
15. EIA=U.S. Energy Information Administration(2010).International Energy Outlook
16. Ganapati, S.,Liu, L.(2008).The Clean Development Mechanism in China and India: A Comparative Institutional Analysis.Public Administration and Development,28,351-362.
17. Glomsrød, S.,Wei, T.(2005).Coal Cleaning: A Viable Strategy for Reduced Carbon Emissions and Improved Environment in China?.Energy Policy,33,525-542.
18. Green, W. H.(2008).Econometric Analysis.New Jersey:Pearson/Prentice Hall.
19. Grossman, G. M.,Krueger, A. B.(1995).Economic Growth and the Environment.Quarterly Journal of Economics,110,353-377.
20. Hausman, J. A.(1978).Specification Tests in Econometrics.Econometrica,46,1251-1271.
21. IEA=International Energy Agency(2010).CO2 Emissions from Fuel Combustion 2010-Highlights.Paris:OECD.
22. IPCC=Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(2007).Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the IPCCContribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the IPCC,Cambridge:Cambridge University.
23. Iwami, T.(2004).Economic Development and/or Environmental Quality: Emissions of CO2 and SO2 in East Asia.Seoul Journal of Economics,17,55-83.
24. Iwata, H.,Okada, K.,Samreth, S.(2010).Empirical Study on the Environmental Kuznets Curve for CO2 in France: The Role of Nuclear Energy.Energy Policy,38,4057-4063.
25. Kaufmann, R. K.,Davidsdottir, B.,Garnham, S.,Pauly, P.(1998).The Determinants of Atmospheric SO2 Concentrations: Reconsidering the Environmental Kuznets Curve.Ecological Economics,25,209-220.
26. Kossoy, A.,Philippe, A.(2010).State and Trends of the Carbon Market.Washington, DC:World Bank.
27. Li, Y.(2000).The Costs of Implementing the Kyoto Protocol and Its Implications to China.International Review of Environmental Strategies,1,159-174.
28. Lin, S. J.,Lu, I. J.,Lewis, C.(2006).Identifying Key Factors and Strategies for Reducing Industrial CO2 Emissions from a Non-Kyoto Protocol Member's (Taiwan) Perspective.Energy Policy,34,1499-1507.
29. Manne, A. S.,Richels, R. G.(1999).The Kyoto Protocol: A Cost-effective Strategy for Meeting Environmental Objectives?.The Energy Journal,Special Issue,1-23.
30. Manne, A. S.,Richels, R. G.(2000).International Carbon Agreements, EIS Trade and Leakage.Energy Modeling Forum,Stanford:
31. Nijkamp, P.,Wang, S.,Kremers, H.(2005).Modeling the Impacts of International Climate Change Policies in a CGE Context: The Use of GTAP-E Model.Economic Modelling,22,955-974.
32. Partridge, I.,Gamkhar, S.(2010).The Role of Offsets in a Post-Kyoto Climate Agreement: The Power Sector in China.Energy Policy,38,4457-4466.
33. Qi, Y.,Ma, L.,Zhang, H.,Li, H.(2008).Translating a Global Issue into Local Priority: China's Local Government Response to Climate Change.The Journal of Environment Development,17,379-400.
34. Ramsey, J. B.(1969).Tests for Specification Errors in Classical Linear Least Squares Regression Analysis.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,31,350-371.
35. Schipper, L.,Unander, F.,Murtishaw, S.,Ting, M.(2001).Indicators of Energy Use and Carbon Emissions: Explaining the Energy Economy Link.Annual Review of Energy and the Environment,26,49-81.
36. Schneider, L.(2007).Report Prepared for WWFReport Prepared for WWF,Berlin:Oko-Institut.
37. Shi, A.(2003).The Impact of Population Pressure on Global Carbon Dioxide Emissions, 1975-1996: Evidence from Pooled Cross-country Data.Ecological Economics,44,29-42.
38. Shimazaki, Y.,Akisawa, A.,Kashiwagi, T.(2000).A Model Analysis of Clean Development Mechanisms to Reduce both CO2 and SO2 Emissions between Japan and China.Applied Energy,66,311-324.
39. Shin, S.(2010).The Domestic Side of the Clean Development Mechanism: The Case of China.Environmental Politics,19,237-254.
40. Stern, N.(2007).The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern Review.Cambridge:Cambridge University.
41. Sutter, C.,Parreño, J. C.(2007).Does the Current Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) Deliver Its Sustainable Development Claim? An Analysis of Officially Registered CDM Projects.Climatic Change,84,75-90.
42. Tamazian, A.,Chousa, J. P.,Vadlamannati, K. C.(2009).Does Higher Economic and Financial Development Lead to Environmental Degradation: Evidence from BRIC Countries.Energy Policy,37,246-253.
43. Viguier, L. L.(2004).A Proposal to Increase Developing Country Participation in International Climate Policy.Environmental Science and Policy,7,195-204.
44. Wara, M. W.(2007).Is the Global Carbon Market Working?.Nature,445,595-596.
45. Wara, M. W.,Victor, D. G.(2008).PESD Working Paper, No.74.PESD Working Paper, No.74.,未出版
46. White, H.(1980).A Heteroskedasticity-consistent Covariance Matrix Estimator and a Direct Test for Heteroskedasticity.Econometrica,48,817-838.
47. Zhang, J.,Wang, C.(2011).Co-benefits and Additionality of the Clean Development Mechanism: An Empirical Analysis.Journal of Environmental economics and Management,62,140-154.
48. Zhuang, G.(2006).Role of China in Global Carbon Market.China & World Economy,14,93-108.
49. 李國志、李宗植(2010)。中國二氧化碳排放的區域差異和影響因素研究。中國人口、資源與環境，20，22-27。
50. 曾少軍(2010)。碳減排：中國經驗─基于清潔發展機制的考察。北京:社會科學文獻出版社。

1. 劉哲良、邱可甄、吳珮瑛(2016)。溫室氣體減量之清潔發展機制功能與專案成本比較。臺灣國際研究季刊，12(3)，115-50。
2. 劉哲良、邱可甄、吳珮瑛(2017)。清潔發展機制對溫室氣體減量之成本效率與成本差異分析－共同邊界架構之應用。農業與經濟，59，73-118。