關稅配額與價格動態反應之結構性變動分析：以大蒜進口爲例

Analysis of Structural Changes in Tariff Quota and Dynamics of Market Prices: The Case of Garlic in Taiwan

10.53106/054696002022120112002

楊明憲(Min-Hsien Yang)；楊奕農(Yi-Nung Yang)；吳朝欽(Tsaur-Chin Wu)

關稅配額 ； 大蒜 ； 結構變動 ； 門檻迴歸模型 ； TRQ ； Garlic ； Structural Changes ； Threshold Regression Model

應用經濟論叢

112期（2022 / 12 / 01）

49 - 84

繁體中文;英文

大蒜為重要的民生產業，然因國內生產成本高於進口價格，故採取關稅配額方式，以兼顧保護國內生產與支持市場價格。由於關稅配額存在著進口高低關稅之特性，所以國內外價差對於國內價格在進口配額內外之反應時間與程度可能有所不同，本文即以門檻迴歸模型檢定結構轉變與臨界值，並估計配額內外進口的反應落遲時間及對國內價格的衝擊程度。結果顯示結構轉變的臨界值為3,768.12公噸，與進口配額相當接近。在前一期的累計進口量小於或高於臨界值時，國內大蒜價格將受到前5期或前2期國內外價差之影響，且不論前期累計進口量是否超過臨界值，若前期國內價格高於國外價格時，即國內外價差為正時，將推升國內大蒜的價格，也反映我國大蒜市場本質為超額需求的特性。由於存在著結構轉變與前期國內外正負價差的影響不同，本文建議觀察最近月份的累計進口量是否達到臨界值，以作為政府採取緊急或鼓勵進口之決定參考，並建議可適度提高配額，以平穩大蒜價格。

Garlic is a crucial crop in Taiwan and a tariff-rate quota (TRQ) has been implemented to protect domestic production and market price under Taiwan's WTO agreement, as the cost of the domestic output is higher than the importing price. The TRQ regime imposes lower tariffs within import quotas and higher tariffs outside of them. This study uses threshold regression models to evidence structural changes in the dynamics of garlic price differentials in Taiwan under the TRQ regime. The estimated structural change threshold for the garlic market was 3,768.12 tons, which is close to the regulated tariff quota. This study also reveals that the domestic price of garlic is affected by previous price differentials for up to 5 months if accumulated imports are less than the TRQ and for only 2 months if accumulated imports are greater than the TRQ. The results indicate a tendency for the domestic garlic price to increase when previous price differentials are positive, reflecting excess demand in the garlic market. Due to structural changes and varying impacts of lagged positive and negative price differentials in previous months, this study suggests monitoring the accumulation of imports in recent months to determine whether it reaches the critical value to maintain the stability of garlic prices under the current TRQ regime. In the future, increasing the TRQ level could also help stabilize Taiwan's domestic garlic market.

1. Abbott, P. C.,Paarlberg, P. L.(1998).Tariff Rate Quotas: Structural and Stability Impacts in Growing Markets.Agricultural Economics,19,257-267.
2. Abbott, P.,Morse, B. A.(2000).Tariff Rate Quota Implementation and Administration by Developing Countries.Agricultural and Resource Economics Review,29,115-124.
3. Aksoy, M. A.,Beghin, J. C.(2005).Global Agricultural Trade and Developing Countries.Washington DC:The World Bank.
4. Bai, J.,Perron, P.(2003).Critical Values for Multiple Structural Change Tests.The Econometrics Journal,6,72-78.
5. Bai, J.,Perron, P.(1998).Estimating and Testing Linear Models with Multiple Structural Changes.Econometrica,66,47-78.
6. Bai, J.,Perron, P.(2003).Computation and Analysis of Multiple Structural Change Models.Journal of Applied Econometrics,18,1-22.
7. Beckman, J.,Arita, S.(2017).Modeling the Interplay between Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures and Tariff-rate Quotas under Partial Trade Liberalization.American Journal of Agricultural Economics,99,1078-1095.
8. Busetti, F.,Taylor, A. M. R.(2005).Stationarity Tests for Irregularly Spaced Observations and the Effects of Sampling Frequency on Power.Econometric Theory,21,757-794.
9. Cioffi, A.,Santeramo, F. G.,Vitale, C. D.(2011).The Price Stabilization Effects of the EU Entry Price Scheme for Fresh Fruit and Vegetables.Agricultural Economics,42,405-418.
10. Dickey, D. A.,Fuller, W. A.(1979).Distribution of the Estimators for Autoregressive Time Series with a Unit Root.Journal of the American Statistical Association,74,427-431.
11. Ghysels, E.,Miller, J. I.(2014).On the Size Distortion from Linearly Interpolating Low-frequency Series for Cointegration Tests.Essays in Honor of Peter C. B. Phillips,Bingley:
12. Hamilton, J. D.(2020).Time Series Analysis.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
13. Kaufmann, R. K.,Juselius, K.(2013).Testing Hypotheses about Glacial Cycles against the Observational Record.Paleoceanography,28,175-184.
14. Miller, J. I.(2019).Testing Cointegrating Relationships Using Irregular and Non ‐Contemporaneous Series with an Application to Paleoclimate Data.Journal of Time Series Analysis,40,936-950.
15. Mönnich, C.(2003).,Center for International Development and Environmental Research (ZEU) , Justus Liebig University Giessen.
16. Moschini, G.(1991).Economic Issues in Tariffication: An Overview.Agricultural Economics,5,101-120.
17. Reimers, H. E.(1992).Comparisons of Tests for Multivariate Cointegration.Statistical Papers,33,335-359.
18. Ryan, K. F.,Giles, D. E. A.(1998).Econometrics Working PapersEconometrics Working Papers,Department of Economics, University of Victoria.
19. Said, S. E.,Dickey, D. A.(1984).Testing for Unit Roots in Autoregressive-moving Average Models of Unknown Order.Biometrika,71,599-607.
20. Santeramo, F. G.,Cioffi, A.(2012).The Entry Price Threshold in EU Agriculture: Deterrent or Barrier?.Journal of Policy Modeling,34,691-704.
21. Tversky, A.,Kahneman, D.(1974).Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases: Biases in Judgments Reveal some Heuristics of Thinking under Uncertainty.Science,185,1124-1131.
22. 黃惠琳, H. L.,陳萬福, W. F.(2000)。大蒜之產銷結構調整。台灣地區重要農產品產銷研討會專集，臺中=Taichung, Taiwan:
23. 楊明憲, M. H.(2020)。行政院農業委員會委託研究計畫行政院農業委員會委託研究計畫,Taipei:行政院農業委員會=Council of Agriculture, Executive Yuan。
24. 賴郁薇與孔德廉，2018，「蒜價大戰提前開打！進口蒜頭惹禍或產地盤商壟斷？農民如何突圍？」，上下游專題報導，取自 https://www.newsmarket.com.tw/blog/108025/，檢索日期：2021/11/28。(Lai, Y. W. and D. L. Kung, 2018, “The Price War of Garlic! Caused by Imports or Price Setting of Wholesalers? How Can Farmers Do?”, News & Market, Retrieved November 28, 2021, from https://www.newsmarket.com.tw/blog/108025/.)