考量碳給付與病蟲害對土地期望價值之經濟分析

The Effects of the Pests and Diseases on the Optimal Forest Rotation and Land Expected Value Considering the Payment of Environmental Services

10.3966/054696002020060107004

林佑儒(Yow-Ru Lin)；柳婉郁(Wan-Yu Liu)

病蟲害 ； 碳給付 ； 最適輪伐期 ； 土地期望價值 ； Disease ； Carbon Payment ； Optimal Rotation Length ； Maximum Land Expectation Value

應用經濟論叢

107期（2020 / 06 / 01）

133-176 - 171

繁體中文

病蟲害對環境資源管理與土地利用管理決策有著重大影響，根據前人文獻可知，臺灣關於病蟲害影響土地期望價值與最適輪伐期之著作付之闕如，因此本研究考慮病蟲害與碳給付影響土地期望價值與最適輪伐期之研究，將臺灣的林業現況應用於其中，模擬病蟲害對臺灣森林經營之最適輪伐期與最大土地期望價值的影響。由本研究之模擬結果顯示，與無病蟲害之情境相較，病蟲害存在之情境有較短的最適輪伐期與較低的最大土地期望價值。由本研究之敏感度分析顯示，在無病蟲害與病蟲害存在之情境下，碳價格、單位木材價格及伐採後地租收入（材積分收率）的提高將延長最適輪伐期與增加最大土地期望價值，伐採成本及伐採後碳釋放比例的提高將延長最適輪伐期與減少最大土地期望價值，折現率的提高將縮短最適輪伐期與減少最大土地期望價值；而在病蟲害存在之情境下發現感染率的提升不一定縮短最適輪伐期，但最大土地期望價值將會降低。

Pets and disease have many impacts on the environmental management and land use decision-making. Previous works less discussed about the effect of disease and carbon payment on the optimal rotation length. This study models the effect of disease on the optimal rotation length and the maximum land expectation value of Taiwan forest management. In the empitical analysis of this study, the situation of disease has a shorter optimal rotation length and a lower maximum land expectation value than the situation of no disease. In the sensitivity analysis of this study, at the both of the situation of no disease and disease, the increase of the carbon price, per-cubic-metre price of timber and land rent after harvesting (distribution rate of timber volumn) will increase the optimal rotation length and maximum land expectation value. The increase of the timber logging cost and carbon release rate after harvesting will increase the optimal rotation length and decrease the maximum land expectation value. The increase of the discount rate will decrease the optimal rotation length and maximum land expectation value. In the situation of disease, the increase of the infection rate will not necessarily decrease the optimal rotation length, but the maximum land expectation value will be decreased.

1. 林國慶, K. C.,柳婉郁, W. Y.(2007)。考慮碳吸存價格下最適輪伐期與土地期望價分析。農業經濟叢刊，12，1-35。
   連結：
2. 柳婉郁, W. Y.,盧又銘, Y. M.,林國慶, K. C.(2009)。同時考慮碳價格與木材價格不確定下最適輪伐期之決定。農業經濟叢刊，15，1-35。
   連結：
3. 柳婉郁, W.Y.,徐寬, K.(2017)。森林碳給付政策之經濟分析。農業與經濟，59，1-48。
   連結：
4. Amacher, G. S.,Ollikainen, M.,Koskela, E.(2009).Economics of Forest Resources.Cambridge:The MIT Press.
5. Appiah, A. A.,Jennings, P.,Turner, J. A.(2004).Phytophthora Ramorum: One Pathogen and Many Diseases, an Emerging Threat to Forest Ecosystems and Ornamental Plant Life.Mycologist,18,145-150.
6. Bauce, É.,Fuentealba, A.(2013).Interactions between Stand Thinning, Site Quality and Host Tree Species on Spruce Budworm Biological Performance and Host Tree Resistance Over a 6 Year Period after Thinning.Forest Ecology and Management,304,212-223.
7. Bishop, J. T.(1998).The Economics of Non-timber Forest Benefits: An Overview.London:International Institute for Environment and Development.
8. Boyd, I. L.,Freer-Smith, P. H.,Gilligan, C. A.,Godfray, H. C. J.(2013).The Consequenceof Tree Pests and Diseases for Ecosystem Services.Science,342,823.
9. Carvalho-Santos, C.,Honrado, J. P.,Hein, L.(2014).Hydrological Services and the Role of Forests: Conceptualization and Indicator-based Analysis with an Illustration at a Regional Scale.Ecological Complexity,20,69-80.
10. Castagneyrol, B.,Jactel, H.,Vacher, C.,Brockerhoff, E. G.,Koricheva, J.(2014).Effects of Plant Phylogenetic Diversity on Herbivory Depend on Herbivore Specialization.Journal of Applied Ecology,51,134-141.
11. Churchill, D. J.,Larson, A. J.,Dahlgreen, M. C.,Franklin, J. F.,Hessburg, P. F.,Lutz, J. A.(2013).Restoring Forest Resilience: From Reference Spatial Patterns to Silvicultural Prescriptions and Monitoring.Forest Ecology and Management,291,442-457.
12. Condeso, T. E.,Meentemeyer, R. K.(2007).Effects of Landscape Heterogeneity on the Emerging Forest Disease Sudden Oak Death.Journal of Ecology,95,364-375.
13. Cudlín, P., ,Seják, J.,Pokorný, J.,Albrechtová, J.,Bastian, O.,Marek, M.(2013).ForestEcosystem Services under Climate Change and Air Pollution.Developments in Environmental Science,13,521-546.
14. D’Amato, A. W.,Troumbly, S. J.,Saunders, M. R.,Puettmann, K. J.,Albers, M. A.(2011).Growth and Survival of Picea Glauca Following Thinning of Plantations Affected by Eastern Spruce Budworm.Northern Journal of Applied Forestry,28,72-78.
15. Englin, J.,Boxall, P.,Hauer, G.(2000).An Empirical Examination of Optimal Rotations in a Multiple-use Forest in the Presence of Fire Risk.Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics,25,14-27.
16. Englin, J.,Callaway, J. M.(1993).Global Climate Change and Optimal Forest Management.Natural Resource Modeling,7,191-202.
17. Forestry Commission Scotland, 2015, Ramorum (on Larch) Action Plan for Scotland, Forestry Commission Scotland, Retrieved August 16, 2017, from https://scotland.forestry.gov.uk/images/corporate/pdf/phytophthora-ramorum-action-plan.pdf.
18. Gilligan, C.,Fraser, R.,Godfray, C.,Hanley, N.,Leather, S.,Meagher, T.,Mumford, J.,Petts, J.,Pidgeon, N.,Potter, C.,Shaw, M.,Unger, J. G.,Woodward, S.,Jeger, M.(2013).Department for the Environment, Food and Rural AffairsDepartment for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs,London:.
19. Hartman, R.(1976).The Harvesting Decision when a Standing Forest Has Value.Economic Inquiry,14,52-58.
20. Hicke, J. A.,Allen, C. D.,Desai, A. R.,Dietze, M. C.,Hall, R. J.,Hogg, E. H.,Kashian, D. M.,Moore, D.,Raffa, K. F.,Sturrock, N. A.,Vogelmann, J.(2012).Effects of Biotic Disturbances on Forest Carbon Cycling in The United States and Canada.Global Change Biology,18,7-34.
21. Jactel, H.,Brockerhoff, E. G.(2007).Tree Diversity Reduces Herbivory by Forest Insects.Ecology Letters,10,835-848.
22. Johansson, S. M.,Pratt, J. E.,Asiegbu, F. O.(2002).Treatment of Norway Spruce and Scots Pine Stumps with Urea against the Root and Butt Rot Fungus Heterobasidion Annosum Possible Modes of Action.Forest Ecology and Management,157,87-100.
23. Johansson, T.,Hjältén, J.,de Jong, J.,von Stedingk, H.(2013).Environmental Considerations from Legislation and Certification in Managed Forest Stands: A Review of Their Importance for Biodiversity.Forest Ecology and Management,303,98-112.
24. Koskela, E.,Ollikainen, M.(2001).Optimal Private and Public Harvesting under Spatial and Temporal Interdependence.Forest Science,47,484-496.
25. Loehle, C.,C. Idso,T. B. Wigley(2016).Physiological and Ecological Factors Influencing Recent Trends in United States Forest Health Responses to Climate Change.Forest Ecology and Management,363,179-189.
26. Macpherson, M. F.,Kleczkowski, A.,Healey, R.,Hanley, N.(2017).Payment for Multiple Forest Benefits Alters the Effect of Tree Disease on Optimal Forest Rotation Length.Ecological Economics,134,82-94.
27. Macpherson, M. F.,Kleczkowski, A.,Healey, R.,Hanley, N.(2018).The Effects ofDisease on Optimal Forest Rotation: A Generalisable Analytical Framework.Environmental and Resource Economics,70,565-588.
28. Marzano, M.,Fuller, L.,Quine, C. P.(2017).Barriers to Management of Tree Diseases: Framing Perspectives of Pinewood Managers around Dothistroma Needle Blight.Journal of Environmental Management,188,238-245.
29. Millar, C. I.,Stephenson, N. L.,Stephens, S. L.(2007).Climate Change and Forests of the Future: Managing in the Face of Uncertainty.Ecological Applications,17,2145-2151.
30. Mullett, M. S.(2014).Imperial College London.
31. Netherer, S.,Schopf, A.(2010).Potential Effects of Climate Change on Insect Herbivores in European Forests-general Aspects and the Pine Processionary Moth as Specific Example.Forest Ecology and Management,259,831-838.
32. Nghiem, N.(2014).Optimal Rotation Age for Carbon Sequestration and Biodiversity Conservation in Vietnam.Forest Policy and Economics,38,56-64.
33. Nielsen, A. B.,Olsen, S. B.,Lundhede, T.(2007).An Economic Valuation of the Recreational Benefits Associated with Nature-based Forest Management Practices.Landscape and Urban Planning,80,63-71.
34. Pautasso, M.,Aas, G.,Queloz, V.,Holdenrieder, O.(2013).European Ash (Fraxinus Excelsior) Dieback - A Conservation Biology Challenge.Biological Conservation,158,37-49.
35. Pautasso, M.,Dehnen-Schmutz, K.,Holdenrieder, O.,Pietravalle, S.,Salama, N.,Jeger, M. J.,Lange, E.,Hehl-Lange, S.(2010).Plant Health and Global Change—Some Implications for Landscape Management.Biological Reviews,85,729-755.
36. Perry, D. A.,Maghembe, J.(1989).Ecosystem Concepts and Current Trends in Forest Management: Time for Reappraisal.Forest Ecology and Management,26,123-140.
37. Pratt, J.(2002).Stump Treatment against Fomes.Forest Research Annual Report and Accounts 2001-2002,Edinburgh:
38. Price, C.,Willis, R.(2011).The Multiple Effects of Carbon Values on Optimal Rotation.Journal of Forest Economics,17,298-306.
39. Redfern, D. B.,Pratt, J. E.,Hendry, S. J.,Low, J. D.(2010).Development of a Policy and Strategy for Controlling Infection by Heterobasidion Annosum in British Forests: AReview of Supporting Research.Forestry: An International Journal of Forest Research,83,207-218.
40. Ribe, R. G.(1989).The Aesthetics of Forestry: What Has Empirical Preference Research Taught Us?.Environmental Management,13,55-74.
41. Rizzo, D. M.,Garbelotto, M.(2003).Sudden Oak Death: Endangering California and Oregon Forest Ecosystems.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,1,197-204.
42. Samuelson, P. A.(1976).Economics of Forestry in an Evolving Society.Economic Inquiry,14,466-492.
43. Seung, J. P.(2007).A Carbon Tax or an Environmental Tax Reform: Difficult Decision for Japan.Proceeding of The Eighth Global Conference on Environmental Taxation,German, Munich:
44. Snyder, D. L.,Bhattacharyya, R. N.(1990).A More General Dynamic Economic Model of the Optimal Rotation of Multiple-use Forests.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,18,168-175.
45. Sturrock, R. N.(2012).Climate Change and Forest Diseases: Using Today’s Knowledge to Address Future Challenges.Forest Systems,21,329-336.
46. Sturrock, R. N.,Frankel, S. J.,Brown, A. V.,Hennon, P. E.,Kliejunas, J. T.,Lewis, K. J.,Woods, A. J.(2011).Climate Change and Forest Diseases.Plant Pathology,60,133-149.
47. Swallow, S. K.,Wear, D. N.(1993).Spatial Interactions in Multiple-use Forestry and Substitution and Wealth Effects for the Single Stand.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,25,103-120.
48. Van Kooten, G. C.,Binkley, C. S.,Delcourt, G.(1995).Effect of Carbon Taxes and Subsidies on Optimal Forest Rotation Age and Supply of Carbon Services.American Journal of Agricultural Economics,77,365-374.
49. Wang, T. F.,Lee, P. C.,Tseng, C. Y.(2001).The Economic Impact Analysis of Air Pollution Prevention in Taiwan: The Application of a CGE Model.Proceedings of 2001 Academic Symposium of Environmental Recource Economics, Management and System Analysis,Taipei:
50. Work, T. T.,McCullough, D. G.,Cavey, J. F.,Komsa, R.(2005).Arrival Rate ofNonindigenous Insect Species into the United States through Foreign Trade.Biological Invasions,7,323-332.
51. 任憶安, I. A.(1994)。臺灣杉木私有林造林生產之回顧與展望。林業試驗所研究報告季刊，9，235-240。
52. 行政院農業委員會農業藥物毒物試驗所，2017，「森林病蟲害」，植物保護手冊，取自http://farmer.iyard.org/ppm/ppm.htm#cat7，檢索日期：2017/12/11。(Taiwan Agricultural Chemicals and Toxic Substances Research Institute, Council of Agriculture, Executive Yuan, 2017, “Forest Pests”, Plant Protection Handbook, Retrieved December 11, 2017, from http://farmer.iyard.org/ppm/ppm.htm#cat7.)
53. 行政院農業委員會林務局，2015，第四次森林資源調查報告，台北：行政院農業委員會林務局，取自 https://goo.gl/75Xpd5，檢索日期：2018/09/07。(Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, 2015, The Fourth Forest Resource Survey Report, Taipei:Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, Retrieved September 07, 2018, from https://goo.gl/75Xpd5.)
54. 行政院農業委員會林務局，2000，「國有林事業區出租造林地管理要點」，植根法律網，取自 https://goo.gl/VTULzH，檢索日期：2017/08/16。(Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, 2000, “Guidelines for Management of National Forest Working Circle of National Forest Leased Reforestation”, Rootlaw, Retrieved August 16,2017, from https://goo.gl/VTULzH.)
55. 行政院農業委員會林務局，2002，「農林字第 0910000477 號函釋」，函釋查詢系統，取自 https://goo.gl/x36iKu，檢索日期：2017/09/11。(Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, 2002, “Letter Interpretation of Nonglinzi No. 0910000477”, Letter Interpretation System, Retrieved September 11, 2017, from https://goo.gl/x36iKu.)
56. 行政院農業委員會林務局，2017，林業統計年報，台北：行政院農業委員會林務局，取自 https://goo.gl/4LH2M6 ，檢索日期： 2017/09/07。 (Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, 2017, Forestry Statistics Annual Report, Taipei: Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, Retrieved September 07, 2017, from https://goo.gl/4LH2M.)
57. 行政院農業委員會林務局, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan(2011)。行政院農業委員會林務局，2011，「一般造林地區、海岸林造林、國有崩塌地植生復育、離島造林海岸林育苗工程表」，宜蘭：林務局羅東林區管理處。(Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, 2011, “Worksheets for Reforestation, Coastal Forest Afforestation, Reforestation of Landslide Areas in National Forest and Outlying Island Afforestation and Coastal Forest Nursery”, Yilan: Luodong Forest District Office, Forestry Bureau, Council of Agricultural.)。
58. 行政院農業委員會林業試驗所，2017，「危害種類案件統計表」，林木疫情鑑定與資訊中心，取自 https://goo.gl/p2GkcG，檢索日期：2017/12/11。(Taiwan Forestry Research Institute, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, 2017, “Hazard Type Case Statistics Table”, Forest Disease Information Center, Retrieved December 11, 2017, from https://goo.gl/p2GkcG.)
59. 行政院農業委員會農業金融局，2016，「造林貸款要點」，農業發展基金貸款，取自https://goo.gl/iGyhGw，檢索日期：2017/08/16。(Bureau of Agricultural Finance, Council of Agricultural, Executive Yuan, 2016, “Key Points of Afforestation Loan”, Agricultural Development Fund Loan, Retrieved August 16, 2017, from https://goo.gl/iGyhGw.)
60. 行政院環境保護署，2015，「溫室氣體減量及管理法」，取自 https://goo.gl/Gaijp3，檢索日期：2017/08/16。(Environmental Protection Administration Executive Yuan, 2015, “Greenhouse Gas Reduction and Management Act”, Retrieved August 16, 2017, from https://goo.gl/Gaijp3.)
61. 柳婉郁, W. Y.(2008)。國立臺灣大學農業經濟學研究所=Department of Agricultural Economics, National Taiwan University。
62. 柳婉郁, W. Y.(2004)。國立臺灣大學農業經濟學研究所=Department of Agricultural Economics, National Taiwan University。
63. 高榕翎, J. L(2013)。國立臺灣大學森林環境暨資源學研究所=Department of Forestry and Resources Conservation, Nation Taiwan University。
64. 劉浚明, C. M.,鍾旭和, H. H.(1993)。臺灣杉非線性收穫模式之建立。中華林學季刊，26，39-49。
65. 鄭欽龍, C. L.,施友元, Y. Y.(2006)。南投地區承租造林地林木伐採成本之分析。中華林學季刊，39，315-237。