新農保對中國農村中老年人口勞動供給之影響－CHARLS全國基線數據之實證

The Impact of New Rural Social Pension Insurance on the Labor Supply of Rural Elderly in China-Evidence from 2011 National Baseline Data

10.3966/054696002020120108004

黃芳玫(Fung-Mey Huang)；葉小婉(Xiao-Wan Ye)

老齡化 ； 新農保 ； 勞動參與 ； 工作時間 ； Aging ； New Rural Social Pension Insurance ； Labor Force Particiaption ； Hours Worked

應用經濟論叢

108期（2020 / 12 / 01）

117 - 164

繁體中文

本研究利用中國健康與養老追蹤調查（China health and retirement longitudinal study, CHARLS）2011全國基線數據從勞動供給角度切入，對2009年開始在農村地區實施的新型農村社會養老保險（簡稱「新農保」）的政策效果進行評估，探討新農保對農村中老年勞動參與及工作時間之影響效果。在控制新農保和勞動供給的內生性下，實證結果顯示，新農保對農村中老年人的勞動供給產生了排擠效果，顯著減少中老年人的工作時間，但是對於中老年人的勞動參與沒有顯著的影響。參加新農保的中老年人比沒有參加新農保的中老年人年工作時間減少161個小時，對於有工作者平均減少82個年工作小時，對60歲以上老年人減少其工作時間的幅度更大更顯著。同時，新農保對農村老年人的勞動參與及工作時間之影響有延後現象，參保時間越久，對勞動供給的排擠效果越明顯。此外，對於男性、健康狀況較差，家庭經濟狀況較不好者，新農保對其工作時間的排擠效果更為明顯。

The New Rural Social Pension Insurance (NRSPI) system implemented in 2009 has filled the gap of China's rural pension system that has been suspended since 1997. In this study, China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study (CHARLS) 2011 national baseline data was adopted to evaluate the effectiveness of the NRSPI, from the perspective of the labor supply of the rural elderly. Empirical findings show that the NRSPI has a ＂crowding-out effect＂ on the the hours worked of the rural elderly. Paticipating in NRSPI significantly lower 161 and 82 hours worked annually for the entire elderly and for the working elderly, respectively. The NRSPI, however, has insignificant impact on the retirement behaviors of the rural elderly. Furthermore, these crowding-out effects are increasing with the duration of the NRSPI participation. The crowing-out impacts of the NRSPI on working hours are also larger, for men and those with poor health, and those with low family income level.

1. Aaron, H. J.(ed.),Burtless, G.(ed.)(1984).Retirement and Economic Behavior.Washington:The Brookings Institution.
2. Ashenfelter O.(ed.),Card, D.(ed.)(1999).Handbook of Labor Economics.Amsterdam:
3. Ashenfelter, O. C.(ed.),Layard, R.(ed.)(1986).Handbook of Labor Economics.Amsterdam:North-Holland.
4. Blau, D. M.(1994).Labor Force Dynamics of Older Men.Econometrica,62,117-156.
5. Blau, D. M.,Goodstein, R. M.(2010).Can Social Security Explain Trends in Labor Force Participation of Older Men in the United States?.Journal of Human Resources,45,328-363.
6. Blundell, R.,Johnson, P.(1998).Pensions and Labor-Market Participation in the United Kingdom.The American Economic Review,88,168-172.
7. Börsch-Supan, A.,Schnabel, R.(1998).Social Security and Declining Labor-Force Participation in Germany.The American Economic Review,88,173-178.
8. Burtless, G.(1986).Social Security, Unanticipated Benefit Increases, and the Timing of Retirement.The Review of Economic Studies,53,781-805.
9. Carrasco, R.(2001).Binary Choice with Binary Endogenous Regressors in Panel Data: Estimating the Effect of Fertility on Female Labor Participation.Journal of Business & Economic Statistics,19,385-394.
10. Chan, S.,Stevens, A. H.(2004).Do Changes in Pension Incentives Affect Retirement? A Longitudinal Study of Subjective Retirement Expectations.Journal of Public Economic,88,1307-1333.
11. Chen, Z.,Bengtsson, T.,Helgertz, J.(2015).IZA Discussion PaperIZA Discussion Paper,未出版
12. Davis-Friedmann, D.(1991).Long Lives: Chinese Elderly and the Communist Revolution.Stanford:Stanford University Press.
13. De-Carvalho-Filho, I. E.(2008).Old-age Benefits and Retirement Decisions of Rural Elderly in Brazil.Journal of Development Economics,86,129-146.
14. Feng, J.,He, L.,Sato, H.(2011).Public Pension and Household Saving: Evidence from Urban China.Journal of Comparative Economics,39,470-485.
15. Giles, J.,Wang, D.,Cai, W.(2011).Workers and Elderly in Comparative Perspective Policy Research Working PaperWorkers and Elderly in Comparative Perspective Policy Research Working Paper,Washington, DC:World Bank.
16. Goode, W. J.(1970).World Revolution and Family Patterns.New York:Free Press.
17. Hurd, M. D.,Boskin, M. J.(1984).The Effect of Social Security on Retirement in the Early 1970s.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,99,767-790.
18. Hussain, A.(1994).Social Security in Present-Day China and Its Reform.The American Economic Review,84,276-280.
19. Kapteyn, A.,de Vos, K.(1998).Social Security and Labor-Force Participation in the Netherlands.The American Economic Review,88,164-167.
20. Krueger, A. B.,Pischke, J. S.(1992).The Effect of Social Security on Labor supply: A Cohort Analysis of the Notch Generation.Journal of Labor Economics,10,412-437.
21. Lee, C.(1998).The Rise of the Welfare State and Labor-force Participation of Older Males: Evidence from the Pre-social Security Era.The American Economic Review,88,222-226.
22. Manski, C. F.,Sandefur, G. D.,McLanahan, S.,Powers, D.(1992).Alternative Estimates of the Effect of Family Structure during Adolescence on High School Graduation.Journal of the American Statistical Association,87,25-37.
23. Mosisa, A.,Hipple, S.(2006).Trends in Labor Force Participation in the United States.Monthly Labor Review,129,35-57.
24. Ning, M.,Gong, J.,Zheng, X.,Zhuang, J.(2016).Does New Rural Pension Scheme Decrease Elderly Labor Supply? Evidence from CHARLS.China Economic Review,41,315-330.
25. Pang, L. H.,de Brauw, A.,Rozelle, S.(2004).Working until You Drop: The Elderly of Rural China.The China Journal,52,73-94.
26. Pang, L. H.,Rozelle, S.,de Brauw, A.(2003).Labor Supply of the Elderly in Rural China.China Economic Quarterly,2,721-730.
27. Samwick, A. A.(1998).New Evidence on Pensions, Social Security, and the Timing of Retirement.Journal of Public Economics,70,207-236.
28. Shen, C.,Williamson, J. B.(2010).China‟s New Rural Pension Scheme: Can It Be Improved?.International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy,30,239-250.
29. Shen, S.,Li, F.,Tanui, J. K.(2012).Quality of Life and Old Age Social Welfare System for the Rural Elderly in China.Ageing International,37,285-299.
30. Shu, L.(2018).The Effect of the New Rural Social Pension Insurance Program on the Retirement and Labor Supply Decision in China.The Journal of the Economics of Ageing,12,135-150.
31. United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs(2011).World Population Prospects: The 2010 Revision, Highlights and Advance Tables.New York:United Nations.
32. Vanderhart, M. J.(2003).Labor Supply of Older Men: Does Social Security Matter?.Economic Inquiry,41,250-263.
33. Vere, J. P.(2011).Social Security and Elderly Labor Supply: Evidence from the Health and Retirement Study.Labor Economics,18,676-686.
34. Wang, D.(2006).China‟s Urban and Rural Old Age Security System: Challenges and Options.China & World Economy,14,102-116.
35. Yang, Y.,Williamson, J. B.,Shen, C.(2010).Social Security for China's Rural Aged: A Proposal Based on a Universal Non-Contributory Pension.International Journal of Social Welfare,19,236-245.
36. 米紅, H.,王鵬, P.(2010)。新農保制度模式與財政投入實證研究。中國社會保障，6，28-30。
37. 吳玉鋒, Y. F.(2011)。新型農村社會養老保險參與行為實證分析─以村域社會資本為視角。中國農村經濟，10，64-76。
38. 李冬妍, D. Y.(2011)。農保制度：現狀評析與政策建議。南京大學學報：哲學、人文科學、社會科學版，1，30-39。
39. 林全玲, C. L.(2011)。我國新型農村社會養老保險制度的構建與完善─兼評《國務院關於開展新型農村社會養老保險試點的指導意見。社會科學家，4，40-43。
40. 林義, Y.(2009)。破解新農保制度運行五大難。中國社會保障，9，14-16。
41. 郝金磊, J. L,賈金榮, J. R.(2011)。西部地區農民新農保參與意願研究。西北人口，2，107-110。
42. 馬光榮, G. R.,周廣肅, G. S.(2014)。新型農村養老保險對家庭儲蓄的影響：基於 CFPS 數據的研究。經濟研究，116(11)，116-129。
43. 國務院，2009，「關於開展新型農村社會養老保險試點的指導意見」，中華人民共和國國務院公報，第 26 號。(The State Council, 2009, “Guiding Opinions of the State Council on Carrying out the Pilot Projects for Establishing a New Type Old-age Insurance System for Rural Residents”, State Council Gazette Issue, No. 26.)
44. 張川川, C. C.,陳斌開, B. K.(2014)。社會養老能否替代家庭養老？ —來自中國新型農村社會養老保險的證據。經濟研究，11，102-115。
45. 張文范, W. F,王義才, Y. T.(2000)。21 世紀的中國老齡問題：我們該如何應對？。人口研究，24，16-29。
46. 張文娟, W. J.(2010)。中國老年人的勞動參與狀況及影響因素研究。人口與經濟，1，85-89。
47. 張朝華, C. H.(2010)。農戶參加新農保的意願及其影響因素——基於廣東珠海斗門、茂名茂南的調查。農業技術經濟，6，4-10。
48. 梁平, P.,胡以濤, Y. T.,付小鵬, X. P.(2012)。新型農村社會養老保險替代率測算方法與預測研究——基於政策的仿真推進視角。安徽農業科學，3628-3630。
49. 陳華帥, H.,曾毅, Y.(2013)。新農保使誰受益: 老人還是子女？。經濟研究，8，55-67。
50. 程令國, L. G.,張曄, Y.,劉志彪, Z. B.(2013)。新農保改變了中國農村居民的養老模式嗎？。經濟研究，8，42-54。
51. 褚福靈, F. L.(2004)。養老保險金替代率研究。北京市計劃勞動管理幹部學院學報，12，17-21。
52. 鄧大松, D. S.,薛惠元, H. Y.(2010)。新型農村社會養老保險制度推行中的難點分析——兼析個人，集體和政府的籌資能力。經濟體制改革，1，86-92。
53. 鄧大松, D. S,薛惠元, H. Y.(2010)。新農保財政補助數額的測算與分析——基於 2008 年的數據。江西財經大學學報，2，38-42。
54. 鄧大松, D. S,薛惠元, H. Y.(2010)。新型農村社會養老保險替代率的測算與分析。山西財經大學學報，4，8-13。
55. 穆懷中, H. Z. ,閻琳琳, L. L.(2012)。新型農村養老保險參保決策影響因素研究。人口研究，36，73-82。
56. 薛惠元, H. Y.,張德明, D. M.(2010)。新農保基金籌集主體籌資能力分析。稅務與經濟，2，32-37。