臺灣設施農民擴建意願與採用決策分析

Facility Farmers' Willingness-to-Expand for their Greenhouse and Adopting Decision in Taiwan

10.3966/054696002018060103007

楊上禾(Shang-Ho Yang)；陳海菁(Hai-Jing Chen)；萬鍾汶(Jong-Wen Wann)

農業設施 ； 設施農戶 ； 採用決策 ； 溫室 ； Agricultural Facility ； Facility Farmers ； Adopting Decision ； Greenhouse

應用經濟論叢

103期（2018 / 06 / 01）

241 - 273

繁體中文

近年氣候劇烈變遷及市場環境變化影響，發展設施農業乃因應穩定供應農產品策略之一。為深入瞭解農民應用農業設施之動機與成因要素，本研究透過問卷調查掌握設施農民對農業設施之擴建意願，並以不同設施態樣種類之決策加以探討採用何種設施態樣之關鍵因素，因此，本研究先採用二元選擇模型中的羅吉斯模型(logit model)探究國內前十大類採用設施栽培之作物(包括：甜椒、菇類、小葉菜、苦瓜、番茄、葡萄、木瓜、草莓、文心蘭、洋桔梗)作為國內設施農業產業發展之依據；然後再以多元羅吉斯迴歸模型(multinomial logit model)探討設施農民採用何種設施態樣種類之決策方向。透過290位全臺設施農民之調查訪問與實證結果顯示未來主要農業設施發展方向以南部較年輕男性農戶、較多設施經驗、有加入產銷班、較注重增加耕種面積效益者、同意設施容許量放寬者、目前種植以水果類設施農民、有出貨到批發市場者、且有生產履歷者皆有意願擴建設施。而會採用不同設施態樣之決策則是與教育程度、土地面積、上過農民學院課程、地區性不同、農民對設施效益有所不同看法、種植品項與通路差異下皆會採用不同設施態樣。上述結果發現，擴建設施意願仍有地區上與年齡上差異，不管在提高產量之效益、通路考量與農產品項種類等特性皆是引導設施農業產業發展的誘因，因此，政策制定仍須考量產業發展動力來源方能顯著提升國內農產業穩定發展。

Since the climate change and market environment have been dramatically influenced recent years, developing facility agriculture is one of strategies for stabilizing supply of agricultural products. In order to understand the motivation and the factors why farmers adopt agricultural facilities, this study utilizes a survey method to investigate the willingness-to-expand on their greenhouse among facility farmers. Furthermore, the key factors of decision making for different types of facility is further discussed how farmers choose the types of facility. Therefore, a Logit Model is adopted to evaluate the expanding decision for their facility which is focused on the top 10 potential facility crops, i.e., bell pepper, mushroom, small leafy vegetable, bitter squash, tomato, grape, papaya, strawberry, dancing-doll orchid, and lisianthus. And then a Multinomial Logit Model is further adopted to investigate the development of each types of facility. Through the interview survey from a total of 290 facility farmers, the empirical results show that facility farmers would like to expand their facility, especially for those who are young male farmers, from southern Taiwan, more experience with facility, join the production and marketing cooperative, emphasizing the benefit of the increasing cultivated area, agreeing to release the limitation of facility capacity, fruit facility farmers, using the wholesale market channel, and having traceability certificate. While farmers adopted different types of facility may be because their education level, land size, joined the plantation courses, from different regions, different perspectives on the benefits of facility, different crops, and different market channels. From above mentioned results we found that the willingness to expand horticulture greenhouses can be affected by different regions and age groups. Not only focusing on the productivity enhancement but also considering market channels and the characteristics of agricultural products are motivated and leading the development of facility agriculture. Therefore, it still needs to consider the motivation of the industrial development when making relative policy, so it would significantly enhance the stable development for the domestic agriculture.

1. 卓輝星(2012)。影響果菜批發市場勞動使用效率與調整因素之探討。應用經濟論叢，2012 生產力與效率特刊，279-313。
   連結：
2. 許聖章、張靜貞(2011)。台灣颱風災害之影響評估—以蔬菜供需為例。應用經濟論叢，89，31-62。
   連結：
3. 戴孟宜、呂麗蓉、胡士文、王葳(2009)。農業政策與內生成長。農業經濟論叢，85，1-45。
   連結：
4. Aramyan, L. H.,Ondersteijn, C. J. M.,Lansink, A. G. J. M. O.,Kooten, O. V.,Wijnands, J. H. M.(2006).Analyzing Greenhouse Firm Performance Across Different Marketing Channels.Agribusiness,22,267-280.
5. Armstrong, H.(2003).Spain's Dependence on Exports.Fruit & Veg Tech,3,14-17.
6. Boon, J. K., 2015, “Spain, the World's Main Exporter of Fresh Fruits and Vegetables”, Fruit & Vegetable Facts, Retrieved November 5, 2017, from http://www.freshplaza.com/article/133294/spain,-the-worlds-main-exporter-of-fresh-fruits-and-vegetables.
7. Calatrava-Requena, J.,Canero, R.,Ortega, J.(2000).A Productivity and Cultivation Cost Analysis in Plastic Covered Horticulture: Results from a Paneled Sample of Greenhouses at the Nijar (Almeria) Area.Proceedings of International Symposium on Protected Cultivation in Mild Winter Climates: Current Trends for Sustainable Technologies,Cartegena, Spain:
8. Cameron, A. C.,Trivedi, P. K.(2005).Microeconometrics: Methods and Applications.New York:Cambridge University Press.
9. Carey, E. E.,Jett, L.,Lamont, W. J., Jr.,Nennich, T. T.,Orzolek, M. D.,Williams, K. A.(2009).Horticultural Crop Production in High Tunnels in the United States: A Snapshot.HortTechnology,19,37-43.
10. Galinato, S. P.,Miles, C. A.(2013).Economic Profitability of Growing Lettuce and Tomato in Western Washington under High Tunnel and Open-field Production Systems.HortTechnology,23,453-461.
11. Grisolia, F.,Farragina, E.(2015).Social Innovation on the Rise: Yet Another Buzzword in a Time of Austerity?.Salute e Societa,11,165-175.
12. Hausman, J.,McFadden, D.(1984).Specification Tests for the Multinomial Logit Model.Econometrica,52,1219-1240.
13. HortiDaily, 2016, “Spain: Greenhouse Acreage Almeria Exceeds 30,000 Hectares”, Retrieved May 11, 2017, from http://www.hortidaily.com/article/25098/Spain-Greenhouse-acreage-Almeria-exceeds-30,000-hectares
14. HortiDaily, 2014, “Spain: 'Almeria Has the World's Largest Greenhouse Acreage with Almost No Phytosanitary Treatments'”, Retrieved May 11, 2017, from http://www.hortidaily.com/article/11776/Spain-Almeria-has-the-worlds-largest-greenhouse-acreage-with-almost-no-phytosanitary-treatments
15. Jett, L. W., 2011, “Economics of High Tunnel Vegetable and Strawberry Production in the Central Midwest”, West Virginia University Extension Service, Retrieved November 5, 2017, from https://www2.ag.purdue.edu/hla/fruitveg/Presentations /econ_summer_crop.pdf
16. Juutinen, A.,Mitani, Y.,Mantymaa, E.,Shoji, Y.,Siikamaki, P.,Svento, R.(2011).Combining Ecological and Recreational Aspects in National Park Management: A Choice Experiment Application.Ecological Economics,70,1231-1239.
17. Kadir, S.,Carey, E.,Ennahli, S.(2006).Influence of High Tunnel and Field Conditions on Strawberry Growth and Development.HortScience,41,329-335.
18. Kaiser, C. and M. Ernst, 2012, “High Tunnel Tomatoes”, University of Kentucky, Retrieved June 18, 2016, from http://www.uky.edu/Ag/CCD/introsheets/hightunnelto matoes.pdf
19. Kotler, P.(1994).Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, Implementing, and Control.New Jersey:Prentice-Hall Press.
20. Lambarraa, F.(2012).The Spanish Horticulture Sector: A Dynamic Efficiency Analysis of Outdoor and Greenhouse Farms.Proceedings of 2012 IAAE Triennial Conference,Foz do Iguacu, Brazil:
21. Lamont, W. J., Jr.(2009).Overview of the Use of High Tunnels Worldwide.HortTechnology,19,25-29.
22. Mattson, N.(2008).Needs Assessment Survey of the New York State Greenhouse Industry.Ithaca:Cornell University Cooperative Extension Press.
23. McFadden, D.(1973).Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behavior.New York:Academic Press.
24. Medina, Y.,Gosselin, A.,Desjardins, Y.,Gauthier, L.,Harnois, R.,Khanizadeh, S.(2009).Effect of Plastic Mulches on Microclimate Conditions, Growth and Yields of Strawberry Plants Grown under High Tunnels in Northern Canadian Climate.ISHS Acta Horticulturae,842,139-142.
25. Reynolds-Allie, K.,Fields, D.,Hartarska, V.(2010).A Comparison of Technical Efficiency in Alabama's Nursery and Greenhouse Sector from 2003 to 2008.Proceedings of 2010 Annual Meeting of the Southern Agricultural Economics Association,Orlando, Florida:
26. Smith, S. A.,Taylor, T. G.(1999).Economic Information ReportEconomic Information Report,University of Florida.
27. Sydorovych, O.,Rivard, C. L.,O'Connell, S.,Harlow, C. D.,Peet, M. M.,Louws, F. J.(2013).Growing Organic Heirloom Tomatoes in the Field and High Tunnels in North Carolina: Comparative Economic Analysis.HortTechnology,23,227-236.
28. TechNavio(2014).Global Greenhouse Horticulture Market 2014-2018.Ireland:Bharat Book Bureau Press.
29. Tout, D.(1990).The Horticulture Industry of Almeria Province, Spain.The Geographical Journal,156,304-312.
30. Yang, S. H.(2014).Fresh Produce Awareness and Consumption of Food Bank Patrons: A Case Study of the 'Farm to Food Banks' in Kentucky.Journal of Agriculture and Forestry,63,195-203.
31. 方怡丹、李春良(2012)。國內設施園藝產業發展現況與展望。精密設施工程與植物工場實用化技術研討會專輯，台南:
32. 王仁晃(2011)。設施種類對颱風季節番木瓜生產的影響。高雄區農業改良場年報，100 年度，42-43。
33. 王耀林(2001)。國內外設施農業現狀及發展趨勢。中國農業科學，34，96-100。
34. 行政院主計總處，1990，79 年農林漁牧業普查總報告 (綜合報告)，臺北：行政院主計總處。
35. 行政院主計總處，2012，99 年農林漁牧業普查總報告：第一卷 綜合報告，臺北：行政院主計總處。
36. 行政院主計總處，2005，94 年農林漁牧業普查總報告 (綜合報告)，臺北：行政院主計總處。
37. 行政院主計總處，1995，84 年農林漁牧業普查總報告 (綜合報告)，臺北：行政院主計總處。
38. 行政院農業委員會(2016)。行政院農業委員會，2016，「農業用地作農業使用認定之法令說明」，105 年農地管理法規課程，臺北：行政院農業委員會企劃處農地利用科。
39. 徐瑞玲、楊明憲、黃裕益(2013)。行政院農業委員會主管科技計畫102 年度研究報告行政院農業委員會主管科技計畫102 年度研究報告,臺北:行政院農業委員會。
40. 陳世芳、戴登燦(2012)。臺中地區不同栽培類型番茄與行銷通路之效益分析。台中區農業改良場研究彙報，116，1-13。
41. 陳枻廷(2017)。全球設施農業產業分析與案例研究。臺灣經濟研究月刊，40，40-47。
42. 黃台心(2007)。計量經濟學。台北市:雙葉書廊。
43. 萬鍾汶、吳柏青、楊上禾、陳海菁(2014)。行政院農業委員會主管科技計畫103 年度研究報告行政院農業委員會主管科技計畫103 年度研究報告,臺北:行政院農業委員會。
44. 萬鍾汶、萬一怒、盧永祥、黃文星、陳海菁(2015)。行政院農業委員會主管科技計畫104 年度研究報告行政院農業委員會主管科技計畫104 年度研究報告,臺北:行政院農業委員會。
45. 蔡宛育、陳彥樺(2012)。彩色海芋設施栽培與露地栽培之生育情形比較。臺中區農情月刊，157，4-4。