消費券政策之總體經濟效果分析

The Macor-Economic Effects of Consumption Vouchers Policy in Taiwan

10.6181/agec.2009.43.04

黃琝琇(Wen-Hsiu Huang)；林建甫(Chien-Fu Jeff Lin)

政府支出 ； 移轉性支出 ； 消費券 ； 總體計量模型 ； Government expenditure ； Transfer payments ； Consumption vouchers ； Macro-Econometric model

農業與經濟

43期（2009 / 12 / 01）

81 - 120

繁體中文

2008年金融海嘯重創全球經濟，台灣政府在景氣低迷之際，採行在國內未曾實施的消費券政策，欲藉由刺激消費以達到提振景氣的目的。政策推出即引起各界廣泛討論，主要的爭議仍是在消費券發放能誘發多少消費？對振興經濟的效果有多少？因此，本文建立－總體經濟計量模型，探討2009年政府以移轉性支出方式，發放消費券振興經濟之總體效果，並模擬分析不同政策的情境。模擬結果顯示，相較於政府投資與政府消費而言，消費券政策對提升經濟成長的效果較爲有限，第一年約提升經濟成長率0.21%，並在改善所得分配方面較有助益。至於，政府投資與政府消費雖能在第一年有較高的經濟成長，但自第二年後卻反有負向效果；其次，針對消費券實施期間長短的效果比較，發現實施期間縮短使經濟成長較高，但實施期間拉長，家戶的邊際消費傾向較大；最後，比較消費券以租稅與債務融通的效果，發現租稅融通對刺激經濟成長效果較大，此突顯出預算平衡對國民經濟的重要性。

This paper analyzes the effects of consumption vouchers policy on Taiwan economy. The consumption vouchers policy is a type of government transfer, and aims at stimulating domestic demand and economic growth. According to the simulations, we have three findings: first, compare to the government investment and consumption, the transfer payments are ineffective in raising economic growth, but effective in improving income distribution. Second, when consumption vouchers policy is implemented in a shorter period, the effects of stimulating economic growth are better. Thirdly, accounting of the effects of different methods to finance the consumption vouchers plan, the tax-financed transfers can raise economic growth much higher than the debt-financed transfers. This indicates the budget balance is important to enhance economic growth.

1. 何金巡、蕭麗卿、周麗芳、林建甫(2004)。開放經濟體系勞工退休制度之總體經濟計量分析。台灣經濟預測與政策，34(2)，73-128。
   連結：
2. 吳中書、范芝萍(2006)。營業稅調整對總體經濟之可能衝擊。台灣經濟預測與政策，37(1)，113-154。
   連結：
3. 吳中書、高志祥、蘇文瑩、陳雅玫、單易、王淑娟、蔡秀慧、黃純宜、羅雅惠(2003)。包含失業隔閡之總供需估測模型。台灣經濟預測與政策，33(1)，111-160。
   連結：
4. 李政峰、藍青玉、連春紅(2007)。非線性消費行為與生命循環假說／恆常所得假說。農業與經濟，38，1-30。
   連結：
5. 郭炳伸、鐘景婷(2002)。消費行爲受資金流動性限制嗎？經濟景氣的不對稱效果。經濟論文，30(4)，443-472。
   連結：
6. Ahmed, H.,S. M. Miller(2000).Crowding-Out and Crowding-In Effects of the Components of Government Expenditure.Contemporary Economic Policy,18(1),124-133.
7. Ando, A.,F. Modigliani(1963).The Life Cycle Hypothesis of Saving: Aggregate Implications and Tests.American Economic Review,53(1),55-84.
8. Aschauer, D. A.(1990).Is Government Spending Stimulative?.Contemporary Economic Policy,8(4),30-46.
9. Aschauer, D. A.(1985).Fiscal Policy and Aggregate Demand.American Economic Review,75(1),117-127.
10. Bailey, M. J.(1971).National Income and the Price Level.New York:McGraw-Hill Press.
11. Barro, R. J.(1981).Output Effect of Government Purchases.Journal of Public Economy,89,1086-1121.
12. Baxter, M.,R. G. King(1993).Fiscal Policy in General Equilibrium.American Economic Review,83(3),315-334.
13. Bean, C.(1986).The Estimation of Surprise Models and the Surprise Consumption Function.Review of Economic Studies,53,497-516.
14. Blanchard, O.,R. Perotti(2002).An Empirical Characterization of the Dynamic Effects of Changes in Government Spending and Taxes on Output.Quarterly Journal of Economics,117,1329-1368.
15. Castelnuovo, E.(2008).Regime Shifts and the Stability of Backward-Looking Phillips Curves in Open Economies.Journal of International Money and Finance,27,40-53.
16. Chow, G. C.(1960).Tests of Equality between Sets of Coefficients in Two Linear Regressions.Econometrica,28(3),591-605.
17. De Castro, F.(2006).The Macroeconomic Effects of Fiscal Policy in Spain.Applied Economics,38,913-924.
18. Devereux, M. B.,C. H. Allen,J. L. Beverly(1996).Monopolistic Competition, Increasing Returns, and the Effects of Government Spending.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,28,233-254.
19. Engle, R. F.,D. F. Hendry(1989).Testing Superexogeneity.San Diego:University of California Press.
20. Engle, R. F.,D. F. Hendry(1993).Testing Superexogeneity and Invariance in Regression Models.Journal of Econometrics,56(1),119-139.
21. Fair, R. C.(1984).Specification, Estimation, and Analysis of Macroeconometric Models.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
22. Fair, R. C.(1994).Testing Macroeconometric Models.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
23. Fatas, A.,I. Mihov(2001).The Effects of Fiscal Policy on Consumption and Employment: Theory and Evidence.CEPR Discussion Paper, No. 2760.
24. Forni, L.,L. Monteforte,L. Sessa(2008).The General Equilibrium Effects of Fiscal Policy: Estimates for the Euro Area.Journal of Public Economics,93,559-585.
25. Friedman, M.(1957).A Theory of the Consumption Function, Princeton.New Jersey:Princeton University Press.
26. Gali, J.,J. D. Lopez-Salido,J. Valles(2007).Understanding the Effects of Government Spending on Consumption.Journal of the European Economic Association,5(1),227-270.
27. Ganelli, G.(2003).Useful Government Spending, Direct Crowding-Out and Fiscal Policy Interdependence.Journal of International Money and Finance,22,87-103.
28. Ganelli, G.,J. Tervala(2009).Can Government Spending Increase Private Consumption? The Role of Complementarity.Economics Letters,103,5-7.
29. Giordano, R.,S. Momigliano,S. Neri,R. Perotti(2007).The Effects of Fiscal Policy in Italy: Evidence from a VAR Model.European Journal of Political Economy,23,707-733.
30. Ho, T. W.(2001).The Government Spending and Private Consumption: A Panel Cointegration Analysis.International Review of Economics and Finance,10,95-108.
31. Hori, M.,C. T. Hsieh,K. Murata,S. Shimizutani(2002).Did the Shopping Coupon Program Stimulate Consumption? Evidence from Japanese Micro Data.ESRI Discussion Paper Series, No.12.
32. Hsiao, C.(1997).Cointegration and Dynamic Simultaneous Equation Model.Econometrica,65(3),647-670.
33. Hunt, B.,D. Rose,A. Scott(2000).The Core Model of the Reserve Bank of New Zealand's Forecasting and Policy System.Economic Modelling,17(2),247-274.
34. Ireland, P. N.(2004).A Method for Taking Models to the Data.Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control,28,1205-1226.
35. Karras, G.(1994).Government Spending and Private Consumption: Some International Evidence.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,26,9-22.
36. Keynes, J. M.(1936).The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money.London:Macmillan Press.
37. Klein, L. R.(1989).Development and Prospects in Macroeconometric Modeling.Eastern Economic Journal,15(4),287-304.
38. Kuehlwein, M.(1998).Evidence on the Substitutability between Government Purchases and Consumer Spending within Specific Spending Categories.Economics Letters,58,325-329.
39. Linde, J.(2001).Testing for the Lucas Critique: A Quantitative Investigation.American Economic Review,91(4),986-1005.
40. Macellino, M.(2002).Some Stylized Facts on Non-Systematic Fiscal Policy in the Euro Area.CEPR Working Paper, No. 3635.
41. Nieh, C. C.,T. W. Ho(2006).Does the Expansionary Government Spending Crowd out the Private Consumption? Cointegration Analysis in Panel Data.The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,46,133-148.
42. Park, J. Y.,P. C. B. Phillips(1988).Statistical Inference in Regressions with Integrated Processes, Part 1.Econometric Theory,4,468-497.
43. Park, J. Y.,P. C. B. Phillips(1989).Econometric Theory,5,95-131.
44. Psaradakis, Z.,M. Sola(1996).On the Power of the Tests for Superexogeneity and Structural Invariance.Journal of Econometrics,72,151-175.
45. Ratto, M.,W. Roeger,J. in''t Veld(2009).Quest III: An Estimated Open-Economy DSGE Model of the Euro Area with Fiscal and Monetary Policy.Economic Modelling,26,222-233.
46. Rudebusch, G. D.(2005).Assessing the Lucas Critique in Monetary Policy Models.Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,37(2),245-272.
47. Sadoulet, E.,A. de Janvry,B. Davis(2001).Cash Transfer Programs with Income Multipliers: PROCAMPO in Mexico.World Development,29(6),1043-1056.
48. Seidman, L.,K. Lewis(2004).Transfers Plus Open Market Purchases: A Remedy for Recession.University of Delaware, Department of Economics Working Paper, No. 04-02.
49. Smets, F.,R. Wouters(2003).An Estimated Dynamics Stochastic General Equilibrium Model of the Euro Area.Journal of the European Economic Association,1(5),1123-1175.
50. Smith, R.(2009).EMU and the Lucas Critique.Economic Modelling,26,744-750.
51. Tiao G. C.,R. S. Tsay,K. S. Man,Y. J. Chu,K. K. Xu,C. Chen,J. L. Lin,C. M. Hsu,C. F. Lin,C. S. Mao,C. S. Ho,R. W. Liou,Y. F. Yang(1998).A Time Series Approach to Econometric Models of Taiwan's Economy.Statistica Sinica,8,991-1044.
52. Valadkhani, A.(2004).History of Macroeconometric Modelling: Lessons from Past Experence.Journal Policy Modeling,26,265-281.
53. Weber, C. E.(2000).Government Purchases, Government Transfers, and the Post-1970 Slowdown in U. S. Economic Growth.Contemporary Economic Policy,18(1),107-123.
54. Willman, A.,M. Kortelainen,H. L. Mannisto,M. Tujula(2000).The BOF5 Macroeconomic Model of Finland, Structure and Dynamic Microfoundations.Economic Modelling,17(2),275-303.
55. 何金巡、周麗芳、林建甫、許振明(2006)。台灣所得分配與經濟成長的總體經濟計量分析。台灣經濟學會與北美華人經濟學會2006年聯合年會研討會，台北:
56. 林立權(2008)。國立臺灣大學經濟研究所。
57. 林建甫(2006)。台灣總體經濟金融模型之建立。中央銀行季刊，28(1)，5-42。
58. 葉芳珠、呂光和(2006)。93年臺灣地區家庭收入與支出變遷分析。主計月刊，602，68-76。

1. 劉碧雯(2011)。奢侈稅與公務員待遇調整之總體計量分析。中原大學國際貿易研究所學位論文。2011。1-75。