安提歐庫斯的哲學

The Philosophy of Antiochus

徐學庸(Hsei-Yung Hsu)

學院 ； 獨斷論 ； 懷疑論 ； 安提歐庫斯 ； 融合主義 ； Academy ； Dogmatism ； Skepticism ； Antiochus ； Syncretism

東吳哲學學報

34期（2016 / 08 / 01）

31 - 60

繁體中文

柏拉圖的「學院」發展至西元前三世紀，從獨斷論的立場轉變為懷疑論的立場；經過一個多世紀的發展，懷疑論的學院在西元前一世紀被安提歐庫斯 (Antiochus of Ascalon) 終結，且回到獨斷論的立場。這篇文章的論述目的有二：第一，安提歐庫斯是何時從懷疑主義的立場轉變為獨斷論的立場；第二，他的獨斷論的學院思想是否與柏拉圖的思想相符。關於第一個議題，傳統的詮釋認為西元前八七／八六年是安提歐庫斯與懷疑論學院決裂的時間，但文中的論述將指出，這個決裂的時間比一般的理解更早。至於第二個議題的處理將聚焦於安提歐庫斯的知識論及倫理學思想的討論，藉以凸顯他的融合主義的學院思想與柏拉圖的相關思想大相逕庭。從這篇文章的討論亦可提供當代的我們，一個較不尋常的方式思考希臘哲學史發展裡，各個哲學學派間關係的機會。

Plato's 'Academy' has switched its philosophical position from dogmatism to skepticism in the third century B.C. And it has not changed its skepticism for the next hundred years until Antiochus of Ascalon ended it, and brought dogmatism back into the Academy. The purpose of the paper is two-fold: Firstly, when did Antiochus change his philosophical allegiance from skepticism to dogmatism? Historians have traditionally proposed that the breakup and falling-out between Antiochus and Skeptic Academy happened in 87/86 B.C. However in this paper I would suggest that it happened a few years earlier than the traditional interpretation. Secondly, whether his thought is compatible with that of the founder of the School, Plato? By virtue of discussing Antiochus's epistemology and ethics, I would like to show that his Academic philosophy is quite different from Plato's. In addition to the abovementioned two issues, the discussions of Antiochus's thought in this paper can provide us a rather unusual way of looking at the development of ancient Greek philosophy.

1. Rackham, H. (Ed. & Trans.). (1945). Cicero: De Oratore Book III, De Fato, Paradoxa Stoicorum, De Partitione Oratoria. Cambridge Mass.: Harvard University Press.
2. Bywater, L. (Ed.). (1894). Aristotelis Ethica Nicomachea. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3. Algra, K.(Ed.),Barnes, J.(Ed.), Mansfeld, J.(Ed.),Schofield, M.(Ed.)(2005).The Cambridge History of Hellenistic Philosophy.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
4. Annas, J.,Barnes, J.(2000).Sextus Empiricus: Outlines of Scepticism.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
5. Barnes, J.(Ed.),Griffin, M.(Ed.)(1999).Philosophia Togata II: Plato and Aristotle at Rome.Oxford:Clarendon Press.
6. Burnet, J.(Ed.)(1978).Platonis Opera.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
7. Bury, R. G.(Ed. Trans.)(1997).Sextus Empiricus: Against the Logicians.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
8. Cherniss, H.(Ed. Trans.)(2004).Plutarch: Moralia.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
9. Dillon, J.(2005).The Heirs of Plato: A Study of the Old Academy (347-247 BC).Oxford:Oxford University Press.
10. Dillon, J.(1996).The Middle Platonists: 80 B.C. to A.D. 220.Ithaca:Cornell University Press.
11. Dillon, J.(Trans.)(1995).Alcinous: The Handbook of Platonism.Oxford:Clarendon Press.
12. Duke, E. A.,Hicken, W. F.,Nicoll, W. S. M.,Robinson, D. B.,Strachan, J. C. G.(1995).Platonis Opera.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
13. Dyson, R. W.(1998).The City of God Against the Pagans.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
14. Fortenbaugh, W. W.(Ed.),Huby, P. M.(Ed.),Sharples, R. W.(Ed.),Gutas, D.(Ed.)(1992).Theophrastus of Eresus: Sources for His Life, Writings, Thought and Influence.Leiden:Brill.
15. Fortenbaugh, W. W.(Ed.),Huby, P. M.(Ed.),Sharples, R. W.(Ed.),Gutas, D.(Ed.)(1992).Theophrastus of Eresus: Sources for His Life, Writings, Thought and Influence.Leiden:Brill.
16. Glucker, J.(1978).Antiochus and the Late Academy.Göttigen:Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
17. Griffin, M.(Ed.),Barnes, J.(Ed.)(1997).Philosophia Togata I.Oxford:Clarendon Press.
18. Hendrickson, G. L.(Eds. Trans.),Hubbell, H. M.(Eds. Trans.)(2001).Brutus, Orator.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
19. Karamanolis, G. E.(2006).Plato and Aristotle in Agreement?: Platonists on Aristotle from Antiochus to Porphyry.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
20. Keys, C. W.(Ed. Trans.)(2000).Cicero: On the Republic, On the Laws.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
21. King, J. E.(Ed. Trans.)(2001).Cicero: Tuscalan Disputations.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
22. King, P.(Trans.)(1995).Augustine: Against the Academicians and the Teachers.Indianapolis:Hackett Publishing Company.
23. Kristeller, P. O.(1993).Greek Philosophers of the Hellenistic Age.New York:Columbia University Press.
24. Long, A. A.,Sedley, D. N.(2005).The Hellenistic Philosophers.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
25. Long, A. A.,Sedley, D. N.(2005).The Hellenistic Philosophers.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
26. Miller, J.(Ed.)(2013).Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics: A Critical Guide.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
27. Miller, W.(Ed. Trans.)(2001).Cicero: On Duties.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
28. Perrin, B.(Ed. Trans.)(1997).Plutarch's Lives II: Themistocles and Camillus, Aristides and Cato Major, Cimon and Lucullus.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
29. Perrin, B.(Ed. Trans.)(1986).Plutarch's Lives VII: Demosthenes and Cicero, Alexander and Caesar.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
30. Rackham, H. (Ed. Trans.)(2000).Cicero: Nature of the Gods, Academics.Cambridge Mass.:Harvard University Press.
31. Rawson, E.(1985).Intellectual Life in the Late Roman Republic.London:Duckworth.
32. Reynolds, L. D.(Ed.)(1998).M. Tulli Ciceronis De Finibus Bonorum et Malorum Libri Quinque.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
33. Ross, W. D.(Ed.)(1957).Aristotelis Politica.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
34. Sedley, D.(1981).The End of the Academy.Phronesis,26(1),67-75.
35. Sedley, D.(Ed.)(2012).The Philosophy of Antiochus.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
36. Slings, S. R.(2003).Platonis Rempublicam.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
37. Tarán, L.(1981).Speusippus of Athens: A Critical Study with a Collection of the Related Texts and Commentary.Leidein:Brill.
38. Woolf, R.(Trans.)(2001).Cicero: On Moral Ends.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.