產業聚集與廠商生產力之關係：以台灣電子產業為例

Relationship between Industry Agglomeration and Firm Productivity: Evidence from Taiwan Electronics Industry

10.3966/054696002016120100001

林惠玲(Hui-Lin Lin)；陳麗旭(Li-Hsu Chen)；羅美蘭(Mei-Lan Lo)；劉訓華(Hsiun-Hua Liu)

電子產業 ； 聚集 ； 勞動生產力 ； EG指數 ； 聚集圈 ； Electronics Industry ； Agglomeration ； Labor Productivity ； EG Index ； Cluster Circle

應用經濟論叢

100期（2016 / 12 / 01）

1 - 34

繁體中文

本文使用經濟部的「工廠校正暨營運調查」2005 年至2009 年工廠層級的廠商資料，探討資源投入與空間聚集程度對廠商生產力的影響。我們採用EG 指數及NNI 方法分析台灣電子產業。研究結果發現：(1) 勞動投入聚集與研發投入聚集呈現增加的趨勢；(2) 研發投入聚集程度與生產力呈正向顯著的關係，而勞動投入聚集與生產力呈現負向顯著的關係；(3) 大致而言，位於聚集圈內的廠商已經有聚集不經濟的現象；(4) 不同面向的聚集程度對生產力的效果，受到廠商特性及區域差異的影響。

Based on the plant-level dataset of Taiwan 2005-2009 Report on Factory Operation Census, which was collected by Ministry of Economic Affairs, R.O.C. This paper investigated the firm productivity was influenced by different dimensions and levels of agglomeration (labor input, R&D input and proximity).By taking industry structure and proximity into account, we calculated EG Index and NNI to analyze the agglomeration phenomena of Taiwan electronics industry. Results showed: (1) The indices of labor input and R&D input agglomeration both increased. (2) There was a significant positive relationship between R&D input agglomeration and productivity, while the effect of labor input agglomeration on productivity was negative. (3) In general, we found the firms located in the cluster have suffered from the agglomeration diseconomies. (4) The relationships between agglomeration and productivity were affected by the plant-specific features and region-specific characteristics.

1. 林惠玲、詹立宇、謝玉玟(2009)。產業聚集與廠商研發活動之研究–台灣電子廠商之驗證。人文及社會科學集刊，21，521-554。
   連結：
2. 詹立宇、張明宗、徐之強(2004)。台灣製造業垂直分工與產業聚集之關係。經濟論文叢刊，32，483-511。
   連結：
3. 詹立宇(2010)。台灣電子業產生技術效率之區域差異與相關。東吳經濟商學報，71，1-26。
   連結：
4. 蘇偉哲、游雅婷、楊志海(2013)。廠商聚集與生產力–臺灣紡織產業的實證研究。台灣經濟預測與政策，44，133-160。
   連結：
5. Hoover, E. M., 1937, Location Theory and the Shoe and Leather Industries, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
6. Sonobe, T., J. Akoten, and K. Otsuka, 2006, “The Development of the Footwear Industry in Ethiopia: How Different Is It from the East Asian Experience,” FASID Discussion Paper Series on International Development Strategies.
7. Andersson, M. and H. Lööf, 2009, “Agglomeration and Productivity: Evidence from Firm-level Data,” Electronic Working Paper, No. 170.
8. Marshall, A., 1920, Principles of Economics, London: Macmillan Press.
9. Åberg, Y.(1973).I. Regional Productivity Differences in Swedish Manufacturing.Regional and Urban Economics,3,131-156.
10. Anderson, T. W.,Hsiao, C.(1982).Formulation and Estimation of Dynamic Models Using Panel Data.Journal of Econometrics,18,47-82.
11. Anselin, L.,Attila, V.,Zoltan, A.(1997).Local Geographic Spillovers between University Research and High Technology Innovations.Journal of Urban Economics,42,422-448.
12. Arellano, M.,Bond, S.(1991).Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data: Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations.Review of Economic Studies,58,277-297.
13. Audretsch, D. B.(2003).Innovation and Spatial Externalities.International Regional Science Review,26,167-174.
14. Audretsch, D. B.,Feldman, P. F.(1996).R&D Spillovers and the Geography of Innovation and Production.American Economic Review,86,630-640.
15. Aw, B. Y.(2002).Productivity Dynamics of Small and Medium Enterprises in Taiwan.Small Business Economics,18,69-84.
16. Aw, B. Y.,Lee, Y.(2008).Firm Heterogeneity and Location Choice of Taiwanese Multinationals.Journal of International Economics,75,167-179.
17. Bagnasco, A.(1977).Tre Italie: La Problematica Territoriale Dello Sviluppo Economico Italiano.Bologna:Il Mulino Press.
18. Baptista, R.(2001).Geographical Clusters and Innovation Diffusion.Technological Forecasting and Social Change,66,31-46.
19. Bottazzi, L.,Giovanni, P.(2003).Innovation and Spillovers in Regions: Evidence from European Patent Data.European Economic Review,47,687-710.
20. Braunerhjelm, P.,Borgman, B.(2004).Geographical Concentration, Entrepreneurship and Regional Growth: Evidence from Regional Data in Sweden, 1975-99.Regional Studies,38,929-947.
21. Brülhart, M.,Mathys, N.(2008).Sectoral Agglomeration Economies in a Panel of European Regions.Regional Science and Urban Economics,38,348-362.
22. Chang, C. L.,Les, O.(2009).Industrial Agglomeration, Geographic Innovation and Total Factor Productivity: The Case of Taiwan.Mathematics and Computers in Simulation,79,2787-2796.
23. Chen, J. R.,Yang, C. H.(2006).The Effects of Knowledge Capital on Enhancing Firms' Productivity in Taiwan: Does R&D or Technology Import Matter?.Hitotsubashi Journal of Economics,47,137-153.
24. Ciccone, A.,Hall, E. R.(1996).Productivity and the Density of Economic Activity.American Economic Review,86,54-70.
25. Clark, P. J.,Evans, F. C.(1954).Distance to Nearest Neighbor as a Measure of Spatial Relationships in Populations.Ecology,35,445-453.
26. Cohen, W. M.,Klepper, S.(1996).A Reprise of Size and R & D.Economic Journal,106,925-951.
27. Cressie, N.(2015).Statistics for Spatial Data.New York:John Wiley & Sons Press.
28. Dumais, G.,Ellison, G.,Glaeser, E. L.(2002).Geographic Concentration as a Dynamic Process.Review of Economics and Statistics,84,193-204.
29. Ellison, G.,Glaeser, E. L.(1997).Geographic Concentration in U.S. Manufacturing Industries: A Dartboard Approach.Journal of Political Economy,105,889-927.
30. Feldman, M. P.,Florida, R.(1994).The Geographic Sources of Innovation: Technological Infrastructure and Product Innovation in the United States.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,84,210-229.
31. Fischer, M.,Thomas, S.,Eva, J.(2006).The Geography of Knowledge Spillovers between High-technology Firms in Europe: Evidence from a Spatial Interaction Modeling Perspective.Geographical Analysis,38,288-309.
32. Florax, R.,Folmer, H.(1992).Knowledge Impacts of Universities on Industry: An Aggregate Simultaneous Investment Model.Journal of Regional Science,32,437-466.
33. Folta, T. B.,Cooper, A. C.,Baik, Y. S.(2006).Geographic Cluster Size and Firm Performance.Jouranl of Business Venturing,21,217-242.
34. Glaeser, E. L.,Kallal, H. D.,Scheinkman, J. A.,Shleifer, A.(1992).Growth in Cities.Journal of Political Economy,100,1126-1152.
35. Grilliches, Z.(1992).The Search for R&D Spillovers.Scandinavian Journal of Economics,94,29-47.
36. Haltiwanger, J. C.,Lane, J. I.,Splezer, J. R.(1999).Productivity Differences Across Employers: The Role of Employer Size, Age, and Human Capital.American Economic Review,89,94-98.
37. Hamermesh, D. S.(1993).Labor Demand.New Jersey:Princeton University Press.
38. Harrison, B.(1992).Industrial Districts: Old Wine in New Bottles?.Regional Studies,26,469-483.
39. Henderson, J. V.(2003).Marshall's Scale Economies.Journal of Urban Economics,53,1-28.
40. Henry, N.,Pinch, S.(2000).Spatializing Knowledge: Placing the Knowledge Community of Motor Sport Valley.Geoforum,31,191-208.
41. Holmes, T. J.(1999).Localization of Industry and Vertical Disintegration.Review of Economics and Statistics,81,314-325.
42. Holtz-Eakin, D.,Newey, W.,Rosen, H.(1988).Estimating Vector Autoregressions with Panel Data.Econometrica,56,1371-1395.
43. Iranzo, S.,Schivardi, F.,Tosetti, E.(2008).Skill Dispersion and Firm Productivity: An Analysis with Employer-employee Matched Data.Journal of Labor Economics,26,247-285.
44. Jacobs, J.(1969).The Economy of Cities.New York:Random House Press.
45. Jaffe, A.,Trajtenberg, M.,Henderson, R.(1993).Geographic Localization of Knowledge Spillovers as Evidenced by Patent Citation.Quarterly Journal of Economics,108,577-598.
46. Jeffcutt, P.,Pratt, A. C.(2002).Managing Creativity in the Cultural Industries.Creativity and Innovation Management,11,225-233.
47. Krugman, P.(1991).Geography and Trade.Cambridge:MIT Press.
48. Krugman, P.(1991).Increasing Returns and Economics Geography.Journal of Political Economy,99,89-113.
49. Lambooy, J.(2002).Knowledge and Urban Economic Development: An Evolutionary Perspective.Urban Studies,29,1019-1035.
50. Lee, B. S.,Jang, S.,Hong, S. Y.(2010).Marshall's Scale Economies and Jacobs Externalities in Korea: The Role of Age, Size and the Legal Organization of Firms.Urban Studies,47,3131-3156.
51. Lissoni, F.(2001).Knowledge Codification and the Geography of Innovation: The Case of Brescia Mechanical Cluster.Research Policy,30,1479-1500.
52. Liu, J.,Tsou, M.,Hammitt, K.(1999).Do Small Plants Grow Faster? Evidence from the Taiwan Electronics Industry.Economics Letters,65,121-129.
53. Maliszewski, P. J.,ÓhUallacháin, B.(2012).Hierarchy and Concentration in the American Urban System of Technological Advance.Papers in Regional Science,91,743-758.
54. Martin, R.,Sunley, P.(2003).Deconstructing Clusters: Chaotic Concept or Policy Panacea?.Journal of Economic Geography,3,5-35.
55. Moomaw, R. L.(1981).Productive Efficiency and the Region.Southern Economic Journal,48,344-357.
56. Morgan, K.(2004).The Exaggerated Death of Geography: Learning, Proximity and Territorial Innovation Systems.Journal of Economic Geography,4,3-21.
57. Nonaka, I.,Takeuchi, H.(1995).Knowledge-creating Company.New York:Oxford University Press.
58. ÓhUallacháin, B.,Satterthwaite, M. A.(1992).Sectoral Growth Patterns at the Metropolitan Level: An Evolution of Economic Development Incentives.Journal of Urban Economics,31,25-38.
59. Paci, R.,Usai, S.(1999).Externalities, Knowledge Spillovers and the Spatial Distribution of Innovation.GeoJournal,49,381-390.
60. Piore, M.,Sabel, C.(1984).Second Industrial Divide.New York:Basic Books Press.
61. Porter, M. E.(2000).Location, Competition, and Economic Development: Local Clusters in a Global Economy.Economic Development Quarterly,14,5-34.
62. Porter, M. E.(1998).Clusters and the New Economics of Competition.Harvard Business Review,76,77-90.
63. Porter, M. E.(1990).Competitive Advantage of Nations.New York:Free Press.
64. Pyke, F.(ed.),Becattin, G.(ed.),Sengenberger, W.(ed.)(1990).Industrial Districts and Inter-firm Co-operation in Italy.Geneva:ILO.
65. Rice, P.,Venables, A. J.,Patacchini, E.(2006).Spatial Determinants of Productivity: Analysis for the Regions of Great Britain.Regional Science and Urban Economics,36,727-752.
66. Rosenthal, S. S.,Strange, W. C.(2003).Geography, Industrial Organization and Agglomeration.The Review of Economics and Statistics,85,377-393.
67. Rosenthal, S. S.,Strange, W. C.(2001).The Determinants of Agglomeration.Journal of Urban Economics,50,191-229.
68. Shanmugam, K. R.,Bhaduri, S. N.(2002).Size, Age and Firm Growth in the Indian Manufacturing Sector.Applied Economics Letters,9,607-613.
69. Storper, M.,Venables, A. J.(2004).Buzz: Face-to-face Contact and the Urban Economy.Joural of Economic Geography,4,351-370.
70. Todo, Y.,Shimizutani, S.(2008).Overseas R&D Activities and Home Productivity Growth: Evidence from Japanese Firm-level Data.Journal of Industrial Economics,56,752-777.
71. Wheeler, C. H.(2003).Evidence on Agglomeration Economies, Diseconomies and Growth.Journal of Applied Econometrics,18,79-104.
72. Yang, C. H.,Li, H. Y.,Lin, H. L.(2013).Influences of Production and R&D Agglomeration on Productivity: Evidence from Chinese Electronic Firms.China Economic Review,27,162-178.
73. 王嘉齡(2009)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立中央大學產業經濟研究所。
74. 許秀暖(2007)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中央大學產業經濟研究所。
75. 陳玟君(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立政治大學地政研究所。
76. 陳劍鋒、唐振鵬(2002)。國外產業集群研究綜述。外國經濟與管理，8，23-28。

1. 張仁家,侯淳馨(2019)。當前電資領域企業對科技大學畢業生的就業力調查。科技與人力教育季刊，6(1)，55-72。