臺灣股市局部最小變異數投資組合之績效

The Performance of Local Minimum-Variance Portfolio based on Taiwan Stocks

10.3966/054696002020120108005

邱萬益(Wan-Yi Chiu)

最小變異數 ； 局部最小變異數投資組合 ； 低波動性 ； 修正訊息值 ； 夏普值 ； Global Minimum-Variance ； Local Minimum-Variance ； Low Volatility ； Modified Information Ratio ； Sharpe Ratio

應用經濟論叢

108期（2020 / 12 / 01）

165 - 206

繁體中文

最小變異數投資組合是從低波動性獲利的有效策略。本研究整合低波動性與Warren Buffett的「安全、便宜、高質量選股風格」，轉換為局部最小變異數投資組合（local minimum-variance portfolio, LMVP）。我們將臺灣證券交易所上市公司劃分為優質、安全、風險報酬調整等三類。績效評比的對象，採用常用的標竿（benchmark）：台股加權指數、臺灣50指數。研究結果顯示：LMVP策略可以達到控制風險的目標，並且打敗標竿。其中，採用MIR（modified information ratio）策略的LMVP投資組合表現最佳。本研究提供一個值得探討的投資組合管理方法，可做為業界發展最小波動性指數的參考。

Previous studies indicate that the minimum variance strategy is a proven approach to profiting from the low volatility effect. This study integrates the low volatility effects and Warren Buffett's ＂safe, cheap, high-quality strategy＂ into the local minimum-variance portfolio (LMVP). To test the model, we use the listed companies on the Taiwan Stock Exchange. The performance evaluation employs the benchmarks commonly used: the TWSE Weighted Index (TAIEX) and the TWSE Taiwan 50 Index. We create 12 LMVPs to evaluate their performance. The results show that the LMVP could achieve the goal of risk reduction. In addition, the evidence indicates that these LMVPs outperforms the TAIEX and the TWSE Taiwan 50 Index. Notably, the LMVP portfolio based on the modified information ratio (MIR) performs the best. This study provides a helpful reference for the finance industry to build the minimum volatility index in Taiwan stocks market.

1. 王麗惠, L. H.,鄭昌錞, C. C.,郭憲章, H. C.(2018)。外資券商分析師關注什麼？價值還是成長？。證券市場發展季刊，30，1-62。
   連結：
2. 高崇瑋, C. W,萬哲鈺, J. Y.(2015)。利率期限結構與貨幣政策：臺灣的實證分析。應用經濟論叢，98，55-100。
   連結：
3. 高崇瑋,C. W.,萬哲鈺, J. Y.(2012)。台灣短期利率指標之研究。應用經濟論叢，92，23-58。
   連結：
4. 張宮雄, K. H. ,呂維恭, W. G.(2006)。應用灰色系統理論改善最小變異數投資組合績效之實證模型—以道瓊 30 指數成分股為例。亞太經濟管理評論，9，61-73。
   連結：
5. 陳立文, L. W.,余歆儀, H. Y.,紀怡禎, Y. J.(2016)。公司本益比和產業平均本益比之間的偏離程度與橫斷面股票報酬：風險或行為?。證券市場發展季刊，28，1-38。
   連結：
6. 賴靖宜, J. Y.,董澍琦, S. C.,楊聲勇, S. Y.,苗建華, C. H.(2011)。價值投資：財務報表與公開資訊之應用」。證券市場發展季刊，22，123-182。
   連結：
7. Bagella, M.,Becchetti, L.,Carpentieri, A.(2000).Size and Value Strategy Premia at the London Stock Exchange.Journal of Banking & Finance,24,893-919.
8. Baker, M.,Bradley, B.,Wurgler, J.(2011).Benchmarks as Limits to Arbitrage: Understanding the Low-Volatility Anomaly.Financial Analysts Journal,67,40-54.
9. Best, M. J.,Grauer, R. R.(1991).On the Sensitivity of Mean-Variance Portfolios to Change in Asset Means: Some Analytical and Computation Results, and the Structure of Asset Expected Returns.The Review of Financial Studies,4,315-342.
10. Bhandari, L. C.(1988).Debt/Equity Ratio and Expected Common Stock Returns: Empirical Evidence.The Journal of Finance,43,507-528.
11. Bhattacharya, U.,Galpin, N.(2011).The Global Rise of the Value-Weighted Portfolio.The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,46,737-756.
12. Bodnar, T.,Okhrin, Y.(2013).Boundaries of the Risk Aversion Coefficient: Should We Invest in the Global Minimum Variance Portfolio?.Applied Mathematics and Computation,219,5440-5448.
13. Campbell, J. Y.,Thompson, S. B.(2008).Rredicting Excess Stock Returns out of Sample: Can Anything Beet the Historical Average?.The Review of Financial Studies,21,1509-1531.
14. Chance, D. M.,Shynkevich, A.,Yang, T. H.(2011).Experimental Evidence on Portfolio Size and Diversification: Human Biases in Naïve Security Selection and Portfolio Construction.The Financial Review,46,427-457.
15. Chiu, W. Y.,Jiang, C. H.(2016).On the Weight Sign of the Global Minimum Variance Portfolio.Finance Research Letters,19,241-246.
16. Chopra, V. K.,Ziemba, W. T.(1993).The Effects of Errors in Means, Variance, and Covariance on Optimal Portfolio Choice.The Journal of Portfolio Management,19,6-11.
17. Chow, T. M.,Hsu, J. C.,Kuo, L. L.,Li, F.(2014).A Study of Low-Volatility Portfolio Construction Methods.The Journal of Portfolio Management,40,89-105.
18. Chow, T. M.,Kose, E.,Li, F.(2016).The Impact of Constraints on Minimum-Variance Portfolios.Financial Analysts Journal,72,52-70.
19. Clarke, R. G.,de Silva, H.,Thorley, S.(2006).Minimum-Variance Portfolios in the U.S. Equity Market.The Journal of Portfolio Management,33,10-24.
20. Danielson, M. G.,Dowdell, T. D.(2001).The Return-stages Valuation Model and the Expectations within a Firm‟s P/B and P/E Ratios.Financial Management,30,93-124.
21. Dutt, T.,Humphery-Jenner, M.(2013).Stock Return Volatility, Operating Performance and Stock Returns: International Evidence on Drivers of the „Low Volatility‟ Anomaly.Journal of Banking & Finance,37,999-1017.
22. Elton, E. J.,Gruber, M. J.(1977).Risk Reduction and Portfolio Size: An Analytic Solution.The Journal of Business,50,415-437.
23. Evans, J. L.,Archer, S. H.(1968).Diversification and the Reduction of Dispersion: An Empirical Analysis.The Journal of Finance,23,761-767.
24. Frazzini, A.,Kabiller, D.,Pedersen, L. H.(2018).Buffett‟s Alpha.Financial Analysts Journal,74,35-55.
25. Green, R. C.,Hollifield, B.(1992).When will Mean-Variance Efficient Portfolios be Well Diversified?.The Journal of Finance,47,1785-1809.
26. Ledoit, O.,M. Wolf(2004).Honey, I Shrunk the Sample Covariance Matrix.The Journal of Portfolio Management,30,110-119.
27. Lockwood, L.,Prombutr, W.(2010).Sustainable Growth and Stock Returns.The Journal of Financial Research,33,519-538.
28. Michaud, R. O.(1989).The Markowitz Optimization Enigma: Is Optimized Optimal?.Financial Analysts Journal,45,31-42.
29. Roll, R.(1977).A Critique of the Asset Pricing Theory‟s Tests.Journal of Financial Economics,4,129-176.
30. Scherer, B.(2011).A Note on the Returns from Minimum Variance Investing.Journal of Empirical Finance,18,652-660.
31. Sharpe, W. F.(1994).The Sharpe Ratio.The Journal of Portfolio Management,21,49-58.
32. Shawky, H. A.,Smith, D. M.(2005).Optimal Number of Stock Holdings in Mutual Fund Portfolios based on Market Performance.The Financial Review,40,481-495.
33. Statman, M.(1987).How Many Stocks Make a Diversified Portfolio?.The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,22,353-363.
34. Stevens, G. V. G.(1998).On the Unverse of the Covariance Matrix in Portfolio Analysis.The Journal of Finance,53,1821-1827.
35. Tang, G. Y. N.(2004).How Efficient is Naive Portfolio Diversification? An Educational Note.Omega,32,155-160.
36. 吳瑞萱, R. S.,岳祥, Y. H.,徍福慶, F. C.(2011)。價值股與成長股之美國實證再檢視：市場錯價與長期成長機會。證券市場發展季刊，22，79-122。
37. 許晉雄, C. H.,鄒慶士, C. S.(2010)。兩階段投資組合均值－變異數模式最佳化分析。經營管理論叢，6，49-71。

1. (2024)。結合「公司治理評鑑」與指標選股之投資績效。應用經濟論叢，115，149-216。