题名

Threshold Cointegration and Dynamics of Crude Oil Futures Volatility and Financial Speculation

并列篇名

原油期貨波動和金融性投機之門檻共整合動態關係

DOI

10.3966/054696002014120096001

作者

李瑞琳(Nicholas Ruei-Lin Lee)；朱香蕙(Hsiang-Hui Chu)；劉榮芳(Jung-Fang Liu)；林益倍(Yih-Bey Lin)

关键词

金融性投機 ； 原油期貨波動 ； 門檻共整合 ； 因果相關 ； 市場不穩定 ； Financial Speculation ； Crude Oil Futures Volatility ； Threshold Cointegration ； Granger Causality ； Market Instability

期刊名称

應用經濟論叢

卷期/出版年月

96期（2014 / 12 / 01）

页次

1 - 34

内容语文

英文
中文摘要

本文以門檻向量誤差修正模型（TVECM）探討紐約商品交易所（NYMEX）原油期貨波動性和投機之間門檻共整合動態關係。門檻的區間係由模型內生決定，並定義誤差修正項在門檻下（上）之（非）一般區間。我們以原油期貨交易量相對未平倉合約數作為投機變數。此外，以原油期貨報酬絕對值與高低價差分別作為波動衡量變數。實證結果顯示，在二個門檻區間，原油期貨波動和投機各自朝向長期均衡有不同的調整速度以及顯著不對稱性結果。此外，我們也發現誤差修正項在門檻下之一般區間，除報酬絕對值波動受投機影響外，波動影響投機的單向因果關係，表示市場具有相對效率。而誤差修正項在門檻上之非一般區間，兩者有回饋現象，代表市場不穩定的惡化現象，具有緩和的傾向。整體上，雖然紐約商品交易所（NYMEX）的原油期貨市場存在門檻效果，但現有制度使原油期貨市場展現大致良好的效率性。
英文摘要

This paper investigates threshold cointegration and dynamics of New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) crude oil futures volatility and speculation in the framework of a threshold vector error correction model (TVECM). Two regimes are determined by the model and divided into the usual and unusual regime. We use the ratio of volume over open interest as speculation variable while we consider two volatilities measures, absolute return and high-low volatilities. Our findings present different and strong asymmetric error correction effects of volatility and speculation in the speed of adjustment to the long-run equilibrium in two regimes. In addition of speculation leading volatility based on former measure, speculation following volatility is found in the usual regime, suggesting relative market efficient. Bidirectional causalities of speculation and different volatilities measures in the unusual regime suggest that market instability mitigated in the unusual regime. In sum, crude oil futures markets seem to work well with the existence of threshold cointegration.
主题分类 基礎與應用科學 > 永續發展研究
生物農學 > 農業
生物農學 > 森林
生物農學 > 畜牧
生物農學 > 漁業
社會科學 > 經濟學
社會科學 > 財金及會計學
参考文献
  1. Lee, N. R.(2010).Energy Futures Volatility, Trading Activity, and Regime Switching.Taiwan Journal of Applied Economics,88,29-58.
    連結：
  2. Khan, M. S., 2009, “The 2008 Oil Price Bubble,” Peterson Institute for International Economics Policy Brief No.PB09-19.
  3. Masters, M. W., 2008, “Testimony before the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs,” United States Senate, Washington, D.C...
  4. Cho, D., 2008, “A Few Speculators Dominate Vast Market for Oil Trading,” Washington Post, August 21, A01
  5. Aslanidis, N.,Kouretas, G. P.(2005).Testing for Two-regime Threshold Cointegration in the Parallel and Official Markets for Foreign Currency in Greece.Economic Modelling,22,665-682.
  6. Balke, N. S.,Fomby, T. B.(1997).Threshold Cointegration.International Economic Review,38,627-645.
  7. Balke, N. S.,Wohar, M. E.(1998).Nonlinear Dynamics and Covered Interest Rate Parity.Empirical Economics,23,535-559.
  8. Bamber, L. S.,Barron, O. E.,Stober, T. L.(1999).Differential Interpretations and Trading Volume.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,34,369-386.
  9. Baum, C. F.,Barkoulas, J. T.,Caglayan, M.(2001).Nonlinear Adjustment to Purchasing Power Parity in the Post-Bretton Woods Era.Journal of International Money and Finance,20,379-399.
  10. Baum, C. F.,Karasulu, M.(1997).Modelling Federal Reserve Discount Policy.Computational Economics,11,53-70.
  11. Bekiros, S. D.,Diks, C. G. H.(2008).The Relationship between Crude Oil Spot and Futures Prices: Cointegration, Linear and Nonlinear Causality.Energy Economics,30,2673-2685.
  12. Caballero, R. J.,Farhi, E.,Gourinchas, P. O.(2008).NBER Working Paper, No.14521NBER Working Paper, No.14521,未出版
  13. CFTC(2009).,Washington D. C.:U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
  14. Chan, K.,Chung, Y. P.(1993).Intraday Relationships among Index Arbitrage, Spot and Futures Price Volatility, and Spot Market Volume: A Transaction Data Test.Journal of Banking and Finance,17,663-687.
  15. Chang, E.,Chou, R. Y.,Nelling, E. F.(2000).Market Volatility and the Demand for Hedging in Stock Index Futures.The Journal of Futures Markets,20,105-125.
  16. Chatrath, A.,Song, F.(1998).Information and Volatility in Futures and Spot Markets: The Case of the Japanese Yen.Journal of Futures Markets,18,201-223.
  17. Chen, L. H. C.,Finney, M.,Lai, K. S.(2005).A Threshold Cointegration Analysis of Asymmetric Price Transmission from Crude Oil to Gasoline Prices.Economics Letters,89,233-239.
  18. Chevillon, G.,Rifflart, C.(2009).Physical Market Determinants of the Price of Crude Oil and the Market Premium.Energy Economics,31,537-549.
  19. Chilton, B.(2008).Chilton, B., 2008, “Staff Report on Commodity Swap Dealers & Index Traders with Commission Recommendations,” U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Washington D.C.Chilton, B., 2008, “Staff Report on Commodity Swap Dealers & Index Traders with Commission Recommendations,” U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Washington D.C.,Washington D.C.:U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
  20. Cifarelli, G.,Paladino, G.(2010).Oil Price Dynamics and Speculation: A Multivariate Financial Approach.Energy Economics,32,363-372.
  21. Ciner, C.(2002).Information Content of Volume: An Investigation of Tokyo Commodity Futures Markets.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,10,201-215.
  22. Coleman, M.(1990).Cointegration-based Tests of Daily Foreign Exchange Market Efficiency.Economics Letters,32,53-59.
  23. Du, X.,Yu, C. L.,Hayes, D. J.(2011).Speculation and Volatility Spillover in the Crude Oil and Agricultural Commodity Markets: A Bayesian Analysis.Energy Economics,33,497-503.
  24. Dunis, C. L.,Laws, J.,Evans, B.(2006).Modelling and Trading the Gasoline Crack Spread: A Non-linear Story.Derivatives Use, Trading Regulation,12,126-145.
  25. Enders, W.,Falk, B.(1998).Threshold-autoregressive, Median-unbiased and Cointegration Tests of Purchasing Power Parity.International Journal of Forecasting,14,171-186.
  26. Fleming, J.,Ostdiek, B.(1999).The Impact of Energy Derivatives on the Crude Oil Market.Energy Economics,21,135-167.
  27. Foster, A. J.(1995).Volume-volatility Relationships for Crude Oil Futures Markets.Journal of Futures Markets,15,929-951.
  28. Fung, H.,Patterson, G.(1999).The Dynamic Relationship of Volatility, Volume, and Market Depth in Currency Futures Markets.Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money,9,33-59.
  29. Fung, W.,Hsieh, D. A.(2000).Measuring the Market Impact of Hedge Funds.Journal of Empirical Finance,7,1-36.
  30. Garcia, P.,Leuthold, R. M.,Zapata, H.(1986).Lead-lag Relationships between Trading Volume and Price Variability: New Evidence.The Journal of Futures Markets,6,1-10.
  31. Granger, C. W. J.(1969).Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-spectral methods.Econometrica: Journal of Econometric Society,37,424-438.
  32. Granger, C. W. J.,Huang, B.,Yang, C. W.(2000).A Bivariate Causality between Stock Prices and Exchange Rates: Evidence from Recent Asianflu.The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,40,337-354.
  33. Gwilym, O. A. P.,McMillan, D.,Speight, A.(1999).The Intraday Relationship between Volume and Volatility in LIFFE Futures Markets.Applied Financial Economics,9,593-604.
  34. Hansen, B. E.(1996).Inference When a Nuisance Parameter Is Not Identified under the Null Hypothesis.Econometrica: Journal of Econometric Society,64,413-430.
  35. Hansen, B. E.(2000).Testing for Structural Change in Conditional Models.Journal of Econometrics,97,93-115.
  36. Hansen, B. E.,Seo, B.(2002).Testing for Two-regime Threshold Cointegration in Vector Error-correction Models.Journal of Econometrics,110,293-318.
  37. Herbert, J. H.(1995).Trading Volume, Maturity and Natural Gas Futures Price Volatility.Energy Economics,17,293-299.
  38. Holthausen, R. W.,Leftwich, R. W.,Mayers, D.(1987).The Effect of Large Block Transactions on Security Prices.Journal of Financial Economics,19,237-267.
  39. Hsueh, P.,Liu, A.,Lee, N. R.(2008).Dynamics of Volatility, Futures Trading, and Investor Sentiments under Different Market Conditions.International Research Journal of Finance and Economics,20,151-163.
  40. Huang, B. N.,Yang, C. W.,Hwang, M. J.(2009).The Dynamics of a Nonlinear Relationship between Crude Oil Spot and Futures Prices: A Multivariate Threshold Regression Approach.Energy Economics,31,91-98.
  41. IMF=International Monetary Fund(2006).World Economic and Outlook: Globalization and Inflation.Washington D.C.:IMF Press.
  42. Karpoff, J. M.(1987).The Relationship between Price Changes and Trading Volume: A Survey.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,22,109-126.
  43. Kaufmann, R. K.,Ullman, B.(2009).Oil Prices, Speculation, and Fundamentals: Interpreting Causal Relations Among Spot and Futures Prices.Energy Economics,31,550-558.
  44. Kellard, N.,Dunis, C.,Sarantis, N.(2010).Foreign Exchange, Fractional Cointegration and the Implied-realized Volatility Relation.Journal of Banking and Finance,34,882-891.
  45. Kocagil, A. E.,Shachmurove, Y.(1998).Return-volume Dynamics in Futures Markets.Journal of Futures Markets,18,399-426.
  46. Kühl, M.(2010).Bivariate Cointegration of Major Exchange Rates, Cross-market Efficiency and the Introduction of the Euro.Journal of Economics and Business,62,1-19.
  47. Kyriacou, K.,Sarno, L.(1999).The Temporal Relationship between Derivatives Trading and Spot Market Volatility in the UK: Empirical Analysis and Monte Carlo Evidence.The Journal of Futures Markets,19,245-270.
  48. Liew, K.,Brooks, R.(1998).Returns and Volatility in the Kuala Lumpur Crude.The Journal of Futures Markets,18,985-999.
  49. Lo, M.,Zivot, E.(2001).Threshold Cointegration and Nonlinear Adjustment to the Law of One Price.Macroeconomic Dynamics,5,533-576.
  50. Luu, C. J.,Martens, M.(2003).Testing the Mixture-of-distributions Hypothesis Using Realized Volatility.The Journal of Futures Markets,23,661-679.
  51. Mamatzakis, E.,Remoundos, P.(2011).Testing for Adjustment Costs and Regime Shifts in BRENT Crude Futures Market.Economic Modelling,28,1000-1008.
  52. Michael, P.,Nobay, A. R.,Peel, D. A.(1997).Transactions Costs and Nonlinear Adjustment in Real Exchange Rates: An Empirical Investigation.Journal of Political Economy,105,862-879.
  53. Nainar, S. M. K.(1993).Market Information and Price Volatility in Petroleum Derivatives Spot and Futures Markets: Some New York Evidence.Energy Economics,15,17-24.
  54. Nakagawa, H.(2010).Investigating Nonlinearities in Real Exchange Rate Adjustment: Threshold Cointegration and the Dynamics of Exchange Rates and Relative Prices.Journal of International Money and Finance,29,770-790.
  55. Natanelov, V.,Alam, M. J.,McKenzie, A. M.,Van Huylenbroeck, G.(2011).Is There Co-movement of Agricultural Commodities Futures Prices and Crude Oil?.Energy Policy,39,4971-4984.
  56. O'Connell, P. G. J.(1998).Market Frictions and Real Exchange Rates.Journal of International Money and Finance,17,71-95.
  57. Pippenger, M. K.,Goering, G. E.(2000).Additional Results on the Power of Unit Root and Cointegration Tests under Threshold Processes.Applied Economics Letters,7,641-644.
  58. Ripple, R. D.,Moosa, I. A.(2009).The Effect of Maturity, Trading Volume, and Open Interest on Crude Oil Futures Price Range-based Volatility.Global Finance Journal,20,209-219.
  59. Shalen, C. T.(1993).Volume, Volatility, and the Dispersion of Beliefs.Review of Financial Studies,6,405-434.
  60. Weiner, R. J.(2009).Speculation and Oil Price Volatility.2009 EIA Annual Conference,Washington, D.C.:
  61. Zhu, H. M.,Li, S. F.,Yu, K.(2011).Crude Oil Shocks and Stock Markets: A Panel Threshold Cointegration Approach.Energy Economics,33,987-994.
被引用次数
  1. 蔡維,陳芳質,林正寶(2019)。多重結構變動下恐慌指標與國際油價的動態關係。應用經濟論叢，106，149-180。
print cancel